PDF Summary:The Psychology of Totalitarianism, by Mattias Desmet

In The Psychology of Totalitarianism, Mattias Desmet explores the relationship between a mechanistic worldview and the rise of totalitarian regimes. Desmet contends that a society dominated by mechanistic thinking—which reduces humans to mere biological machines—can foster isolation, existential angst, and aggression. This psychological state makes societies vulnerable to the lure of charismatic leaders who promote unifying narratives and promise certainty.

Desmet suggests adopting a new perspective that recognizes consciousness, symbolism, and the inherent creativity of the cosmos. By nurturing individuality, upholding truth, and embracing life's uncertainties, Desmet argues that societies become more resistant to totalitarian control and mass formation.

(continued)...

• Environmental and moral challenges are often global in nature, requiring international cooperation and a shared commitment to addressing issues like climate change and resource depletion.
• The mechanistic view gained prominence in the 17th century with thinkers like Isaac Newton, who described the universe in terms of predictable, mathematical laws, influencing how people perceived nature and human existence.

A tendency to favor authoritarian leadership often arises alongside the expansion of totalitarian regimes and the phenomenon of mass formation, all of which unfold in an environment where the world is perceived mechanistically.

In his examination, Desmet explores the psychological forces he contends associate the limitations inherent in a mechanistic viewpoint with the widespread rise of uniformity and the rise of totalitarian governments. Desmet suggests that the contemporary sense of isolation, the lack of meaningful pursuits, and a widespread, vague sense of anxiety together create a fertile environment for the rise of group movements and charismatic leaders who provide certainty and direction in an increasingly chaotic world.

Societal inclinations toward group behaviors frequently arise in environments dominated by individualism and routine procedures.

Desmet posits that a society is vulnerable to collective hypnotic phenomena when it is characterized by four specific psychological conditions: pervasive isolation and a sense of disconnection, a prevailing feeling of meaninglessness, significant amounts of free-floating anxiety, and a heightened level of latent aggression and resentment. Desmet posits a close relationship between these conditions and the psychological outcomes that arise from the aforementioned mechanistic viewpoint.

A pervasive sense of isolation, an absence of purpose, and an unidentifiable sense of apprehension

Desmet's previous research suggests that the rise of an outlook centered on mechanization, along with technological progress, has weakened the ties of traditional communities and promoted a sense of individuality, leading to widespread feelings of solitude and detachment within the populace. Jobs that lack fulfillment, coupled with feelings of isolation and a decrease in meaningful community connections, result in a profound sense of aimlessness. An approach that exclusively emphasizes the workings of mechanical processes falls short in providing a comprehensive grasp of the complex dimensions of human existence, our inevitable demise, and the diverse types of human suffering, leading to a widespread, indistinct sense of unease among people. The discomfort, along with the dissatisfaction stemming from a lack of significant pursuits, cultivates a reservoir of unvoiced fury seeking a suitable target for blame.

Practical Tips

• Engage in a 'digital detox' weekend once a month to strengthen local relationships. During this time, commit to only using technology for emergencies and instead visit local shops, parks, and engage with neighbors and friends in person. This practice can help you appreciate the value of direct human connections and community.
• Create a "Neighbor Introduction Kit" to break the ice with people living nearby. This could be a simple card or a small gift, like a plant or baked goods, with a note introducing yourself. The act of giving creates an opportunity for connection and can help reduce feelings of detachment by fostering a sense of community.
• Start a fulfillment journal to track the aspects of your job that bring satisfaction versus those that don't. Each day, jot down tasks that you found meaningful and those that felt aimless. Over time, this can help you identify patterns and areas where you might seek change or growth.
• Organize a "skill-share" series within your community where individuals can teach others something they're good at. This could range from cooking classes to basic car maintenance. It not only helps people learn new skills but also creates a sense of interdependence and community bonding.
• Volunteer with organizations that support individuals facing serious illness or hardship. Engaging directly with people in these situations can provide a firsthand perspective on the multifaceted nature of human suffering and the importance of empathy and emotional support, rather than just focusing on systematic solutions.
• You can track your mood fluctuations to identify patterns of unease by keeping a daily journal. Note down times when you feel anxious or uneasy without a clear reason, and look for common triggers or circumstances. This could help you pinpoint environmental or habitual factors contributing to your sense of unease, allowing you to address them directly.

