PDF Summary:The WSJ Guide to the 50 Economic Indicators That Really Matter, by Simon Constable and Robert E. Wright

In this modern economic landscape, understanding key financial indicators is crucial. In The WSJ Guide to the 50 Economic Indicators That Really Matter, authors Simon Constable and Robert E. Wright provide an insightful overview of the essential economic metrics to analyze. The guide examines domestic consumer spending, business investment, trade dynamics, and global factors shaping financial conditions and policies.

Through detailed explanations and practical examples, the authors demonstrate how economic indicators like consumer sentiment, manufacturing activity, and inflation serve as valuable predictors of economic trends. They also emphasize the importance of integrating global measures to gain a comprehensive perspective on worldwide economic patterns and their impact on domestic markets.

(continued)...

The authors emphasize the significance of incorporating predictions about market trends when evaluating the weekly figures related to petroleum reserves. An unexpected increase in the amount of unsold goods might indicate that consumer demand is not as high as expected, while a rapid decline could suggest a greater level of economic activity than was originally considered, potentially influencing market reactions. Additionally, they note that exceptionally low interest rates may encourage speculative behaviors and the stockpiling of oil as a hedge against price increases, which can result in anomalies within the oil trading market. This event can temporarily alter the common trend of oil prices and stock values moving inversely, highlighting the need to consider the broader economic circumstances when assessing these economic measures.

The authors emphasize the significance of the Bank of Japan's quarterly Tankan Survey as a crucial tool for assessing the vigor of Japan's economy. They underscore that the survey compiles insights and predictions from corporate executives, providing a detailed overview of different sectors and the overall economic environment. The Diffusion Index from the survey, which implies expansion when it registers above zero and contraction when it falls below, acts as a potent predictor of economic growth in Japan.

The authors emphasize the unique significance of the Tankan Survey in contrast to other Japanese economic indicators. The authors emphasize that the trustworthiness of Japan's GDP data as an indicator of current and forthcoming economic trends is compromised by the regular and significant revisions it undergoes. The Tankan Survey is a reliable barometer of the business climate, providing a valuable tool for understanding the economic trends of Japan, a country with substantial impact on the global economic scene.

The TIC data acts as a barometer for global demand for U.S. financial assets and may signal impending changes in interest rates.

The authors highlight the importance of monitoring the flow of funds into and out of the United States via the Treasury International Capital (TIC) data, as it affects the pressure on interest rates and the attractiveness of U.S. securities to investors. The authors explain that a substantial flow of foreign capital into U.S. securities, particularly those issued by the government, often results in lower borrowing costs as the available amount of lendable funds increases. A global decline in interest for these securities could lead to increased borrowing costs for corporations and people due to a rise in interest rates.

The authors argue that the TIC data can provide valuable information about the worldwide appetite for U.S. assets, which may signal impending changes in the cost of borrowing. Despite indicators suggesting an upward trend, the persistent global appetite for U.S. Treasury bonds kept yields low, the authors note. The authors acknowledge the limitations concerning the timeliness of the Treasury International Capital data, yet they emphasize its significance in shedding light on the global demand for U.S. debt securities and its ability to forecast potential changes in interest rates.

Other Perspectives

• While consumer spending is significant, focusing solely on it may overlook other critical economic factors such as investment, government spending, and net exports, which also drive economic activity.
• Car sales as an economic indicator may not account for changes in consumer preferences, such as a shift towards more sustainable transportation options or the increasing use of ride-sharing services.
• Retail sales data from major companies may not fully represent the broader retail market, especially with the rise of e-commerce and small businesses.
• The relationship between home sales, underemployment, and consumer spending may not be straightforward due to various intervening factors like government policies, interest rates, and demographic changes.
• Business investment is a volatile and sometimes lagging indicator of economic health, and overemphasis on it could misrepresent the current state of the economy.
• The semiconductor order-to-ship ratio may not always accurately predict manufacturing demand due to rapid changes in technology and global supply chain dynamics.
• Copper prices as an indicator might not account for technological advancements and recycling efforts that can affect copper demand independently of economic activity.
• Durable goods orders and housing permits can be influenced by factors other than economic confidence, such as regulatory changes and natural disasters.
• Industrial production and capacity utilization figures may not capture the full scope of a country's economic health, especially as service sectors grow in importance.
• Surveys from the manufacturing and services sectors may suffer from biases or inaccuracies due to the subjective nature of the responses.
• Government spending's impact on economic growth and inflation can be complex, and the relationship is not always direct or immediate.
• Net exports may not fully capture the value of intellectual property and services, which are increasingly important in a digital economy.
• The Baltic Dry Index is subject to short-term volatility and may not always be a reliable predictor of long-term global economic trends.
• The Big Mac Index, while useful for illustrating purchasing power parity, may not account for local economic factors affecting the price of goods.
• Current account deficits might not always signal economic problems; they can also reflect a country's investment attractiveness and stage of development.
• The Tankan survey, while informative, is specific to Japan and may not always correlate with global economic conditions.
• TIC data is retrospective and may not provide real-time insights into the current state of international capital flows or immediate future trends.

