PDF Summary:Principles of Economics, by Saifedean Ammous

In Principles of Economics, Saifedean Ammous delves into the core beliefs and principles rooted in the tradition of Austrian economics. He explores concepts like subjective value, marginal utility, and time preference that shape individual economic behavior. The book also examines the importance of property rights as the foundation for a capitalist system, the role of markets in coordinating supply and demand, and the effects of banking policies on economic cycles.

Ammous further analyzes the impact of fiat currencies, arguing that their instability distorts economic incentives. He proposes Bitcoin as a market-driven alternative that could restore sound monetary policies and encourage long-term thinking in economic decision-making.

(continued)...

Practical Tips

• Consider volunteering for a local land trust to help maintain and protect property rights in your community. Land trusts often work to conserve land for public use and ensure that property rights are respected. This hands-on approach gives you a practical understanding of how property rights contribute to efficient market economies.
• Develop a neighborhood tool-sharing program to encourage collaboration among neighbors. Use a simple sign-out sheet or digital app to track who borrows items like lawn mowers, ladders, or power tools. By establishing clear temporary property rights, neighbors can benefit from shared resources without the cost of individual ownership, promoting a sense of community and cooperation.
• Explore local foraging to discover natural resources you can legally gather and use. Research your local area for edible plants, herbs, and fruits that grow wild. Many regions have foraging groups or online communities where you can learn what's available and how to harvest sustainably. For example, you might find wild berries in a nearby forest that you can pick and make into homemade jam.
• Develop a cooperative game night with friends or family where the games chosen are based on resource management and fair play. Games like "Settlers of Catan" or "Ticket to Ride" require players to acquire and control resources strategically. Playing these games can help you understand and appreciate the importance of rightful control over resources in a fun, interactive setting.

Unclear definitions of property ownership can lead to conflicts and hinder the process of making solid economic choices.

Ammous argues that the absence of well-defined private property rights can lead to conflicts, inefficient use of resources, and impede prosperous economic endeavors. Without clear ownership, people lack an incentive to properly maintain and invest in resources as they cannot be certain of reaping future benefits. A focus on the short term often results in excessive consumption and eventual exhaustion of resources.

Ammous clarifies this concept by using the example of land utilization. When private property rights are not assured, individuals are prone to excessively use land without considering the future consequences, leading to its significant depletion and degradation. The issue known as the "tragedy of the commons" can be mitigated when individuals are granted exclusive ownership, which motivates them to steward their resources responsibly and with foresight for enduring preservation. The principle in question extends to all other forms of property ownership as well. Secure private property rights are essential for individuals to value and invest in their future, enabling them to lower time preference and build a more prosperous future.

Context

• Economists like Ronald Coase have discussed how well-defined property rights can reduce transaction costs and lead to more efficient market outcomes.
• In contemporary settings, unclear property rights can deter foreign investment and economic growth, as investors seek stability and assurance that their assets will be protected.
• Modern case studies, such as the management of fisheries in Iceland, show how assigning property rights can lead to sustainable practices and economic benefits.
• Short-term consumption without regard for future consequences can lead to environmental degradation, such as deforestation and soil erosion, which can have long-lasting negative effects on ecosystems and biodiversity.
• This concept describes a situation where individuals, acting in their own self-interest, overuse and deplete a shared resource, leading to long-term negative outcomes for the entire group. It highlights the need for clear ownership to prevent resource exhaustion.
• Some critics argue that privatization isn't always feasible or ethical, especially in cases involving indigenous lands or essential public resources.
• Ownership creates a psychological incentive for individuals to care for and improve their property, as they directly benefit from any enhancements or maintenance efforts.

The functioning of markets within a capitalist framework.

The section delves into the fundamental nature of capitalism and how it serves as a catalyst for economic progress. Capitalism, as described by Ammous, is characterized by individuals holding capital, the autonomy of entrepreneurs in making business choices, and a market mechanism free from centralized oversight that coordinates the interactions between producers and consumers, enabling a sophisticated distribution of responsibilities that cannot be achieved within a centrally managed socialist system.