A compelling narrative serves to channel these psychological states towards a unified objective.

Desmet suggests that a compelling narrative identifying an issue and offering a solution has the power to influence a substantial number of people collectively when specific psychological circumstances exist. The story offered serves as a conduit for widespread disquiet, channels collective hostility towards a shared adversary, and reignites a sense of unity and purpose by engaging in a joint endeavor. Individuals often seek to escape the discomfort of solitude and aimlessness by embracing a collective identity that provides excitement.

Context

• Narratives that resonate with cultural values or historical myths are more likely to be accepted and internalized by large groups.
• Effective narratives often appeal to emotions rather than logic, using fear, hope, or anger to galvanize people into action and create a sense of urgency around the proposed solution.
• By channeling hostility towards a shared adversary, individuals experience emotional relief from personal grievances and frustrations, which are projected onto the identified enemy.
• Leaders who effectively communicate these narratives often possess charisma, which helps them inspire and mobilize large groups of people.
• In modern times, media plays a crucial role in disseminating narratives quickly and widely, influencing public opinion and behavior on a large scale.
• As traditional social structures change, people may seek new forms of identity and belonging, often found in collective movements or ideologies.

The occurrence of mass formation often develops into authoritarian rule.

This part of the text explores the origins of totalitarian governments alongside the occurrence of mass formation. Desmet suggests that governments with a totalitarian bent utilize psychological mass formation as a strategy to solidify their dominance and establish a rigid social order based on a strictly regulated ideological narrative.

Totalitarian leaders firmly adopt a mechanical worldview and demonstrate a willingness to impose this perspective with a complete disregard for compassion.

Desmet suggests that rulers with a totalitarian bent often become captivated by the ideological narratives they use to exert control over the people. The steadfast belief in the ideology, coupled with the leader's susceptibility to the captivating effects of collective trance, often results in a determined effort to impose this ideological vision on society, regardless of the consequences. Desmet uses examples from Nazi Germany and Stalinist Russia to support his point, underscoring that the leaders were steadfast in their conviction to their ideology and ready to use any means necessary to quell dissent and achieve their goals.

Other Perspectives

• The concept of a mechanical worldview implies a level of consistency and rationality that may not accurately reflect the often chaotic and contradictory nature of totalitarian regimes.
• Some leaders might argue that their strict measures are necessary to maintain order and protect the populace from greater harm.
• The effectiveness of ideology in exerting control is dependent on the willingness of the people to accept and internalize it, which is not a given and can vary widely among different societies and cultures.
• The term "collective trance" implies a lack of agency or conscious choice, which could be a misrepresentation of totalitarian leaders who may be fully aware and deliberate in their actions, rather than being under the spell of ideology.
• The term "ideological vision" is broad and can encompass a range of beliefs and policies, some of which may be more benign or widely accepted, thus challenging the notion that all ideological impositions are negative or harmful.
• Some leaders may start with a strong ideological conviction but become more flexible or disillusioned with their ideology over time due to practical challenges or failures.
• The phrase "any means necessary" could be an overgeneralization, as not all totalitarian leaders may engage in extreme measures, and some may operate within certain moral or ethical boundaries.
• Totalitarian leaders may not entirely lack compassion but may prioritize their political ideology or the perceived greater good over individual suffering.

Totalitarian systems are fundamentally designed to silence opposition and eliminate any form of dissent.

Desmet suggests that the collapse of governments is frequently triggered by their authoritarian traits, which become more pronounced due to the intolerance that is typically observed within the interactions of sizable collectives. These governments are driven by an uncontrollable desire to control all aspects of life, constantly identifying new threats and foes to justify their authoritarian measures. After eliminating opposition and clearing away all potential challengers, the authoritarian regime starts to fall apart.

Other Perspectives

• Some argue that in certain historical contexts, strong centralized control was believed necessary to mobilize resources effectively, especially during times of crisis or war.
• International support or intervention can sometimes prop up authoritarian regimes, providing them with the means to maintain control despite their authoritarian traits.
• Large groups can also foster a diversity of opinions and dissent, which can act as a check against authoritarianism rather than exacerbating it.
• The effectiveness of totalitarian control is often undermined by informal networks and social systems that operate beneath the surface, beyond the reach of official edicts.
• The process of identifying threats could be influenced by external pressures or international relations, not solely the regime's desire for control.
• In some cases, the elimination of opposition can temporarily strengthen a regime by consolidating power and reducing immediate threats to its authority.

