PDF Summary:The End of Craving, by Mark Schatzker

Does the carbohydrate-insulin model fully explain why we gain weight? In The End of Craving, Mark Schatzker delves into the complex mechanisms behind appetite and metabolism, exploring how nutrient fortification, synthetic flavors, and processed foods may disrupt our body's natural hunger signals.

Schatzker examines the divide between the neural pathways for cravings versus satisfaction. He suggests that nutrition studies focused too narrowly on specific nutrients like carbs or fats, missing the intricate interplay between nutrients, genetics, environment, and the brain's regulation of caloric intake. The book presents a holistic view, arguing that to truly address overeating, we must understand the entire metabolic system—including our innate drive for nutritious, whole foods.

(continued)...

The rise in obesity rates within the United States may be attributed to the intake of foods that are nutrient-dense yet metabolically ambiguous.

The author argues that the prevalent access to processed foods and the escalated use of refined grains have led to circumstances in which individuals frequently ingest foods that seem nutrient-dense yet are laden with calories. An organism's innate drive to seek out a variety of nutrient-dense foods is hindered when it no longer receives crucial signals that signify a deficiency in vital nutrients. Americans' excessive consumption might stem from insufficient self-discipline and an unyielding pursuit of calories.

Context

• Over the past few decades, there has been a significant shift from whole, unprocessed foods to highly processed options, which can contribute to metabolic ambiguity and obesity due to their altered nutrient profiles.
• This term refers to the body's confusion in processing foods that do not provide clear signals about their nutritional content, potentially leading to overeating as the body seeks missing nutrients.
• Modern diets high in processed foods can disrupt the natural balance of gut microbiota, which plays a role in signaling nutrient needs to the brain.
• In the U.S., portion sizes have increased over the years, which can lead to higher calorie consumption as people often eat what is served rather than what they need.

The tradition in Italy of using foods that are unrefined and minimally processed might have contributed to the preservation of the body's natural mechanisms for controlling appetite and managing energy equilibrium more efficiently.

Schatzker highlights the inclination of Italians towards consuming foods in their natural, unaltered state, a choice that might have unintentionally protected them from the negative consequences linked to nutrient fortification. Their dietary approach, which prioritizes a diverse selection of fruits and vegetables coupled with whole grains, likely delivers a more comprehensive spectrum of nutrients that aligns closely with nature's varied bounty. Enhanced communication between the digestive system and the brain could lead to better regulation of appetite and calorie intake. The author suggests that should processed foods be enhanced with essential nutrients, they could become akin to "nutritional Walmarts," offering an all-encompassing supply for dietary requirements, but this might disrupt the intricate and subtle cues that encourage a well-rounded diet.

Practical Tips

• Create a "Farmers' Market First" rule for grocery shopping, committing to buy a certain percentage of your produce from local markets. This encourages you to eat seasonally and supports local agriculture, which often uses less processing. You might discover new fruits and vegetables that you wouldn't find in a regular supermarket.
• Experiment with "Meatless Mondays" by preparing meals that are rich in whole grains and plant-based proteins. This can help shift the focus of your diet towards more fruits, vegetables, and grains, similar to a Mediterranean dietary pattern. Try making a lentil Bolognese sauce served over whole-grain pasta, which offers a new twist on a classic Italian dish while sticking to the principle of variety and wholesomeness.
• Create a nutrient journal to track your daily intake and ensure you're getting a broad spectrum of nutrients. Start by listing all the foods you eat each day and use a reliable online nutrition database to log the vitamins, minerals, and other nutrients they contain. Over time, you'll be able to identify any gaps in your nutrient intake and make informed adjustments to your diet.

The book delves into the complex mechanisms of the brain that regulate our dietary patterns, with a special emphasis on the neural pathways linked to enjoyment and fulfillment.

Our brains operate as sophisticated regulators of metabolism, continuously monitoring and fine-tuning our nutritional state to precisely control hunger and maintain the balance of energy within our bodies.

The writer highlights the remarkable capacity of our cerebral system to regulate metabolic requirements, a feat that outshines the most sophisticated computational advancements. Our intricate physiological network employs various detectors, chemical messengers, and hormonal mechanisms to preserve a delicate balance between the intake of calories and their expenditure.

The brain is capable of regulating our body weight by modulating appetite and metabolic rate to ensure equilibrium.