Ownership of capital in a capitalist system resides with individuals instead of being under the control of corporate executives.

Ammous argues that the true nature of capitalism is rooted in its entrepreneurial spirit, as opposed to elements associated with management. Entrepreneurs, who spearhead the path of innovation, constantly seek new ways to provide benefits to customers, embracing risks and allocating resources to the most promising opportunities. Entrepreneurs invest their resources in anticipation of market demands, making decisions based on market price signals prior to initiating production.

Traditional economic theorists sometimes miss the subtlety that capitalist systems can function efficiently even when the means of producing economic outcomes are administered through socialist techniques. Ammous contends that the significance of personal property rights lies in empowering business innovators to reap the rewards of their successful endeavors and bear the responsibility for their failures, which in turn motivates them to judiciously manage the allocation of their assets. The fundamental basis of economic calculation is the evaluation of gains and deficits.

Context

• Historically, the shift from feudal or state-controlled systems to capitalist ones involved transferring ownership from centralized authorities to private individuals, fostering economic growth and innovation.
• A focus on customer benefits means that entrepreneurs must understand and respond to consumer needs and preferences. This customer-centric approach helps ensure that businesses remain relevant and successful in the market.
• Successful entrepreneurial ventures can lead to job creation, increased productivity, and economic growth, contributing to the overall health of the economy.
• Some industries, like utilities or transportation, may be publicly owned but privately managed, allowing for efficient service delivery while maintaining public accountability.
• Personal property rights facilitate economic calculation by allowing individuals to assess the profitability of their ventures. This involves analyzing costs and potential revenues, which is essential for making informed business decisions.
• By focusing on gains and deficits, economic calculation encourages efficiency and innovation. Entrepreneurs are motivated to find cost-effective methods and innovative solutions to maximize profits.

The pricing system naturally coordinates the actions of buyers and sellers through the fundamental process of earning profits and incurring losses.

Ammous emphasizes the critical role that the pricing mechanism plays in synchronizing the activities of consumers and producers in a market economy based on capitalism. Market prices emerging from voluntary exchanges in free markets serve as vital signals, conveying the scarcity of commodities and the value that consumers place on them.

The mechanism of pricing directs resources to their optimal use by rewarding entrepreneurs who successfully fulfill consumer demands and penalizing those who fail to do so through the dynamics of profit and loss. Ammous clarifies that market prices incentivize producers to cut costs and deliver products of higher quality while maintaining affordability, which also empowers consumers to make informed decisions about their purchases based on their personal preferences and budgetary constraints.

Context

• The interaction of buyers and sellers through the pricing system helps achieve market equilibrium, where the quantity supplied matches the quantity demanded, minimizing shortages and surpluses.
• The pricing system inherently involves risk, as producers must anticipate consumer needs and preferences. Successful anticipation leads to profits, while misjudgments result in losses, encouraging careful market analysis and strategic planning.
• Prices act as a communication tool, providing information about consumer preferences and resource availability without the need for centralized control or planning.
• In a competitive market, multiple producers vie for consumer attention. This competition drives innovation and efficiency, as companies strive to offer better products at lower prices to attract buyers.
• Prices reflect not just the cost of production but also the demand for a product. A higher price can indicate greater demand or scarcity, guiding consumers on the relative value of goods.

Economic calculation depends on market prices and private property, which are absent in socialist systems.

Ammous delves into the complexities of entrepreneurship and the pricing mechanism, contemplating Mises' essential examination of economic calculation, a cornerstone in the Austrian School's dismissal of socialist ideology. According to Mises, rational economic calculation, the process of comparing costs and benefits for allocating resources efficiently, is impossible in a socialist economy where private ownership of capital is absent, and consequently, so too are market prices, which emerge from individuals' choices about their scarce resources and their subjective valuations.

