PDF Summary:Unthinkable, by Helen Thomson

Our memories, consciousness, and personal life narrative profoundly shape our sense of self. In Unthinkable, Helen Thomson explores the brain's remarkable capacity to construct our perception of reality and how disruptions in these processes can lead to profound shifts in self-awareness and identity.

Thomson delves into conditions like highly superior autobiographical memory, depersonalization disorder, and mirror-touch synesthesia. She illustrates how our sense of self is intertwined with how we process memories, sensations, and our ability to orient ourselves. Through compelling case studies, Thomson reveals insights into the intricate neural mechanisms that govern our experience of existence and individuality.

(continued)...

• The notion that HSAM is tied to improved linking and solidification of memories rather than encoding or retrieval could be debated, as some researchers might argue that encoding processes could also be enhanced in these individuals.
• The idea that repetitive and compulsive behaviors are a common feature among individuals with HSAM could be challenged, as not all individuals with HSAM may exhibit these behaviors, and such behaviors could be due to other psychological factors.
• The effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy and medication for depersonalization disorder may not be universal, and some individuals may not respond to these treatments or may find alternative therapies more beneficial.
• The assertion that hallucinations can occur in healthy individuals and are not always indicative of mental illness might be nuanced by considering that while some hallucinations are benign, they can also be early indicators of neurological or psychiatric conditions in some cases.
• The explanation of Charles Bonnet syndrome as a result of the brain filling in gaps due to diminished sensory input could be complemented by alternative theories that emphasize the role of neural hyperactivity in specific brain regions.
• The predictive processing model's explanation for hallucinations could be contested by those who argue for a more complex interplay of brain functions, including memory, attention, and perception, in the generation of hallucinations.

The integration of spatial awareness, orientation, and sensory processing.

The section explores the remarkable capacity of the brain to understand spatial dimensions and ascertain its own location in relation to them. Thomson delves into the debilitating world of those with developmental topographical disorientation, revealing the constant struggle of feeling "permanently lost," even in familiar locations. The author explores an intriguing occurrence where individuals' perception of their own identity blends with others', highlighting the profound connection between our sensory perceptions and our ability to empathize.

Damage to specific regions of the brain can greatly impair an individual's ability to navigate and orient themselves within their environment.

Thomson illustrates the difficulties Sharon encounters due to a condition that impedes her understanding of the environment around her, highlighting the effects on a mind that finds spatial orientation challenging. Sharon experiences a constant change in her perception of reality, which results in a sense of disorientation and hinders her ability to form a stable mental image of her surroundings. Thomson clarifies that her experience sheds light on the complex neural interplay essential for our perception and comprehension of the space around us, emphasizing the significance of specific brain regions in navigating our environment.

People with the rare disorder called developmental topographical disorientation struggle to form mental maps of their surroundings.

Helen Thomson explores a distinct neurological condition in which an individual is unable to form and utilize mental representations of their environment, a condition referred to as Developmental Topographical Disorientation (DTD). The book depicts the emergence of DTD in everyday tasks by sharing Sharon's experiences. Sharon recounts the ongoing challenges she encounters in orienting herself within the confines of her long-term residence. Traveling to familiar destinations can sometimes evoke anxiety and unease. Thomson highlights that individuals with DTD, despite having normal intelligence, face difficulties due to the brain's insufficient ability to process and assimilate spatial information.

People with this condition may constantly feel lost in familiar places due to their brain's unique method of interpreting spatial information.

Thomson explores the neurological underpinnings of DTD, emphasizing the contributions from the esteemed field expert, Giuseppe Iaria. Our comprehension of where we are in relation to key landmarks is supported by an innate structure that functions as a cognitive map of our surroundings. Individuals with DTD face challenges due to their inability to create an adequately dynamic representation, leading to their perpetual feeling of being lost. Sharon offers detailed narratives, particularly when she recounts the sudden alterations in her environment, transforming familiar locations into unrecognizable ones, thereby illuminating the perplexing characteristics of DTD and highlighting the ongoing struggle to navigate through a world that lacks consistency and certainty.

People with orientation difficulties can improve their navigation skills through the use of various additional methods, such as in-depth exploration and mental rehearsal of the path.

Helen Thomson underscores the importance of understanding and devising methods to handle DTD, despite its challenging nature. Sharon found that rotating with her eyes shut provided her with a momentary shift in her cognitive viewpoint. This emphasizes the potential for identifying tailored strategies to manage the turmoil, highlighting the brain's remarkable capacity for adaptation. Thomson highlights advancements within genetics that have identified potential genes associated with DTD, fostering hope for early intervention and the development of teaching strategies to help children learn alternative navigation techniques.

Our understanding of self and interaction with the environment depends on the brain's ability to outline our body and integrate different types of sensory information.