Schatzker explores a variety of research that underscores the remarkable capacity of the brain to regulate body mass. The author examines Michel Cabanac's personal nutritional trials where he intentionally reduced his caloric consumption, which initially led to weight loss, followed by a plateau, and ultimately a heightened sense of appetite that returned his weight to its original level. He also scrutinizes the research conducted by Jules Hirsch concerning obese individuals who, even when their caloric consumption was significantly restricted, persistently displayed a strong inclination to revert to their former weight. The brain plays a vital role in maintaining a certain body mass, as evidenced by studies and the challenges people face in keeping significant weight off.

Context

• The hypothalamus is a key brain region involved in regulating appetite and energy expenditure, responding to signals like leptin and ghrelin.
• The body's ability to maintain internal stability, such as temperature and energy balance, is crucial for survival. This includes regulating hunger and energy expenditure to keep body weight stable.
• Emotional and psychological factors, such as stress and food addiction, can influence eating behaviors and contribute to weight regain.
• The brain's ability to adapt and change, known as neuroplasticity, can affect how it regulates body weight, potentially altering responses to diet and exercise.
• The concept of a "set point" suggests that the body has a natural weight range it strives to maintain, regulated by the brain. This involves complex interactions between hormones, metabolism, and appetite.

Different neural pathways responsible for desire and satisfaction shed light on why certain foods can provoke intense cravings without providing a commensurate sense of pleasure or fulfillment.

Schatzker emphasizes the groundbreaking work of a researcher who has demonstrated a distinct divide between the neural circuits for pleasure and those for reward, showing that the sensations of desire and enjoyment are separate. He explains Berridge's research on rodents, showing that by modifying dopamine levels, it's possible to dissociate the craving for sustenance from the enjoyment obtained through eating. This split, observed in individuals with addictive behaviors, sheds light on the paradoxical desire for sustenance that fails to deliver true enjoyment.

Context

• The brain has complex networks of neurons that process different types of information. Neural pathways are specific routes that signals travel through the brain, and they can be specialized for different functions, such as processing emotions, sensory input, or motor control.
• Sometimes cravings can be linked to the body's need for specific nutrients, but the foods craved may not actually provide those nutrients, leading to a cycle of craving without fulfillment.
• Pleasure is often linked to the release of endorphins and other neurotransmitters that create a sense of well-being, while reward is more about the anticipation and motivation to obtain a desired outcome, often driven by dopamine.
• This separation can have psychological effects, contributing to feelings of dissatisfaction or emptiness when desires are met without true enjoyment, potentially impacting mental health and well-being.
• In addiction, the reward system can become dysregulated, leading to increased cravings without corresponding increases in satisfaction, which can perpetuate compulsive behaviors.
• The food industry often exploits this split by creating products that trigger strong cravings through additives and flavorings, which may not provide nutritional satisfaction or true enjoyment.

Dopamine, an essential neurotransmitter, plays a role in the complex mechanisms that control the reward and motivation aspects associated with our dietary habits, instead of merely indicating "pleasure."

Schatzker proposes that dopamine's role in our eating habits is not limited to providing pleasure but also acts as an incentive signal that determines the desirability of a potential reward. Dopamine release can trigger powerful cravings that drive us to pursue food, even when our bodies do not require sustenance.

Changes in the brain's dopamine circuits, often seen in addictive patterns, can lead to detrimental associations with food, potentially causing disorders characterized by an inability to control overeating.

Schatzker argues that the compulsion to eat can intensify to a point where it becomes overwhelming as addictive substances or actions hijack our brain's reward system, even though the satisfaction derived may diminish or the unease may increase. This illuminates the reason why people who often overeat persistently feel hungry and why those with additional weight find it challenging to control their cravings.

Practical Tips

• Experiment with new food-related experiences to diversify your palate. Try cooking a new recipe each week that includes ingredients you're not used to, or visit a restaurant that serves cuisine from a culture you're unfamiliar with. This can help break old associations by creating new, positive experiences with food.
• Establish a support network by starting a virtual check-in group with friends or family who also want to manage their eating habits. Set up regular meetings to discuss challenges and successes, share healthy recipes, and encourage each other to stick to your goals. This creates a sense of accountability and community, which can be powerful motivators for change.
• Create a "distraction plan" with a list of activities to turn to when you feel the urge to eat compulsively. This could include a quick walk, calling a friend, or working on a puzzle. The key is to have these options readily available and visible, perhaps on your fridge or pantry door, so when the compulsion hits, you can immediately engage in an alternative behavior that also provides a sense of reward or accomplishment.
• Create a "satisfaction scale" from 1 to 10 and use it before deciding on second helpings. Before you reach for more food, pause and rate your current level of satisfaction. If you're above a 7, consider skipping the extra portion. This can help you become more attuned to your true satisfaction levels and prevent overeating.
• Use smaller plates and bowls to naturally reduce portion sizes without feeling deprived. By serving your meals on smaller dishware, you trick your brain into thinking you're eating more than you actually are, which can help you feel satisfied with less food.
• You can create a visual craving control board by gathering images and quotes that represent your health goals and the negative consequences of giving in to cravings. Place this board in a prominent place where you'll see it when cravings typically hit. For example, if you often crave sweets after dinner, put the board on the fridge or pantry door to serve as a reminder of your goals when you're most tempted.

