PDF Summary:Vietnam, by Max Hastings

Max Hastings' vivid account, Vietnam, provides an in-depth examination of the long and divisive conflict. Beginning with the roots of French colonial rule, Hastings traces the complex origins of Vietnamese nationalism under Ho Chi Minh's leadership. He then chronicles America's fateful intervention amid Cold War tensions, delving into key battles, strategy shifts, and the war's polarizing domestic impact.

Hastings also spotlights the intricate interplay of social and political forces within Vietnam itself. He explores the consequences of America's withdrawal in the conflict's final chapter, from the mass exodus to Vietnam's post-war path under Hanoi's rule. Vietnam paints a comprehensive yet deeply personal portrait of a war seared into the global consciousness.

(continued)...

General William Westmoreland's strategy, which focused on tracking down and neutralizing the opposition in irregular warfare, revealed its shortcomings.

Max Hastings provides an in-depth explanation of the intensification of the war's devastation, which resulted from an increased deployment of military forces and equipment, along with a strengthened commitment to the "search and destroy" tactic. Max Hastings observed that, despite the significant force of American weaponry, combatants frequently remained concealed from each other's view. He presents compelling personal narratives that underscore the Vietcong's strategic and unyielding warfare tactics.

The intensification of air strikes during Operation Rolling Thunder, as well as its moral and political consequences, including civilian casualties and the contentious issues surrounding Lavelle

The intensification of US involvement, which retrospectively proved almost as detrimental to their ultimate goals as the introduction of combat forces, signified another significant rise in their commitment. The US Air Force and Navy launched "Operation Rolling Thunder," a prolonged assault aimed at disrupting North Vietnam's logistics channels, and this operation later grew to encompass the country's industrial strengths. Hastings details both aircraft roles and types. He provides a memorable narrative that vividly captures the pilots' trepidation and their intermittent, extraordinary displays of courage amidst significant peril.

American soldiers encountered a reality shaped by the challenging terrain, distinct cultural customs of the inhabitants, and growing disillusionment due to the escalating unpopularity of the conflict, all exacerbated by the enemy's use of concealed explosives.

Even with more than 500,000 American troops deployed, the Johnson administration struggled to secure the backing of the American public for the war. Across the nation, opposition to the war grew stronger, fueled by moral indignation, dread of the draft, and doubts regarding the truthfulness of government reports on the events transpiring in Vietnam. The story depicts the escalating dissent among Americans and portrays the perception of US troops who increasingly saw the struggle as not just fruitless but also unjustified.

The interplay between social and political elements in Vietnam.

The intricate nature within Vietnam

Both the Northern and Southern Vietnamese administrations were characterized by authoritarian rule, yet the North benefited from a cohesive ideological conviction and more rigorous regulation of information dissemination, demonstrated by its successful propaganda campaigns.

The author, Max Hastings, casts doubt on the sincerity of the governments engaged in the Vietnam War. Should the rural populace of South Vietnam have fully comprehended the ramifications of a communist victory, they might have chosen to endure the shortcomings of the Saigon administration. The writer notes that Hanoi skillfully portrayed itself as a symbol of the nation's aspirations while skillfully hiding its harsh tactics for reaching its objectives from the international perspective.

In both the North and South, a campaign targeted real and presumed opponents, which included land redistribution efforts in the North and Diem's oppressive actions toward Buddhists in the South.

Hastings emphasizes the intense nature of Vietnam's internal strife, which mirrored the savagery seen in the civil wars of China and Spain, showing that such extreme violence was not unique to the revolutionaries. Ngo Dinh Diem ascended to a position of dominance and solidified his rule as a dictatorial figure, embarking on a relentless pursuit against those he regarded as real or possible threats in a climate rife with suspicion. The book elaborates on the reliance of Saigon's administration on an oppressive security apparatus that was directed at the Buddhist majority, resulting in a significant moral dilution of its position.

The conflict resulted in profound changes to the fundamental nature of community life in Vietnam, affecting families and villages with the struggles of forced resettlement, compulsory conscription, and the ever-present threat of warfare.

The author presents a thorough depiction of the social stratification in Vietnam, underscoring its significance to both personal and shared beliefs. The conflict led to significant stress and often broke these ties due to compulsory relocations, conscription, exile, and a high number of fatalities. For numerous generations, the most pressing priority for those in Vietnam has been the preservation of their own survival.

Key occurrences and the resulting impacts

The Tet Offensive, although ultimately a tactical reversal for the communist forces, significantly altered the perspective of the American public, accelerating the decline in morale and amplifying demands for withdrawal.

Hastings describes Tet as a strategic blunder that led to significant losses among the communist forces, drawing on a plethora of detailed narratives. Hanoi's capacity to coordinate large-scale attacks on unexpected targets significantly undermined the morale of American forces, impacting both soldiers in Vietnam and public opinion in the United States.

The strategy of gradually transferring combat duties to the South Vietnamese, thereby enabling the pullout of US troops, exposed their critical weaknesses and accelerated the collapse of their regime.

The war progressed into its ultimate stage, which was derisively tagged with an "-ism" designation by the communist faction. Acknowledging that the United States had abandoned its hopes for victory, the moment had come to withdraw its troops and at the same time provide the Army of the Republic of Vietnam with increased material, financial, and technological assistance. Hastings depicts Vietnamization as a deceptive tactic that significantly undermined the ethical stature and global standing of the United States. The South Vietnamese found themselves isolated in a dire situation, one they likely would not have encountered had they not been previously supported by the United States, at a time when Washington had relinquished all real expectation of Saigon's survival.

The strategy of Nixon's administration and the resulting accords in Paris sought to briefly halt the conflict while essentially abandoning a true commitment to uphold the independence of South Vietnam.

