PDF Summary:Overcoming Oppositional Defiant Disorder, by Gina Atencio-MacLean

For parents of children with oppositional defiant disorder (ODD), every day can feel like an uphill battle. But as psychologist Gina Atencio-MacLean explains in Overcoming Oppositional Defiant Disorder, there are methods to help shape your child's behavior in positive ways. This guide provides a roadmap for managing your own feelings as a caregiver while teaching your child valuable skills like emotional regulation, task planning, and social abilities.

Atencio-MacLean outlines strategies for establishing clear boundaries, employing consistent consequences, and collaborating with your child to find solutions. By focusing on their skill deficits—not the challenging behaviors—parents can develop compassion and resilience for the journey ahead. Though the road is difficult, Atencio-MacLean offers a path to better communication and stronger family bonds.

(continued)...

• It equips children with the tools to resolve conflicts peacefully, as they learn to articulate their needs and listen to others.
• Using negative communication methods like commands or insults can lead to increased anxiety, lower self-esteem, and behavioral issues in children. Positive communication supports emotional and social development.
• Children often learn behaviors by observing adults. When caregivers use respectful communication, they demonstrate how to handle conflicts and express emotions constructively, which children are likely to imitate in their interactions.
• This involves being mentally present and not allowing distractions, such as phones or other tasks, to interfere with the conversation. It shows respect and prioritizes the speaker's message.
• Each child is unique, with their own personality and temperament. Recognizing these individual differences is important in understanding why a child might see things differently from others.
• Reflecting or repeating back what children say is a technique known as active listening. It involves not just hearing words but understanding the emotions and intentions behind them, which can help build trust and rapport.

Child Collaboration for Goals and Finding Solutions

Atencio-MacLean also stresses the importance of collaboration in dialogues with children. She encourages parents to approach conversations with their kids as a collaboration rather than a competition to be won. While the parent is still the authority figure, collaborating with the child, she writes, allows the child's requirements and perspective to be considered in problem-solving and decision-making. This approach shows kids that their input is valued, which can reduce their need for defiance and aid them in developing more effective communication skills.

Context

• Viewing conversations as collaborative rather than competitive can help reduce power struggles, making interactions more peaceful and productive.
• By involving children in problem-solving, parents can help develop their critical thinking and decision-making skills. This practice encourages children to analyze situations, weigh options, and foresee potential outcomes.
• When children see that their opinions matter, it boosts their self-esteem. Higher self-esteem can lead to more positive interactions and less need to act out defiantly.
• Collaboration encourages children to practice active listening, which involves fully concentrating, understanding, and responding thoughtfully to others. This skill is crucial for effective communication.

Developing Emotional Control Strategies

This section offers tools to teach children and parents how to regulate challenging feelings.

Identifying, Labeling, and Handling Intense Emotions

Atencio-MacLean explains that emotion regulation involves the capacity to recognize, comprehend, and handle our feelings in effective and suitable manners. Since kids with an ODD diagnosis frequently exhibit significant deficits in this area, parents need to teach them specific skills to help them better regulate their intense emotions. She emphasizes that labeling and ranking the strength of a feeling is a helpful starting point because it strengthens children's capacity to communicate their experiences and request help if needed. For example, the author suggests teaching children to rate their anger from 1 to 5, where 5 is extremely intense. When they can identify that their anger is at a level 3, she writes, they can then be taught to use coping skills like deep breathing or taking a break.

She encourages parents to support their children in understanding how these feelings impact their behavior. This may be achieved by openly discussing the relationship between emotions, thinking, and actions. For example, the author suggests that parents can talk with their children about how feeling angry might lead to impulsive actions, and how developing the ability to take a moment before acting can help them make better choices.

