PDF Summary:This House of Sky, by Ivan Doig

In the poignant memoir This House of Sky, author Ivan Doig embarks on a journey to understand his family heritage and its connection to the rugged landscapes of Montana. He reflects on the resilience and determination of his ancestors, who carved out a living through ranching, farming, and sheep herding in the harsh yet beautiful terrain.

The narrative delves into Doig's close relationships with his father and grandmother, as well as the transformative experiences that shaped his growth. It explores the challenges faced by the family, including the effects of illness, loss, and the evolving dynamics of their rural way of life. Through this intimate account, Doig offers a profound appreciation for the enduring values and traditions that defined his Montana roots.

(continued)...

• These are warm, dry winds that descend the eastern slopes of the Rockies, causing rapid temperature increases and snowmelt. They are named after the Chinook people and are known for their dramatic impact on local weather, often leading to significant changes in a short period.
• The state's economy has traditionally been based on agriculture, mining, and forestry, industries that are highly dependent on and influenced by the natural environment and weather patterns.

The author's evolving perspective on his Montana roots as he encounters new environments and experiences

Venturing far from his Montana roots, Ivan Doig pursued higher education and embarked on a career path that took him from his rural beginnings, yet his reflections often circled back to his Montana heritage, with his perspective shaped by a variety of experiences and interactions. His transition to urban living and scholarly pursuits challenged his fundamental values, yet it also deepened his admiration for the resilience and resourcefulness characteristic of the way his relatives lived.

The author greatly respects the enduring values and traditions inherent in the way his family lived.

Considering his formative years in Montana from a distance, Doig achieves a deeper understanding of the enduring values and traditions that shaped the life of his family. He recognizes the steadfast character of his father, the perpetual vitality of his grandmother, and their shared legacy of hard work, which he continues to honor as he sets out on his own unique path. Ivan Doig's fundamental values were influenced by the resourcefulness cultivated through life on remote homesteads, coupled with the ability to adapt to challenging circumstances and the solace found in strenuous work.

He also cherishes the authentic perspectives provided by individuals who played a significant role during his early development. Ivan Doig met a variety of vibrant individuals in different locations, including the town famous for its medicinal springs, Dupuyer, and while spending time on numerous ranches, which offered him profound understanding of endurance, humor, and a humble recognition of life's unforeseen turns. These encounters provided a counterpoint to the academic world he navigated, reminding him of the diverse spectrum of human experience.

Context

• The ability to find solace in hard work also speaks to an emotional resilience, where physical labor provided a sense of purpose and stability amidst life’s uncertainties.
• Oral traditions and storytelling were important in preserving family histories and cultural values, providing a sense of identity and continuity across generations.
• In these communities, family units were central to survival and success. Each member contributed to the collective effort, and the legacy of hard work was often passed down through generations as a source of pride and identity.
• Life on remote homesteads often required families to be self-sufficient, relying on their own skills to build, repair, and maintain their homes and tools. This environment fostered a culture of innovation and problem-solving, as families had to make do with limited resources and find creative solutions to everyday challenges.
• The perspectives Doig valued were likely rooted in the social values of the time, such as self-reliance, neighborliness, and a deep connection to the land.
• Academic environments often focus on theoretical knowledge and structured learning, while Doig's experiences in Montana provided practical, hands-on lessons about life, resilience, and adaptability.

The author's struggle to reconcile his rural Montana heritage with his pursuit of a professional career

The author struggled to reconcile the principles instilled in him during his formative years in Montana with the aspirations of his burgeoning career as he navigated the shift from a country background to an urban academic environment. The academic atmosphere, prioritizing theoretical understanding and scholarly activities, felt foreign to an individual familiar with the tactile governance of a ranch and the straightforward, pragmatic wisdom characteristic of Montanans. He wrestled with the concept of how these contrasting realms could simultaneously exist within his being, acknowledging the distinct advantages and constraints each viewpoint offered.

Ultimately, Doig recognizes that his unique childhood experiences served as a source of strength, enabling him to channel his innate storytelling abilities and deep connection to Montana's terrain into the bedrock of a successful writing profession. He uses his skills to chronicle the lives of the hardworking individuals who lived amidst the beautiful but harsh landscapes of his youth, ensuring their stories are preserved and not lost to the passage of time.

