PDF Summary:The Way of the Samurai, by Inazo Nitobe

In The Way of the Samurai, Inazo Nitobe explores the deeply influential Bushidō, the ethical and moral code that governed Japan's samurai warrior class. Rooted in an amalgam of philosophical traditions, including Buddhism, Shinto, and Confucianism, Bushidō emphasized rectitude, courage, benevolence, sincerity, loyalty, and honor. Though arising during Japan's feudal era, the ideals of Bushidō resonated with Japanese society at large, shaping the nation's culture and collective identity.

While containing elements that may seem shocking to Western audiences—ritual suicide, blood revenge—Bushidō sought to cultivate both physical and moral strength. Nitobe explores Bushidō's complex interplay of martial prowess and compassion, teaching restraint as well as decisive action. He examines Bushidō's far-reaching legacy in Japan and ponders its continued relevance amidst rapidly-changing values brought on by modernization and Westernization.

(continued)...

Practical Tips

• Host a minimalist-themed gathering where the emphasis is on the experience rather than the decor. Invite friends or family over for a simple meal or tea, using plain but elegant dishware, and engage in meaningful conversation or enjoy a shared activity like listening to music or playing a board game. This encourages appreciation of the company and conversation, rather than the usual focus on elaborate entertainment or decorations.
• You can create a minimalist art piece for your living space that captures the essence of simplicity and elegance. Start by choosing a single, striking image or symbol that resonates with you. Use a plain, solid-colored background to make the image stand out, and frame it in a simple, unadorned frame. Hang this piece in a focal area of your room to draw attention and create a space of visual calm.
• Engage in a weekly "art of decluttering" session in your living space. By methodically organizing and simplifying your surroundings, you can practice the discipline of maintaining order and purpose in your environment. This activity not only improves your living space but also trains your mind to focus on what's essential, reflecting the authentic self-cultivation through rigorous self-discipline.

Samurai Training and Lifestyle

Samurai Received Rigorous Education Emphasizing Physical and Ethical Growth

Samurai Training Included Martial Arts, Horsemanship, Practical Skills, Classical Studies, and Philosophical Thought

Nitobe delves into the rigorous training regimen of samurai, explaining how it was meticulously designed to cultivate both physical prowess and moral character. The author insists that developing character was paramount while "wisdom, intelligence, and reasoning" were less emphasized. While "intellectual superiority was, naturally, valued," it was only sought after insofar as it aided in the development of virtue.

The program included martial arts like fencing, archery, and jiujutsu, an art that uses anatomical insight for both attack and defense. Horsemanship, spear handling, and military tactics were also deemed essential. According to Nitobe, Bushido demanded more than mere proficiency in warfare, however, so the curriculum also emphasized the arts of calligraphy, which expressed personal character, along with the serious study of ethical philosophy, literary works, and historical events. Because for the Samurai, as for Socrates, knowledge should not be pursued for its own sake, but for how it can be practically applied in life and as a method of cultivating wisdom, this training blended the practical, aesthetic, and moral.

Context

• The development of these martial arts was influenced by the constant warfare in Japan during the feudal period, necessitating a highly skilled warrior class.
• The integration of these aspects aimed to create a well-rounded individual who was not only skilled in combat but also cultured and morally upright, embodying the ideal of a "gentleman warrior."

Other Perspectives

• Overemphasizing character development might lead to undervaluing the importance of critical thinking and knowledge, which are necessary for adapting to new challenges.
• Military tactics are undoubtedly important, but their application and relevance would vary greatly depending on the specific historical context and the nature of the conflicts faced by the samurai.
• The skill of calligraphy, while aesthetically pleasing, may not have a direct impact on the moral or ethical decisions a person makes, which are also critical components of character.
• The interpretation of what constitutes ethical philosophy and valuable literary works could be subjective, with different clans or teachers emphasizing different texts and teachings.
• Wisdom is not only cultivated through practical application but also through contemplation, introspection, and the exploration of abstract concepts that may not have direct practical use.

