PDF Summary:Other Rivers, by Peter Hessler

In Other Rivers, author Peter Hessler weaves together his years of teaching experience in China, spanning different eras and generations of students. Juxtaposing his time instructing in the 1990s as China underwent rapid economic transformation with his present-day teaching of the "Generation Xi," the book offers a nuanced portrayal of the nation's evolution and its profound impact on the lives of everyday people.

Beginning in the rural town of Fuling, Hessler provides an intimate look at his former students from the "Reform Generation" as they ventured out to forge new paths, overcome challenges, and navigate changing societal norms. He then shifts focus to Sichuan University's current student body, unpacking how factors like censorship, academic pressures, and rising nationalism shape the perspectives of China's youth. Through this tapestry of personal stories, Hessler paints a vivid picture of a society in flux, revealing the hopes, struggles, and complex identities that exist within China's ever-shifting landscape.

(continued)...

Fuling's transformation mirrors the more extensive advancements occurring across China on a smaller scale.

Upon returning to Fuling, Hessler observed profound changes within the urban landscape. The serene river town, previously characterized by its charming narrow streets and simple conveniences, has evolved into a bustling cityscape, complete with high-rise buildings, numerous bridges, and a comprehensive network of thoroughfares that connect it to different areas throughout the nation. The site where Fuling Teachers College once stood, where he had taught in the past, has become a quiet spot on the outskirts of the city, as the institution's spacious new grounds have been established elsewhere, creating a space imbued with historical resonance. The colossal undertaking of constructing a barrier over the Three Gorges significantly altered the landscape, flooding river valleys and necessitating the displacement of millions, including many students who had once been taught by Hessler.

The rapid transformation of rural areas into urban landscapes in China highlights the government's dedication to substantial infrastructure projects and the noticeable improvement in the quality of life for numerous citizens. However, Hessler also critiques the costs of these transformations, including the displacement of rural communities, the environmental impact of massive constructions such as the immense hydroelectric endeavor on China's longest river, and the uneven distribution of benefits, where some groups face economic hardship while others enjoy newfound prosperity.

Urban landscapes and their infrastructures are undergoing swift changes, with the emergence of skyscrapers, the growth of academic facilities, and the improvement of transit systems that now feature more bridges and thoroughfares.

Hessler chronicles the transformation of Fuling's urban landscape, which underwent significant changes due to extensive construction projects. Universities like Yangtze Normal University are now situated on what used to be undeveloped terrain, marking a shift from traditional infrastructures. Urban development has transformed former rice paddies and simple village landscapes into towering structures and living complexes, accommodating those who have migrated from the countryside in search of job opportunities in the city. The building of new bridges across the Yangtze and Wu rivers has enhanced transportation connections and played a crucial role in connecting the expanding urban areas on both sides. This widespread movement across the country highlights the significant shift of populations and the change from a predominantly rural society to one focused on city living, along with the government's dedication to infrastructure projects that have reshaped cityscapes.

Hessler observes these changes as he moves from a familiar but declining educational backdrop to territories that are unexplored and novel. The exchanges evoke a disorienting sense of time and place changing, highlighting how swiftly change happens in China, and how quickly old landscapes and traditions are replaced by modern advancements.

Context

• Improved transit systems, including bridges and thoroughfares, are crucial for reducing congestion, improving air quality, and connecting different parts of a city, facilitating the efficient movement of people and goods.
• The shift from traditional infrastructures to modern facilities, like those at Yangtze Normal University, is indicative of significant government investment in infrastructure to support urban growth and modernization.
• The transformation of rural areas into urban landscapes is often driven by economic policies aimed at boosting industrial growth and creating job opportunities in cities, which attract rural populations seeking better livelihoods.
• Building bridges over major rivers involves significant environmental planning to minimize ecological disruption, as these rivers are home to diverse ecosystems.
• China's household registration system, known as hukou, historically restricted rural residents from moving to cities. Reforms in this system have gradually allowed more mobility, enabling rural populations to settle in urban areas more easily.
• Although primarily international, the Belt and Road Initiative has domestic components that enhance infrastructure within China, improving connectivity between urban centers and facilitating trade and logistics.
• The rapid pace of change in Chinese cities can create a sense of dislocation and nostalgia among residents, as familiar landscapes and ways of life are replaced by modern infrastructure and urban environments, a theme explored in various literary and cultural works.

