PDF Summary:The Coming China Wars, by Peter Navarro

In The Coming China Wars, Peter Navarro explores how China's economic and trade policies have disrupted global markets and impacted other countries. He argues that China has gained an unfair advantage through labor exploitation, currency manipulation, intellectual property theft, and lax quality controls leading to dangerous exported products.

Navarro also examines China's increasing military strength, suppression of dissent, and growing environmental crisis. He warns that if left unchecked, China could destabilize international power dynamics and threaten global security.

(continued)...

In China, the silencing of those who expose misconduct obstructs the swift recognition of concerns pertaining to the safety of products.

Navarro argues that the lack of protections for whistleblowers in China exacerbates the problem of dangerous goods being produced in the country. Whistleblowers exposing unscrupulous practices within companies operating in China frequently encounter severe consequences, which promotes a culture of silence and allows dangerous practices to continue unchecked.

People in China face threats, physical attacks, and imprisonment when they disclose information about dangerous or defective products.

The author emphasizes the considerable dangers faced by individuals who expose wrongdoing in China's healthcare industry, citing the harsh consequences suffered by people like Dr. Tang Zhixiong, as well as Ms. Zhou Huanxi and Mr. Shi Yuefu, for disclosing unethical practices. Individuals often hesitate to report concerns about product safety due to fear of possible consequences, hindering the prompt identification and resolution of dangerous goods that may pose a risk to consumer health.

Other Perspectives

• Many goods manufactured in China adhere to international safety and quality standards, with numerous Chinese companies holding reputable certifications and undergoing rigorous quality control processes.
• The Chinese government has been making efforts to improve regulatory oversight and has implemented stricter safety standards and harsher penalties for violations in recent years.
• Global supply chains are complex, and product safety issues are not unique to China; other countries also face challenges with ensuring the safety of consumer goods.
• There are instances where Chinese manufacturers have been proactive in recalling defective products and taking responsibility for quality issues.
• The concept of "quality fade" is not exclusive to Chinese vendors and can occur in any competitive manufacturing sector where cost-cutting pressures exist.
• China has a growing number of consumer advocacy groups and legal reforms aimed at protecting whistleblowers and improving product safety.
• The Chinese market itself is becoming more sophisticated, with domestic consumers increasingly demanding higher-quality products, which drives improvements in manufacturing standards.
• International businesses operating in China often play a significant role in defining the quality and safety standards of the products they commission, suggesting that responsibility also lies with foreign companies that outsource production to China.

China's environmental degradation has repercussions that extend worldwide.

Navarro argues that China's unyielding pursuit of economic growth has resulted in significant environmental damage. Peter Navarro warns that the ecological damage originating from China has repercussions that transcend its national boundaries, impacting the overall health of the planet's environment.

China holds the position of being the principal contributor to global greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, largely because of its significant reliance on coal for energy production, a source known for its high level of impurities.

Navarro highlights China's heavy reliance on coal, the most contaminating fossil fuel, as the main reason for its significant air pollution and status as the world's leading greenhouse gas emitter.

The manufacturing and power generation activities in China release pollutants into the atmosphere at unprecedented levels, leading to the accumulation of hazardous particulates in the air and the creation of acid precipitation.

China consumes more coal annually than the United States, the United Kingdom, and Japan put together. He details the environmental toll of this dependence, describing Chinese cities shrouded in "chog" (Chinese smog), documenting the toll of acid rain falling across China and neighboring countries, and describing how the worldwide ecosystem is being polluted by hazardous substances, which encompass a range of poisonous compounds like mercury.

China's environmental decline is increasingly spilling over its borders, negatively impacting the air and ecosystems of neighboring countries.

Navarro cites studies showing that a considerable amount of the air pollution impacting cities, including Los Angeles and San Francisco, originates from China. He also delves into the ways in which China's environmental degradation not only affects its own territories but also spreads detrimental consequences, including "Chinese chog" and acid rain, to nearby countries such as Japan, Korea, and Taiwan, highlighting the extensive nature of the problem.

The pollution of water bodies in China is escalating, posing substantial obstacles for the nation's agricultural sector.

Navarro argues that China is on the brink of a severe water crisis, with its rivers increasingly obstructed by industrial waste and sewage, its lakes turning barren, and the depletion of its groundwater resources occurring at a disturbing pace.

