PDF Summary:There Are Moms Way Worse Than You, by Glenn Boozan

Every new parent is consumed by worry—from the mundane fear of burping their baby incorrectly to the far-fetched anxiety about their child tumbling off a cliff. In There Are Moms Way Worse Than You, Glenn Boozan reassures parents that their concerns are normal, but also that perfection in parenting is neither achievable nor necessary.

The book presents humorous examples of shockingly poor parenting from the animal kingdom as a reminder that human parents' occasional mistakes pale in comparison. Boozan's message is that what really matters is the love and care behind your parenting efforts, not striving for an impossible ideal of perfection.

(continued)...

Parents of certain carrion beetles might decrease their brood size by selectively eliminating some of the larvae when the accessible carcass is insufficient.

The writer illustrates that a certain type of beetle, known for its unique nurturing habits, tends to care for its young by utilizing the decomposing carcass of a lesser animal. The parents meticulously prepare this unique nursery by thoroughly sanitizing the remains and applying their secretions to inhibit decomposition. However, if space is limited within, the beetle mother will decisively thin out her brood to ensure the survival of the remaining offspring.

Other Perspectives

• The comparison between human and animal parenting may not be entirely valid due to the vast differences in consciousness, societal norms, and ethical considerations.
• What is considered "inadequate" parenting in animals may be a natural adaptive behavior necessary for survival, which does not translate to human moral and ethical standards.
• The book's focus on extreme cases of animal behavior might not provide a balanced view of the diversity of parenting strategies in the animal kingdom.
• The interpretation of animal behaviors as neglectful or detrimental is anthropomorphic and may not accurately reflect the intentions or the outcomes of these behaviors in their natural context.
• The use of extreme animal behaviors to alleviate human parenting anxieties could inadvertently minimize the importance of addressing genuine issues of neglect or abuse in human parenting.
• The suggestion that mother hamsters eat their offspring due to nutrient deficiencies or stress does not consider the full range of biological and evolutionary factors that may influence this behavior.
• The portrayal of giraffe mothers as inadvertently injuring their offspring may overlook the possibility that such nudging is a carefully evolved strategy that maximizes the calf's chances of survival.
• The description of the Dracula ant queen's feeding habits may fail to acknowledge the complex social structures of ant colonies and the role that such behaviors play in the overall health of the colony.
• The depiction of carrion beetle parenting strategies may not take into account the potential benefits of brood reduction for the long-term survival of the species under resource-constrained conditions.

Bad Parenting Practices by Animal Fathers

The book highlights examples of fathers from various wildlife species who display neglect or harmful behavior towards their offspring.

In the world of wildlife parenting, Boozan implies that fathers are equally susceptible to parenting blunders as the so-called "bad moms" who typically face greater criticism. He presents several examples where paternal instincts seem to go awry, often with detrimental consequences for their offspring.

Fathers among pipefish restrict the sustenance given to their offspring, which guarantees that only the strongest survive, while they assimilate the ones less equipped to survive.

Consider the pipefish, which shares a close kinship with the seahorse. While male seahorses are recognized for their commitment to child-rearing, fathers among the pipefish species appear to prioritize practicality over caregiving. The marsupial's body pouch functions as a means of transport for their young, but it favors the more robust embryos, resulting in the demise and reabsorption of the less resilient ones. Essentially, they engage in a form of pre-emptive natural selection, ensuring that only the fittest offspring survive.

Male horses occasionally engage in violent behavior, targeting and eliminating offspring sired by other stallions, regardless of whether there is uncertainty about their own paternity.

Horses, despite their seemingly gentle nature, can also exhibit shockingly brutal parenting behaviors, particularly the males. Male horses sometimes commit infanticide against foals they believe could be the progeny of competing males. This act, while seemingly cruel, is rooted in a biological imperative to ensure the survival of their own genes. By removing rivals, they enhance the chances that their young will receive their domain and assets.

Male poison dart frogs carry moisture to their offspring using their cloaca to prevent desiccation, yet this is the limit of their nurturing behavior.

Finally, we have the male dart-poison frog. While not overtly abusive, their approach to fatherhood could best be described as "minimal effort." The main responsibility of these caregivers is to ensure the young's initial state remains hydrated, accomplished by delivering water to the eggs through their cloaca, an all-in-one opening that functions as their anus and urethra.