A variety of metrics related to economics.

Integrating a range of data points and metrics provides a more comprehensive and nuanced view of the economic environment.

Indicators that offer a current glimpse of economic conditions and predict future economic trends.

Indicators provide crucial understanding of the economy's current condition and suggest potential directions it may take in the future. The authors recognize that a more complete and subtle grasp of economic changes can be achieved by incorporating a range of indicators.

The index known as Aruoba-Diebold-Scotti compiles various real-time economic indicators.

The book examines the Aruoba-Diebold-Scotti Business Conditions Index, developed by the Philadelphia Federal Reserve, emphasizing its importance as a simultaneous indicator for assessing the overall state of the American economic landscape. The index amalgamates a range of economic indicators such as data on quarterly production, employment figures, and manufacturing-related statistics into a cohesive gauge that undergoes frequent updates, sometimes even weekly.

The authors emphasize that the index offers assessments of economic conditions that are updated more frequently and are timelier than the conventional GDP figures released quarterly. The writers describe how the ADS Index incorporates information that is updated on an ongoing basis, which allows investors to detect changes in the economy in real-time, thereby offering a quicker insight into the state of the economy and circumventing the lag that comes with data released quarterly. The index values, which are adjusted to have an average of zero, serve as definitive signals of the prevailing economic climate, with readings above zero indicating expansion and those beneath zero signaling a contraction.

The survey conducted by the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia assesses manufacturing operations in a key region.

The authors emphasize the importance of the Business Outlook Survey by the Philadelphia Federal Reserve, highlighting its role as a key forecasting instrument for assessing the health of the manufacturing sector across eastern Pennsylvania, southern New Jersey, and Delaware. The survey gathers insights from regional manufacturing firms, encompassing a variety of metrics such as the volume of new orders, the amount of goods shipped, pending orders, the length of time for deliveries, inventory levels, production expenses, sales prices, employee numbers, average workweek length, and capital expenditures. This extensive dataset, conveyed through metrics that quantify the spread of data, equips investors with the instruments to scrutinize particular facets of manufacturing operations and leverage this insight to predict wider economic patterns.

The authors elucidate that despite the survey's limited geographical scope, its in-depth focus on a sector highly responsive to economic fluctuations bolsters its utility in forecasting broader economic patterns. They advise paying careful attention to the metric that tracks new orders because it often reflects manufacturers' expectations for future business endeavors. An increase in new orders could signal an upcoming surge in manufacturing production, which may suggest broader growth in the economy. The authors suggest closely monitoring the survey's six-month forecasts, which offer a glimpse into the confidence of regional manufacturers, even though these forecasts are more speculative than evidence-based.

Uncertainty and Risk

Grasping the nuances of uncertainty and the possibility of economic volatility is essential, as it sheds light on the general sentiment of investors and can predict future market movements. The authors detail specific indicators designed to more accurately gauge market sentiment, thereby assisting investors in making more informed decisions.

The VIX index functions as an indicator of market turbulence, reflecting investor apprehension levels.