Samurai Lifestyle: Frugality, Loyalty, Commitment to Bushido Code

Nitobe underscores the importance of frugality in the Samurai lifestyle, insisting that seeking wealth was deemed incompatible with the quest for honor. He emphasizes that while intellect was valued, it was viewed as secondary to moral feelings, for both humanity and the cosmos were considered to be ethical and spiritual. The author points out that mathematics was noticeably absent from samurai training, primarily because their rigorous moral code discouraged them from concerning themselves with financial matters.

Samurai lived by the maxim, "ambition…chooses loss over a gain that tarnishes." Nitobe notes how, like Don Quixote, who feels prouder of his meager equipment and decrepit steed than of wealth and property, the Samurai scorned the pursuit of riches and viewed money itself with a degree of disdain. Religious figures or the lower classes handled financial affairs. Samurai, even those who governed, were expected to live austerely, often embracing voluntary poverty and eschewing luxury. The author claims this disdain for materialism largely explains the long-observed lack of financial corruption among Japan’s leaders, and he laments how the insidious advance of government by the wealthy is threatening this noble tradition.

Other Perspectives

• The concept of honor is subjective and can be reconciled with wealth accumulation if done in a manner that does not compromise one's integrity or responsibilities.
• The prioritization of moral feelings above intellect might have contributed to a rigid social structure, where questioning or reforming the established moral code was discouraged, possibly leading to stagnation or resistance to beneficial change.
• The study of mathematics could have been seen as a way to develop mental discipline and abstract reasoning, qualities that are in line with the samurai's dedication to self-improvement and mastery of various arts.
• The idea that ambition should choose loss over gain might discourage innovation and risk-taking, which are often necessary for societal advancement and prosperity.
• The notion of samurai governance without luxury may overlook instances where samurai engaged in the patronage of the arts and supported artisans, which could be seen as a form of luxury spending.
• The effectiveness of a disdain for materialism in preventing corruption might not translate to contemporary society, where the complexities of global finance and the influence of money in politics present challenges that differ from those faced by samurai-era leaders.
• The evolution of government may reflect the changing needs and complexities of society, which could require different skill sets and resources, including those provided by wealthy individuals.

Seppuku and Kataki-Uchi Sanctioned by the Honor Code of Bushido

Seppuku: Atoning or Avoiding Dishonor Through Ceremonial Suicide

Nitobe addresses the controversial subjects of seppuku and kataki-uchi, two practices unique to the Bushido code that might appear barbaric to outside observers. The author carefully analyzes this “self-immolation by disembowelment," highlighting that the practice was deeply rooted in ancient anatomical beliefs about the abdomen as the location of the soul, allowing a samurai to demonstrate the purity or lack thereof within his own being. Nitobe insists that the Western reader should not find this any more strange than the words Shakespeare gives to Brutus, who speaks of Caesar’s spirit turning swords "into our proper entrails.”

Rather than a random act of suicide, Nitobe insists that seppuku, although seeming absurd on the surface, was “an institution, legal and ceremonial.” It served as a way for fighters to atone for their offenses, make amends for mistakes, avoid humiliation, vindicate their allies, or demonstrate their honesty. The author explains that because of the high value placed on honor, seppuku was sometimes chosen over a less honorable, but potentially more bearable death. He recounts the execution of Taki Zenzaburo, who chose seppuku as a method of atoning for ordering his soldiers to fire on foreigners. Nitobe includes a detailed description of the ritual, which he himself witnessed.

Practical Tips

• Practice decision-making with a "Bushido Dilemma" game night. Invite friends or family to join in a role-playing game where each person must make tough decisions based on a personal code of ethics. Create scenarios that challenge participants to choose between difficult options, encouraging discussion and reflection on what values are most important when making decisions.
• Create a personal reflection ritual that involves focusing on your abdominal area to connect with your inner self. Set aside a few minutes each day to sit quietly, breathe deeply into your belly, and pay attention to any sensations or emotions that arise. This can serve as a modern, introspective practice that echoes the ancient belief in the abdomen as the soul's location, allowing you to explore your own feelings and intuitions.
• Volunteer with a legal aid organization to understand the intersection of law and personal actions. By assisting in cases or workshops, you'll see firsthand how legal frameworks shape individual decisions and societal norms. This could involve helping with community outreach programs that educate people about their legal rights and responsibilities, thereby giving you insight into the structured nature of actions within a legal context.
• Develop a "vindication voucher" to support allies when you've made a mistake that affects them. This could be a written statement or a creative token that you give to someone affected by your actions, symbolizing your commitment to rectify the situation and publicly affirming their integrity or stance.
• Reflect on personal accountability by journaling about times you've made mistakes and how you addressed them. Writing down past errors and the steps you took to rectify them can help you understand your approach to accountability. For example, if you missed a deadline at work, note down how you communicated with your team and what measures you took to prevent a recurrence.
• Create a visual representation of commitment to a chosen endeavor. This could be a piece of artwork, a digital design, or a simple item that you carry with you as a constant reminder of a commitment you've made. The physical representation serves as a daily cue to uphold the standards and dedication you've set for yourself, mirroring the symbolic depth of traditional rituals.