Context

• The prefrontal cortex, which is responsible for decision-making and self-control, plays a significant role in emotion regulation. This area of the brain continues to develop into early adulthood, which is why children often need guidance in managing emotions.
• Effective interventions often include cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), parent management training, and social skills training to help children develop better emotion regulation skills.
• This practice aligns with SEL programs in schools, which aim to develop emotional literacy and resilience in children, contributing to better academic and social outcomes.
• The connection between emotions and behavior is often explained through cognitive-behavioral principles, which suggest that thoughts and feelings can drive behavior. By understanding this link, children can learn to modify their responses to emotional triggers.
• Discussing these relationships helps children develop impulse control, which is crucial for making thoughtful decisions rather than reacting based on immediate emotions.
• Anger can impair judgment and decision-making, making it difficult to think through the consequences of actions.
• Techniques such as counting to ten or practicing mindfulness can help children pause and reflect, reducing the likelihood of reacting impulsively.

Helping Kids Express Emotions Productively

Atencio-MacLean encourages parents to teach their child to openly and safely communicate their emotions, while also providing them with alternative ways of conveying their emotions and needs. These could include using words, drawing pictures, or engaging in physical activities like jogging or jumping. Teaching a child to verbalize their feelings and practice expressing those feelings in constructive ways, she writes, can be a powerful tool in helping them to regulate their emotions more successfully. She suggests that parents can model this for their kids by openly sharing their own feelings, even difficult ones like sadness or irritation. By normalizing the experience of having feelings, she explains, parents can help their kids feel secure sharing their own vulnerabilities, even when those expressions involve negative emotions.

Context

• Techniques for teaching emotional communication should be tailored to the child’s developmental stage, as younger children may need more concrete methods like storytelling or play.
• Engaging in activities like drawing or physical exercise can aid in the development of fine and gross motor skills, which are crucial for a child's overall growth.
• Emotional regulation refers to the ability to manage and respond to emotional experiences in a healthy way. It involves recognizing emotions, understanding their impact, and using strategies to cope with them effectively.
• By openly discussing emotions, parents can reduce the stigma associated with expressing feelings, particularly negative ones. This can prevent children from feeling ashamed or embarrassed about their emotions.

Identifying Child's Skill Deficits and Behavior Patterns

In this section, Atencio-MacLean shifts focus to what the child requires. She explains how to determine their unique "trouble spots," or areas of difficulty, so these can be targeted for change.

Skill Deficits in Managing Emotions, Executing Tasks, and Social Abilities Contributing to ODD Behaviors

Here, the author lays out the three main skill areas that kids with ODD frequently struggle with and explains why those deficits contribute to their problematic behaviors.

Children With ODD Struggle to Handle Emotions, Plan, and Socialize

Atencio-MacLean explains that the defiant behavior linked to ODD is most often caused by skills deficits in the areas of managing emotions, executive functions, and social abilities. She explains that emotion regulation means understanding and handling feelings, even intense ones, safely and effectively. Kids who have ODD typically struggle to label their emotions, rate their intensity, and choose appropriate coping strategies. This, she explains, leads to frequent meltdowns since they are flooded with overwhelming feelings and lack the resources to cope. She writes that executive function involves complex cognitive processes such as focusing, creating plans, exercising discipline, and facing challenges. When ODD kids become overwhelmed with difficult emotions, it disrupts their ability to think clearly and make good choices, which then leads to acting on impulse, inflexibility, and struggles with consequences. Social skills, she writes, are essential to building and keeping relationships and navigating social situations successfully. ODD kids, she explains, often misinterpret social cues and have difficulty managing their emotions in interactions with others. Because of these challenges, they often experience peer rejection and have difficulty developing and maintaining friendships.