The building of the Three Gorges Dam has had a significant impact on the city and its residents, as well as on the local environment, leading to the relocation of communities and changes to the ecological landscape.

The construction of the immense Three Gorges Dam, designed to control flooding and generate hydroelectric power, profoundly impacted Fuling and the surrounding regions. Hessler recounts how the creation of the dam's reservoir led to the inundation of numerous valleys, forcing millions to relocate and establish new homes. Peter Hessler observes how the once untamed flows of the Yangtze have been calmed into a tranquil reservoir, altering the landscape and affecting the livelihoods of fishing-dependent communities.

Hessler delves into the challenges that arise during his encounters with former students who had no choice but to abandon their homes. He also explores the ecological consequences of the dam, including soil erosion and a reduction in biodiversity, as well as the disappearance of important historical and cultural sites, one of which is the White Crane Ridge, famous for its age-old carvings that recorded the changing waters of the Yangtze River. The initiative highlights both the benefits and the negative consequences associated with the vast development endeavors in China, noting that although modernization may facilitate progress, it can also lead to significant social and environmental disruption.

Context

• Many archaeological and cultural sites were submerged or relocated due to the rising waters of the reservoir. This includes ancient towns and historical artifacts, leading to a loss of cultural heritage.
• The dam's construction was controversial and faced opposition from environmentalists and human rights organizations due to its social and ecological impacts.
• The dam generates a substantial amount of electricity, contributing significantly to China's energy supply and reducing reliance on coal.
• Fishing communities often rely on specific fish species for their economic livelihood, and changes in fish populations can lead to economic hardship and necessitate a shift to alternative sources of income.
• Compensation and support for relocated residents varied, with some receiving inadequate resources to rebuild their lives, leading to economic and social difficulties.
• The change in water levels and flow can affect riverine vegetation, which plays a crucial role in maintaining the ecosystem. Loss of vegetation can lead to further erosion and habitat loss.
• The carvings on White Crane Ridge are considered a significant part of China's cultural heritage, offering insights into the region's history, art, and the relationship between humans and the environment over centuries.
• While modernization brings technological progress, it can also lead to job displacement in traditional sectors, requiring significant workforce retraining and adaptation.

The story of River Town Golf chronicles the rise and fall of a venture marked by grandiose plans, deceptive practices, and squandered assets.

Hessler draws a comparison between the city's transformation and the ill-fated River Town Golf project, a lavish getaway built on Beishanping that boasts a panoramic view of the urban skyline. The scheme to attract wealthy tourists through the development of a golf course was ultimately abandoned due to several complications, such as the government's revised position on the development of golf courses, political repercussions stemming from a corruption scandal involving a senior Party official, and questionable financial decisions made by the project's initiators. The imitation of Munich's Siegestor, set against the backdrop of abandoned villas and overgrown golf courses, starkly illustrates the consequences of overambition, resource mismanagement, and the hazards of hasty development strategies.

This undertaking highlights the opulence and paradoxes inherent in China's swift growth era, emphasizing the intricate dynamics between economic ambitions, political strategies, and entrenched corruption. The narrative also shows that authorities are prepared to forsake substantial initiatives, despite considerable monetary investments and the displacement of inhabitants, when such projects become politically or economically unsustainable.

Context

• The imitation of Western landmarks, like Munich's Siegestor, reflects a trend in some Chinese developments to emulate Western architecture and culture, aiming to project an image of global sophistication.
• Golf is sometimes perceived as an elitist sport in China, which can lead to public and governmental backlash against projects that prioritize luxury over community needs.
• These can include misallocation of funds, lack of transparency, and poor financial planning. In large-scale projects, such decisions can lead to budget overruns, incomplete developments, and financial losses, often exacerbated by inadequate oversight and accountability mechanisms.
• The project’s downfall can be seen as part of a broader pattern in China’s rapid urbanization, where ambitious projects often face setbacks due to shifting political priorities, regulatory changes, and corruption.
• The real estate sector became a significant driver of China's economy, with local governments and developers investing heavily in large-scale projects. This often resulted in speculative developments that sometimes outpaced actual demand.
• Large projects often result in the displacement of local communities, leading to social tensions. The lack of adequate compensation or relocation plans can exacerbate these issues, highlighting the human cost of unchecked development.
• New laws or regulations can impact the feasibility of ongoing projects, necessitating their reevaluation or termination.