We should adopt a new perspective that recognizes the cosmos, consciousness, and societal structures as more than mere mechanical entities.

In the final section of Desmet's book, he emphasizes the need to move beyond a limited, mechanical view of the world and adopt a holistic understanding that truly acknowledges the complex interplay between matter, consciousness, and the realm of symbols. The author suggests that by embracing individualism, moral principles, and truthfulness, along with acknowledging the uncertainties of life, we can cultivate a society that is less susceptible to the temptations of uniformity and less likely to succumb to authoritarian control.

Advancements in the fields of chaos theory and quantum mechanics have challenged the view that the universe functions as an inanimate, predetermined machine.

Desmet contends that portraying the universe as a deterministic, lifeless apparatus fails to capture its complexity, emphasizing that insights from chaos theory and quantum mechanics reveal the limitations of a simplistic, mechanistic view. The author argues that these scientific fields reveal a universe marked by increased intricacy and liveliness, along with a more profound interconnectedness than previously comprehended.

The extraordinary characteristic of complex systems is their inherent capacity for self-organization and the manifestation of creativity, which eludes complete explanation through mechanistic interpretations.

Desmet suggests that ideas originating from chaos theory reveal the intricate and unforeseeable nature of behaviors in systems that might seem simple on the surface. The capacity for phenomena like signal transmission noise patterns and the behavior of water droplets to self-organize and generate structure transcends explanations rooted solely in mechanical theories. The insights gathered suggest that there is an inherent wisdom and inventiveness in the cosmos that transcends basic mechanistic explanations, as opposed to merely being a collection of particles involved in arbitrary impacts.

Practical Tips

• Enhance your environment's potential for creativity by rearranging your workspace every month. Change the layout of your furniture, add new art or plants, or alter the lighting. A dynamic physical environment can stimulate your brain to think differently and adapt to changes, potentially sparking new ideas and ways of working that you wouldn't have discovered in a static setting.
• Create a visual art project using sand and sound vibrations to witness self-organization in action. Place a thin layer of sand on a metal sheet and play different tones using a speaker underneath. Observe how the sand forms patterns at various frequencies, which can help you visualize the concept of self-organization through the medium of sound and matter.
• Create a personal ritual or meditation that focuses on the feeling of being part of a larger, intelligent cosmos. You might sit quietly each morning, visualizing the vastness of the universe and your place within it, aiming to tap into a sense of collective consciousness. This could help foster a personal sense of connection to the inherent wisdom the book discusses.

Observations at the quantum level indicate that the properties of matter can be affected by conscious observation.

Desmet also contends that the subjective nature of reality, which is dependent on consciousness, is underscored by quantum mechanics through its illustration of how the act of observation affects what is being observed. Consciousness appears to be deeply woven into the essence of existence, rather than being a mere byproduct of material processes, as demonstrated by the behavior of subatomic particles that exist in multiple potential states until observed, prompting a definitive state upon measurement. This viewpoint sharply diverges from the idea that the physical realm operates independently, unaffected by human awareness.

Context

• The observer effect in quantum mechanics suggests that the act of measurement affects the system being observed. This is famously illustrated by the double-slit experiment, where particles behave differently when observed.
• Proposes that all possible outcomes of quantum measurements are realized in some "world" or universe, eliminating the need for wave function collapse and suggesting a multiverse.
• The concept challenges classical physics, which assumes that objects have definite properties regardless of observation.
• While the influence of observation on quantum systems is well-documented, the exact role of consciousness remains controversial and difficult to test experimentally, leading to ongoing research and debate in the scientific community.

Empathy, intuition, and a comprehensive perception are crucial in comprehending what fundamentally constitutes life.

This section of the text underscores the necessity of moving beyond a purely logical standpoint, often promoted by an analytical mindset focused on individual components, and emphasizes the need to incorporate empathy, intuition, and a holistic view to truly understand the complex tapestry of being. Desmet suggests that by forging a stronger bond with the essential aspects of our being, we can nurture a community that is both more robust and meaningful, thereby reducing its susceptibility to the allure of authoritarian rule.

