PDF Summary:The Queering of the American Child, by Logan Lancing

In The Queering of the American Child, Logan Lancing explores the incorporation of controversial Queer Theory principles into various facets of contemporary American society, with a particular emphasis on the educational system and healthcare industry. Lancing examines the philosophical foundations of Queer Theory, tracing its conceptual roots to Marxist thought and ancient Gnostic and Hermetic traditions, while highlighting its influence on policies regarding preferred pronouns, gender identity, and "gender-affirming" medical interventions for children.

Lancing delves into the detrimental effects that medical procedures such as puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones can have on young individuals, underscoring the permanent consequences often associated with these interventions. He also scrutinizes the tactics employed by LGBTQ+ activists to purposefully undermine parental authority, exposing the ways in which confidential information regarding children's gender identities is frequently withheld from parents.

(continued)...

Schools now implement "inclusive" policies that compel the use of preferred pronouns, eliminate gendered language, and allow students to socially transition without parental knowledge or consent.

Lancing reveals how the principles of Queer Theory have been subtly woven into policies that purport to champion inclusivity, diversity, and equity. Logan Lancing contends that the measures adopted by educational institutions like those in Montgomery County, Maryland, and Madison, Wisconsin, which encompass recognition of students' preferred pronouns, the removal of gender-presumptive language, and the permission for students to undergo social transition without parental consent, are fundamentally based on Queer Theory tenets. Lancing emphasizes the detrimental effects of these policies, arguing that they diminish parental authority and promote the idea that sex and gender are entirely subjective. Lancing argues that although these policies appear to promote inclusivity, they actually facilitate the introduction of radical gender theories into educational settings, which ingrains these ideas in the consciousness of young learners and bestows upon them an aura of legal validity.

Other Perspectives

• Compelling the use of preferred pronouns could be seen as a form of compelled speech, which may conflict with individual rights to freedom of expression.
• Such policies could potentially oversimplify the complexity of language and its role in identity formation, possibly neglecting the ways in which language can be empowering.
• In some jurisdictions, the law may recognize the rights of minors to make certain decisions about their own welfare, which can include aspects of their social identity and expression.
• The principles of Queer Theory might be one of many frameworks that inform these policies, and it could be an oversimplification to attribute the policies' existence to Queer Theory alone.
• The implementation of these policies may require significant teacher training and resource allocation, which could be seen as a diversion of educational resources from other academic priorities.
• These policies may be aimed at creating a safe and supportive environment for all students, which is a core responsibility of educational institutions.
• The term "radical" is subjective; what is considered radical by some may be viewed as progressive or simply respectful by others.
• The adoption of inclusive policies could be driven by empirical evidence suggesting that such measures improve the mental health and educational outcomes for transgender and non-binary students.

Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives in education are heavily informed by Queer Theory's goal of dismantling traditional norms and categories.

Lancing makes a clear connection between the aims of school-based DEI initiatives and the central purpose of Queer Theory, which is to dismantle traditional standards and categories. Logan Lancing reveals how Queer Theory's tenets have shaped the objectives and approaches of DEI initiatives in their pursuit of fairness and inclusiveness. Logan Lancing argues that Queer Theory's focus on deconstructing traditional norms and scrutinizing entrenched power structures aligns perfectly with DEI initiatives that prioritize identity politics and advocate for profound changes in society. Lancing contends that programs designed for inclusivity strive to normalize all "queer" identities, reflecting Queer Theory's objective, but this overlooks potential impacts on children's welfare and parental rights. Furthermore, Lancing notes that the dedication to principles of diversity, equity, and inclusion often masks the infusion of harmful Queer Theory-related agendas into educational environments, which hinders the ability of parents and community stakeholders to contest these measures.