Economic progress and its costs: rising prosperity, uneven wealth distribution, and health challenges from pollution and unhealthy lifestyles

Hessler acknowledges the significant economic progress observed by numerous people in China during this transformative era. The economic circumstances of his previous pupils have ameliorated, demonstrated by their heightened ability to acquire significant assets like homes and automobiles, leading to an uplift in their standard of living. He also underscores the disparate allocation of these advantages, pointing out that while some prosper, groups such as agricultural laborers and industrial employees continue to confront persistent financial hardships.

Hessler also discusses the negative health consequences associated with this prosperity, including the persistent impact of pollution and the harmful practices often found in the guanxi culture, characterized by a significant emphasis on alcohol consumption and social gatherings that include indulgent, high-calorie meals. He connects these patterns to a rise in diseases like lung cancer, highlighting the complex relationship between the progression of China's economy, shifts in society, and the resulting impacts on the health of the public.

Context

• Rising incomes have led to the emergence of a consumer culture, with increased spending on luxury goods, travel, and entertainment, reflecting changes in lifestyle and aspirations.
• Industrial employees often face challenging working conditions, including long hours, low wages, and limited labor rights, which can hinder their financial stability despite the overall economic growth.
• Integration into the global economy has brought wealth to some sectors and regions, particularly those involved in export-oriented industries, while others lag behind.
• Economic inequality can exacerbate health disparities, as wealthier individuals may have better access to healthcare and healthier lifestyle options, while poorer populations might face greater exposure to environmental hazards and have limited healthcare access.
• Guanxi refers to the system of social networks and influential relationships that facilitate business and other dealings in China. It is a fundamental aspect of Chinese culture, emphasizing mutual obligations, trust, and reciprocity.
• Rapid industrial growth in China has led to increased air pollution, particularly from coal-burning factories and vehicle emissions, which are major contributors to respiratory diseases, including lung cancer.

The enduring influence of the Reform era.

Hessler suggests that the current era of transformation continues to influence different aspects of contemporary societal structures within China. The shift from a planned economy to one driven by market forces, coupled with substantial internal migration and the creation of a diverse educational system, has profoundly impacted family relationships, social structures, and personal goals. He investigates how the era's changes influenced the cultural convictions, ambitions, and viewpoints of his students from Fuling as they matured.

Drawing on his personal insights and the experiences shared by his past pupils, Hessler discerns trends and paradoxes that illuminate the capacity and constraints of people navigating a swiftly evolving nation. He highlights the enduring significance of age-old principles such as respect for elders and the value of diligence, noting how shifts in social and economic conditions have altered familial relationships, nuptial customs, and the influence of schooling within the Chinese populace.

The impact that relocating has on individual and family stories, which depict victories, struggles, and the changing dynamics of love and marriage.

Hessler examines how the substantial internal migration in the Reform era affected not only individuals but also their family structures. He illustrates the complex and challenging aspects of this major social transition through a detailed depiction centered on the experiences of his former student, encompassing tales of individuals who journeyed to cities seeking better opportunities and of those who remained in their birth villages. He explores the transformation of conventional relationship dynamics and matrimonial customs as couples navigate the challenges of distance, postponed nuptials, and evolving aspirations related to work and home responsibilities due to migratory influences. He also explores the agonizing decisions of parents who decide to entrust their children to the care of elders in countryside villages while they pursue job opportunities in cities.

Hessler's collection of personal stories and thorough research reveals the psychological and social costs incurred by these changes, while also highlighting the resilience and adaptability of individuals pushing forward during China's rapid economic transformation. In his account, he offers an in-depth portrayal of the impact of migration on the daily existence of ordinary Chinese citizens, illustrated by the successes and struggles of people like his former student Emily.

