PDF Summary:The Light Eaters, by Zoë Schlanger

What if plants possess an intelligence we have long overlooked? In The Light Eaters, Zoë Schlanger explores this tantalizing possibility. She navigates the debates between scientists who believe that the complex behaviors of plants may point toward a form of consciousness, and those who maintain that plants cannot be "aware" without a brain.

Schlanger unveils recent research suggesting plants can communicate via chemical signals, recognize their relatives, and learn from experiences—even passing on adaptations through generations. Along the way, she ponders how human activities may be disrupting plants' subtle social connections, an idea with profound implications for the future of our environment.

(continued)...

• The idea that plants have sensory faculties akin to human perception is controversial, with some scientists suggesting that plants' responses to stimuli are more mechanical and less cognitive than some research suggests.
• The concept of plant cognition and the comparison to animal or human cognition is debated, with some researchers emphasizing that plant responses, while complex, do not necessarily imply consciousness or intentionality.
• The notion of plants having a form of vision is not widely accepted, and the evidence for this is not as robust as for other types of plant sensory responses.
• The anthropomorphic language used to describe plant interactions with other species (e.g., "recruiting" ants or "deceiving" wasps) may not accurately reflect the non-conscious, evolutionary processes driving these interactions.
• The impact of human-induced pollution on plant communication is an area of active research, and while there is evidence of disruption, the long-term ecological consequences and the resilience of plant signaling networks are still being explored.

Flora possess the ability to remember, learn, and make decisions.

Schlanger explores the intriguing capacity of plants to preserve recollections of their encounters and adjust their behavior accordingly, challenging the traditional view that plants operate purely on instinct without any consciousness.

Plants have demonstrated the capacity to store and recall information, challenging the long-held view that they are merely passive organisms.

The plant life has developed the ability to predict and remember the timing of its pollinators' visits.

The writer highlights how the Andean flower Nasa poissoniana adeptly coordinates its pollen dispersal to coincide with the expected reappearance of bumblebees, based on their prior visitation schedule. Schlanger details botanist Tilo Henning's experiment showing that the flower can learn and adapt to changes in the pollinators' schedule, adjusting its behavior based on stored information. The vegetation demonstrates a sophisticated capacity for learning and memory, which calls into question the notion that plants are merely inanimate objects.

Studies have shown that plants are capable of adjusting to their surroundings based on past encounters and can transmit these changes to their offspring.

Schlanger also draws on research by Sonia Sultan, who studies how plants pass on adaptations to their offspring, demonstrating a form of transgenerational memory. Sultan's research indicates that offspring of plants cultivated in challenging environments, like those with scarce water or inadequate sunlight, are inherently equipped to prosper in comparable adverse conditions. The book details how smartweed, which has survived drought conditions, produces progeny with seedlings that possess longer and thinner roots to improve their water-seeking capabilities; it also delves into the way yellow monkeyflowers, following predation on their forebears, give rise to descendants with spiked leaves for protection. The ability to transmit knowledge through generations, shaped by environmental conditions, suggests that memories passed down can manifest as characteristics sculpted by the environment.

Investigating how plants preserve and interpret information deepens our comprehension of their cognitive abilities and consciousness.

Discussions persist on the topic of whether the actions exhibited by plants should be interpreted as indicators of intelligence or awareness, similar to cognitive abilities observed in the animal kingdom.

Schlanger highlights the significant influence on debates about plant memory and learning capabilities, enhancing our comprehension of their cognitive abilities and awareness. Critics argue that plants lack the capacity for true intelligence or conscious awareness due to their absence of a brain. Schlanger presents the case that human memory is not confined to the brain alone, as evidenced by the ability of the immune system to remember past infections and by the transmission of stress or trauma effects to subsequent generations via epigenetic modifications. The author emphasizes deep explorations of cognitive processes, individuality, and distinctiveness, suggesting that these characteristics might also be found in entities other than humans.

Philosophical questions around the nature of intelligence, agency, and subjectivity, and whether they must be defined in human terms

Schlanger encourages audiences to reconsider their assumptions about intellect and to adopt alternative approaches to perceiving the environment around them. The writer suggests that, drawing on Anthony Trewavas' studies, plants may possess a form of consciousness that permeates their cellular makeup, equating the whole entity to a "brain" that operates collectively. Ultimately, Schlanger champions a broader viewpoint that recognizes the extraordinary capabilities of plants, appreciating that intelligence can present itself in diverse forms.