Other Perspectives

• Some DEI programs focus primarily on addressing tangible disparities in access and outcomes, which is not inherently connected to the deconstruction of norms as suggested by Queer Theory.
• The use of the term "normalize" could be misleading, as DEI initiatives typically strive for acceptance and inclusion, not to make all identities "normal" in a homogenizing sense.
• Advocating for profound changes in society implies a radical overhaul, which may not accurately represent the scope or intent of all DEI initiatives, as some may focus on specific, targeted reforms.
• Efforts to enforce inclusiveness may suppress legitimate diversity of thought by penalizing those who hold traditional or dissenting views.
• The focus on equity and inclusion can help to address systemic biases and discrimination that negatively affect children's welfare, thus potentially improving outcomes for all students.
• The goal of DEI is to foster an inclusive environment for all students, which includes teaching respect and understanding for different identities and backgrounds, rather than promoting a specific agenda.
• Many DEI initiatives include transparent communication strategies that keep parents and community members informed and involved, rather than hindering their participation.

The book scrutinizes the methods by which children's relationships with their parents are undermined, including the use of certain educational and healthcare tactics.

The book examines the methods by which Queer activists deliberately target younger demographics, leveraging vulnerabilities in educational and healthcare settings to advance intricate notions of gender identity. Lancing highlights the strategies used by Queer Activists to subtly undermine parental authority, emphasizing their tactics in excluding parents from crucial decisions about their children's well-being.

Queer Theorists view childhood "innocence" as a social construct used to oppress children and prevent them from exploring their "true" queer identities.

Lancing suggests that a core tenet of Queer Theory challenges the notion that youth is characterized by a natural and protective innocence during a particular developmental phase. Activists within the queer community view it as a societal tool used by the mainstream to control children and limit their exploration of their true queer identities. Lancing suggests that Queer Theory disputes the concept of an innocent and typical child, which is often perceived as being naive about matters of sex and gender, and uses this concept to uphold rigid, heteronormative paths of development. Logan Lancing stresses that the common belief in the inherent innocence of youth is harmful because it deprives young people of their independence and constrains their ability to conceive of a future that embraces a diversity of identities and ways of living. Logan Lancing contends that Queer Activists aim to create an environment where all children can freely explore and receive support in their understanding of sexual and gender identities, ensuring exposure to queer ideas.

Advocates for the rights of LGBTQ+ individuals argue that the conventional distinction between childhood and adulthood ought to be reevaluated, proposing that children have the capacity to make knowledgeable decisions about their own gender and sexual identities.

Queer Theory seeks to dissolve the conventional boundaries that separate childhood from adulthood. Lancing contends that the justification for exposing young children to sophisticated concepts regarding sex, gender identity, and sexual orientation, which are frequently considered inappropriate and potentially harmful, lies in the diminishing distinction between these topics. Lancing suggests that viewing children as inherently sexual beings with the capacity to make informed choices about their identities challenges the traditional view that they are innocent in these matters. Lancing believes that such assertions provide Queer Activists with a basis to promote nontraditional perspectives on children's gender, indicating that these youths possess the self-determination and capacity to decide on social transitioning and possible medical interventions.

Context

• Different cultures have varying perceptions of when childhood ends and adulthood begins, often marked by rites of passage or specific age milestones. Understanding these cultural differences can provide insight into why the distinction is being questioned.
• Social transitioning, which can include changes in name, pronouns, and clothing, is often considered a reversible step that allows children to explore their gender identity without medical intervention.
• Traditionally, childhood has been viewed as a period of innocence and protection from adult concepts, a notion that emerged strongly during the Victorian era. This separation was meant to shield children from the complexities of adult life, including sexuality and gender roles.
• Parents and educators play a crucial role in guiding children through complex topics, ensuring that information is age-appropriate and supportive of the child's individual needs and context.
• The accessibility of information through media and technology has changed how children learn about and engage with concepts of gender and sexuality, potentially accelerating their understanding and self-awareness.

Queer Pedagogy aims to promote introspection among children by deliberately exposing them to scenarios that question their sense of self, thus acquainting them with the innovative viewpoints inherent in the field of study that explores the fluidity of sexuality and gender.