Context

• The migration was largely fueled by the rapid industrialization and economic opportunities in urban areas, particularly in coastal cities, which became manufacturing and economic hubs.
• Despite the challenges, many individuals demonstrated remarkable resilience and adaptability, finding ways to maintain family connections and support systems across distances.
• Long-distance relationships can strain communication, requiring couples to adapt to new ways of maintaining their connection, such as relying on technology for regular contact.
• Migration often resulted in shifts in traditional gender roles within relationships. Women who moved to cities for work gained more financial independence, which could alter power dynamics in relationships and challenge conventional expectations of marriage.
• Studies have shown that both parents and children can experience significant stress and anxiety due to prolonged separations, affecting family dynamics and individual well-being.
• The departure of large numbers of people from rural areas can lead to the decline of local communities, reducing social cohesion and support networks for those who remain.
• Adaptability was crucial as individuals navigated new urban environments, often learning new languages or dialects, acquiring new skills, and adjusting to different cultural norms and lifestyles.
• Over time, government policies began to address some of these issues, aiming to improve conditions for migrants and reduce the rural-urban divide, though challenges remained.

Education's role has evolved from a tool for alleviating poverty into a contentious field of conflict.

Hessler contrasts his observations of educational methods in China from the 1990s with recent advancements to analyze their evolution. At the university in Sichuan, his pupils viewed their studies as a path not only out of impoverishment but also as a means to a brighter future, while they navigated the demanding educational landscape that included the intense pressures from the "gaokao," the college entrance examination. The quest for scholarly distinction has evolved from a mere ambition to enhance personal situations into an unyielding fixation on score optimization and securing a competitive advantage amidst a vast multitude of peers.

Hessler observed that the community, which highly regards thorough academic readiness, supplementary educational pursuits, and shared concerns, exerts considerable influence on children starting at an early age. He illustrates how parents are compelled to funnel their efforts and finances into "buxi," supplementary courses designed to improve their only child's chances in an intensely competitive environment. Students like Darker Liao, who excelled scholastically but suffered consequences for participating in extracurricular pursuits like robotics, underscore the stringent demands placed on exam preparation.

Context

• In recent years, China's education system has seen technological integration, increased international collaboration, and a shift towards more holistic educational approaches, although the pressure of exams remains intense.
• At the time, China's one-child policy meant that families often invested heavily in the education of their single child, hoping to secure a prosperous future for them. This policy intensified the pressure on students to succeed academically.
• The "gaokao" system has been criticized for promoting rote memorization and limiting creativity, as students focus primarily on test performance rather than holistic learning.
• The emphasis on score optimization can exacerbate social inequalities, as wealthier families are better able to afford additional educational resources, giving their children an advantage over those from less affluent backgrounds.
• In many East Asian cultures, education is often seen as a key determinant of social status and future success, leading to a strong emphasis on academic achievement from a young age.
• The financial burden of "buxi" classes can be significant for families, often requiring sacrifices in other areas of life to afford the additional educational expenses.
• Parents and students may invest heavily in private tutoring and supplementary education to gain a competitive edge, which can create financial strain and widen educational inequalities.

Enduring values such as a strong work ethic, respect for family, and reverence for the wisdom of elders coexist with shifting perspectives on self-reliance and societal challenges.

Despite the considerable changes taking place, Hessler observes that certain traditional values persist. Despite achieving success as business owners or experts in urban environments, they persist in holding family customs, diligence, and respect for their seniors in high regard. They preserve connections to their rural roots, often extending assistance to their extended family members and typically consider it their responsibility to aid their less fortunate relatives in navigating the intricacies of modern existence.

Hessler notes a shift in perspectives regarding individual freedom and societal matters, especially within the younger demographic. Young scholars at the university in Sichuan often point out these values as points of contention with the preceding generation, showing a heightened awareness of issues like individual liberties, LGBTQ+ issues, and the difficulties of harmonizing varied beliefs within a global community. The book emphasizes the lasting impact of social and economic transformations, illustrating how China's younger generation adapts to the demands of an ever more diverse and globally connected society.