Kissinger, as Hastings observes, was aware of the pointlessness of America's continued efforts and advocated for postponing Hanoi's symbolic victory to improve Nixon's chances in the 1972 presidential race. The Paris Accords of January 1973, despite securing the release of American prisoners, did not change the ultimate outcome of the war. The transition moved from a time characterized by active combat between the United States and Hanoi to a stage distinguished by growing internal strife in Vietnam.

The swift collapse of Saigon in 1975 highlighted the ARVN's military shortcomings and the widespread disillusionment within South Vietnamese society.

As officers at a firebase in Phuoc Long Province, located 130 miles northeast of Saigon, prepared for lunch on the afternoon of March 9, 1975, their commander proposed delaying the meal due to the expectation of forthcoming combat operations. As dusk settled, the communists swiftly gained control over most of the base following the commencement of their offensive. The directive issued by President Nguyen Van Thieu, which came only a few hours afterward, was crucial in determining the future of his country, its armed forces, and its people. He commanded the Airborne Division, valiantly holding their ground near the Demilitarized Zone, to abandon their positions and reinforce Saigon's fortifications. On March 10th, Ban Mê Thuột, home to a hundred thousand inhabitants and serving as the Central Highlands' administrative hub, was attacked by NVA forces. Two ARVN regiments disintegrated and retreated hastily. On March 15, the entirety of South Vietnam came under a widespread assault by communist forces.

Following the pullout

The US forces were progressively pulled out.

Nixon's pursuit of "peace with honor" and Kissinger's role in negotiating a withdrawal agreement that ensured the release of US prisoners but abandoned Saigon to its fate

The withdrawal of US forces in accordance with the Paris Peace Accords resulted in a feeling of despair within the leadership of Saigon, but it offered comfort to many Americans who perceived their country as caught in a conflict that appeared to be without hope of victory, or at its worst, engaged in a pursuit that was ethically indefensible. The author acknowledges the difficulties faced by American soldiers upon their return, as they encountered scornful reproach from fellow citizens firmly convinced of the United States' actions' intrinsic righteousness. President Richard Nixon sought to conclude the hostilities while preserving the honor and reputation of the United States, a strategy that subsequently gained notoriety.

The devastating impact on human life was evident through the struggles faced by those who managed to flee during the last exodus and the outcomes for those who stayed behind.

In the chaos, countless South Vietnamese, encompassing both civilians and soldiers who aspired to evacuate, were overwhelmed and pushed aside by the frantic rush of individuals desperate to flee. Hastings paints a bleak picture of numerous abandoned vehicles scattered along the roadside, with their desperate owners escaping into the surrounding wilds or open spaces. Soldiers threw away their uniforms, and often their weapons, to seek anonymity among the crowds. Senior military officials often faced criticism for prioritizing their own evacuation by air, leaving their subordinates behind.

The conflict's lasting impact significantly shaped the foreign policy and military engagements of the United States, and it also sparked substantial domestic social and political unrest.

America's withdrawal from Saigon in 1975 dealt a significant blow to the nation's standing, signifying a setback that would present enduring difficulties, even though some, including a number of Vietnamese, hold the view that attempts to expunge this stain on their honor have been unsuccessful. The narrative concludes with the author stating that the Americans acted both impulsively and severely, eventually forsaking the very people they had previously supported as allies.

The impact was deeply felt across the entirety of Vietnam.

Hanoi's creation of a strict autocratic government, marked by mandatory re-education camps, economic hardships, and extensive purges, resulted in a profound feeling of disillusionment among many former Southern communists.

Max Hastings notes that the Vietnamese merely shifted from one form of autocratic rule to another. In the southern areas, many people who had previously been associated with the Vietcong realized that the governance of the communists posed a threat to their dreams of independence and a better life.

Vietnamese individuals fleeing their homeland faced ongoing challenges as they tried to acclimate to unfamiliar settings, grappling with the need to surmount previous traumas, assimilate into different cultural surroundings, and the complexities involved in establishing fresh starts.

The personal accounts of individuals who were displaced deeply influenced the author's storytelling. In 1954, a significant population movement took place, with a million people moving to the southern part of the country. After 1975, there was a comparable large-scale exodus. Hastings documents the severe trials faced by these people, who braved dangerous travels that frequently ended in death or disaster, in their quest for asylum across various nations including the Philippines and an increasing array of Western countries. Many individuals who endured the perilous ocean voyage later encountered appalling circumstances and endured hardships within the refugee camp boundaries.

The eventual success of the ideologies once linked to the southern part of Vietnam is evidenced by the steady adoption of capitalist practices, engagement in global commerce, and the formation of a positive partnership with the United States.

Hastings convincingly argues that, notwithstanding their tactical victories, the communists ultimately faced a slow decline in their economy. A few years following the implementation of strict policies throughout the country by Hanoi, the governing body began to cautiously integrate aspects of capitalism and engage with the international market, which resulted in a reduction of extreme poverty among the populace. This transition is regarded as a triumph for the principles that are highly esteemed by numerous individuals in the southern part of Vietnam.

The war has left an indelible imprint on Vietnam, shaping its domestic strategies and affecting its position on the world stage, deeply embedded in the country's collective psyche and etched across its landscape.

In summary, Hastings acknowledges that the conflict inflicted enduring harm on Vietnam's landscape as well as on the psyche of its people. The country's wealth has increased, but a deep sense of disenchantment, akin to the experience of many Americans, has gripped a significant portion of its populace. The stark truth is that the same generation of communist leaders who fought with valor to shape a more promising destiny governed through a period marked by numerous challenges in the economic, social, and political spheres, culminating in Vietnam's rise as an international success story after a gradual and hesitant move away from many foundational revolutionary ideals.