Lancing emphasizes that Queer Pedagogy utilizes the concept of "crisis" to intentionally disrupt the fixed identities of children, thus rendering them more receptive to the core principles of Queer Theory. He underscores the significance of scholarly work within the realm of Queer Theory, especially highlighting Kevin Kumashiro's recognition of embracing crisis as an integral and deliberate part of the educational process. Logan Lancing utilizes Queer Pedagogy to initiate meaningful discussions with children regarding self-identity and societal injustices, employing methods that question traditional norms and analyze the deeper implications of language. These tactics, Lancing asserts, are designed to dislodge children from their existing sense of normalcy and create a state of "uncomfortable disequilibrium" that leaves them vulnerable to radical indoctrination. Lancing suggests that in the critical stages of identity formation, children's natural curiosity and susceptibility are utilized by Queer Activists to encourage the adoption of a unique viewpoint grounded in Queer Theory to understand themselves and their surroundings.

Practical Tips

• You can foster introspection by creating a 'Day in Another's Shoes' activity for your family where each member spends a day adopting a different role or set of characteristics within the household. For example, if one person is typically the cook, they might swap roles with someone who usually does the cleaning. This role reversal can lead to discussions about expectations, identity, and empathy.
• You can explore identity fluidity by journaling your reactions to different social situations, noting moments when you felt your identity was challenged or shifted. This self-reflection can help you understand how identities are not fixed but can be influenced by context and interactions. For example, you might feel more conservative at a family gathering and more adventurous with friends, indicating the malleability of your social identity.
• Create a "crisis journal" to document moments of confusion or uncertainty in your learning journey. Whenever you encounter a concept that disrupts your thought process, write it down, along with your emotional response and any questions it raises. Reviewing this journal periodically can help you track your growth and identify patterns in how you deal with intellectual challenges.
• Encourage critical thinking by asking children open-ended questions about identity and relationships when watching TV shows or movies together. Instead of just consuming media passively, pause at key moments and engage in a dialogue about the characters' decisions, relationships, and identities. For instance, if a character comes out as queer, ask the child how they think the character might feel, or what challenges they might face, to promote empathy and understanding.

The increasing acceptance of "gender-affirming care" for children, which includes the use of puberty blockers and hormones corresponding to a child's self-identified gender, is largely attributed to the dedicated work of queer activists within the healthcare industry.

The text delves into the significant and disconcerting influence that Queer Theory has on pediatric healthcare, illustrating how it extends past the realm of education and into clinical practice. Lancing sheds light on the strategy embraced by LGBTQ+ rights proponents, which consists of providing supportive aid designed specifically for the unique gender identity of adolescents who are dealing with concerns pertaining to their sexual orientation and gender, a route that might result in hazardous medical interventions.

Medical interventions may result in permanent infertility, reduced bone density, and other substantial, long-lasting effects on young individuals.

Lancing exposes the serious risks associated with "gender-affirming care," arguing that the harmful effects of these medical interventions are often downplayed by Queer Activists and complicit medical professionals. He cites medical research indicating that the use of drugs to delay the beginning of puberty could lead to irreversible infertility, reduced bone strength, and potential problems with brain development. He further emphasizes the risks associated with gender transitioning treatments, including potential heart issues, an increased risk of strokes, and mental health concerns. Through alarming accounts from individuals like Jamie Reed, formerly of the Transgender Center at Washington University, Lancing emphasizes the profound and occasionally permanent consequences that these treatments may have on young individuals.

Context

• Before starting treatment, individuals may have the option to preserve fertility through methods like sperm banking or egg freezing. However, these options can be costly and are not always accessible or feasible for young individuals.
• Bone density is often measured using a DEXA scan, which assesses the strength and mineral content of bones. Lower bone density can increase the risk of fractures and osteoporosis later in life.
• Ethical medical practice requires informed consent, where patients and their guardians are fully educated about the potential risks and benefits of treatments, allowing them to make informed decisions.
• Puberty blockers work by suppressing the release of sex hormones like testosterone and estrogen, which are responsible for the development of secondary sexual characteristics.
• Different countries and medical organizations have varying guidelines and protocols for administering gender-affirming treatments, reflecting ongoing debates and research in the field.