Practical Tips

• Develop a personal "work ethic tracker" using a simple spreadsheet or app that helps you monitor and reflect on your daily productivity and work habits. This self-assessment tool can help you stay accountable to your work ethic by setting targets for tasks completed, hours worked, or new skills learned, and reviewing your progress weekly.
• Set up a monthly 'respect for seniors' day in your personal calendar. Dedicate this day to engaging with older members of your community or family. It could involve visiting a senior relative, volunteering at a retirement home, or even just making a point to have a meaningful conversation with an elderly neighbor. The key is to make it a consistent part of your routine, showing respect through regular, dedicated interactions.
• Start a family skill-sharing webinar series where each member teaches something they excel at. This could be a monthly virtual gathering where one family member presents on a topic like online safety, another on budgeting in a modern economy, or someone shares gardening tips. Use free video conferencing tools to make it accessible for everyone, and record the sessions for those who can't attend live.
• You can expand your cultural fluency by engaging with international media. Choose films, TV shows, and music from a variety of countries and make it a point to consume them regularly. This will expose you to different perspectives and social norms, helping you to understand and appreciate the diversity in a globally connected society.

China's educational landscape is characterized by limited scope in course material, environments that are intensely competitive academically, and the impact of state policy decisions.

In "Other Rivers," Hessler delivers an in-depth analysis of the intricate and bureaucratic elements that form the educational structure in China. He scrutinizes the configuration of the mechanisms intended to propel the country's rapid progress while simultaneously preserving political stability. Hessler explores the impact of censorship on students' access to information and their discomfort in expressing opposition to authority figures, as well as the pervasive environment that promotes secret accusations against people for alleged violations of political behavior.

Peter Hessler underscores the enduring influence of the gaokao, China's pivotal university admission test, along with the intense competitive forces that drive even young children to concentrate on achieving the highest scores. Hessler explores the intricacies of the educational structure in China, which, although it produces a group of hardworking and scholastically proficient students, also exposes their difficulties in understanding broader concepts of intellectual freedom, independent thinking, and a deeper awareness of social and political truths.

Establishing control within the political arena

Hessler argues that censorship and political control strongly shape China's education system. A range of tactics support these regulatory systems, among them the vast network barrier overseeing online activities and restricting the spread of information, in addition to the tacitly promoted practice of self-reporting that fosters a climate of intimidation, prompting people to self-censor. He highlights the difficulties encountered when broaching topics in learning environments considered delicate by the ruling political entity, observing the discomfort felt by educators and pupils alike.

Hessler's narrative weaves in personal experiences, particularly when his article sparked outrage among students and ultra-nationalists online due to his challenges to the dominant narrative on issues like sovereignty. He also delves into the difficulties encountered by student journalists contributing to "Common Sense," a covert publication that necessitated its contributors to employ subtle reporting methods to lessen the dangers associated with revealing controversial subjects. These instances illustrate the development of an environment where coercion and self-restraint thrive, thereby obstructing the free exchange of ideas and diminishing the chances for thorough contemplation and examination.

Navigating the challenges of restricted online connectivity and its influence on academic studies necessitated employing technology to create secure connections over the internet.

Hessler illuminates how China's pervasive internet censorship network, often referred to as the Great Firewall, influences daily life and the freedom of thought within the nation. It limits students' access to commonly visited global platforms, including major internet sites for search, video sharing, and social networking, thus limiting their sources of information and hindering their communication capabilities. He elucidates that institutions like SCUPI and universities counter these constraints by providing various global research platforms that are widely available, though these alternatives often face suppression and may disappear suddenly, particularly during periods of heightened governmental scrutiny.

Students and faculty often rely on the essential but precarious method of utilizing protected network channels to reach content that is typically restricted. Hessler illustrates the strain on students at Sichuan University who rely on unapproved VPN services to explore the wider internet. These experiences emphasize the extreme measures students must undertake to conduct autonomous studies and illustrate how censorship profoundly and disconcertingly impedes scholarly exploration.

Other Perspectives

• The focus on restricted access to global platforms overlooks the availability and utility of numerous Chinese platforms that provide similar services and are tailored to the needs of Chinese users, including students.
• Relying on institution-provided platforms may inadvertently create a dependency that could be problematic if the institution faces pressure to conform to censorship demands or if it experiences technical or financial difficulties.
• The notion of suppression could be challenged by the argument that governments have a right to regulate the internet within their borders for national security or cultural preservation, which may not necessarily be viewed as suppression by all stakeholders.
• While students at Sichuan University may use unapproved VPN services to access restricted content, it's possible that the university provides approved, legal alternatives for accessing necessary academic resources, which could mitigate the need for unapproved methods.
• The focus on accessible content within the censorship framework might encourage deeper engagement with available materials rather than a superficial overview of an abundance of unrestricted information.

