PDF Summary:Product Management's Sacred Seven, by Neel Mehta, Parth Detroja, and Aditya Agashe

Building a successful product, whether physical or digital, involves equal parts art and science. In Product Management's Sacred Seven, authors Neel Mehta, Parth Detroja, and Aditya Agashe guide readers through key principles of strong product development. This insightful summary delves into the psychology of understanding user behavior and motivations, creating intuitive interfaces, and devising pricing and growth strategies.

The authors share practical techniques for aligning business goals with consumer needs—ensuring mutual benefit through thoughtful design choices, data-driven tactics, and astute management of product economics. From avoiding dishonest patterns to nurturing viral loops, this guide equips product managers with strategies for optimizing today's digital landscape.

(continued)...

The authors point out that for startups lacking the financial resources, workforce, or brand recognition, creation is often the only viable path. Furthermore, it is advantageous to begin development when your organization possesses pre-existing expertise or understanding that can ease the challenges of starting a new endeavor; such as Microsoft's deep familiarity with corporate security measures significantly contributing to its independent development of the Teams platform. In situations where your product's main feature isn't the central aspect of its value proposition, it's often wiser to pursue collaborations, such as an accounting application that could gain greater advantages by partnering with a well-known social media platform rather than attempting to build its own. Borrowing can be as straightforward as outsourcing a specific job to a service provider, like hiring a design agency to craft your company's logo, or initiating a complex partnership, exemplified by the joint venture that led to the creation of MSNBC, a collaborative effort between Microsoft and NBC. Acquiring a product may serve a strategic purpose when its development poses significant challenges or when the aim is to suppress market competition; the authors cite the example of a leading social media corporation acquiring a widely-used photo-sharing app to illustrate how this move can thwart potential rivals like Twitter and Google from gaining a foothold in the burgeoning market of that application. Companies should conduct a comprehensive evaluation of all potential options prior to deciding on a particular approach for market entry.

Establishing enduring advantages in competition.

Mehta, Detroja, and Agashe characterize the strategic benefits that protect a company's position in the market from rivals or establish obstacles for customers who might consider transitioning to a different service as "financial fortifications."

The authors emphasize that the requirement for a substantial initial outlay in expensive equipment serves as a barrier to market entry. The aviation sector's hefty financial commitments to sizable aircraft, coupled with the oil and gas industry's requisite for drilling apparatus and production tools, as well as the costly infrastructure utilities necessitate, establish formidable barriers to entry that usually only substantial corporations can surmount, frequently resulting in oligopolistic or monopolistic market configurations within these conventional "old economy" industries. In tech, there’s a big difference between software companies, whose up-front costs are low, and “old economy" companies. The delivery infrastructure of Amazon is so well-designed and operates so efficiently that it may only be rivaled by other large companies like Walmart. Navigating the stringent regulations that govern sectors like financial technology, healthcare, and cybersecurity can be a lengthy process, often taking multiple years, which can deter new companies from entering these fields. Finally, intellectual property (IP), such as proprietary knowledge and confidential processes, can also heighten market entry barriers, particularly when an entity holds a crucial patent—Mehta highlights that the substantial licensing revenue Qualcomm enjoys stems from its exclusive dominance over specific wireless communication technologies. Companies encounter challenges when they try to change their approaches, due to resistance from customers as well as deliberate strategies by businesses to keep users engaged. Companies can foster consumer devotion by creating distinctive product environments, such as the AirPlay system that functions solely within the domain of a particular technology behemoth, or by building robust brand personas that lead customers to view changing brands as a betrayal of loyalty. The principle of network effects suggests that as more individuals use a product, its value escalates, thereby solidifying the dominance of entrenched firms and creating substantial barriers for new entrants to secure a market presence. Facebook's growth has been greatly enhanced by its approach of integrating other businesses, which is crucial because the worth of social networks lessens when one's personal network is not active on the platform. Mehta, Detroja, and Agashe emphasize the importance of creating strong financial defenses to maintain a product's ongoing success, cautioning that without these, the product might soon lose its distinctiveness, resulting in a relentless downward spiral of reduced profits, as shown by the case of a well-known ride-sharing company.

Understanding and applying the fundamental concepts related to the economics of individual units.

This segment concentrates on the monetary elements of business frameworks, particularly highlighting the significance of grasping the concepts of incremental expenses, income generation, and financial gain. Agashe, Mehta, and Detroja highlight the differences in cost structures between physical products and digital offerings, underscoring the significance of scaling to generate profits in tech companies.

Evaluating the incremental costs and earnings.