Advocates frequently use subtle tactics and cunning techniques to keep their activities hidden from parents and to exclude them from participating in decisions about their children's welfare, especially when it pertains to their children's sexual orientation and gender identity.

Lancing argues that participants in the Queer movement deliberately undermine parental authority, employing a variety of tactics to conceal their efforts and to exclude parents from decisions related to their child's welfare. He highlights how the educational policies are structured to prevent parents from being informed about the specifics of their child's self-identified persona, including any alternative names or pronouns the child may adopt, by citing examples from the Eau Claire Area School District in Wisconsin. The author examines how schools might withhold information based on the possibility that revealing a student's deeply personal gender identity, coupled with the unfounded claim that unsupportive parents might drive their children to self-harm, could be used as justification.

Lancing reveals that a variety of school districts have implemented comprehensive "Gender Support Plans" aimed at safeguarding the confidentiality of certain information such as a pupil's chosen name and gender pronouns, along with their access to particular amenities like bathrooms and changing areas, while also not disclosing these details to parents. Lancing emphasizes the dangerous aspects of these secretive policies, especially in terms of the emotional turmoil they can cause for children and their family members.

Practical Tips

• Incorporate a pronoun field in any forms or sign-ups you create for events or organizations you're involved with. This small addition can make a significant impact on inclusivity. For example, if you're organizing a local sports league or a volunteer signup, adding a simple "Preferred Pronoun" field next to the name and contact information sections can make everyone feel more welcome and respected.

Other Perspectives

• Some may suggest that the focus on parental authority does not fully account for the complexity of family dynamics and that in some cases, the involvement of advocates may actually help facilitate better communication and understanding within families over time.
• Advocates may argue that their actions are not about concealing efforts or excluding parents, but rather about protecting the privacy and safety of children who may not feel safe disclosing their sexual orientation or gender identity to their parents.
• The approach taken by schools might be seen as a way to balance the rights of parents with the rights of the child, particularly in situations where the child's welfare is a concern.
• In some cases, the school's policy may be designed to comply with non-discrimination laws that protect students from being outed against their will, which could lead to potential harm or discrimination.
• Gender Support Plans may inadvertently create a lack of transparency between schools and families, potentially eroding trust.
• Emotional turmoil is not solely the result of school policies; societal attitudes and the broader cultural context also play significant roles in the experiences of children and their families.

The book examines the dangerous medical treatments imposed on children and critically analyzes the foundational beliefs and historical origins that are intertwined with Queer Theory.

Lancing underscores the profound harm caused to children by medical procedures intended to confirm their gender identity. He then delves into the unsettling philosophical roots that gave rise to Queer Theory, revealing its connections to old Gnostic and Hermetic groups, as well as its association with the dangerous utopian concepts often seen in Marxist ideology.

The use of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones, when directed by the tenets associated with Queer Theory, causes significant and lasting harm.

Lancing underscores the significant adverse effects that can arise from medical interventions aimed at affirming a child's sense of their own gender. He underscores the permanent character of numerous such interventions, especially surgeries that alter genitalia. Lancing emphasizes the considerable population who, following their transition, deal with lasting consequences of the medical interventions they underwent during their departure from their transgender identity. He underscores narratives that often portray severe psychological and physical suffering, portraying them as a strong rebuke of the prevailing approach that endorses gender affirmation, an approach that is advocated by organizations including the American Academy of Pediatrics.

Administering puberty blockers carries substantial risks, one of which is the possibility of causing permanent infertility.