Providing flavorful options with fewer calories that activate the brain's pleasure centers may be more effective in transforming dietary patterns than simply restricting calories.

The author examines the concept, drawing from Anja Hilbert's research, that altering the brain circuits that dictate our dietary choices may prove to be a superior approach compared to simply reducing intake of detrimental foods in addressing poor eating patterns. She strives to cultivate a healthier relationship with food, guiding people towards dishes that offer profound satisfaction without excessive caloric content, thus emphasizing the joy found in genuine enjoyment. This approach is consistent with the discoveries made by Berridge, indicating that utilizing the "liking" system could provide a more enduring solution to managing detrimental desires.

Context

• Eating is not just about physical nourishment but also about emotional and psychological satisfaction. Foods that are both enjoyable and healthy can help fulfill these needs, reducing the likelihood of seeking out unhealthy options.
• Emerging technologies, such as neurofeedback or brain stimulation, are being explored as ways to modify brain activity related to cravings and eating behaviors.
• Focusing on enjoyment rather than restriction can lead to more positive behavioral changes, as people are more likely to stick with habits that bring them pleasure.
• The "liking" system refers to the brain's response to pleasure and enjoyment, distinct from the "wanting" system, which drives cravings and desires. Understanding this difference is crucial for developing strategies that focus on enhancing genuine enjoyment rather than just satisfying urges.

Modern methods of food processing have disrupted our natural ability to discern the flavor and nutritional value of our food.

The widespread use of synthetic sweeteners, along with various other additives, by the food industry has resulted in a notable divergence between the flavor of food and its true nutritional value.

Schatzker argues that the widespread incorporation of synthetic sweeteners, alternative fats, and a variety of additives within the food sector has altered our taste experience, resulting in a distinct disconnect between the taste we detect and the actual nutritional value our food offers. The disruption hampers the brain's inherent mechanisms that evaluate a food's caloric content and regulate appetite.

When the brain inaccurately assesses a food's caloric content relative to its actual nutritional worth, it may disrupt the innate control of appetite, potentially causing overeating.

The author underscores the importance of the connection between the taste of a food and its energy content in preserving metabolic equilibrium, an idea that is backed by the research of Dana Small. In her study, she discovered a link between drinks with a mismatch between anticipated sweetness and actual calorie content, leading to decreased insulin sensitivity, a condition particularly noticeable in young people at the brink of pre-diabetes onset. Our metabolic health could be profoundly affected by misleading cues within our food that not only lead us astray in our conscious food choices but also exert a more profound influence.

Context

• The brain's reward system is involved in processing the pleasure and satisfaction derived from eating. When caloric content is misjudged, it can alter dopamine signaling, which plays a role in motivation and reward, influencing eating behavior.
• Historically, humans evolved to associate certain tastes with specific energy contents, such as sweetness with high-calorie foods like fruits. This helped in selecting energy-rich foods necessary for survival.
• Many low-calorie or diet foods use artificial sweeteners to mimic sweetness without the calories. These can confuse the brain's ability to associate sweetness with caloric intake, potentially affecting metabolic processes.
• Consistent consumption of foods with misleading cues can contribute to chronic conditions such as obesity, type 2 diabetes, and cardiovascular disease.

The escalating issue of obesity could be worsened due to the challenge the brain faces in accurately assessing and responding to the caloric content of highly processed foods, which frequently does not align with their nutritional value.

Schatzker posits that the pervasive issue of poor dietary balance plays a crucial role in encouraging overconsumption, which is a key contributor to the escalating prevalence of obesity. The brain often falls for foods that mimic the sensation of being sweet and satiating without delivering the necessary calories, since it typically predicts the caloric content of our food through its taste. Research on gerbils and rats has indicated that a continuous feeling of uncertainty can trigger a primal reaction to avoid possible scarcity, leading them to consume more as they prepare for potential future scarcities.