Ammous clarifies that without a market where entrepreneurs compete for resources and influence using a common currency, central planners lack the ability to determine the best allocation of capital goods logically. He cites the downfall of socialist governments as solid proof that supports the hypothesis proposed by Mises. He highlights the Soviet Union's reliance on international market prices to make some semblance of economic calculations, and how this central planning system still resulted in a dysfunctional economy built on waste and capital destruction.

Practical Tips

• You can observe the impact of market prices on your purchasing decisions by tracking price changes of items you regularly buy and noting how it affects your buying habits. For instance, if the price of your favorite coffee brand increases, record whether you switch to a cheaper brand, buy less coffee overall, or remain loyal despite the price hike. This personal data collection helps you understand the role of market prices in economic calculation on a micro level.
• Understand the role of private property by participating in a sharing economy platform. Engage with a service like a tool library or a clothing swap, where goods are shared rather than owned by individuals. Reflect on your experiences with the service, paying attention to how the lack of private ownership affects your usage, care, and value of the items. This can provide insight into how communal use of goods might operate in a non-private property context.
• Start a book club focused on economic systems with friends or community members to discuss and compare the practical outcomes of different economic theories in real-world scenarios. Each member could present a case study of a business or country operating under a specific economic system, discussing the challenges and benefits observed. This will help you understand the practical implications of economic systems on businesses and societies.
• You can explore the impact of private ownership by starting a small investment club with friends or family. Pool a modest amount of money together and collectively decide on investments, tracking the performance over time. This hands-on experience will give you a practical understanding of how ownership and investment decisions affect economic outcomes and personal wealth.
• Start a small garden or a simulated trading account to experiment with resource allocation on a micro-scale. Allocate a fixed amount of resources, like space, seeds, and water for the garden, or virtual money for the trading account, and make decisions on how to distribute these resources to achieve the best yield or investment return. This will help you grasp the complexities of resource allocation and the importance of informed decision-making.
• You can observe and analyze your local market to identify what resources are in high demand and low supply. Start by visiting local businesses and noting which products or services they seem to be lacking. For example, if you notice that several coffee shops don't offer plant-based milk options, this could indicate a gap in the market for this resource.
• Consider volunteering at a local non-profit organization and propose a project where you compare the allocation of resources in two scenarios: one where the non-profit is the sole provider of a service, and another where it competes with another service provider. Document the differences in how resources are used, the quality of service delivered, and the feedback from service recipients.
• You can analyze historical events to understand economic theories by comparing the outcomes of different government systems in similar situations. For instance, look at two countries with contrasting economic policies that faced a similar crisis. Research how each government's approach impacted the recovery process, and use this to evaluate the effectiveness of socialist versus non-socialist policies.
• Consider using a global pricing index as a benchmark for your freelance or consulting work to remain competitive. If you offer services that could be outsourced internationally, such as graphic design or writing, knowing the going rate in different countries can help you set competitive prices. This way, you're not undercharging for your services in a global market.
• Start a personal "investment" project by allocating a small amount of money to different "departments" of your life, such as health, education, and leisure. Treat each category as a sector of your personal economy, and after three months, evaluate which investments yielded the most value in terms of personal growth, happiness, or health. This will help you understand the concept of capital allocation and its impact on productivity and well-being.

The Austrian school's viewpoint on economic cycles is centered around the management of the money supply.

In this section, the distinctive perspective of Austrian economics is scrutinized, highlighting the impact of bank credit expansion on business cycle volatility and the detrimental consequences of an unstable currency on monetary policy management. Ammous clarifies that when the amount of money circulating is manipulated, it distorts the interest rates, leading to poor investment decisions and a deceptive economic boom that is inevitably set to fail. He also argues that fiat money systems enable governments to debase the currency, undermining economic rationality and, ultimately, civilization.

The impact of expanded lending on economic cycles.

This section delves into the way credit accessibility can distort capital costs through alterations in interest rates, offering an insight into economic cycles from the standpoint of Austrian economics. Ammous clarifies that banks, through their unique dominance of central banking coupled with the fractional reserve banking system, issue credit unsupported by actual savings, leading to unviable investments that precipitate economic downturns.