We must reignite our connection to the poetic and spiritual dimensions that are inherently woven into our human experiences.

Desmet suggests that the unyielding pursuit of understanding by science has, paradoxically, uncovered elements of reality that elude logical interpretation. The author argues that the element of non-rationality should not be underestimated; rather, it forms the essential foundation of existence.

Desmet underscores the necessity of recognizing the limits of logical reasoning and shifting our focus toward the poetic, spiritual, and symbolic dimensions that are crucial to our being. He believes these aspects allow us to connect with the essential mystery and meaning of existence in a way that logic and reason cannot. The writer argues that such a change lays the foundation for a society imbued with empathy and satisfaction, one that respects both logical and illogical aspects, along with scientific and spiritual elements.

Practical Tips

• Start a 'spiritual journal' where you reflect on moments of awe, gratitude, or connection each day. Writing down these experiences can help you identify and savor the spiritual aspects of everyday life, fostering a greater sense of meaning and interconnectedness.
• Engage in creative activities that rely on intuition rather than logic, like abstract painting or freeform writing. These activities encourage you to let go of the need for logical structure and embrace a more fluid and spontaneous form of expression. By doing so, you'll experience firsthand how understanding can emerge from beyond the logical mind.
• Develop a habit of flipping a coin when faced with minor decisions to introduce an element of non-rationality. For example, if you're undecided about what to cook for dinner or which movie to watch, let the coin decide. This practice can help you become more comfortable with the role of chance and spontaneity in your life.
• Develop a habit of seeking diverse perspectives to challenge your logical conclusions. Whenever you're about to make a significant decision, actively seek out opinions from people who come from different backgrounds or hold different views from your own. For instance, if you're considering a career change, talk to individuals who have taken a similar leap, as well as those who decided against it. This can expose you to alternative ways of thinking and potential blind spots in your own logic.
• Create a 'symbolic self-sculpture' using found objects that represent different aspects of your life. Gather items that hold personal meaning or symbolize your dreams, challenges, and achievements. Assemble these objects into a sculpture or collage that reflects your spiritual and symbolic journey. This hands-on activity allows you to physically manifest and connect with the intangible dimensions of your life.
• Create a "meaning map" by drawing connections between your daily activities and the values or larger purposes they serve. This visual representation can help you see how even mundane tasks contribute to your life's meaning. For instance, cooking dinner might connect to values of health and nurturing relationships, while your work might relate to personal growth and contributing to society.
• Create a "kindness journal" where you jot down one act of kindness you've done each day, how it made you feel, and any reactions you observed. This practice not only encourages you to perform daily acts of kindness but also serves as a reflection tool to see the ripple effect of empathy in your community and personal life.
• Engage in a personal project that combines both logical and spiritual elements, like designing a garden based on both botanical knowledge and Feng Shui principles. This hands-on activity allows you to experience the harmony of blending scientific understanding with spiritual aesthetics.

To counteract the tendency toward despotic governance, fostering individual distinctiveness, upholding ethical principles, and adhering to truthfulness is essential.

Desmet proposes that developing a robust individual identity, maintaining ethical principles, and persistently advocating for honesty can counteract the tendencies toward solitude, conformity, and blind obedience that empower dictatorial governments. The author suggests that the human spirit thrives when we welcome the mysteries of life and foster an environment that appreciates diverse perspectives and the liberty of artistic expression, which in turn encourages uniqueness. Desmet suggests that by recognizing our personal truths and actively listening to the stories shared by others, we can foster a society marked by fairness, empathy, and contentment.

Context

• A robust individual identity contributes to psychological resilience, enabling people to withstand external pressures and maintain their beliefs and values even in challenging environments.
• Societal norms and values that prioritize ethics and integrity can influence political systems by promoting leaders who are committed to justice and accountability.
• Honesty can serve as a defense against propaganda and manipulation, which are often tools of totalitarian regimes to enforce blind obedience.
• By valuing diversity and mystery, societies can enhance social cohesion, as people learn to respect and understand differences, reducing conflict and promoting harmony.
• Empathy is the ability to understand and share the feelings of another. It is crucial for building strong, supportive relationships and fostering a compassionate society.