Other Perspectives

• The behaviors of male pipefish, horses, and poison dart frogs may not be "blunders" but rather evolved strategies that increase the likelihood of their offspring's survival in their specific environments.
• Infanticide in male horses could be seen as a strategy to ensure that resources are not wasted on offspring that do not carry their genes, which from an evolutionary standpoint, could be considered a rational behavior.
• The limited nurturing behavior of male poison dart frogs might be perfectly adapted to the needs of their offspring and the ecological niche they occupy, rather than a sign of neglect.
• The term "bad parenting" is anthropomorphic and may not accurately reflect the complexities of survival strategies in the animal kingdom.
• The behaviors described could be the result of complex evolutionary pressures that favor these strategies over what humans might consider more nurturing approaches.
• The examples provided may not represent the full spectrum of paternal care in these species, and there could be instances where males exhibit more nurturing behaviors than mentioned.
• The concept of "bad moms" and "bad dads" in the animal kingdom is a human moral judgment that may not be applicable or relevant to non-human species.

The essence of parenting lies in the commitment demonstrated, and the notion that one can be a flawless parent is unattainable.

The book's purpose is to comfort caregivers by affirming that their sincere attempts place them ahead of numerous animal parents in terms of care.

After presenting a variety of dubious parenting methods observed in the natural world, Boozan reassures readers that what truly counts is the motivation behind their actions. He comforts caregivers by recognizing that mistakes and feelings of being swamped are part of the journey, and if nurturing their children's well-being is their foremost aim and they are sincerely dedicated to fostering a nurturing atmosphere, they are indeed performing admirably.

Parents who doubt their adequacy or commit errors can take comfort in the fact that the natural world abounds with examples of parenting that are significantly more flawed.

He encourages readers to find humor in these outrageous animal parenting strategies and, more importantly, to use them as a point of comparison when self-doubt starts to creep in. Even a hamster can overcome the instinct to eat its young, which suggests that a human caregiver can likewise forgive themselves for occasionally losing their temper or resorting to incentives to secure their child's cooperation.

The book celebrates "mediocre" parenting and encourages parents to embrace the imperfect, chaotic nature of raising children, rather than striving for an unattainable ideal.

Boozan reassures readers that the quest for parental perfection is futile and urges them to release themselves from such burdens. Instead of striving for an unattainable ideal, he encourages them to embrace the imperfections and find humor in the chaos that inevitably comes with raising children. In his view, "mediocre" parenting, where mistakes are expected and learning happens along the way, is not something to fear but rather a reflection of a healthy, loving, and realistic family dynamic.

Ultimately, the book imparts the wisdom that what is genuinely important is the aspiration to look after and provide for your children, rather than achieving flawlessness.

Boozan concludes his book by reiterating his central message: what truly matters in parenting is not achieving some unattainable standard of perfection, but rather the unwavering love, care, and intention behind every decision a parent makes. He comforts those starting the path of raising children by affirming that beginning with affection and a genuine commitment to their offspring's development sets them on the right path, despite the possibility of minor missteps along the way.

Other Perspectives

• While commitment is crucial, striving for excellence in parenting can lead to better outcomes for children, even if perfection is unattainable.
• Comparing human parenting to animal parenting may oversimplify the complex nature of human child-rearing and the unique challenges it presents.
• Emphasizing "mediocre" parenting might inadvertently lower standards or excuse neglectful behavior, rather than promoting a balanced approach that acknowledges imperfection but still encourages improvement.
• Encouraging humor in the face of parenting flaws can be beneficial, but it should not replace the need for reflection and learning from mistakes.
• Embracing imperfections and chaos can help reduce stress, but it's also important to provide structure and consistency for children's development.
• While it's true that striving for perfection can be futile, setting high standards can motivate parents to seek resources and support that improve their parenting skills.
• Focusing solely on providing for children might overlook the importance of emotional availability and the quality of the parent-child relationship.
• The concept of "mediocre" parenting could be seen as dismissive of the efforts of those who go above and beyond in their parenting role, potentially undervaluing their dedication.