Mehta, Detroja, and Agashe stress the importance of thoroughly understanding the economic metrics associated with each product or service a company offers, which requires a detailed analysis of the costs, revenue, and profit for each sale, whether it's for electronics like smartphones, food items, meal delivery services, or online movie rentals.

The writers stress the significance of analyzing the costs of manufacturing additional units, the income they bring, and their impact on profit margins in relation to production volume to fully understand the financial health of a business. The authors stress that the sustainability and endurance of a business or product are fundamentally connected to its capacity for profit-making, irrespective of the level of investment it has attracted or the regularity of its promotional activities. Mehta, Detroja, and Agashe illustrate this principle through two case studies, one examining physical items like USB storage devices and the other concentrating on software programs. Producing physical goods requires a significant upfront investment in factory setup and machinery purchase, and the profit margin for each additional item sold is often slim, exemplified by the slender earnings obtained from individual flash drive transactions. To realize considerable earnings from physical goods, strict cost minimization is crucial because even minimal savings can be impactful. The creation of additional units of a digital product generally involves negligible expenses. The expense associated with creating another unit of a song, software application, or streaming service subscription is negligible, leading to a significant enhancement in profit margins. They often face significant fixed costs, including salaries for their technical team and expenses related to renting premises for their operations. Agashe, Mehta, and Detroja contend that attracting more users to a company's digital offerings is a highly efficient method for boosting its income, since each additional user contributes significantly to earnings without incurring substantial extra costs, thereby enhancing profit margins.

The importance of expanding digital product offerings.

Mehta, Detroja, and Agashe emphasize that high upfront costs for tech companies coupled with low marginal costs, meaning that getting a large "install base" of users or customers is crucial to achieving profitability.

The writers emphasize that substantial funding is essential for the creation of a tech product, leading to a high reliance on external financing from investors in the tech industry. Manufacturing sectors, which are foundational to the conventional economy, may have the capacity to self-fund, but technology companies require external capital to initiate and scale their operations before they are able to generate income. The book offers illustrations of numerous businesses that have expended funds to achieve this critical juncture. At the turn of the millennium, Google faced financial instability because the founders were hesitant to show ads, but the situation improved when the company started to profit from its large user base through the introduction of advertising. Before Google started to reap financial rewards, it had already secured a significant global footprint, in contrast to Uber that faced annual losses amounting to billions before its 2019 debut on the stock market. The rapid growth in Uber's clientele was solely responsible for the losses. Investors were confident that Uber's large number of users, coupled with its low incremental costs, would result in significant revenue and earnings, often resulting in higher profit margins. Product managers must recognize that the financial success of digital products is largely due to the low additional expenses and significant additional earnings, emphasizing the necessity of expanding their reach and attracting a vast number of users. The cycle of virtue outlined by Mehta, Detroja, and Agashe suggests that enhancing a product leads to the expansion of its user community, thereby yielding more data and sustaining the cycle's momentum.

Grasping the economic significance of how customers act is crucial.

This part of the text examines a technique for determining the financial feasibility of a product, an idea referred to as customer economics. Essential indicators of the framework encompass both the expenses associated with securing a new customer and the revenue they generate over the duration of their association with the company. The authors stress the importance of focusing on the long-term financial value provided by a customer rather than being swayed by less significant metrics that could give a false impression of success.

Calculating the cost incurred when a new customer is acquired, often referred to as the CAC.

The book underscores the significance of evaluating the full spectrum of interactions customers have over time instead of focusing on standalone products or services. Customer Acquisition Cost represents the average expenses incurred when gaining a new customer. Many Product Managers incorrectly believe that calculating Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) is simply a matter of dividing total marketing and sales spending by the number of new customers acquired, but this approach does not provide the necessary precision. To precisely determine the Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC), one must include all costs associated with acquiring a new customer, including marketing and sales spending, compensation for technical personnel, charges for server and cloud services, and sometimes, overhead for the company's office space, even though this latter cost may be difficult to attribute. Calculating the cost of acquiring a customer is further complicated by the lack of clear standards for identifying who qualifies as a "customer" and the exact point at which they are considered acquired. How long should Spotify monitor to determine the cost of acquiring a new paid subscriber – is it one month, six months, or a year? What distinguishes people who sign up for the free version from those who would have signed up anyway? Mehta and his colleagues underscore the necessity of pinpointing the precise customer demographic for a particular product and choosing a suitable timeframe for evaluation when examining the costs involved in acquiring new clientele.

Assessing the enduring worth of a customer's association with a business.