The writers delve into the significance of the VIX, also referred to as the CBOE Volatility Index, as a tool for assessing fluctuations in the market and the moods of investors. They elucidate that the index, commonly known as the "fear index," reflects the expected volatility in the S&P 500, deduced from the pricing of options associated with it, highlighting its significance as a barometer of the U.S. stock market, with transactions occurring on the Chicago Board Options Exchange. High VIX readings suggest a growing concern among investors, who anticipate larger fluctuations in market prices, signifying an elevated perception of potential risk and the likelihood of significant price changes. Conversely, lower VIX values suggest a more tranquil market atmosphere, indicating that traders are less anxious and anticipate reduced volatility in the market.

The writers emphasize the significance of utilizing the VIX to predict future market movements. An increase in the Volatility Index often signals upcoming market downturns, indicative of increased investor concern regarding the economic future or specific events that could lead to a decline in stock values. While they caution against using VIX for short-term options trading, they suggest that a substantial one-day increase in the index exceeding 20% could signal opportunities to acquire equities at reduced prices, anticipating a subsequent rebound in the market.

The state of the economy is gauged by observing the clothing worn by service staff in the vicinity.

The final indicator among the Fantastic 50, known as the VIXEN index, provides a distinctive and insightful view of the economic landscape, focusing especially on the service sector. This gauge evaluates the allure of personnel in local eateries, utilizing this criterion to signify the availability of better-compensated roles that prioritize physical appeal. The authors emphasize the importance of fostering unconventional thinking to gain a unique insight into the workings of the economy.

In times of economic growth, those considered attractive tend to obtain higher-paying jobs that value appearance, while those seen as less attractive may find employment in local eateries. Economic downturns result in fewer available high-paying positions, intensifying the race for ordinary service jobs and consequently increasing the need for roles like wait staff. While acknowledging the subjective nature of "attractiveness," they suggest devising a personalized index that tracks the appeal of local service workers, which reflects shifts in the employment landscape of the service sector. The fundamental goal of this distinctive metric is to motivate investors to employ their creativity in developing fresh viewpoints and metrics that enhance their understanding of the intricacies of the economy.

Other Perspectives

• While integrating a range of data points can provide a comprehensive view, it can also lead to information overload and conflicting signals that may confuse rather than clarify economic conditions.
• Indicators may offer insights into current conditions, but their ability to predict future trends is not guaranteed due to the complex and often unpredictable nature of economic systems.
• The Aruoba-Diebold-Scotti Business Conditions Index, while useful, may not capture all relevant aspects of the economy, and its real-time data could be subject to revisions or inaccuracies.
• The ADS Index's frequent updates are beneficial, but they may also reflect short-term volatility rather than long-term trends, leading to potential overreactions in the market.
• The Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia's Business Outlook Survey has a limited geographical scope, which may not be representative of the national manufacturing sector.
• The survey's reliance on self-reported data from manufacturers could introduce bias or inaccuracies, as responses may be influenced by individual perceptions or company interests.
• Understanding uncertainty and economic volatility is important, but the indicators available may not fully capture the complexity of market sentiment or the myriad factors that contribute to economic fluctuations.
• The VIX index, while a popular measure of market volatility, is based on options pricing and may not always accurately reflect true market sentiment or the likelihood of future market movements.
• High VIX readings might indicate investor concern, but they can also be the result of speculative trading or external events that do not necessarily relate to fundamental economic conditions.
• Lower VIX values suggesting a calmer market atmosphere could be misleading if they are the result of complacency or a lack of awareness of underlying economic issues.
• The VIXEN index's use of the appearance of service staff as an economic indicator is highly subjective and may not be a reliable or ethical measure of economic conditions.
• The assumption that economic growth leads to higher-paying jobs based on attractiveness is a simplification that ignores other factors such as education, skills, and experience.
• The VIXEN index's focus on the service sector may overlook significant trends in other sectors of the economy that are equally or more important for understanding economic conditions.

Worldwide financial conditions and fiscal policies shape results.

Economic policies are pivotal in molding the broader economic environment, which in turn greatly affects trade, capital movements, and the valuation of currencies. Investors must carefully examine these factors to understand how they shape investment decisions and the general trends within the marketplace.

Anxiety over escalating costs, unease, and skepticism.

The authors outline three potent dynamics capable of triggering significant disturbances in financial markets, which in turn can adversely impact the performance of investments over a prolonged timeframe: inflation, fear, and uncertainty. Investors can anticipate potential risks, adjust their investment approaches, and might also uncover hidden opportunities by keeping an eye on specific measures that mirror these aspects.