Other Perspectives

• The behaviors observed in plants may not necessarily indicate "memory" or "learning" in the same sense as animals but could be the result of simple biochemical feedback mechanisms that have been misinterpreted as cognitive processes.
• The concept of "decision-making" in plants could be an anthropomorphic interpretation of natural adaptive responses to environmental stimuli, which are governed by genetic and biochemical processes rather than conscious thought.
• The ability of plants to "predict" the timing of pollinator visits may not be a form of cognitive anticipation but rather a synchronized biological rhythm developed through evolutionary processes.
• While plants can exhibit adaptive responses, the transmission of these adaptations to offspring could be explained by genetic variations and natural selection rather than a form of transgenerational "memory."
• The comparison of plant responses to animal cognition might be misleading due to the fundamental differences in the biological structures and processes involved in these two kingdoms of life.
• The debate on plant intelligence and consciousness may be rooted in a lack of clear definitions and measurable criteria for these concepts, leading to subjective interpretations of plant behavior.
• The suggestion that plants have a form of consciousness could be considered speculative without concrete empirical evidence to support such a claim, as current scientific understanding of consciousness is closely tied to the presence of a central nervous system.

Plants establish intricate interconnections and associations, encompassing a variety of species as well as among their own kind.

Schlanger explores the complex relationships between various plant roots and the microorganisms in the soil, highlighting the advanced social dynamics that occur within different plant populations.

Plants have the capacity to recognize kin and interact with neighboring flora in ways that can be either collaborative or antagonistic.

Plants exhibit an inclination to adjust their root development and leaf orientation to avoid competing with their relatives.

Schlanger portrays the American searocket, a humble coastal shrub, as growing numerous roots when surrounded by unrelated flora. However, these plants thoughtfully restrict their root growth when in proximity to their relatives, thus allowing their kin to share in the available nutrients and resources. Impatiens and sunflowers, in addition to a range of different flora, recognize their kin and engage in cooperative behaviors. The author delves into Rubén Torices' intriguing studies, showing that a particular Spanish herb species intensifies its colorful flower displays when surrounded by genetically similar flora, suggesting it willingly diminishes its reproductive potential to boost that of its kin.

Debates around the evolutionary benefits and ethical implications of plant sociality

Schlanger explores the concept that an organism is predisposed to assist its kin when the benefits to their shared genetic heritage outweigh the risks to its own existence. The idea, originally linked to animal behavior, illuminates the possibility that interactions among plants could bolster the survival and proliferation of closely related organisms within a collective. The findings have the potential to significantly alter agricultural practices by encouraging some researchers to advocate for the cultivation of plant varieties that foster symbiotic relationships and discern kinship ties, potentially enhancing yields and reducing counterproductive competition.

The understanding that plants are dynamic elements intertwined with extensive ecological systems, rather than isolated units, has become more widely accepted.

Many organisms, including insects, fungi, and microbes, are known for their affinity towards plants, which frequently results in them being affected by these flora.

Schlanger delves into the intricate mutualistic relationships that plants form with diverse living entities. Certain ant species receive nourishment and shelter from plants, and reciprocally, these ants defend the flora against enemies, participate in the reciprocal transfer of nutrients with soil fungi, and help preserve an essential equilibrium with the organisms that pollinate the plants. The author explores a concept made well-known through the work of evolutionary biologist Lynn Margulis, defining a 'holobiont' as a collective of various interdependent species that operate as a single organism. Schlanger suggests that this idea offers a more vivid depiction of how plants are deeply embedded in a dynamic web of interdependence and connectivity.

Human activity can disrupt the delicate balance of interactions among various species by changing their surroundings.

Schlanger emphasizes the fragile dynamics of communication between different species, emphasizing how pollution caused by humans affects these exchanges. The author highlights studies by Jarmo Holopainen and James Blande which suggest that air pollution may reduce the scent of flowers and disrupt the communication mechanisms plants use to attract pollinators and beneficial predators. Interfering with the complex systems of interaction within the plant community may heighten vulnerability to pest invasions and threaten the productivity of agricultural harvests. The writer reflects on the importance of recognizing that plant communities depend on shared support and collaborative actions to bring about change, promoting a move away from the sole emphasis on environmental competition.

Other Perspectives

• While plants do establish intricate interconnections, it's important to note that not all species have been observed to exhibit such complex behaviors, and some associations may be more opportunistic than truly social.
• The concept of plants recognizing kin is based on observable behaviors, but the mechanisms of recognition are not fully understood, and attributing intention or social dynamics to these behaviors can be anthropomorphic.
• Adjustments in root development and leaf orientation to avoid competition could also be interpreted as a result of resource optimization strategies rather than kin recognition.
• The restriction of root growth near kin could be a result of chemical signaling or other non-cognitive processes rather than a deliberate "thoughtful" action.
• Cooperative behaviors in plants like Impatiens and sunflowers are often inferred from outcomes rather than direct evidence of intent or strategy.
• The intensification of flower displays by a Spanish herb could be a byproduct of other selective pressures, not necessarily a conscious reduction in reproductive potential for the benefit of kin.
• Debates around the evolutionary benefits of plant sociality often hinge on the interpretation of observed behaviors, and alternative explanations based on individual survival and reproduction may also account for these behaviors.
• The application of kin selection theory to plants is still contentious, and some researchers argue that the benefits of such behaviors may not always outweigh the costs.
• The concept of plants as dynamic elements within ecological systems, while widely accepted, may sometimes overshadow the importance of individual plant species' adaptations and survival strategies.
• Mutualistic relationships, such as those between ants and plants, can also involve exploitation and conflict, and not all interactions are mutually beneficial.
• The 'holobiont' concept, while useful, may oversimplify the complex and sometimes transient nature of interspecies interactions.
• Human activity's impact on plant interactions is complex, and some species may adapt to or even benefit from changes in their environment caused by humans.
• The effects of air pollution on plant communication are an area of active research, and the extent of these effects can vary widely among different plant and pollinator species.
• The assumption that interference with plant community interactions will uniformly increase vulnerability to pests does not account for the potential for some species to adapt to new conditions or for ecosystems to reach new equilibria.