Mehta, Detroja, and Agashe delve into the concept of the total revenue a customer contributes over their engagement with a product, known as customer lifetime value (LTV); this period may span from just a week to ten years, adding complexity to defining a standard duration! LTV is thus more long-term than the unit economics methods we saw earlier, since it doesn't look at individual purchase but rather a customer's entire "journey" with your product. The authors describe the conventional method for determining LTV as summing up the incremental gains, or the net profits, anticipated from each transaction with a given customer. The authors employ the gaming console industry as an example. Predicting the exact number of gaming consoles or cartridges that each customer will purchase from Nintendo is a considerable challenge. Nintendo earns a profit of $100 from each console sold and gains an additional $40 from every game cartridge. To determine the Lifetime Value (LTV), one should add the cost of two gaming consoles, each at $100, to the sum of five games, each costing $40, which amounts to $400. The additive approach is also beneficial for a range of different software commercial strategies. Assuming an average Google user engages with 100 advertisements over their lifetime, and each ad contributes fifty cents to Google's revenue, the total Lifetime Value (LTV) would be $50. While this amount might appear small, it is consistent with the Lifetime Values of a variety of different businesses. Determining the long-term value is complex due to the variable and unpredictable length of time a customer stays engaged. Churn, as defined by Mehta, is a metric that determines the percentage of users who cease to engage with the service over a given period, often tracked monthly or yearly. If 50% of an ecommerce platform's buyers don't visit the platform for a year, the annual churn rate is 50%, and you can estimate that the average customer lifetime is one divided by the churn rate, or two years in this example. This technique is also employed in the field of nuclear chemistry to determine the time required for radioisotopes to diminish to half of their original quantity. The annual contribution to revenue from each user is used to ascertain the lifetime value in businesses with subscription models, such as SaaS. To calculate the Lifetime Value, one must start by multiplying the average yearly income generated from each user by the gross margin, and then divide the result by the rate at which customers cease their subscriptions, which is indicative of the revenue that is not absorbed by expenses.

The dynamic relationship between the long-term value of customers and the expenses associated with their acquisition.

Mehta, Detroja, and Agashe then draw a parallel between crucial financial indicators, particularly the cost associated with acquiring a customer and the value of a customer over the duration of their relationship with the company. It is essential for the lifetime value of a customer to exceed the cost of acquiring them; otherwise, it is not financially viable to spend more on acquisition than what the customer will ultimately contribute in revenue. Ensuring profitability presents its challenges, particularly because accurately calculating the costs involved in acquiring new customers can be difficult, even when the long-term revenue generated by a customer surpasses the associated acquisition expenses.

To reduce uncertainty, the business must ensure that it generates significant profits by maintaining a lifetime value to customer acquisition cost ratio of no less than threefold. The objective is to make certain that the long-term value derived from a customer exceeds the initial expenses incurred to acquire them, thus guaranteeing that each customer contributes to overall profitability. The concept of LTV to CAC ratio has grown so fundamental for experts in Silicon Valley and on Wall Street that it is often called "the magic number." The authors, Mehta, Detroja, and Agashe, illustrate the efficacy of this ratio by using the Kindle Fire as an example. Amazon markets its Kindle Fire devices at prices so competitive, occasionally starting at $50, that it is commonly believed they might be sold without profit or even at a deficit. Amazon employs a clever approach in marketing its Kindle Fire, resulting in a scenario where the long-term value derived from customers significantly surpasses the initial costs of acquiring them. Kindle Fire tablets don't run a normal version of the Android operating system, they run “Fire OS,” a fork of Android that doesn't have access to Google services; instead the phones' home screens are full of Amazon services like the Kindle ebook reader, Amazon's app store, Prime Video, Prime Music, and the Amazon store. Amazon is thus betting that each Kindle Fire sold will make users spend more money on Amazon than the tablet cost to make, thus getting LTV to exceed CAC. Agashe and his co-authors emphasize a commercial strategy similar to the one where razors are offered at minimal prices while the blades are sold at a premium, which is comparable to the method of marketing printers at reduced prices and earning significant revenue from the ink sales, among various other instances. Occasionally, it's justifiable to have initial customer acquisition costs that surpass early revenue if there are plans in place to ensure significant long-term financial benefits from the customer relationship.