When credit expansion that isn't backed by genuine savings keeps interest rates artificially low, it leads to misguided investment choices, setting off economic instability.

Ammous suggests that the oscillations of the business cycle are heavily impacted by the expansion of credit by banks, especially when it pertains to the generation of fiduciary media. Financial organizations distribute credit instruments that pledge more monetary disbursements than the actual cash reserves they hold. Financial institutions that issue loans exceeding their reserve holdings play a role in increasing the overall quantity of money and distort the inherent interest rates, leading to rates that are reduced compared to what would exist in a market relying only on credit underpinned by tangible assets.

He argues that such meddling creates an illusion of abundant resources, enticing entrepreneurs to initiate enterprises that would probably collapse in a setting where interest rates accurately signify their market value. The expansion of credit not backed by genuine savings leads to malinvestment, where projects are initiated due to distorted economic signals stemming from interest rates that have been unnaturally reduced, rendering these ventures incapable of completion due to a lack of resources.

Context

• This theory, associated with economists like Ludwig von Mises and Friedrich Hayek, explains how credit expansion leads to cycles of boom and bust. It emphasizes the importance of interest rates as signals for resource allocation.
• This occurs when banks increase the amount of loans they issue, often by creating money through mechanisms like fractional reserve banking, where they lend out more than they hold in actual deposits.
• The generation of fiduciary media raises questions about the need for regulatory oversight to ensure that financial institutions maintain adequate reserves and do not engage in excessive risk-taking.
• Understanding malinvestment can inform monetary policy, suggesting a need for caution in manipulating interest rates and credit availability to avoid economic instability.
• The illusion of abundant resources can lead to economic booms, where investment and consumption increase rapidly. However, when the true scarcity of resources becomes apparent, these booms can quickly turn into busts, leading to economic downturns.
• Projects initiated under false pretenses of resource availability often lack the necessary funding or materials to reach completion, resulting in financial losses and wasted resources.

Central bank interventions, through their manipulation of interest rates and control over the quantity of money, impede the market's natural ability to allocate resources efficiently.

Ammous underscores the role of central banks in exacerbating the harmful effects of expanding credit. Central banks, as the sole regulators of the monetary system, act as the primary protectors of financial stability, which allows banks to expand their credit services and create financial instruments with minimal worry about insolvency. They also wield direct influence over monetary policy and deliberately manipulate interest rates, thus steering the capital markets, an essential element of a market-based economic system.

Ammous argues that the economy's cyclical pattern of expansion and contraction is driven by the artificial adjustment of interest rates and the introduction of unsupported credit into the marketplace. Keeping interest rates artificially low promotes an environment where there is a surge in borrowing, leading to unwise investment choices. When it becomes apparent that certain projects are unsustainable because the essential resources required for their completion are unavailable, this triggers a downturn marked by the forced closure of companies, resulting in a rise in unemployment. He also critiques the traditional economic methodology for its failure to comprehend this dynamic, focusing more on evading recessions instead of taking preemptive measures to prevent them.

Other Perspectives

• Central bank interventions are often based on extensive economic research and data analysis, aiming to make informed decisions that benefit the overall economy rather than impede it.
• The provision of liquidity by central banks, especially during times of financial stress, can prevent market failures and ensure that resources continue to flow to productive uses.
• Expanding credit is not inherently harmful; it can facilitate economic growth, innovation, and development when managed properly.
• Insolvency concerns are also addressed by other financial regulatory bodies that work alongside central banks to ensure the soundness of the banking system.
• The idea that markets can always allocate resources efficiently without any intervention overlooks instances where market imperfections, such as monopolies or externalities, lead to suboptimal outcomes.
• Interest rates are influenced by a variety of factors, including market expectations, inflation rates, and global economic conditions, not solely by central bank policies.
• Economic cycles are complex phenomena influenced by a multitude of factors beyond credit introduction, including technological changes, geopolitical events, consumer behavior, and more.
• Artificially low interest rates are sometimes necessary to counteract deflationary pressures, which can be more damaging to the economy than the risks associated with increased borrowing.
• Low interest rates can also lead to innovation and technological advancements by providing startups and growth companies easier access to capital.
• Some unsustainable projects may not lead to downturns if they are isolated or too small to impact the broader economy significantly.
• Economic methodology encompasses a wide range of theories and models, some of which, like the Austrian School of Economics, do indeed recognize and critique the impact of interest rate manipulation.
• Economic methodologies often incorporate preemptive measures such as regulatory frameworks, fiscal policies, and stress testing of financial institutions to mitigate the risk of recessions.