Practical Tips

• Engage in role-playing scenarios with your child that practice executive function skills like problem-solving, flexibility, and emotional control. You could set up a 'pretend' shop where your child has to use planning and organization to 'shop' for items, or a board game evening where taking turns and managing frustration are key.
• Create a visual task board at home to help children with ODD organize their day. Use a simple corkboard or magnetic whiteboard and divide it into sections for different times of the day or types of activities. Include easy-to-move visual cues like colored pins or magnets that children can manipulate to indicate task completion. This tactile interaction can make planning and focusing more engaging for them.
• Implement a token economy system at home where good decision-making earns tokens that can be exchanged for rewards. This system reinforces the idea of consequences by providing immediate positive feedback for impulse control and considering the outcomes of actions.
• Create a "Friendship Passport" for your child with ODD, where they can collect stamps or stickers for positive social interactions they have each day. This tangible record can encourage them to engage more with peers and recognize their own progress in building friendships. For example, a stamp can be earned for sharing a toy, asking a peer a question, or playing a game together.

Recognizing a Young Person's "Trouble Spots" - Areas of Difficulty

This section focuses on recognizing your child's unique "trouble spots": rigidness, opposing authority figures, and emotional volatility/dysregulation.

Inflexibility and Difficulty Adapting to Change

Atencio-MacLean explains that inflexibility most frequently presents in situations in which expectations or desires are not met and the child has difficulty adapting to unexpected circumstances. This can include struggling with schedule changes, unmet desires, and ambiguous predictions. She emphasizes that children have different learning speeds; while some children easily adapt to change, those who have ODD frequently exhibit inflexibility because they lack the cognitive and emotional skills needed to readily adjust. They also have difficulty tolerating distress, which then makes it challenging to manage unpleasant emotions like frustration, anger, and sadness. The author notes that many children take flexibility for granted, but it actually involves a complex skill set that involves managing emotions, planning ahead, and being able to redirect their mental focus between tasks or ideas.

Practical Tips

• You can practice mental flexibility by setting a daily "adaptability challenge" for yourself. Choose a routine task each day and intentionally alter the way you approach it. For example, if you usually check emails first thing in the morning, save it for midday. This small change can help you become more comfortable with unexpected shifts in your daily patterns.
• Use role-playing games to practice handling ambiguous situations. Create scenarios where the outcome isn't clear and guide your child through different ways to respond. This helps them develop cognitive and emotional skills to deal with uncertainty. For example, set up a game where your child is a detective solving a mystery, which requires them to adapt as new 'clues' are introduced that change the direction of the story.
• Develop your planning skills by creating a "future sketch pad" where you draw or write out potential scenarios and your responses to them. This could be as simple as envisioning how you'll handle a busy upcoming day, including potential disruptions, and sketching out a plan to navigate these effectively.

Defiance of Authority Figures

Atencio-MacLean explains that challenging authority figures, a defining characteristic of ODD, most often occurs as a result of reinforced behavior patterns, difficulty regulating feelings, and weak impulse control. In these situations, defiance becomes a maladaptive method of communicating emotions and needs. The author emphasizes that resisting authority is typical human behavior; we often rebel, particularly when it seems like we're being impeded from reaching our goals. Children who have ODD are constantly testing limits and pushing boundaries to get a sense of where those lines are, and they're especially sensitive to feeling controlled because of their impulse control and emotion regulation challenges.

Practical Tips

• Practice expressing disagreement in a structured and respectful way. Role-play scenarios with a friend where you disagree with an authority figure and practice articulating your points calmly and constructively. This can help you build the skills to handle real-life situations without being oppositional.
• Develop a personal emotion thesaurus to articulate feelings more accurately. Start by writing down common emotions you experience and then expand each one into more nuanced sub-emotions. For example, if you often feel angry, break it down into frustration, disappointment, or feeling undervalued. This practice can help you communicate your emotions and needs more effectively without resorting to defiance.
• Experiment with saying "yes" to minor requests from authority figures that you would typically resist. For example, if your boss suggests a new filing system that seems unnecessary, try implementing it without pushback. Track the outcomes over several weeks to see if this change in approach leads to different results, such as improved relationships or unexpected benefits from the new system.