Kataki-Uchi: Avenging Wrongs Against Your Master or Family, a Bushido Moral Duty

Nitobe explains that the revenge practiced by samurai served as a substitute for formal justice in the chaotic period before Japan formally established criminal courts and law enforcement systems. Kataki-uchi, similar to the vengeance practiced in many other places, allowed the family of a murdered person, or the devoted retainer of a murdered Lord, to enact vengeance directly as a way to satisfy the natural human desire for justice. Nitobe quotes the Egyptian god Osiris, who responded to the question "What's the loveliest thing on earth?" with the words, "Seeking revenge for a parent's wrongs." A Japanese samurai, he says, would have added, “and a master’s."

This practice, while seemingly bloodthirsty, is explained by the author as demonstrating deep loyalty, arising from the belief that justice demanded an exact balancing of the scales. This was especially true when the legal system failed to adequately address a wrong, as with the Forty-Seven Ronin. According to Nitobe, these warriors were, and continue to be, revered for enacting revenge on the person who unjustly killed their Lord. The author also notes that this practice was not arbitrary. Samurai were expected to personally endure wrongs committed against themselves, their wives, or even their children, but the murder of one's Lord or father demanded a decisive response.

Other Perspectives

• While samurai practiced kataki-uchi before formal justice systems were established, it's important to recognize that informal and community-based systems of justice and conflict resolution often existed in societies prior to formal legal institutions.
• By taking justice into their own hands, families or retainers might bypass opportunities for reconciliation or restorative justice that could benefit the broader community.
• The satisfaction derived from kataki-uchi may be temporary and could leave individuals with feelings of guilt or remorse, which indicates that it may not fulfill a deeper, more enduring human desire for justice.
• The concept of revenge as a form of justice can perpetuate cycles of violence, leading to ongoing feuds and societal instability, which is contrary to the aims of a harmonious and orderly society.
• The concept of "exact balancing of justice" is subjective and can lead to disproportionate responses, as personal vendettas may cloud judgment on what constitutes a fair retribution.
• The reverence for the Forty-Seven Ronin could be seen as a glorification of vengeance, which may conflict with modern ethical standards that emphasize forgiveness and restorative justice over retribution.
• The idea of responding decisively to the murder of a Lord or father could be seen as valuing the lives of certain individuals over others, which raises questions about equality and the intrinsic value of all human beings.

Influence and Legacy of Bushido in Japan

Bushido's Principles Influenced Japanese Cultural, Political, and Social Development

Bushido Shaped Japan's National Character and Identity

Nitobe insists that, although Bushido originated as a code by which the elite Samurai class conducted themselves, its influence spread organically throughout all levels of society in Japan, shaping its national identity and character. The author notes that, as in England where "most plays and every novel...depict this figure [gentleman]," so too in Japan’s literary landscape where tales of Samurai like Nobunaga and Hidéyoshi captivated both men and women of all social classes.

The principles of Bushido, Nitobe argues, permeated all aspects of life, serving as a guiding light for social interactions and ethical decision-making. He notes how theatrical performances, storytelling traditions, and even children's tales celebrated the Samurai and their exploits, keeping their deeds and virtues alive in the Japanese people's collective imagination. These values of loyalty, honor, self-discipline, integrity, and courage helped to create a cohesive social fabric and defined Japanese identity both within the nation's borders and abroad.