Context

• Definitions of success can vary greatly, with rural areas often valuing practical achievements and community contributions, while academia may prioritize intellectual accomplishments and recognition.
• In rural settings, communication might be more direct and straightforward, whereas academic environments can involve more nuanced and complex discourse.
• This internal struggle is common among individuals who move from rural to urban settings, as they must navigate the cultural and social differences that accompany such a transition.
• The close-knit communities in rural Montana, with their unique characters and lifestyles, offered Doig a wealth of human experiences and interactions to draw upon for his storytelling.
• The intimate connection with nature and the land informed his thematic exploration of humanity's relationship with the environment.
• The narratives often explore themes of family, identity, and belonging, resonating emotionally with readers who may share similar backgrounds or appreciate the universal aspects of these experiences.
• By documenting these stories, the author contributes to the genre of Western American literature, which seeks to capture the unique experiences and voices of the American West.

Changing family dynamics and relationships across generations

The narrative explores the complex and occasionally strained relationships that span generations within a family, focusing especially on the author's profound relationship with his paternal figure and ancestors on his mother's side. Doig explores how their distinctive characteristics, shared past, and the unchanging elements of life in rural Montana shaped their connections, leading to periods of tension, instances of unity, and, in the end, a profound understanding of one another.

The author's complex relationship develops not only with his father but also with a figure who provides maternal guidance.

This section of the narrative delves into the intricate web of family connections involving Ivan Doig, his father Charlie Jr., and his grandmother Bessie. It delves into the challenges they faced as a nontraditional family unit, highlighting the ways in which their personalities clashed and eventually found common ground.

The family unit endures a succession of conflicts and disputes as they navigate through health crises and substantial transformations in their existence.

As a young boy, Ivan was deeply influenced by the quiet grief of his father and the stern yet profoundly loving nature of his grandmother. His father, grappling with the grief of losing his spouse and the challenges of single parenthood, frequently found solace in solitude, finding peace in the routine tasks of ranch management and also in the camaraderie found in neighborhood taverns. Bessie, in her pursuit of a meaningful role during her later years, encountered resistance from both Charlie Jr. and his later wife Ruth, creating a tense atmosphere that Ivan, still young, had to navigate with diplomacy.

The decision to move onto the Jensen property, prompted by an unstable deal with the unreliable McGrath, did little to ease the family's internal discord. The unyielding demands of operating a sheep ranch in a rugged terrain tested their endurance, culminating in pivotal instances like an intense tempest that required driving their sheep across expansive meadows to the safeguarding shores near the Two Medicine. These events not only showcased the collective resilience they possessed but also laid bare the insecurities and profound anxieties present in their impromptu familial group.

Other Perspectives

• The focus on the father's grief and grandmother's love may overshadow the potential impact of positive experiences and interactions Ivan had outside the family unit, such as with friends, mentors, or educational opportunities.
• Finding solace in solitude could potentially lead to social isolation, which might exacerbate feelings of loneliness and sadness.
• The resistance Bessie encountered could be indicative of a natural generational shift in values and responsibilities within the family, rather than a personal affront to her.
• The move to the Jensen property could have been part of a larger strategic decision for the family's future, rather than a reactive decision to an unstable deal with McGrath.
• The rugged terrain might not have been the primary factor testing the family's endurance; other factors such as interpersonal relationships or financial stress could have played a more significant role.
• The focus on resilience might overshadow the need for external support or resources that the family could have benefited from but did not receive or seek out.
• The change of environment might have offered new opportunities for the family to bond and work together, potentially easing discord.
• Insecurities and anxieties are common in any group dynamic, not just familial ones, and may not necessarily indicate a dysfunctional or problematic family structure.

As time went on, the principal figures in the story cultivated a mutual appreciation and comprehension.

Over time, Charlie Jr., Ivan, and Bessie developed a slowly emerging bond of mutual understanding and respect. As Ivan grew older, his bond with his father became more profound. Engaging in the strenuous tasks of ranch life and witnessing his father's skill and knowledge fostered an initial respect that evolved into a profound bond. His father's fondness for him was sincere, even though it was concealed by a gruff exterior and a tendency to prioritize strenuous labor over intimate bonds.

Bessie, confronting personal challenges over a prolonged period and experiencing a sense of disorientation with advancing age, found purpose in her connection with Ivan. Her unwavering love, shown by her firm direction, insightful advice, and a constant feeling of comfort, created a connection that endured through the years. Despite often finding herself at odds with her grandson's modern views, she fervently supported his educational endeavors and emerged as a resolute supporter.