The Misery Index, in conjunction with the GDP deflator and the cost of gold, serves as an indicator for gauging the strength of inflationary pressures.

The authors stress the significance of a particular inflation metric, which derives from the variations in prices of the entire spectrum of goods and services that constitute the Gross Domestic Product, in assessing the inflationary direction of the economy. They emphasize its advantage over the commonly cited Consumer Price Index (CPI) because it encompasses a broader range of economic activities and offers more uniform comparisons across various nations. The GDP deflator assesses inflation by considering the price changes of all domestically produced goods and services, providing an assessment that is more comprehensive than the CPI, which focuses on a set selection of consumer goods.

The writers recommend using the GDP deflator to evaluate and compare the pace of price increases among various countries, particularly in the context of analyzing currency markets. The authors suggest that a nation experiencing a rise in inflation, as reflected by the GDP deflator, will likely see its currency's value decline relative to that of countries with less inflation. Acknowledging that using this metric exclusively to predict changes in the value of currency could fall short because of factors such as governmental interference in currency markets, the authors consider the measure that excludes the impact of unstable prices to be a valuable tool for understanding inflation trends and their potential impact on worldwide currency values.

Gold acts as an indicator of economic and geopolitical unrest, reflecting investor sentiment and their inclination towards secure investments during times of uncertainty. During periods of robust economic growth, stable inflation, and few international disputes, the appeal of gold as a stable investment often wanes, resulting in lower prices for the precious metal. During times of economic instability, market volatility, or widespread doubt, investors often seek refuge in gold, viewing it as a stable investment, which usually leads to a rise in its price. The authors argue that variations in gold prices are a vital gauge for gauging investor sentiment and the overall sense of risk in the world's economic and political spheres.

The authors emphasize the correlation between substantial increases in the value of gold and key global occurrences such as the collapse of the dot-com bubble, the decline of the U.S. housing market, the worldwide financial turmoil, and ongoing geopolitical tensions, reflecting the escalating concerns of investors about the steadiness of the economic and political climates.

The Misery Index, which combines unemployment and inflation rates to assess societal economic challenges, is characterized by Constable and Wright as a crucial measure of economic and social well-being. Elevated and increasing MI values indicate widespread economic distress, especially affecting individuals with lower earnings and constrained financial assets. This particular metric reflects not only current economic challenges but also has the potential to predict political and social unrest that could influence election outcomes and guide the formation of government policies.

The Index of Producer Prices serves as a precursor to forthcoming trends in consumer pricing.

Constable and Wright's book characterizes the Producer Price Index (PPI) as an early indicator that tracks fluctuations in the prices of goods sold by domestic manufacturers, mainly to retailers, and posits that it may foreshadow subsequent shifts in consumer prices, as indicated by the Consumer Price Index (CPI). The authors argue that by closely examining fluctuations in the index that tracks producer prices, one can gain insights into the economic pressures faced by companies, which could ultimately influence the costs incurred by consumers. An ongoing upward trend in the Producer Price Index across several months frequently indicates forthcoming inflation that will impact the prices for consumers, since businesses usually pass on the higher costs of production to their clientele. A decrease in the Producer Price Index may signal the onset of an economic slump or deflation, leading businesses to lower their prices to stay competitive in the market.

The authors suggest focusing on the "core" PPI, which excludes the volatile prices of food and energy, to more precisely identify consistent trends. To identify meaningful patterns and reduce fluctuations, they recommend analyzing the Producer Price Index's average annual growth rate over a span of three to five months. Market observers can anticipate potential shifts in the economic environment by monitoring the ebb and flow of Producer Price Index (PPI) movements, which allows them to adjust their investment strategies accordingly in anticipation of inflationary impacts.

Variations in retail investment and the disparity in credit spreads are indicative of the confidence level of investors and their inclination towards more speculative endeavors.

The authors suggest tracking the flow of capital as it is allocated by individual investors across different investment vehicles, particularly mutual funds, to identify potential changes in market directions. Retail investors, often lacking the sophisticated resources and knowledge that institutional investors possess, tend to acquire assets at peak values and sell them following significant drops in value. This conduct, which involves purchasing at elevated prices and offloading at reduced ones, can offer significant understanding of market emotions and prospective price trends.