Context

• These were two of the most influential daimyo (feudal lords) during the Sengoku period, a time of social upheaval, political intrigue, and near-constant military conflict in Japan. Nobunaga is known for initiating the unification of Japan, while Hideyoshi completed much of this work, setting the stage for the Tokugawa shogunate.
• The international image of Japan has often been associated with these values, contributing to a perception of the Japanese as disciplined, respectful, and committed to excellence.

Samurai's Values of Loyalty, Discipline, and Self-Sacrifice Ingrained In Japanese Psyche

Nitobe explores how Bushido's principles resonated with the collective consciousness of the Japanese people, fostering a unique sense of national identity and unity. The author draws parallels between the Samurai’s unwavering loyalty to their ruler and the deep-seated patriotism felt by all Japanese citizens. He points to the national anthem, which evokes the image of loyalty enduring throughout the ages, and to the widespread admiration for figures like Yoshida Shoin, a pioneer of modern Japan who embraced death for his convictions, as evidence of Bushido's enduring power.

The author highlights the significance of Yamato Damashii, the Soul of Japan, which he claims embodies the collective spirit, the Volksgeist, of the Japanese people, shaped largely by Bushido's principles. He even suggests that, because Bushido evoked emotions and inspired profound feelings of commitment and devotion, it can rightly be considered a kind of secular religion that instilled shared morals and values, promoting social harmony and a sense of unity across the nation.

Practical Tips

• Start a tradition or ritual that celebrates your community's achievements or commemorates its history, akin to how samurai traditions honored their values. This could be an annual gathering, a storytelling night, or a community art project. By creating and participating in these traditions, you help keep the community's legacy alive and strengthen the collective identity.
• Start a tradition of sharing stories of loyalty within your family or friend group. Once a month, gather and share tales of loyalty from your own lives, history, or books you've read. This practice can help to deepen your understanding of loyalty's role in human relationships and society, and inspire you to embody this virtue in your interactions.
• Create a personal code of conduct inspired by Yamato Damashii that guides your decisions and actions. Write down a set of rules or affirmations that resonate with the spirit of collective well-being and personal integrity. Refer to this code every morning or during challenging times to remind yourself of the values you aspire to live by.
• Start a 'values journal' where you record daily actions that align with your personal code. This could be as simple as noting when you chose to be patient in a stressful situation because patience is one of your values. Over time, this journal can help you see patterns in your behavior and guide you towards living in harmony with your values.

The Samurai Code's Focus on Honor, Duty, and Self-Reliance Resonated With the Population

Samurai Tales Inspired Generations Across Japan

According to Nitobe, the tales of Samurai that captivated the imaginations of the Japanese people served not only as entertainment but as sources of moral and ethical instruction. These stories instilled within commoners the importance of virtues like loyalty, courage, and integrity, even in those who lacked the socioeconomic status of samurai. He suggests that even today, in the modernized Japan of his era, beneath the veneer of Westernization one may still find “a Japanese…with disheveled hair, wearing shabby clothing…[who] is the self-imposed guardian of national honor.”

These tales, Nitobe insists, provided role models and a moral compass for generations in Japan. From the peasant farmers huddled around their hearths to the clerks and shop-boys seeking respite from their daily toil, and even to the very young children learning to lisp, everyone knew the stories of the Samurai's brave deeds and unwavering loyalty. These tales, Nitobe says, served as a powerful "leaven for society," elevating everyone's ethical values. He credits these stories with inspiring the Japanese people to "go back to their daily responsibilities with renewed vigor and determination," demonstrating how Bushido's influence transcended social hierarchies and reached deep into the hearts of everyday people.

Context

• These tales were often passed down orally or through literature and theater, such as Noh and Kabuki, making them accessible to all social classes and ensuring their widespread influence.
• The virtues mentioned are part of Bushido, the samurai code of conduct, which emphasized honor, discipline, and moral behavior. This code influenced not only samurai but also the broader Japanese culture.
• In times of national crisis or change, such as the Meiji Restoration or post-World War II reconstruction, samurai tales were invoked to inspire unity and resilience, reinforcing a sense of national identity.
• During the Edo period, the rise of terakoya (temple schools) helped spread literacy among commoners, allowing more people to read and share these stories.
• In baking, leaven refers to a substance like yeast that causes dough to rise. Metaphorically, it suggests that the tales of the Samurai acted as a transformative agent, subtly but powerfully influencing and uplifting societal values.
• During the Edo period (1603-1868), Japan experienced a long period of peace, which led to the samurai transitioning from warriors to bureaucrats and moral exemplars. Bushido became more focused on ethical behavior and personal development.