Context

• The story is set in the mid-20th century, a time when traditional family roles and values were prominent. This period emphasized hard work and familial duty, which likely influenced the dynamics between Charlie Jr., Ivan, and Bessie.
• The skills and knowledge associated with ranching are not only practical but also carry cultural significance, representing a way of life that is deeply rooted in tradition and history. This cultural aspect can enhance the respect and admiration a son might feel for his father.
• The father’s behavior might reflect generational attitudes towards parenting, where providing materially and ensuring the family’s survival were seen as primary expressions of love and care.
• In the context of rural Montana, women like Bessie often played crucial roles in maintaining family cohesion and managing household responsibilities, which could be a source of purpose and identity.
• For Ivan, education might have been a path to understanding his own identity and aspirations beyond the confines of ranch life, a journey Bessie supported even if she didn't fully share his vision.

The dynamics within their relationships were significantly altered due to changes in the Doig family's situation.

This part of the narrative emphasizes the significant transformations that the Doig family and their neighbors are experiencing, particularly the move away from conventional ranching practices and the influence this has on the dynamics of their interpersonal connections. It explores the ways in which their resilience and capacity for adapting to change ultimately shape their destinies.

As their longstanding practice of ranching started to disintegrate, it coincided with the loss of the ancestral home that had been passed down through their family for generations.

The writer chronicles the wider financial and societal forces that precipitated the downfall of their traditional ranching existence, while concurrently weaving in the story of his family's history. The period previously abundant with opportunities for land ownership and the possibility of independence for livestock herders evolved into a time marked by the prevalence of large-scale ranching businesses and the progression of farming ventures. The Doig family, in pursuit of a stable life, often relocated between short-term rentals and tentative sharecropping arrangements following their departure from the family's long-held properties in the Tierney Basin.

The author's decision to pursue higher education and a different career marked a significant deviation from his family's traditional ranching lifestyle. The author expresses a sense of grief, aware that his decisions mark a departure from the deep-rooted traditions and way of life of his ancestors, despite his father and grandmother supporting his choices.

Other Perspectives

• The term "disintegrate" could be too strong if the family still maintains some aspects of their ranching heritage, even if it's not their primary occupation.
• The correlation between losing the ancestral home and the decline of ranching does not necessarily imply causation; the two events might be coincidental rather than directly linked.
• The focus on financial and societal forces might not account for environmental and ecological factors, such as drought or disease, which can also have a profound impact on the viability of ranching.
• The shift towards larger ranching businesses might be a response to increasing demands for efficiency and lower costs, which could benefit consumers overall.
• The term "significant deviation" carries a negative connotation, but this change could be positively framed as growth or expansion of the family's legacy into new realms.
• The concept of tradition is not static, and what is considered a traditional way of life can change and expand over time to include new professions and lifestyles.
• Feeling grief does not preclude the author from also experiencing a sense of accomplishment or excitement about his new career and educational opportunities.
• The family's support could also be seen as a sacrifice, valuing the author's individual success over the collective maintenance of their ranching heritage.

They endeavored to adapt and find new ways to preserve their unity.

The Doig family discovered innovative methods to maintain their bond and adjust to the alterations in their customary lifestyle. As Charlie Jr.'s health declined, preventing him from continuing his work as a rancher, he and Bessie found happiness in simpler pursuits like fishing trips and spending time with close friends. Her artistic talent, which had gone unnoticed, came to the forefront as she crafted vibrant and intricate quilts, after first expressing her creativity through culinary arts and the relentless creation of lace.

Throughout his time at university and the initial phase of his career, Ivan maintained a strong connection with his father and grandmother, even though they were physically far apart. Ivan ensured they stayed updated on the shifts and progress in his life through phone calls, letters, and holiday visits, which were crucial for preserving their relationship.

Practical Tips

• Implement a 'family challenge' system where members team up to achieve specific goals. These could range from fitness challenges to reading a certain number of books together. Set up a tracking system on a shared digital platform or a physical scoreboard at home to monitor progress and celebrate achievements as a family.
• Implement a 'virtual dinner date' where you synchronize a mealtime with your distant family members. With video calling technology, set up a time to eat 'together' and catch up on each other's lives. This simulates the experience of a family meal and can help maintain the emotional connection that comes from sharing experiences in real-time.
• Start a private family blog where each member can post updates, photos, and videos. This can serve as a digital scrapbook that documents your family's life over the years. You can set up a blog on a free platform and send out invites to your family members, encouraging them to participate by sharing their own posts.