The Harmful Effects of Unstable Currency

This part examines the persistent impact of volatile currency, especially fiat currency, on economic motivations, altering our appraisal of present in comparison to future commodities, and presenting a threat to the progress of society. Ammous argues that the shift toward a centralized authority possessing the power to enforce rules has detrimentally impacted the economy in every aspect.

By instituting systems of fiat currency, governments have the power to devalue currency, consequently distorting economic evaluations and undermining the foundational aspects of social organization.

Ammous argues that the world's economic structures have been significantly undermined and the advancement of human civilization has been hindered due to the dependence on government-issued currency, which lacks backing by physical assets and possesses no intrinsic value. Fiat currency, as he elucidates, encourages a focus on immediate concerns and undermines the capacity of people to accumulate savings, make investments, and prepare for future events because it grants the government the ability to diminish the value of money through inflationary practices.

He argues that this continuous decline in worth also impairs the economic evaluations that entrepreneurs depend on for making knowledgeable choices about resource allocation. Since prices are no longer grounded in sound money whose value is determined by market forces, fiat money causes constant and unpredictable distortion of market prices and interest rates, making the future more uncertain. An increased level of uncertainty typically leads to a greater inclination towards instant gratification as opposed to long-term benefits. Ammous emphasizes the significant societal and cultural consequences that arise from a trend which has resulted in increased consumption and borrowing, reduced savings, and the depletion of capital resources.

Practical Tips

• Educate yourself on personal finance and currency impact by subscribing to newsletters or podcasts that focus on economic literacy without requiring deep financial knowledge. This will help you understand how currency devaluation affects your personal finances and what actions you can take to mitigate those effects. Look for resources that break down complex economic concepts into layman's terms.
• Support local barter systems or community currencies that are backed by goods and services within the community. This can help you understand the value of direct exchange and reduce reliance on fiat money. Look for local exchange trading systems (LETS) or time banks where you can exchange your skills or goods for others without the need for traditional money.
• Develop a side hustle that provides a service or product with value that is less likely to be eroded by inflation. For example, if you have a knack for crafting, you could sell handmade goods online. Since the value of unique or custom items doesn't always decline with inflation in the same way that mass-produced items might, this could be a way to maintain or even increase your income relative to inflation.
• Educate yourself on hedging strategies to protect against currency risk if you're involved in any cross-border financial activities. Simple hedging techniques like forward contracts or options can be used even by non-experts. For example, if you're an online freelancer who gets paid in a different currency, you might use a forward contract to lock in an exchange rate for your future payments, ensuring you don't lose value if the currency weakens.
• Create a personal inflation index to track the cost of goods and services you regularly purchase. This can give you a clearer picture of how inflation impacts your personal expenses, separate from the general market. Start by listing items you buy frequently, note their prices, and update the list monthly. Over time, you'll see a pattern that reflects the true inflation rate for your lifestyle, which can inform your budgeting and saving strategies.
• Engage in peer-to-peer lending platforms as a way to invest your money, potentially earning higher returns than traditional savings accounts. This can encourage you to save more and make your capital work for you, rather than depleting it. By lending to individuals or small businesses, you're also contributing to the productive use of capital, which can lead to overall economic growth.