In academic environments, students often watch their peers closely, exercise control over their own speech, and as a result, navigate the complexities of political topics with a reduced level of open dialogue.

Hessler emphasizes how the fear of being accused of political errors, known as "jubao," shapes the current educational environment within China. He recounts how he faced extensive criticism on digital forums due to perceptions that his remarks were disparaging toward those in power. Students are instructed to avoid subjects deemed "sensitive," which include various social and political topics, and educators are under pressure to cleanse their teaching content, making certain that they refrain from starting conversations that could be seen as opposing the official positions of the ruling political entity.

The environment, characterized by a pervasive monitoring system on campus, fosters a climate where the constant possibility of consequences continuously restricts candid and uninhibited dialogue. The atmosphere it creates is one where educators and pupils alike are hesitant to voice opposing opinions or delve into detailed discussions on controversial subjects. Hessler notes that such a tendency hinders the development of independent thinking and discourages students from pursuing research that could be considered politically delicate.

Other Perspectives

• Technological advancements and the use of online platforms for discussion can sometimes anonymize interactions, reducing the tendency for students to watch their peers closely in virtual spaces.
• Some students might actively choose not to self-censor, as a form of protest or to encourage open dialogue.
• The reduction in open dialogue could be a result of a broader cultural trend towards digital communication, where nuanced discussions are less common, rather than a direct result of political self-censorship.
• While the fear of "jubao" may influence behavior, it is not the sole factor shaping the educational environment; other cultural, social, and economic factors also play significant roles.
• Digital forums often include a wide range of opinions, and the criticism faced may come from a vocal minority rather than reflecting the broader consensus.
• The avoidance of sensitive topics might not be a blanket rule but rather a guideline that allows for flexibility depending on the context and maturity of the students involved.
• The concept of avoiding opposition to official political positions might be a misinterpretation of guidelines aimed at promoting a respectful and balanced discourse within educational settings.
• Monitoring systems may be intended to ensure safety and security on campus rather than to restrict dialogue.
• In some cases, the presence of consequences can lead to the development of more creative and subtle forms of communication, where students and educators learn to convey their ideas through implication and inference rather than direct statements.
• Some educators and students may actually feel more empowered to voice opposing opinions in an academic setting, seeing it as a safe space for intellectual challenge and growth.
• Avoidance of detailed discussions on controversial subjects can sometimes be a strategic choice to focus on foundational knowledge before tackling complex debates.
• Some may argue that constraints can sometimes foster creativity and independent thinking, as individuals must navigate within a set framework and find unique ways to express their thoughts.
• The concept of being discouraged is subjective; some students might interpret the same environment as a call to action or a need to innovate in their research methodologies.

The Communist Party's influence was evident in the mandatory political indoctrination, the push to embed specific ideologies, and the diverse effects of their systematic dissemination of information.

Hessler scrutinizes how the Communist Party molds and controls the educational framework, highlighting the continuous infusion of propaganda and the teaching of ideological tenets. The educational program required students to participate in mandatory political courses which solidified the government's interpretation of China's past and current happenings. The instructional material is heavily laden with specialized vocabulary and overused expressions, offering an officially sanctioned narrative that is devoid of originality and adaptability.

Hessler observes that today's students seem to be less swayed by the political doctrines of the Party than those in the 1990s, when such messages appeared to have a greater effect. He attributes the transformation to a combination of factors, including their access to a wide range of information through technological channels and their generally pragmatic and questioning outlook. Students often distance themselves from the educational content by concentrating on alternative topics, amusing themselves with mobile games, or completely disregarding the political discussions that occur, while the Party makes efforts to embed its own ideologies.