Other Perspectives

• While cost leadership can provide a competitive advantage, it may also lead to a "race to the bottom" where companies compromise on quality or sustainability to maintain low prices.
• Differentiation strategies can lead to exclusivity that may alienate broader market segments and can be imitated over time, reducing their effectiveness.
• The blue ocean strategy, while innovative, can be risky and resource-intensive, with no guarantee of finding or successfully exploiting untapped markets.
• Entering new markets through in-house development, partnerships, or acquisitions can be complex and costly, and there's no one-size-fits-all approach that guarantees success.
• Barriers to entry and customer loyalty can be double-edged swords, potentially stifling innovation and leading to complacency within established companies.
• The focus on scaling and external financing in tech companies can lead to prioritizing growth over profitability, which may not be sustainable in the long term.
• Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) and Customer Lifetime Value (LTV) are important metrics, but they can be difficult to measure accurately and may not capture the full complexity of customer relationships.
• A high LTV to CAC ratio is ideal, but focusing too much on these metrics can lead companies to overlook other important aspects of their business, such as customer satisfaction and product quality.

Mastery in the fields of expansion and promotional strategies, coupled with the skill of influence, is crucial.

Grasping the essential desires and driving forces behind consumer behavior.

This section explores the psychological aspects of designing products that enthrall users and foster their continued involvement. Agashe, working alongside Mehta, delves into various models to understand what propels human ambition, emphasizing the essential requirement to fulfill users' deep-seated desires for expertise, autonomy, importance, and belonging.

Internal and external motivations

Agashe delve into the concept of intrinsic motivation, characterized by the pursuit of activities for their own enjoyment and personal satisfaction, as well as the concept of extrinsic motivation, which involves performing tasks driven by external rewards or to prevent negative consequences. Product managers need to understand the subtleties of the different types, because a mistake here might put the product's success at risk.

Agashe, along with Mehta, underscore that the presence of an external incentive, like monetary rewards for accomplishing tasks, might diminish the intrinsic interest in engaging with a product, indicating that such rewards can frequently lessen individuals' innate motivations. The authors depict this event by detailing how the implementation of fines at Israeli daycare centers for tardy pickups by parents actually led to more delays, as the parents began to view the fine as a justifiable cost for additional service, thus justifying their lateness. The book is replete with a diverse array of practical examples sourced from the technology industry. Intellectual forerunners were attracted to the platform that specialized in exchanges of questions and answers because it offered a mix of intrinsic rewards and external recognition, including community support and the chance for online fame, rather than monetary compensation. Mehta, Detroja, and Agashe also highlight the broad acceptance of software that originates from an open-source setting, which is developed and maintained by a diverse group of contributors who dedicate their expertise to intricate products like internet navigation applications and the core components of operating systems, frequently without monetary reward. Internal motivation frequently exerts a stronger influence than external rewards, especially in the context of products that demand innovation, sophisticated abilities, or contribute to a sense of community, although external rewards can also markedly enhance motivation, similar to how a catalyst functions in the language of startups.

Individual autonomy and the concept of independence.

The authors delve into the factors that drive internal motivation in individuals, drawing on the principles of self-determination theory. SDT posits that individuals have an intrinsic motivation to satisfy three fundamental cravings. These encompass proficiency in a particular field, the ability to independently navigate one's path, and experiencing a connection with others.

The authors explain how these desires manifest themselves. People feel skilled when they improve their skills and see clear results from their efforts, essentially seeing the results of their work and realizing they are becoming more capable. Mehta, Detroja, and Agashe propose that people attain the greatest sense of satisfaction when they participate in tasks that harmonize precisely with their skills, similar to the captivating settings created by video game designers, which accounts for the intense allure of video games. Products should assess user capabilities and present challenges that correspond appropriately to their proficiency to maintain engagement and interest. The second desire, autonomy, represents the liberty to steer and decide based on individual preferences. Creating a clear and structured approach to product development is crucial, while also ensuring that users have maximum freedom within that structure. The authors praise Khan Academy for its adaptable learning framework that permits students to choose their lessons according to their preferences, unlike the often inflexible framework found in numerous online courses. And finally, relatedness involves feeling liked, cared for, and establishing a bond with others. Digital tools often face challenges in fostering inclusive conversations among their user base, but platforms dedicated to social networking stand out for their ability to enable individuals to observe the behaviors of other participants.

The model developed by Galloway is segmented into four quadrants.

The authors Mehta, Detroja, and Agashe utilize Scott Galloway's NYU framework, which correlates the underlying desires of users with the fulfillment of four basic human needs: intellectual stimulation, emotional connection, the joy of consumption, and sexual attraction.