The Future Prospects for Bushido's Legacy

Japan Modernization Challenges Traditional Bushido Ethos

Abolition of Feudal System Undermined Bushido

Nitobe, although deeply appreciative of Bushido and its influence on Japanese identity, was not blind to the challenges that modern life poses to traditional values. The author notes how the formalized abolition of Japan's feudal system in 1870 signaled the demise of Bushido and how this was further cemented by the subsequent edict of 1875 prohibiting the carrying of swords. This shift, according to Nitobe, ushered in a new age, one of "sophisters, economists, and calculators," where ancient values like honor and virtue were beginning to lose their place.

Nitobe recognizes that the forces of Westernization, democracy, and industrialization were rapidly transforming Japanese society in ways that were incompatible with the hierarchical structures and traditional values upon which Bushido relied. While a tradition as entrenched as Bushido wasn't able to vanish instantly, the author makes it clear that a fundamental shift was taking place, one where the "state based on Honor...is swiftly being overtaken by squabbling lawyers and babbling politicians."

Other Perspectives

• The challenges to traditional values in modern life may prompt a renaissance or revival of these values as people seek grounding in a rapidly changing world.
• Westernization, democracy, and industrialization were not the only forces that transformed Japanese society; internal factors such as the Meiji Restoration and the desire for modernization from within also played significant roles.
• Hierarchical structures are not inherently incompatible with change; they can adapt and evolve to fit new societal norms and expectations.
• The skills and expertise of economists and calculators, for example, can be used to address social inequalities and improve the welfare of society, which can be seen as a modern expression of the Bushido value of benevolence.
• Traditional values and modern legal and political systems are not mutually exclusive; they can coexist and even complement each other in a society.
• It might be contended that the fundamental shift was not as rapid or as comprehensive as suggested, given the persistence of traditional cultural practices and the respect for the past that is still evident in many aspects of Japanese life.

Democracy, Industrialization, and Western Values Threatened Bushido's Cultural Relevance

Nitobe grapples with the looming question of whether Bushido's ethos is capable of evolving with the wave of modernization that is sweeping across Japan. The author acknowledges that the ethos of Bushido, emphasizing "minor social group loyalty," honor, and martial valor, is under threat from the ideals of democracy, industrial progress, and Western individualism. He points to the increasing "crudeness of society" and the breakdown of traditional customs that is visible, even during his era, as people adopt more utilitarian and materialistic ways.

Nitobe sees the Christian faith in its purest form as the only force capable of competing with the "profit-and-loss" mindset of Western utilitarianism and materialism, which was gaining in popularity in his time. He warns against a superficial grafting of Western forms of Christianity, which are all too often adulterated by “Anglo-Saxon freaks and fancies," onto Japanese culture and laments that many Christian missionaries are ignorant of Japanese history, dismissing it as "heathen records," when according to the author even past cultures are a palimpsest that deserves to be understood.

Context

• The emphasis on "minor social group loyalty" reflects the feudal system where samurai pledged allegiance to their daimyo (feudal lords), prioritizing group loyalty over individual desires.
• The focus on economic growth and efficiency often prioritized profit over cultural and spiritual values, leading to a more materialistic society where success was increasingly measured by wealth and status.
• Christian missionaries often played a dual role as both religious and cultural ambassadors, but their lack of understanding of Japanese culture sometimes led to resistance and misinterpretation of their message.
• The imposition of Western religious practices can be seen as a form of cultural imperialism, where dominant cultures impose their beliefs on others, potentially erasing or marginalizing indigenous traditions.
• The term "heathen" was historically used by some Westerners to describe non-Christian societies. This perspective often reflected a Eurocentric view that undervalued or misunderstood the complexities and values of other cultures.
• The metaphor warns against the superficial adoption of foreign ideas without understanding the underlying historical and cultural context, which can lead to misunderstandings and cultural dissonance.