The degradation of many aquatic ecosystems in China has been accelerated by agricultural runoff and the discharge of untreated contaminants and waste from manufacturing activities.

The waterways in China are tainted with a spectrum of red, blue, and green from industrial dyes, and the accumulation of dangerous heavy metals in riverbeds and lakes, along with the overuse of pesticides and fertilizers, results in the pollution of both surface and groundwater. He emphasizes the concerning reality that more than nine-tenths of China's untreated industrial wastewater and sewage is discharged, leading to a dangerous concoction that gravely impacts human health and the health of oceanic ecosystems.

The intensification of water shortages in China and the expansion of its desert regions stem from the nation's irresponsible utilization and mismanagement of water resources.

Navarro discusses the alarming depletion of underground water sources in China's northern areas, attributing the significant decline in aquifer levels, which results in land sinking and the drying up of rivers and lakes, to the overuse of this essential resource for farming and manufacturing purposes. He also addresses the advancing deserts, noting that each year, around 2,000 square miles of land in China fall victim to desertification, a condition worsened by overgrazing, deforestation, and unsustainable farming practices.

The construction of a multitude of large-scale dams by China is resulting in considerable environmental damage and is forcing millions to relocate.

Navarro criticizes China's intense commitment to dam building, depicting it as a decision that prioritizes short-term economic gains over the long-term well-being of the environment.

The development of the Three Gorges Dam is associated with an increase in landslides, environmental contamination, and more frequent flooding incidents.

He scrutinizes the massive hydroelectric endeavor along China's longest river, revealing a series of unforeseen and catastrophic outcomes: the forced relocation of numerous people, the vanishing of important historical sites and productive agricultural land, heightened risk of landslides, and the buildup of hazardous waste in the dam's expansive reservoir. He details the potential for a catastrophic failure of a dam, which could be triggered by accumulated sediment in the reservoir, posing a threat to countless individuals.

China's unilateral construction of dams on major rivers like the Mekong is disrupting ecosystems and water supplies in downstream countries.

Navarro also criticizes China's construction of dams on international rivers like the Mekong, arguing that China, due to its advantageous upstream location and dominant power, can ignore the ecological consequences and the repercussions for neighboring countries that share the river. He warns that the diminishing water resources and changes in usual flooding cycles might put Vietnam's crucial Mekong Delta farming area at risk, highlighting the potential for disputes due to a lack of water.

Other Perspectives

• China has been making significant investments in renewable energy and is now one of the world's largest producers of solar panels and wind turbines, indicating a shift towards cleaner energy.
• The Chinese government has implemented various environmental policies and regulations aimed at reducing pollution and promoting sustainable practices.
• Many countries have contributed to global greenhouse gas emissions, and developed nations have historically been the largest polluters on a per capita basis.
• The issue of air pollution is not unique to China; many industrialized nations have gone through similar phases of environmental degradation during their development.
• International trade contributes to China's pollution, as many countries outsource manufacturing to China; thus, the responsibility for emissions is shared.
• China's water pollution challenges are being addressed through initiatives like the "Action Plan for Water Pollution Prevention and Control," which aims to improve water quality.
• The construction of dams, while having environmental impacts, also provides renewable energy and is part of China's efforts to reduce reliance on coal.
• The Three Gorges Dam has also played a role in flood control and electricity generation, contributing to the region's economic development.
• China's actions on international rivers are part of broader geopolitical and economic strategies, and it engages in diplomatic discussions and agreements with downstream countries.
• Desertification and water shortages are complex issues influenced by global climate change, and China is not the only country facing these challenges.

China's implementation of strict controls, enhancement of its military strength, and the subsequent global repercussions.

Navarro argues that China's authoritarian rule, combined with its aggressive suppression of dissent and rapidly expanding military capabilities, poses a threat to both its own citizens and global peace and security.

In China, the government rigorously quashes any opposition, enforces limitations on the freedom of speech, and exercises tight control over independent civil society groups.

Navarro describes the governing body of China as one that enforces severe control, with the government strictly regulating the flow of information, enforcing media censorship, and applying strict restrictions on internet access, all in an effort to aggressively quash dissent.