The authors clarify that monitoring the movement of funds into and out of mutual funds, which reflects the investment patterns of individual investors, enables the identification of assets that are attracting significant attention and investment from these individuals. A significant surge of investment into a specific category of assets, along with robust recent increases in value, may indicate that the market is nearing a high point, which could precede a decline and imply that caution is warranted. A significant exit of funds from a specific type of investments after a period of disappointing returns could indicate that the valuation has bottomed out, signaling a potential buying opportunity. The authors recommend combining these statistics with additional economic metrics and a fundamental analysis to evaluate the dependability of contrarian indicators.

Wright and his co-author stress that the differences in yield across different corporate bond ratings act as a precursor to shifts in the economy. They explain that wider credit spreads indicate a heightened perception of risk among bond investors, reflected in higher borrowing costs for riskier companies. Investors inclined toward risk-taking often demonstrate their economic optimism by accepting slimmer credit spreads, which can lead to increased investment activities.

The difference in yields from Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities compared to other investment options provides insight into credit conditions and expected inflation rates.

By analyzing the difference between the yields on three-month U.S. Treasury bills and the rates for three-month London Interbank Offered Rate, Constable and Wright evaluate the TED spread's effectiveness in forecasting the state of credit accessibility and the level of stress in the financial sector. The TED spread serves as a barometer for tension in the market where banks lend to each other, highlighting the variance in interest rates they impose on one another, which signifies a drop in trust among financial institutions when there is a significant increase. Conversely, a narrow TED spread signifies that the market for interbank lending is robust and typically reflects advantageous conditions for credit.

The authors argue that monitoring the TED spread, which is the variance between the interest rates of Treasury bills and Eurodollar rates, serves as a dependable approach for assessing the stability of the financial system and pinpointing potential economic risks. A widening gap in the TED spread could signal tightening credit conditions, difficulties in obtaining financing, and a possible slowdown in economic expansion. A narrowing TED spread often indicates easing credit conditions, as banks demonstrate an increased willingness to provide loans, potentially foreshadowing a betterment in the broader economic climate.

The authors introduce the TIPS spread, which represents the difference between yields on regular U.S. Treasury bonds and Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS), as a leading indicator reflecting bond market investors' expectations for future inflation. TIPS protect the returns for investors against inflation by adjusting the principal and interest payments to reflect changes in the Consumer Price Index. The yield gap between Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities and standard Treasury bonds reflects the premium investors are willing to pay for protection against inflation, thus providing a measure of inflation expectations derived from the market.

The authors emphasize the importance of analyzing the difference in yields between Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities and regular Treasury bonds to gauge investor attitudes and anticipate shifts in monetary policy. The authors suggest that a persistent TIPS spread signaling annual inflation expectations exceeding 2% could signal an impending rise in interest rates by the Federal Reserve to temper inflation, potentially affecting outcomes in the government securities market. Anticipations of inflation dipping under the 2% mark might signal a transition to a more accommodating monetary stance, potentially leading to a preference for equities and commodities.

Global Factors

Understanding the global economy's interplay and its influence on domestic markets is crucial for those investing in them. The authors emphasize the significance of integrating information and metrics from international sources to deepen the comprehension of worldwide economic trends and their impact on domestic financial markets.

The Tankan survey offers a glimpse into the robustness of Japan's economic health.

The Bank of Japan compiles and distributes the Tankan Survey, which serves as a detailed measure of the country's economic environment, by collecting perspectives and predictions from executives across different industries. The survey offers an insightful examination of Japan's economic landscape, recognized as the world's third-largest, by delving into various economic aspects including market conditions, future expectations, pricing trends, commercial transactions, workforce statistics, and currency valuation. The publication of the report occurs every three months.

The writers emphasize the importance of the Tankan Survey as a predictive tool, providing reliable preliminary signals of Japan's economic expansion and contractions before the official GDP figures are published. They argue that the indicator's significant accuracy and timeliness stem from its ability to mirror the expectations of business leaders, who often make their decisions based on their forecasts regarding the direction of the economy, thereby providing a forward-looking perspective on economic health. Investors can utilize the insights provided by the Tankan to assess investment opportunities in Japan, particularly for those who are keen on investing in Japanese stocks or assets that are closely linked to the nation's economic health, as the book's authors indicate.