Practical Tips

• You can track your body's response to processed foods by keeping a food and feelings diary. After consuming highly processed foods, note any feelings of hunger or satiety along with the time these sensations occur. This will help you become more aware of how these foods affect your hunger cues and can guide you towards making adjustments in your diet for better satiety.
• Use a smartphone app to track the nutrient density of the foods you eat. Choose an app that allows you to scan barcodes or manually enter food items and provides a breakdown of the nutritional content. This can help you make more informed decisions at the grocery store by comparing the nutrient density of processed foods versus their whole food counterparts. For example, you might discover that a processed granola bar has less fiber and more sugar than a handful of almonds with a piece of fruit.
• Engage in a 'rainbow challenge' where you include fruits and vegetables of different colors in every meal.
• Challenge yourself to modify recipes by reducing high-calorie ingredients and enhancing flavors with spices, herbs, or other low-calorie flavorings. For example, if you're making a creamy soup, try using pureed cauliflower instead of heavy cream to achieve a similar texture with fewer calories. Pay attention to how these changes affect your satisfaction and satiety levels after eating.
• Create a "needs vs wants" checklist to use before making any purchase. This simple tool can help differentiate between items you need for your current lifestyle and items you're buying to mitigate future fears. When you feel the urge to buy something, go through the checklist; if it's a 'want' that's driven by uncertainty, consider postponing the purchase.

Processed foods, although enhanced with nutrients to correct dietary shortfalls, might have unintentionally disrupted our innate systems that regulate hunger and ensure caloric equilibrium.

Schatzker suggests that while the decision to enrich processed grains successfully eliminated pellagra, it may have had unintended effects on our metabolic health over time. Fortification can promptly remedy specific nutritional deficiencies, but it may interfere with the intricate processes our bodies employ to regulate our dietary patterns based on the nutrients detected in what we consume.

Fortified foods, by providing a readily available supply of dense nutrients, may have interfered with the brain's inherent system that regulates consumption according to the nutrient density it detects.

The author suggests that the widespread availability of nutrient-fortified processed foods, which are packed with energy, provides people with a constant supply of nourishment similar to animal feed, bypassing the need for dietary diversity and reducing our reliance on natural cues to choose our food. He argues that this diminishment in our ability to truly savor our food drives us to consume more than necessary as we chase the elusive balance of nutrients that our brains find difficult to gauge accurately, because of absent vital cues.

The customary Italian habit of eating foods that are unprocessed and barely changed might have preserved the brain's ability to manage dietary patterns more efficiently by relying on natural taste and metabolic signals.

Schatzker emphasizes the contrast in food attitudes between the United States and Italy, noting how Italy prioritizes high-quality ingredients, the pleasure obtained from their tastes, and a commitment to traditional, less processed elements. The author suggests that by focusing on the enjoyment of consuming food, they may have inadvertently maintained their natural appetite control systems. Italians may have maintained an understanding of metabolism that remains robust in comparison to countries where synthetic food items have replaced authentic nourishment, by taking pleasure in whole foods that provide genuine sensory enjoyment and a wide range of nutrients.

Practical Tips

• Experiment with a 30-day challenge where you focus on eating whole, nutrient-dense foods instead of fortified products. Before you start, note your general well-being, energy levels, and any health metrics you can measure, like blood pressure or weight. After the 30 days, compare your notes to see if there's been a significant change.
• Engage in a community swap where you exchange homemade, nutrient-rich meals with friends or neighbors. This initiative encourages you to prepare foods that are naturally high in nutrients, without relying on fortification. By sharing these meals, you'll not only diversify your diet but also get a sense of how different foods can satisfy hunger and provide nourishment in a more natural context.
• Create a visual food diary using a photo app on your phone to track the changes in your meals as you incorporate more Italian diet principles. Take a picture of each meal that aligns with the unprocessed, Italian-style eating and review these images weekly to see your progress and stay motivated. This visual record can serve as a powerful tool to reflect on your dietary evolution and maintain your commitment to healthier eating habits.
• Organize a monthly "Traditional Dish Potluck" with friends or family where everyone brings a dish made from scratch using traditional recipes and techniques. This could be an opportunity to research and cook a regional Italian dish, for instance, using only fresh, high-quality ingredients. Sharing these meals can foster a deeper appreciation for the culinary traditions and the importance of ingredient quality.
• You can create a "Mindful Menu" for the week where each meal is an event. Plan your meals as if they were special occasions, dedicating time to savor each bite and appreciate the flavors. This could mean setting the table nicely, even if dining alone, and turning off distractions like the TV or phone to focus on the eating experience.