Illness, decline, loss, and the author's role in caring for aging family members

The concluding parts of "This House of Sky" tackle the difficult themes related to illness, decline, and sorrow. Doig openly describes the impact of his father's struggle with severe emphysema, which not only diminished his once active way of life but also shaped the dynamics within their household. The author's duty to care for his aging father and resolute grandmother highlights the complex emotions and difficult decisions that arise as family members inevitably deteriorate.

The author's paternal grandfather, who was suffering from severe emphysema, was the recipient of unwavering care and assistance provided by his relatives.

The narrative illustrates how Charlie Jr.'s emphysema profoundly steered the family's course as the disease progressed relentlessly. Doig, through his own research and consultations with various medical experts, provides a moving and at times harrowing portrayal of his father's struggle for every breath, the disease's impact in diminishing his once-strong body to a fragile semblance, and the way it limited his cherished activities in the natural world.

The author embarked on a comprehensive search to ensure the best medical care for his parents.

Faced with the devastating diagnosis, Doig immersed himself in researching emphysema, seeking to understand its course and explore potential treatments. He consulted with various specialists, weighing various options, driven by the need to preserve the hopeful outlook of his dad yet also provide an honest assessment of the medical condition. Conversations often proved challenging, marked by the differing perspectives on illness and its consequences that his father and grandmother maintained.

Doig, while championing the most effective medical treatments, also wrestled with the constraints of medical knowledge, acknowledging that emphysema was incurable and that every medical procedure came with its unique complications and hazards. He wrestled with the difficult decision of whether to seek aggressive medical treatments for his father or to accept the limitations of the illness and focus on making his father's final days as fulfilling as possible.

Context

• During the time period when Doig was likely seeking care, treatment options for emphysema were limited, focusing mainly on symptom management rather than cure.
• Patients are often advised to quit smoking, avoid lung irritants, and maintain a healthy lifestyle, including regular exercise and a balanced diet, to help manage the disease.
• Weighing treatment options involves considering the potential benefits and side effects, the progression of the disease, and the patient's quality of life.
• Patients with chronic illnesses may experience anxiety, depression, or denial, which can affect their outlook on treatment and prognosis. Supporting a hopeful outlook involves addressing these psychological aspects through counseling or support groups.
• Personal experiences with healthcare, either positive or negative, can shape how individuals view medical advice and treatment options, leading to differing opinions within a family.
• The damage caused by emphysema is irreversible, and the disease typically progresses over time, leading to a gradual decline in lung function.
• In chronic conditions, patient-centered care emphasizes the patient's quality of life and personal preferences, which can sometimes mean opting for less aggressive treatments to avoid unnecessary suffering.
• The choice between aggressive treatment and palliative care can raise ethical questions about prolonging life versus ensuring dignity and comfort in a patient's final days.
• This approach often includes holistic methods such as music therapy, art, or other activities that bring joy and comfort, tailored to the individual's preferences and interests.

The decline of his father's health and subsequent passing presented both emotional and practical difficulties.

Witnessing his father's declining well-being was a challenging time for Doig, profoundly influencing his emotions and daily existence. He was balancing the progression of his professional life while also taking on the increasing duties of caring for his father. Doig found it increasingly difficult to assess his father's well-being and provide solace during their lengthy telephone conversations as the tension escalated. His father's fleeting moments of energy were overshadowed by his ongoing struggle to breathe during their journey to Montana.

Ivan Doig's candid account of his father's final period of life reveals the profound emotional toll associated with observing the deterioration of a beloved family member who is battling a grave illness. He depicts the arduous everyday responsibilities of administering medication, providing his father with oxygen, and endeavoring to maintain a semblance of normalcy, all while coming to terms with the unavoidable decline of his father's health. These personal encounters provide a broad contemplation on the intricacies of mourning, bereavement, and the persistent connections that tie kin together.

Context

• As health declines, communication can become strained, with conversations often focusing on health updates rather than personal or meaningful exchanges.
• Balancing these responsibilities would require exceptional time management skills, as caregiving can be unpredictable and demanding, often requiring immediate attention.
• Without visual cues, it can be challenging to assess physical symptoms or emotional states, which are often more apparent when face-to-face.
• Breathing difficulties in elderly individuals can be symptomatic of various health conditions, such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) or heart failure, which require careful management and can be worsened by travel.
• Watching a loved one suffer can lead to feelings of helplessness, anxiety, and anticipatory grief, which is the mourning that occurs before an impending loss.
• Attempting to maintain normalcy in such situations can involve continuing daily routines, engaging in familiar activities, and providing emotional support to help the patient feel more at ease despite their condition.
• The role of a caregiver, especially for a terminally ill family member, can lead to emotional exhaustion, stress, and a deepened sense of responsibility, affecting one's mental health and family dynamics.