Emotional Instability and Fluctuating Moods

This section highlights the emotional instability that often accompanies ODD. Atencio-MacLean explains that kids who have ODD tend to experience emotional volatility or dysregulation that can be exhausting and scary for both the child and their parents. She explains that a child's emotions are frequently changing, often for what seems like no reason, making their moods difficult to predict and manage. During an outburst, children who have ODD cannot self-soothe, which often leads to extreme behavior outbursts. She writes that although often considered "bad behavior," these emotional outbursts come from a lack of skills, not motivation. They simply don't have the ability to bring themselves back down from a heightened emotional state, even if they want to.

Practical Tips

• Create a mood chart to track emotional patterns in children with ODD, using colors or symbols to represent different moods throughout the day. This visual tool can help you identify triggers and patterns in mood fluctuations, making it easier to anticipate and manage emotional instability. For example, use a green smiley face for calm moods and a red frown for more turbulent emotions, and note the time and context of each mood.
• Develop a signal system with your child that they can use when feeling overwhelmed, such as a hand signal or a specific word, to communicate their need for a break without escalating the situation. This non-verbal cue can help prevent confrontations and allows for a quick response to their emotional state.

Program of Alternatives, Boundaries, and Consequences to Develop Skills

This section of Atencio-MacLean's book offers a program to help parents systematically address their child's deficiencies in skills and modify problematic behaviors. The treatment model consists of what the author refers to as the "ABCs": choices, limits, and outcomes.

Providing Alternative, Adaptive Behaviors to Replace Problematic Ones

Atencio-MacLean explains that when trying to change a child's problematic behaviors, parents should focus on offering them alternative, and more appropriate, ways of responding in those situations.

Teaching Children Emotional Expression, Frustration Management, and Direction Following

Atencio-MacLean explains that it is essential to first identify and teach alternative adaptive behaviors that the child can use to replace their problematic behaviors. These alternatives can take many forms, depending on what the child needs. She reminds parents that, as was introduced in Dr. Ross Greene's book The Explosive Child, "Kids do well if they can." By recognizing that a child's problematic behaviors are ineffective attempts to manage their overwhelming feelings, the author encourages parents to see those behaviors as opportunities for learning and growth. She explains that to reduce defiant behavior, parents need to first teach children to identify and name their emotions and ideas, including rating their intensity, so that they can begin to recognize their own triggers and take steps to calm down when needed. She also recommends helping children express emotions safely and appropriately, either through words, drawing, or physical activity.

Atencio-MacLean explains that a common challenge for children who have ODD is their resistance to following directions, which is often due to an inability to inhibit impulses. To address this, she recommends that parents teach their children to pause before reacting, using strategies like counting to ten, taking deep breaths, or using a stress ball, in order to give them time to calm down and then make a better choice. She also points out that transitions, like shifting from one task to another or stopping a preferred activity, are difficult for kids with ODD, and recommends that parents prepare their children for those shifts whenever possible. This could involve giving them warnings or allowing for transition time in routines, like telling them that bedtime is soon.

Context

• Parents play a key role in modeling and reinforcing adaptive behaviors at home. Their involvement is crucial for the generalization of these behaviors across different settings.
• Children may not have learned or been taught effective coping mechanisms, so they resort to behaviors that are instinctual or have worked in the past to get attention or relief.
• This approach is related to the concept of a growth mindset, where challenges are seen as chances to develop new skills. By reframing behaviors as opportunities, parents can foster resilience and adaptability in their children.
• By learning to rate the intensity of their emotions, children can develop self-regulation skills. This helps them gauge when they might need to employ calming strategies before emotions become overwhelming.
• Triggers are specific situations, people, or environments that provoke a strong emotional response. Teaching children to recognize these helps them anticipate and manage their reactions.
• Creating a safe space for expression ensures that children feel secure and supported, which is essential for them to open up and share their feelings.
• Impulse control is the ability to resist or delay an impulse, drive, or temptation to act. Children with ODD often struggle with this, leading to difficulties in following directions as they may act on immediate urges without considering consequences.
• Deep breathing can activate the parasympathetic nervous system, promoting relaxation and reducing stress, which can help children feel calmer and more in control.
• Transitions refer to the process of moving from one activity or state to another, which can be challenging for children with ODD due to their difficulty in managing change and unpredictability.