The evolution and change in the variety of plant species over the years.

Schlanger highlights the extraordinary adaptability of plants, demonstrating their capacity to flourish in constantly changing surroundings.

Plants exhibit remarkable adaptations, showcasing their capacity to surmount obstacles and dispelling the common misconception that they are passive or primitive entities.

Schlanger depicts plants as sentient and adaptable beings, skillfully navigating the challenges associated with a fixed existence. The writer documents the progression of algae from simple forebears to the diverse species we see today, emphasizing their vital role in altering the planet's air composition through the process of photosynthesis. The author illustrates the ingenious strategies plants employ to overcome the obstacles of a stationary existence, ranging from predatory traps to protective chemical mechanisms.

The advent of primitive vegetation was pivotal in the evolution of photosynthesis, which in turn markedly altered Earth's atmospheric makeup.

Schlanger highlights the essential role that flora plays in fostering an environment conducive to the flourishing of life on Earth. She elucidates how photosynthesis changed the Earth's atmosphere, setting the stage for the emergence of animal life rich in oxygen by converting sunlight into usable energy. The writer emphasizes the enduring impact of this change, pointing out the continuous resilience and inventiveness inherent in the flora.

Plants have evolved numerous ingenious adaptations, including methods for ensnaring prey and the ability to mimic other life forms.

Schlanger delves into the variety of tactics that plants employ to thrive in various environments. She delves into the intricate workings of Venus flytraps, highlighting how they evolved leaves that trap and digest insects, and their advanced capability to numerically tally and metabolize their quarry for sustenance. The author explores how certain weeds have developed an evolutionary tactic to blend in with surrounding crops, thereby avoiding detection and elimination, by examining examples like rye that has changed its seeds to resemble wheat and barnyard grass that has taken on a likeness to young rice plants. Schlanger delves into examples of mimicry among various species, such as the common lungwort's leaves that take on the guise of bird droppings to deter herbivores, and certain passionflower species that craft patterns on their leaves akin to butterfly eggs, thereby deceiving insects that are seeking suitable locations for egg deposition.

Human actions are escalating the threat to various species, increasing the likelihood of their disappearance and putting the variety of plant life at risk.

The preservation of uncommon and threatened flora presents distinct challenges.

Schlanger introduces Steve Perlman, a scientist with a focus on Hawai'i's distinctive plant life, who is dedicated to the preservation of plant species on the brink of extinction. The writer joins Perlman on his daring expeditions to remote cliffs and high-flying adventures, depicting the lengths he goes to protect unique plant life that is under threat from non-native organisms.

The study provides insights into the resilience and adaptability of certain plants that thrive in new environments, shedding light on plant agency and potential.

Schlanger subsequently turns her attention to the remarkable resilience of invasive species such as Japanese knotweed, which have flourished in new habitats and proliferated swiftly worldwide. The writer explores the extraordinary growth strategies and widespread spread of these plants, demonstrating how they question conventional wisdom with their unique combination of versatility and possession of highly specialized abilities. Schlanger delves into the ways in which plant self-sufficiency and the potential use of their resilience can aid various species in adapting to the rapidly evolving conditions on Earth.

Other Perspectives

• While plants do exhibit remarkable adaptations, it's important to note that not all plant species have been equally successful in adapting to changing environments, and some have become extinct when they could not cope with rapid changes.
• The role of primitive vegetation in the evolution of photosynthesis is crucial, but it's also worth mentioning that photosynthesis likely evolved in multiple lineages independently, and not all photosynthetic organisms have had the same impact on Earth's atmosphere.
• While many plants have evolved ingenious adaptations, these adaptations are the result of natural selection over long periods and not indicative of conscious strategy or sentience in plants.
• Human actions indeed pose a threat to various species, but it's also true that humans have taken steps to conserve and protect plant diversity through botanical gardens, seed banks, and conservation laws.
• The preservation of rare and endangered flora is challenging, but there are also success stories where human intervention has helped to recover species that were once on the brink of extinction.
• The resilience and adaptability of invasive species can be seen as a problem rather than a positive attribute, as these species often outcompete native flora, leading to reduced biodiversity and the disruption of local ecosystems.