Bushido Shapes Japanese National Character

Bushido's Honor, Duty, and Self-Discipline Shape Japan's Social, Political, Cultural Dynamics

Nitobe insists that, despite the challenges that modernization presents, the essence of Bushido remains deeply embedded within the Japanese national character. He emphasizes that many of Japan's national strengths, its people's patriotism, politeness, fortitude, and bravery, which were all demonstrated so powerfully in the war with China, are directly attributable to the enduring legacy of Bushido's values.

These values, he argues, continue to shape the way Japanese people think, feel, and act, despite the rapidly changing society. He notes how Bushido’s emphasis on honor and loyalty contributed to the lack of corruption in Japanese public life, and recognizes how the Japanese people's own faults and shortcomings, their oversensitivity to insult and propensity towards conceit, are also "pathological" outcomes of their ingrained sense of honor.

Other Perspectives

• The interpretation of Bushido's influence on Japan's national character might be subject to historical revisionism, where the importance of Bushido is emphasized retrospectively, rather than it having a continuous and unbroken influence.
• The connection between Bushido and certain negative traits, such as oversensitivity to insult and a propensity towards conceit, may not be a direct causation but rather a correlation with other cultural or psychological factors that are not exclusively derived from Bushido.
• The idea that Bushido leads to an absence of corruption could mask underlying issues, such as underreporting or a lack of transparency in public life, which might give the appearance of low corruption levels.
• The idea that certain negative traits are a result of an ingrained sense of honor could be seen as an oversimplification that does not account for individual differences and the capacity for personal growth and change.

Future of Bushido: Adapting and Integrating With Evolving Social and Ethical Frameworks

Nitobe expresses hope that, although Bushido is endangered by modernity, it will not disappear entirely. Instead, he envisions a scenario where its values adjust to the complexities of modern life and find new ways to express themselves. The author suggests that, just as stoicism has transformed from being a rigid philosophical system to becoming an enduring virtue, the essence of Bushido, its commitment to honor, duty, self-sacrifice, and self-control, might likewise find a way to persist in the future, not as a stand-alone code of conduct but as "the perfume with which it will enrich life.”

Nitobe, reflecting on the inherent “fighting instinct” present in all humans, acknowledges the need for a moral framework that transcends this propensity towards aggression. This, he suggests, is where the principles of Shinto, the insights of Mengzi, and Wang Yangming's philosophy, all of which emphasize compassion, might converge with “the Christian idea of love." The author recognizes the limitations of Bushido, which, being rooted in military ideals, did not fully embrace this "diviner instinct––to love", but he insists that the “summons of the future" is to expand upon the moral foundation of the Bushido code and embrace a worldview that recognizes the value of compassion and cooperation. He concludes by expressing hope that, even though “its customaries will have been buried and its very name forgotten,” the essential fragrance of Bushido, its potential to inspire “sweetness and light, of strength and comfort,” will linger in the hearts of the generations to come.

Context

• Modern ethical frameworks often emphasize universal human rights, equality, and environmental sustainability, which can sometimes conflict with traditional codes that were developed in different historical and cultural contexts.
• The digital age presents new ethical challenges. Bushido's focus on self-discipline and integrity could be relevant in discussions about digital citizenship and online behavior.
• The metaphor of perfume suggests something subtle yet pervasive. Perfume is not seen but is sensed, indicating that Bushido's influence might be indirect, affecting cultural and ethical norms without being explicitly recognized.
• The idea of an inherent fighting instinct can be linked to evolutionary biology, where early humans needed aggression for survival, hunting, and protection. This instinct is thought to be a remnant of our ancestors' need to compete for resources and mates.
• Wang Yangming was a Chinese philosopher who developed the Neo-Confucian concept of the unity of knowledge and action. He argued that true knowledge is realized through action and that moral intuition is innate, advocating for self-cultivation and introspection.
• In the contemporary world, there is a growing emphasis on global cooperation and understanding, driven by interconnected challenges such as climate change and international conflicts, which necessitate a focus on compassion and collaboration.
• The Christian idea of love, or agape, emphasizes unconditional love and compassion for all, which contrasts with Bushido's traditional focus on loyalty and duty within a hierarchical structure. Integrating this concept can broaden the ethical scope of Bushido.