Establishing Clear, Consistent Boundaries and Expectations

This section emphasizes the importance of establishing clear boundaries. Atencio-MacLean explains that kids with ODD require more structure than most because of their emotional and behavioral challenges.

Setting Rules and Limits With the Child

Atencio-MacLean writes that boundaries consist of restrictions, guidelines, and expectations. These, she explains, provide a feeling of structure, predictability, and safety for the child. While all children need boundaries to learn healthy behavior patterns, they're especially important for those who have ODD, as they have so much difficulty with authority. She recommends that parents collaborate with their children when establishing boundaries, to give them some autonomy and to increase their chances of adhering to those boundaries. For less negotiable topics, she recommends that parents clearly state what's expected and the rationale behind it.

She explains that a common challenge with setting limits is inconsistency. While a lot of parents are good at setting boundaries, she writes, they often struggle to apply them consistently. She reminds parents that boundaries are useless if they are not consistently upheld, and emphasizes that kids with ODD will persistently push boundaries until they are sure that the limits will remain in place. This, she explains, creates a more chaotic environment and reinforces, rather than reduces, defiance. As a general rule, she recommends that parents maintain flexibility with their child but be steady in enforcing the boundaries they've set together.

Other Perspectives

• While restrictions, guidelines, and expectations can provide structure, predictability, and safety, they may also limit a child's creativity and ability to learn through exploration if not balanced with opportunities for free play and decision-making.
• In situations where safety is a concern, it may not be appropriate to collaborate with the child, as the parent needs to enforce certain non-negotiable boundaries without the child's input.
• In some cultural contexts, the expectation for parents to provide rationales for their decisions might not align with traditional parenting practices, which could lead to confusion or conflict within the family.
• Some argue that a degree of inconsistency can help children develop problem-solving skills and resilience, as they learn to navigate an unpredictable world.
• The effectiveness of consistent boundary enforcement can vary depending on cultural, social, and individual family values, which means that the struggle to apply boundaries consistently may not be a universal experience.
• The concept of flexibility is subjective and can vary greatly between different parents, potentially leading to confusion or mixed signals for the child.

Reinforcing Positivity and Selective Ignoring for Boundaries

Atencio-MacLean emphasizes how consequences help maintain boundaries. If your child respects a boundary, she recommends that you reward their compliance with praise and encouragement. If they break the boundary, she explains that you can temporarily ignore the behavior (extinction) or provide a logical consequence for what they did. She recommends using punishment sparingly, explaining that it often only teaches children what not to do, rather than how to better regulate their behavior.

Context

• Implementing extinction can be challenging because the behavior might initially increase in frequency or intensity—a phenomenon known as an "extinction burst"—before it decreases. Consistency and patience are crucial during this phase.
• If a child draws on the walls, a logical consequence might be having them help clean it up. This teaches responsibility and the importance of respecting shared spaces.
• Constructive feedback and guidance provide children with opportunities to learn from their mistakes and understand the reasons behind rules and boundaries.

Using Consequences Strategically to Shape How a Child Behaves

This section focuses on the role of consequences in helping kids adaptively control their behavior. Atencio-MacLean explains that punishment, though sometimes necessary, isn't as impactful as positive reinforcement, and offers specific methods for parents to use these consequences effectively.

Relying on Reward to Encourage Positive Actions

Atencio-MacLean emphasizes relying on encouragement to guide a child's actions. Though she explains how and when to use punishment, she also emphasizes that punishment is generally ineffective for children who have ODD since those children tend to become more defiant in response. To shape their behavior in positive ways, she writes, reinforcing positivity is much more effective. She stresses that reinforcement should be immediate and tied directly to the desired behavior. For example, if parents are working on teaching their child to stay seated at mealtimes, then they should provide immediate praise when they are seated:"I'm so happy that you chose to sit down for dinner." By consistently recognizing and praising even small attempts at positive behaviors, she writes, parents can encourage those behaviors, which will ultimately increase the child's overall competence.