The interest and value of the U.S. dollar, along with current interest rates, are influenced by the level of international investment in U.S. assets, which is tracked through data on Treasury International Capital.

Constable and Wright discuss TIC data, which tracks cross-border investments in U.S. securities and other financial assets, as a crucial indicator for understanding foreign demand for U.S. assets and its influence on interest rates and the dollar. The authors clarify that a strong worldwide appetite for these assets can result in lower interest rates because of the increased availability of capital for lending, potentially spurring economic growth. A reduction in foreign investment could result in elevated interest rates along with a diminished value of the dollar, potentially slowing down the pace of economic expansion.

The writers emphasize the importance of analyzing data on Treasury International Capital to anticipate potential changes in the value of the U.S. dollar and shifts in interest rates due to the transfer of capital across countries. A steady rise in global investments in U.S. assets might signal a movement towards reduced interest rates and a strengthened dollar, while a continuous decline in these investments might point to an increased probability of interest rates climbing and a decline in the dollar's worth. Investment attractiveness within the United States can be significantly influenced by these trends, potentially guiding investment decisions on both a domestic and international scale and impacting the general dynamics of the financial markets.

Context

• The Misery Index is an economic indicator that combines the unemployment rate and the inflation rate to provide insight into the overall economic condition of a country. It is used to gauge the level of economic hardship experienced by the population. A higher Misery Index value indicates more economic distress, while a lower value suggests a healthier economy. The index can also be used to predict potential social and political unrest based on economic conditions.
• The GDP deflator is a measure that compares the nominal GDP to the real GDP to reflect the overall price level changes in an economy over time. It is different from the Consumer Price Index (CPI) as it considers all goods and services produced domestically. The GDP deflator helps in understanding the inflation or deflation of an economy by adjusting for changes in the price of goods and services. It is a crucial indicator used in economic analysis to assess the true growth or contraction of an economy.
• A Consumer Price Index (CPI) is a measure that tracks the average change over time in prices paid by consumers for a basket of goods and services. It helps gauge inflation by reflecting how much more consumers are paying for the same items. The CPI is calculated based on a representative basket of goods and services commonly purchased by households. It is a key economic indicator used to assess changes in the cost of living and inflation rates.
• The Producer Price Index (PPI) measures the average changes in prices received by domestic producers for their output. It includes various sectors like manufacturing, mining, agriculture, and more. The index helps track inflationary pressures at the producer level before they reach consumers. The PPI is calculated by comparing current prices to a base period and is used to understand trends in production costs and pricing strategies.
• The TED spread is the difference between the interest rates on interbank loans and short-term U.S. government debt. It is used as an indicator of perceived credit risk in the economy, reflecting changes in liquidity and counterparty risk. A rising TED spread can signal potential downturns in the stock market. The spread is typically measured in basis points and fluctuates over time.
• Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS) are U.S. government bonds designed to protect investors against inflation. The principal value of TIPS adjusts with changes in the Consumer Price Index (CPI). This adjustment ensures that the bond's value keeps pace with inflation, providing investors with a hedge against rising prices. TIPS pay interest every six months based on a fixed rate applied to the adjusted principal value.
• The Tankan survey is a key economic indicator in Japan conducted by the Bank of Japan every three months. It gathers insights from business leaders across various industries to provide a comprehensive view of Japan's economic landscape, including market conditions, pricing trends, and workforce statistics. The survey offers early signals of economic expansions or contractions, aiding investors in assessing opportunities in Japanese stocks and assets tied to the country's economic health.
• Treasury International Capital (TIC) data tracks the flow of money into and out of the United States by monitoring cross-border investments in U.S. securities and other financial assets. This data is crucial for understanding foreign demand for U.S. assets, influencing interest rates and the value of the U.S. dollar. Analyzing TIC data helps anticipate changes in the dollar's value and interest rates based on the movement of capital across countries. It provides insights into how global investments in U.S. assets impact economic conditions and investment decisions.