Bitcoin offers a sophisticated technological alternative to centralized fiat currencies, which could restore prudent monetary policies and encourage wise economic choices.

Ammous advocates for Bitcoin as a solution, driven by market forces, to the problems that arise from depending on fiat currency. Bitcoin functions as a self-governing system that facilitates the exchange of value without the need for supervision by government or banking entities. The currency's worth is protected from devaluation because there is a strict cap of 21 million coins, which guarantees that its value cannot be reduced through inflationary actions taken by governmental or central banking authorities.

Ammous argues that Bitcoin's unique properties offer the possibility of restoring sound money and economic rationality, allowing individuals to save with confidence, plan for the future, and engage in economic decision-making without needing to constantly adjust for fiat debasement. Bitcoin's capacity to enable worldwide transactions independently of governmental or financial intermediaries may pave the way for the reestablishment of a dependable monetary system and foster a shift towards valuing long-term advantages over short-term gains, crucial for the revival of the foresight and behavior characteristic of a society that exhibits significant social advancement and cultural refinement.

Practical Tips

• You can track Bitcoin's price fluctuations and compare them with major economic indicators to understand market correlations. By doing this, you'll see how Bitcoin responds to changes in the stock market, interest rates, or gold prices. For example, if the stock market dips and Bitcoin's price also falls, you might infer a correlation that can inform your investment decisions.
• Consider using a decentralized application (dApp) for a service you regularly use, such as file storage or online marketplaces. By choosing a dApp, you engage with platforms that operate on principles similar to Bitcoin, with self-governing protocols and no central point of control. This firsthand experience will give you a practical understanding of how decentralized systems function in different contexts.
• Educate yourself on the security practices necessary for safeguarding cryptocurrencies. Since there's no bank to rely on for security, learning to protect your digital assets is crucial. Research and implement security measures such as two-factor authentication, hardware wallets, and secure backup solutions to ensure that your experience with cryptocurrencies is safe and controlled solely by you.
• Engage in conversations with friends or family about the concept of digital scarcity and how it relates to Bitcoin. By discussing the limited supply, you can explore the implications of digital assets with finite availability. This can lead to a deeper understanding of supply and demand in the digital age and how it might affect your approach to digital investments.
• Experiment with using Bitcoin for small, regular transactions to get a feel for its practicality as a day-to-day currency. Choose a set amount each month to spend in Bitcoin and use it for online purchases, or at local businesses that accept it. Track these transactions to assess the ease of use, transaction fees, and any financial benefits compared to using traditional money.
• You can diversify your savings by allocating a small percentage to Bitcoin. Start by determining a comfortable amount you won't need in the short term and purchase Bitcoin through a reputable exchange. This approach allows you to explore cryptocurrency as a savings tool without significant risk.
• Set up a recurring purchase plan for Bitcoin to automate the process of investing and reduce the impact of market volatility. By investing a fixed amount at regular intervals, you can practice dollar-cost averaging, a strategy that doesn't require timing the market. Many cryptocurrency exchange platforms offer this feature, allowing you to set it and forget it while potentially growing your investment over time.
• Explore charitable donations with Bitcoin to experience its borderless transaction capabilities. Many international charities now accept Bitcoin, allowing you to donate directly without the need for currency conversion or financial intermediaries. This can also introduce you to the tax implications and potential benefits of donating cryptocurrency.
• You can shift your investment mindset by starting a 'future gains' savings account where you deposit a small amount of your income regularly, earmarked for long-term investments like retirement funds or education savings. This practice encourages you to think beyond immediate gratification and focus on the substantial benefits of long-term financial planning. For example, if you typically spend on short-term pleasures, redirecting even 5% of that spending into this account can significantly impact your future wealth.
• Develop a habit of playing "implication chess" with daily news stories. With each significant news story, take a few minutes to write down or discuss with a friend the potential second and third-order effects. This could be as simple as reading a news article about a merger between two companies and brainstorming how this might affect competitors, suppliers, and job markets.