In this segment, Thomson explores the fascinating processes by which our brains comprehend our bodily structure, discussing in-depth examples of disorders that disrupt this recognition. The focus is mainly on mirror-touch synesthesia, a rare condition that provides a unique lens through which to understand the intertwined nature of bodily perception and empathy.

People who have mirror-touch synesthesia experience a merging of their own tactile sensations with those of someone else, sensing the touch that another person feels.

Thomson introduces us to a medical professional named Joel, who possesses the remarkable ability to feel what others feel, a phenomenon referred to as mirror-touch synesthesia. Joel experiences the physical feelings of others as if they are happening to him. Whenever another person's cheek receives a caress, Joel feels corresponding sensations on his own face. This blurring of the line between self and other makes Joel's profession particularly challenging. He feels the sting of injections given to others, shares in the discomfort of their injuries, and possesses a profound empathy for the experience of someone else's death. Joel's brain produces genuine tactile sensations when he watches others, as emphasized by Helen Thomson, are not merely figments of imagination or empathy.

The state of the brain reveals the deep link between how we perceive our own physical existence and our ability to empathize and comprehend the feelings and life events of other people.

The author delves into the neurological underpinnings that account for Joel's unique sensory experiences, drawing on research conducted by Michael Banissy, who specializes in the study of mirror-touch phenomena. We activate a vital neural circuit not only during our own actions but also while observing someone else perform the same activity. We cultivate a vital understanding that nurtures empathy by mimicking the actions of the people we encounter. Individuals with mirror-touch synesthesia have an enhanced reflective process that allows them to experience tactile sensations when they observe another person being touched, highlighting the intricate link between self-awareness and empathy.

Individuals with mirror-touch synesthesia continuously adjust to a persistent flow of tactile impressions that stem from watching other people engage in daily actions.

Thomson explores the impact of Joel's distinctive sensory condition, synesthesia, on his daily activities, including his professional and social interactions. He continuously employs strategies such as concentrating on a non-living item or seeking out the most composed individual in the vicinity to mitigate the barrage of sensory input from those around him and manage the overwhelming emotions. Joel has utilized the unique abilities of his mind to his advantage, in spite of the challenges he encounters. He has a remarkable talent for detecting subtle cues and expressions on people's faces, which often helps him forge deeper connections with patients, offering a heightened sense of understanding that is crucial when delivering difficult diagnoses and offering comfort during stressful moments. The concluding remarks by the author emphasize Joel's experience as an example of the remarkable ability of the human brain to adjust and find advantages in situations that may seem highly restrictive.

Other Perspectives

• While the brain's capacity to understand spatial dimensions is indeed remarkable, it is also worth considering that this ability can vary significantly among individuals and can be influenced by factors such as genetics, experience, and even cultural background.
• The statement that damage to specific brain regions can impair navigation abilities might be too deterministic, as there is evidence of neural plasticity allowing other parts of the brain to compensate for damaged areas, especially in young or rehabilitated individuals.
• The concept of DTD might be oversimplified in the text; it's important to acknowledge that there is a spectrum of severity and that some individuals may develop compensatory strategies that mitigate the impact of the disorder.
• The idea that people with DTD feel lost in familiar places due to spatial interpretation issues could be complemented by discussing the role of attention, memory, and other cognitive processes in spatial navigation.
• Suggesting that various methods can help improve navigation skills in individuals with orientation difficulties may not fully account for the individual variability in response to these interventions, and some methods may not be effective for everyone.
• The connection between mirror-touch synesthesia and enhanced empathy could be questioned, as empathy is a complex construct that involves more than just sensory processing, including cognitive and emotional components.
• The link between self-perception and empathy in individuals with mirror-touch synesthesia might not be causal; it could be that people with a higher baseline of empathy are more likely to report or notice such synesthetic experiences.
• The idea that individuals with mirror-touch synesthesia adjust to a constant flow of tactile impressions from others might not capture the full range of experiences of those with the condition, as some may find it overwhelming and not be able to adjust as effectively.

Our sense of self and personal identity are deeply intertwined.

The final section of the book delves into the intricate relationship between our brain and our sense of self and personal identity. The writer explores how certain brain injuries can lead to significant alterations in an individual's character, leaving them feeling estrategically alienated from their former selves. She concludes by highlighting how the interplay of genetics and environment shapes our unique personalities, emphasizing the intricate dance between nature and nurture.

Sometimes, an individual's personality may undergo sudden and profound changes due to physical harm or disruptions to the cerebral processes.

This section emphasizes the delicacy of our self-perception, showing that malfunctions within the brain can lead to significant changes in an individual's behavior, emotions, and sense of self. Thomson explores specific cases that vividly illustrate the profound effects resulting from damage to different brain regions.

Injury to the brain's frontal areas can markedly alter a person's actions and decision-making.