The author's matriarch faced her own health challenges with steadfast resilience and determination.

Bessie Ringer's remarkable resilience could not forever shield her from the inevitable challenges that come with aging and personal health issues. Her steadfast dedication to her ailing partner never wavered, but the sorrow stemming from the loss of her daughter, combined with ongoing worries for her grandson, ultimately led to her experiencing a heart attack.

The author played a pivotal role in assisting his grandmother to preserve her self-sufficiency.

Doig became more involved in caring for his grandmother following her heart attack, carefully maintaining a balance between honoring her strong self-sufficiency and recognizing her increased need for help. Doig discovered ways to lighten the burden of household chores and provided activities that reinforced her feeling of importance, recognizing her natural desire to stay busy in spite of limitations imposed by her health. She became involved in organizing index cards for his writing projects, which engaged her mind while allowing her body to rest.

Doig suggested she join a club for seniors, offering her companionship after her partner died. He also nurtured her burgeoning passion for creating quilts, recognizing it as a satisfying outlet for her creative energy and a reliable way to strengthen her connections with family members and the wider community.

Practical Tips

• Develop a simple home modification checklist to enhance the safety and accessibility for someone with limited mobility. Walk through their living space and note areas that could be improved, such as adding grab bars in the bathroom, securing loose rugs to prevent slips, or rearranging furniture to create clear pathways. Implement these changes gradually, prioritizing the most critical areas first.
• Create a "Help-Offer Checklist" to use when you're with someone who values their independence but may need assistance. On this checklist, include non-intrusive questions and actions that respect the person's autonomy while subtly offering support. For example, instead of asking, "Do you need help?" you might say, "I'm heading to the kitchen, can I bring something for you?"
• You can delegate one small household task each week to another family member or a friend to lighten your load and foster a sense of community. Start with something simple like watering plants or setting the table for dinner. This not only gives you a break but also helps others feel involved and needed, which can strengthen relationships.
• Create a mobile "task gallery" by hanging index cards with tasks on a string with clothespins in your workspace. As you complete tasks, remove the cards, creating a dynamic and satisfying visual representation of your accomplishments. This can serve as a daily reminder of your progress and motivate you to keep moving forward.
• Start a hobby that involves group participation, such as a dance class, cooking workshops, or a local sports league. Engaging in a shared activity can create a sense of camaraderie and provide regular opportunities to meet and bond with new people.
• Organize a quilt-themed book club with friends or community members. Choose books that feature quilting or creativity as a central theme and discuss them in a group setting. This can foster a sense of community and provide new insights and inspiration for your quilting projects.

The author was engulfed by profound grief and a substantial void following the passing of his maternal elder.

The depiction of the transition of Doig's grandmother is profoundly touching, reflecting a calm acceptance of the natural course of life. He recounts the story of her last day in a direct way, emphasizing the enduring strength of her spirit as an homage. From spending her morning working on a quilt to attending a funeral coffee hour and then preparing for a card game with friends, her final hours were spent engaged in the routines of a life filled with purpose and connection.

Despite his efforts to prepare for the loss, the author's profound grief is clearly evident in his writing. During the peaceful reflection of her final day and the dignity of her interment, Doig conveys profound grief, acknowledging that her passing has broken a connection to a vital and distinctive part of his heritage. However, he also recognizes that her unwavering strength, constant warmth, and vibrant determination will continue to shape his character for years to come.

Context

• The presence of a supportive community can be crucial in navigating grief. Shared memories and communal rituals can help in processing the loss and finding solace.
• The calm acceptance of death can be a coping mechanism for dealing with loss, allowing individuals to focus on celebrating the life and legacy of the deceased rather than solely on their absence.
• Quilting can symbolize the weaving together of life’s experiences and relationships. The grandmother’s work on a quilt may represent her ongoing influence and the legacy she leaves behind.
• Card games are a form of social interaction that fosters camaraderie, mental engagement, and relaxation. They often serve as a way to maintain friendships and community ties.
• Authors often use their writing as a means to process and express complex emotions, such as grief, which can add depth and authenticity to their narratives.
• Grandparents often serve as emotional anchors in families, offering stability and wisdom, which can be deeply felt when they are gone.
• The grandmother's strength and determination could serve as a model for emotional resilience, teaching the author how to cope with adversity and loss.