Journalists, activists, and individuals of various ethnicities have faced arbitrary imprisonment, torture, and execution as methods of oppression.

He details the strategies employed to maintain dominance within China, utilizing a vast network of security forces, comprehensive surveillance, and strict rules designed to quell any opposition. He details how the government employs methods such as detention without clear justification, compulsory labor camps, torture, and capital punishment as means to discipline dissenters. He underscores the intense difficulties encountered by journalists, activists, and a range of religious groups, along with practitioners of Falun Gong and diverse ethnic populations in regions like Tibet and Xinjiang, who endure unyielding oppression, imprisonment, and occasionally death for defying governmental orders.

American technology companies have played a role in creating digital surveillance systems that limit online connectivity for the people of China.

Navarro criticizes American technology companies for bolstering the authoritarian actions implemented by China's ruling authorities. He addresses the role of companies like Cisco in providing sophisticated equipment to Chinese officials, equipment that is employed to restrict internet liberty, monitor digital activities, and identify and penalize government dissenters.

China is rapidly modernizing and expanding its military capabilities, posing risks to neighbors and the global balance of power.

Navarro suggests that the rapid growth of China's economy is simultaneously fueling its military ambitions. He cautions against a nation utilizing a broad strategy, incorporating elements like economic influence and digital tactics, to fulfill its ambitions.

China is directing more financial resources to its military at a pace that outstrips its economic expansion, which supports the maintenance of a sizeable land force, the cultivation of a navy for global operations, and the enhancement of its capabilities in both aerial and missile technology.

Peter Navarro examines the significant growth in China's military strength, marked by consistent increases in defense spending by ten percent or more annually, which has led to the modernization of its unmatched ground troops, the broadening of its naval influence with global consequences, and the advancement of complex missile and space capabilities that challenge the dominance of the United States' military.

Tensions over territorial claims in the South China Sea and other contested regions have the potential to intensify, potentially leading to a direct clash between China and the United States.

Navarro highlights several potential triggers that could lead to an armed confrontation involving China and nations like the United States. He emphasizes the volatile situation across the Taiwan Strait, where China has clearly indicated its readiness to use military force to prevent Taiwan from declaring independence. He also warns of potential conflicts over resource-rich territories in the maritime region south of China, emphasizes Beijing's growing military ties with nations like Iran and Venezuela, which frequently find themselves sidelined internationally, and examines the risks associated with escalating trade disagreements.

China's strategic use of its UN Security Council veto power shields rogue states and enables human rights abuses worldwide

Navarro argues that China uses its expanding economy and advancing military, along with its power to veto in the U.N. Security Council, to undermine the international framework and shield countries that disregard global standards.

China impedes global sanctions and interventions to ensure its continued procurement of resources and entry into markets within nations such as Sudan, Iran, and Zimbabwe.

He depicts China's influence on international affairs as troubling, particularly its obstruction of the United Nations' efforts to impose sanctions and prevent atrocities against humanity in countries like Sudan, Burma, and Zimbabwe. He points out that China consistently prioritizes its own economic interests – securing access to resources and markets – over global security and the wellbeing of people in countries that are victims of rogue regimes.

Other Perspectives

• China's governance model is based on its unique political and cultural history, and it may argue that its approach is necessary for maintaining stability and development in a populous and diverse nation.
• The Chinese government may contend that its security measures are aimed at preventing terrorism and separatism, which it views as threats to national unity and the well-being of its citizens.
• Some American technology companies have taken steps to implement human rights considerations into their business practices and have engaged in dialogues about the ethical use of technology.
• China's military modernization is often presented as a means to protect its sovereignty and legitimate national interests, similar to how other nations invest in their defense.
• The increase in military spending can also be seen as a natural outcome of China's growing economy and its desire to assume a role commensurate with its status as a major global power.
• China's actions in the South China Sea can be framed as exercises of its territorial claims, which it bases on historical grounds, and it participates in diplomatic negotiations and maritime cooperation with neighboring countries.
• The use of veto power in the UN Security Council by China is not unique and is a right exercised by all permanent members, sometimes argued as a check against unilateral actions that may not consider the interests of all parties involved.
• China's international relations strategy, including its engagement with countries facing sanctions, can be viewed as a form of diplomacy that prioritizes dialogue and economic development as pathways to stability and reform.