Thomson revisits the historical case of Phineas Gage, a railroad worker who suffered a devastating brain injury in the 19th century. The incident with the tamping iron severely changed Gage's personality. Once recognized for his reliability and calm demeanor, he turned impetuous, frequently using foul language, and found himself incapable of executing his plans. Thomson illustrates that Gage's case was pivotal in uncovering the crucial role played by the frontal lobes in regulating emotions, decision-making, and overseeing social behavior. The story emphasizes the significant impact that slight damage to specific brain regions can have on altering our self-perception.

In some instances, particularly when dealing with the condition known as Cotard's syndrome, individuals may come to believe that they no longer exist or that they have been stripped of their essential human characteristics.

Thomson explores the unsettling and peculiar condition where individuals are under the impression that they have passed away, ceased to exist, or are missing vital organs, despite irrefutable evidence to the contrary; this condition is referred to as Cotard's syndrome. After an attempt on his own life, Graham came to believe that he was no longer alive in the brain. Graham's experience vividly illustrates the significant detachment from his own personal reality that can occur when injuries impact the brain regions tasked with self-awareness, emotional regulation, and rational thought.

Current vigorous and engaged research delves into the neural foundations responsible for changes in an individual's personality, particularly how these changes affect self-awareness and emotional regulation.

Helen Thomson's work emphasizes the ongoing scientific exploration into the ways in which sudden changes in a person's personality can be driven by the brain. She investigates various theories that examine the underlying mechanisms that could induce such transformations, highlighting how damage to specific brain regions can disrupt the delicate balance that regulates self-perception, emotional regulation, and cognitive operations. She highlights the importance of ongoing research to shed light on these complex conditions and develop effective treatments.

Individual characteristics are shaped by a combination of innate genetic predispositions and the impact of environmental elements.

In the final section of this chapter, Thomson delves into the ongoing debate about the origins of our distinctive traits. In her examination, she delves into the complex relationship between our genetic makeup and life experiences that mold our identity.

Studies involving twins brought up separately often reveal strikingly similar characteristics, indicating a significant hereditary influence.

Thomson explores various studies on twins, demonstrating the significant role of genetic predisposition in shaping personality. She tells the captivating tale of two identical twins, both named Jim, who were separated at birth and upon reuniting as adults, were amazed to find striking similarities in their life journeys, such as their common first name, the towns they originated from, and the names of their significant others. Thomson's analysis of a study on twins raised separately reveals that traits including leadership, inclination towards risk-taking, and emotional reactivity are predominantly influenced by genetics. Our inherent tendencies and predispositions might naturally steer us toward certain personality traits.

An individual's unique path, influenced by specific experiences and environmental factors, significantly contributes to the development of their mental, emotional, and behavioral traits.

While acknowledging the role of genetics, Thomson emphasizes that personality is not solely determined by our genes, that our environment significantly shapes who we are. Helen Thomson underscores the profound influence that personal encounters, particularly those related to stress and health, exert on the development of an individual's character, including among identical twins raised in identical surroundings. As we grow and experience various events in life, our early years have a profound impact on our thoughts, emotions, and behaviors.

Neurological conditions such as mirror-touch synesthesia can shape the way people engage with and perceive their surroundings, and this can also mold their personality.

The concluding section of the book explores how various neurological disorders shape an individual's personality. She delves into how Joel's distinctive neurological condition, which enables him to feel the physical sensations of others, shapes his social interactions and choices. His career trajectory and interpersonal interactions have been significantly shaped by the unique way his brain cross-wires sensory experiences, highlighting the complex interplay between neural function, behavior, and the development of personal identity. The writer communicates that our individualities are intricate tapestries, woven from a unique combination of inherent inclinations and the diverse life events that shape who we are.

Other Perspectives

• While brain injuries can lead to personality changes, it's also true that many people retain their sense of self despite significant cerebral trauma, suggesting resilience and plasticity in the brain's structures.
• The case of Phineas Gage, while pivotal historically, is sometimes contested in terms of the extent and permanence of his personality changes, with some researchers arguing that the changes were not as severe or long-lasting as often portrayed.
• Cotard's syndrome is a rare and extreme example of dissociation and may not be representative of most individuals' experiences with self-perception following brain injury or illness.
• The emphasis on genetic predispositions and environmental factors may overlook the role of individual agency and the capacity for self-change through introspection, choice, and effort.
• Twin studies, while informative, have limitations and cannot fully disentangle the complex interplay of genes and environment, as twins often share more of their environments than is sometimes acknowledged.
• The interpretation of neurological conditions like mirror-touch synesthesia shaping personality could be seen as deterministic, potentially underestimating the individual's ability to adapt and manage their condition.
• The narrative that our personalities are shaped by a combination of genetics and environment might oversimplify the complex, dynamic, and often unpredictable nature of human development and identity formation.