The first one, the brain, is about an unending quest for knowledge and development, akin to the way a child needs a constant supply of milk. The authors liken the act of using Google Search to tapping into an extensive wellspring of understanding, comparable to linking with a vast compendium of wisdom that encompasses the cosmos. The sense of fulfillment people gain as they enhance their skill set in Excel by learning keyboard shortcuts, create complex graphics in Photoshop, or achieve advanced levels in Duolingo highlights how our intellect is stimulated by activities that expand our expertise or competence. The essence is completed through affection, societal acceptance, and the establishment of robust interpersonal relationships. Platforms like Facebook are adept at creating a community atmosphere, which is similarly accomplished by platforms that effectively nurture a sense of being well-liked or the belief that one's input is beneficial to the group, thereby cleverly leveraging societal standards. Incorporating milestones in a personal finance application can instill a sense of accomplishment in users, since the completion of tasks is frequently linked to uplifting emotions. The unquenchable desire is to amass an abundance of possessions, ranging from tangible assets such as homes, vehicles, or sustenance, to information, and even currency. Agashe argues that our inclination to gather items and knowledge is rooted in an evolutionary history where scarcity was the norm. Ecommerce sites obviously pander to getting people more stuff, but so do news sites that offer endless lists of stories, social media apps' infinite scrolling feeds, or anything that gives users a sense of completion, a rush of energy from completing a collection task (like filling your library of Kindle ebooks). The pursuit of sexual attraction, as expected, motivates the reproductive organs. People often use luxury items as a means to display their wealth, which can be appealing to prospective mates, and this idea is also applicable to various other aspects: improving one's image with photo filters on social platforms, indirectly showing off leisure time by sharing pictures of holiday homes on digital platforms, and so on. The authors conclude this section with the insight that products are designed to appeal to more than just one sense. Google Photos enthralls its audience by addressing their intellectual needs with enhanced photo sorting capabilities, stirring emotions by offering features that facilitate sharing memories with loved ones, meeting utilitarian demands with the offer of "unlimited storage," and catering to their sense of beauty through advanced image improvement options and filters.

Utilizing innovative strategies to accelerate customer progression through the various phases of the marketing funnel.

This section explores modern marketing approaches that focus on data-driven methods to improve the conversion of users, encourage swift and widespread distribution, and leverage the power of network effects to accelerate growth. The authors illustrate their points with notable examples of businesses that have secured significant achievements by employing strategic methods designed for rapid expansion.

Creating Viral Loops

Mehta, Detroja, and Agashe introduce the concept of growth hacking as a way for products to "market themselves."

Products are designed with features that incentivize existing customers to attract new ones, thereby diminishing reliance on traditional marketing costs. The authors depict a situation in which the number of individuals using a product experiences a significant surge, akin to the shape of a hockey stick's curve, propelled by a widespread surge in user recommendations, often known as "viral marketing." The writers bolster their argument by referencing the familiar yet somewhat outdated example of Hotmail's free email service, which, in its initial phase, included the tagline "PS: I love you" in its messages. Each message ended with a captivating slogan that advertised Hotmail's complimentary electronic mail service. The approach was crucial in driving the growth of the email service during the late 1990s, culminating in its acquisition by Microsoft for $400 million. Mehta, Detroja, and Agashe propose that instituting incentives for referrals constitutes an effective tactic. PayPal's expansion truly took off when it implemented a strategy of rewarding users with $20 for every new member they referred. The authors characterize these strategies as a systematic approach for scaling, allowing companies to meticulously assess and modify their path of expansion. Due to its swift and unsustainable growth, PayPal opted to decrease the incentive for new accounts to $10.

Hacking Consideration and Conversion

The authors stress the significance of making the core functionalities of your product, like handling financial transactions, booking lodgings, or posting personal photos on the internet, more accessible and user-friendly.

The authors discuss several examples. Amazon's focus on making transactions effortless is a surefire strategy to boost profits. The company's proprietary technology streamlined the checkout experience, allowing customers to complete their purchases with a single click, which simplified the process by eliminating the typical multiple steps required for entering payment details and choosing shipping preferences and addresses. The authors contend that by minimizing obstacles, the likelihood of individuals taking the desired action increases significantly.

Other Perspectives

• Mastery in expansion and promotional strategies, while crucial, may not be sufficient without a strong product foundation and customer service.
• Understanding consumer behavior is complex, and psychological models may not capture the full spectrum of human desires and motivations.
• Intrinsic and extrinsic motivations are not the only factors that impact product success; market conditions, competition, and timing also play significant roles.
• The assumption that individual autonomy and independence are universal drivers of motivation may not hold in collectivist cultures where community and group goals are more valued.
• Galloway's model may oversimplify human needs and not account for cultural and individual differences in what users find fulfilling.
• Innovative strategies for customer progression can sometimes lead to a focus on growth at the expense of sustainability and long-term customer satisfaction.
• Viral loops and growth hacking techniques may not be applicable to all products or services, especially those that require high trust or investment.
• Making core functionalities more accessible and user-friendly is important, but over-simplification can sometimes remove valuable features or customization options that some users may desire.