Lancing elaborates on his initial assertions by carefully detailing the hazards associated with hormone treatments that postpone puberty and encourage the development of secondary sexual characteristics commonly attributed to the opposite sex. He draws upon the expertise of scholars and medical professionals who have courageously challenged prevailing convictions. Lancing cites research indicating that the use of medications to delay puberty may potentially result in brain damage, weakened bones, and cardiovascular complications. He emphasizes the irreversibility of surgical interventions and the often debilitating nature of attempting to reverse the procedures should regret arise.

Many young people who have undergone medical transitions subsequently struggle with regret and permanent changes to their bodies.

Lancing emphasizes the deep remorse and anguish experienced by individuals who reverse their transitions after having undergone medical interventions. He references the journalistic work of Abigail Shrier, who gained recognition for her publication "Irreversible Damage," and who conducted thorough interviews with individuals that have retracted their decisions to transition genders, many of whom lamented the absence of careful and discerning adults who could have shielded them from the detrimental effects of "gender-affirming care." Lancing highlights the narratives of those who underwent surgical procedures, concentrating on the mental anguish they endured in their efforts to mitigate the resulting difficulties. Many detransitioners, Lancing notes, express regret over their reduced fertility, face irreversible changes to their bodies, and endure ongoing mental distress.

Practical Tips

• Develop a habit of seeking second opinions for significant health decisions. Whenever you're faced with a choice that carries potential long-term consequences, like the use of puberty blockers, make it a point to consult at least one additional healthcare professional to gain a broader perspective on the risks involved.
• Create a personal health journal to track any physical or emotional changes if undergoing hormone treatments. This can be a simple notebook or a digital app where you note daily observations about your well-being. Over time, this record can provide valuable insights into how your body is responding to the treatment and can be a useful tool for discussions with your healthcare provider.
• Organize a support group with friends or family where you discuss and share information about medical decisions, especially regarding surgeries. Use this group to gather diverse viewpoints, emotional support, and personal experiences that can inform your decision-making process without relying solely on medical professionals.
• Engage in reflective journaling to explore your feelings about body changes before taking any action. Set aside time each week to write about how you feel regarding your body and any desired changes. This practice can help you identify the root of your feelings and may reveal whether your desire for change is consistent or fluctuates over time, providing a deeper understanding of your motivations.
• Engage in conversations with individuals who have made significant life changes, focusing on understanding their long-term satisfaction and challenges. This can be done through online forums, community groups, or even podcasts that feature personal stories. Listening to a variety of experiences can provide a broader perspective on the potential long-term effects of major decisions, helping you to consider outcomes you may not have initially thought of.

The hazardous ideas and practices associated with Queer Theory stem from ancient Gnostic and Hermetic traditions, drawing inspiration from Marxist thought which sought to create a "new man" through substantial social transformation.

Lancing reveals the foundational concepts and initial emergence of Queer Theory, identifying its connections to the arcane doctrines of Gnostic and Hermetic collectives, alongside its association with the Marxist ideal of significant transformation in society. The book's final section uncovers the intricate and frequently obscured core tenets of Queer Theory, emphasizing its fundamentally transformative and progressive nature.

Queer Theory's core beliefs, such as the idea that reality is a "prison" constructed by the powerful to oppress the marginalized, are directly descended from Gnostic and Hermetic religious doctrines.

Lancing posits a clear connection between the foundational tenets of Queer Theory and the olden Gnostic and Hermetic sects, maintaining that the concept of reality as a confining structure created by the influential to subjugate the marginalized is a notion repurposed from these ancient spiritual teachings. He contends that Queer Theory adopts a Gnostic perspective by viewing the material world, including biological sex and traditional gender roles, as a "false reality" designed to incarcerate individuals' true spiritual selves. Lancing clarifies that in this context, "queer" goes beyond simply denoting sexual preferences, symbolizing a level of awareness comparable to the quest for arcane knowledge found in Gnostic traditions. Furthermore, the writer suggests that the core principle of Queer Theory is its mysterious emphasis on transformation, seeking to merge and dissolve the distinctions linked to sex, gender, and sexuality, in an effort to achieve a balanced state.