She encourages parents to determine what is most motivating to their child and tailor rewards to those preferences. For example, many children are motivated by additional time on their devices. In this case, she recommends that parents make screen time a privilege to be earned by their kid: "Once you've finished your chores, you will be able to use your phone for an extra 15 minutes tonight."

Context

• Tailoring encouragement to a child's specific interests and motivations can make the reinforcement more impactful and meaningful.
• Oppositional Defiant Disorder (ODD) is a behavioral disorder characterized by a pattern of angry, irritable moods, argumentative/defiant behavior, or vindictiveness. Children with ODD often resist authority and may have difficulty accepting rules or discipline.
• The idea of immediate reinforcement is rooted in behavioral psychology, specifically operant conditioning, which suggests that behaviors followed closely by a reward are more likely to be repeated.
• Regular positive interactions through praise can strengthen the parent-child relationship, fostering trust and communication, which are often strained in families dealing with ODD.
• Cultural background can play a role in what is considered a desirable reward. Some cultures may emphasize communal activities or family time as rewards rather than individualistic incentives.
• Assigning chores helps children learn responsibility and the value of contributing to household tasks. It also provides a structured opportunity to earn rewards, reinforcing the connection between effort and privilege.

Employing Logical Consequences and Punishing Sparingly

Atencio-MacLean also explains that while positive reinforcement will probably be the most heavily relied upon consequence used in her program, there are occasions where punishment is required. The author writes that disregarding undesired actions (extinction) can be very effective but is not always practical, particularly with more intense behaviors. She recommends that when punishment is unavoidable, it should be used strategically and should always be followed by positive reinforcement whenever the child makes an improved decision. If a kid crosses a boundary, she suggests that parents briefly reiterate what the boundary is and what the outcome will be for violating it, and then follow-through if necessary. For example, if the boundary is to speak respectfully to family members, and the child says something hurtful, she recommends that the parent say, "It's important that we speak to one another with kindness and respect. If you continue to use hurtful words, you'll have to take a break in your room."

Atencio-MacLean emphasizes that parents should stay composed and act uniformly when applying consequences, using brief, mild punishments delivered right after the undesired behavior. She discourages corporal or physical punishment, explaining that it is ineffective and often teaches children to associate pain and fear with those closest to them. The focus here should never be to humiliate, control, or frighten the child but to give them a clear understanding of expectations and consequences in order to help them improve their behavior.

Context

• Unlike punishment, which can lead to fear or resentment, positive reinforcement aims to motivate and encourage children by focusing on their strengths and achievements.
• While sometimes deemed necessary, punishment is not the only tool. Alternatives include natural consequences, logical consequences, and problem-solving strategies that encourage children to understand the impact of their actions.
• Ignoring certain behaviors can be emotionally challenging for caregivers, especially if the behavior is attention-seeking and the child becomes distressed when not receiving a response.
• This involves carefully considering when and how to apply punishment to ensure it is effective and fair. It means using punishment as a last resort and only in situations where other methods, like positive reinforcement or ignoring minor misbehaviors, have not worked.
• Reiterating boundaries helps reinforce cognitive understanding and memory retention in children, aiding in the internalization of rules over time. This is particularly important for children with ODD, who may have difficulty processing and remembering rules.
• A calm demeanor aids in clear communication, ensuring that the child understands the reason for the consequence without confusion.
• Corporal punishment can lead to increased aggression, antisocial behavior, and mental health issues in children, as it may teach them that violence is an acceptable way to solve problems.
• This involves rewarding desired behaviors to encourage their recurrence. It is a proactive approach that focuses on building good habits rather than just correcting bad ones.
• There could be information on building support systems, including working with educators, therapists, and other professionals, to provide a holistic approach to managing ODD.