Practical Tips

• Create a personal reflection journal where you document how the principles of Gnosticism and Hermeticism manifest in your daily life and interactions. This exercise will help you to internalize the connections and see the practical implications of these philosophical underpinnings in real-world scenarios. Reflect on situations where you challenge binary thinking or embrace fluidity, and consider how these instances relate to the broader philosophical doctrines.
• Start a personal journal to reflect on daily experiences through the lens of power dynamics. By writing down instances where you feel constrained or influenced by societal structures, you can become more aware of the 'prison' of reality in your life. For example, note when workplace hierarchies affect your behavior or when consumer culture sways your purchasing decisions, and consider alternative actions you could take to resist these pressures.
• Try altering your routine in small, unexpected ways to challenge the notion of a fixed reality. For example, take a different route to work, rearrange your furniture, or eat something for breakfast that you'd usually have for dinner. These small changes can help you realize that your daily structure isn't as rigid as you think, opening up a sense of possibility and adaptability in your everyday life.
• Explore the symbolism of "queer" through creative writing by crafting short stories or poems that draw parallels between personal identity and the search for hidden knowledge. This allows you to reflect on your own understanding of identity and awareness, similar to the way Gnostic traditions value the pursuit of esoteric wisdom. For example, you might write a story where a character's journey to self-acceptance mirrors the quest for arcane truths.
• Foster open-minded conversations by initiating a monthly discussion group with friends or acquaintances where you can talk about topics related to identity, transformation, and societal norms. Each month, choose a different theme or question to explore, ensuring that the topics encourage participants to think about and discuss the fluidity of identity and the potential for personal and societal transformation.
• Create a 'gender-neutral day' in your routine where you consciously avoid using gendered language and instead use people's names or gender-neutral pronouns like 'they/them'. This can be a way to practice seeing people as individuals rather than through the lens of gender expectations.

Queer Theory's passionate pursuit to deconstruct entrenched social norms and categories mirrors the ambitious and often disastrous goals found in Marxist thought, exemplified by the disastrous Cultural Revolution initiated by Mao Zedong in China.

Lancing draws a comparison between the passionate objectives of Queer Theory and the utopian aims of Marxism, while also referencing the disastrous consequences of Mao Zedong's Cultural Revolution in China. He emphasizes that both ideologies are united in their core objective to overthrow all current power hierarchies and establish a utopian reality by means of profound societal change. Lancing clarifies that the objective of Queer Theory is to deconstruct traditional norms and categories related to sex, gender identity, and sexual orientation, paralleling the Marxist ambition to abolish class distinctions and the notion of private property, as promoted by figures like Karl Marx and Mao Zedong. Lancing argues that the fervor is deeply troubling, particularly in light of the extensive violence and societal upheaval that led to many deaths during the period of Mao Zedong's radical campaign to reform Chinese society. Lancing posits that without opposition, the trajectory of Queer Theory could threaten the well-being and stability of Western societies.

Practical Tips

• Consider swapping skills or services with friends or neighbors instead of exchanging money. For instance, if you're good at cooking and a friend excels at fixing things, offer a home-cooked meal in exchange for help with a repair. This barter system can help you understand the value of labor and services beyond monetary transactions, reflecting a non-capitalistic exchange of value.
• Create a personal code of ethics to guide your actions during times of societal change. Think about the values that are important to you, such as non-violence, empathy, or community support, and write them down as a set of principles. Refer to this code when making decisions, especially in situations that challenge your beliefs or when you're faced with peer pressure. This can help you maintain integrity and contribute positively to your community, even in tumultuous times.
• Develop critical thinking skills by analyzing case studies from various societies. Look for case studies that examine the effects of different social theories on community well-being. Analyze these cases by identifying the outcomes, both positive and negative, and consider how similar scenarios might unfold in your own society. This exercise can sharpen your ability to assess the potential implications of theoretical frameworks on real-world situations.