Other Perspectives

• The use of specialized vocabulary and expressions could be intended to provide students with the official lexicon necessary for understanding and discussing political concepts accurately in a scholarly context.
• Embedding specific ideologies could be seen as a way to foster social cohesion and a shared sense of identity among citizens.
• The effects of the Communist Party's information dissemination may not be as diverse as suggested, as they could be limited by the extent to which the population engages with and accepts the information.
• Such courses could potentially stifle critical thinking by presenting a singular, government-approved perspective on political matters.
• The assertion that education solidifies the government's interpretation overlooks the agency of educators and students who may engage with the material critically, discuss alternative perspectives, and thus not fully subscribe to the official narrative.
• Overused expressions may actually aid in reinforcing key ideas, making them more memorable and easier for students to grasp and recall.
• Adaptability in political narratives could lead to ambiguity and confusion, potentially undermining the authority and governance of the state.
• The perception of decreased influence might be due to the complexity of measuring such influence, especially in a society with restricted freedom of expression, where students might not openly share their true beliefs.
• A pragmatic outlook might not always equate to resistance against political indoctrination; pragmatism could lead some students to outwardly conform to political ideologies for personal or career advantages.
• The focus on alternative topics or mobile games does not necessarily indicate a lack of interest in politics but could be a way to cope with the stress or monotony of a highly politicized educational environment.
• Ideological education is not unique to the Communist Party; many countries incorporate their values and beliefs into their educational systems.

The consequences for scholarly inquiries included constrained information availability, topic limitations, and the necessity for clandestine methods in investigative work.

Hessler scrutinizes the limitations imposed on student investigations and journalistic endeavors as a result of political scrutiny and the withholding of information. Students frequently encounter obstacles when seeking information, and they consistently struggle to find dependable primary sources, especially on contentious subjects. The country's strict regulation of internet usage hampers its citizens' capacity to reach important international websites and resources, and widespread censorship on the web limits the range of opinions available within the country. Academic freedom is further curtailed by restrictions on topics deemed politically inappropriate, and students who dare to challenge these limitations face the risk of being reported or disciplined.

Hessler observes that contributors to "Common Sense" and other autonomous publications frequently employ journalistic strategies that may be ethically ambiguous but serve to mitigate the risks involved. They use pseudonyms to remain anonymous, construct composite characters to protect their sources, and hold secret discussions to avoid detection by authorities. The methods employed by up-and-coming journalists to chase significant stories underscore the way their capacity for conducting transparent and unrestricted investigations can be compromised by political forces.

Other Perspectives

• Students may have access to a wide range of information sources beyond primary sources, such as secondary analyses, expert interviews, and meta-studies, which can also provide valuable insights into controversial topics.
• The regulations might be in place to prioritize bandwidth for essential services, ensuring that critical online infrastructure remains available and reliable.
• The concept of absolute academic freedom could be idealistic, as all countries have some form of regulation or ethical guidelines that inherently limit what can be researched and published.
• The disciplinary actions, if any, might be mild and educational rather than punitive, aiming to guide students rather than suppress their inquiries.
• Anonymity could potentially be abused, allowing writers to evade accountability for false or harmful information.
• This practice may inadvertently contribute to the spread of misinformation if readers are not clearly informed about the use of such techniques in the reporting.
• Secret discussions may inadvertently undermine the credibility of the journalistic process, as they can lead to a lack of transparency that is fundamental to the integrity of reporting.
• Relying on ethically ambiguous methods can create a slippery slope, potentially justifying increasingly questionable practices in the name of protecting sources or information.
• In some instances, political pressure can act as a catalyst for journalists to form stronger networks and support systems that can enhance their investigative capabilities.

Fierce rivalry and stress

Hessler notes the intense pressure students in China's educational system face, largely because the gaokao, their pivotal college admission test, is highly competitive. From a young age, students experience considerable stress, which shapes their behavior, choices, and perspectives on their surroundings. In this highly challenging environment, young people develop a sense of entrapment in a relentless cycle of effort that often results in diminishing returns, reflecting their growing disenchantment.

Hessler explores the various forms this competition takes, highlighting the rise of the "buxi" industry, the obsession with securing top gaokao scores, and the development of distinctive and occasionally odd skills, such as mastering a particular calligraphy style, all in pursuit of a slight edge within the intense battle for academic advancement. This analysis reveals the psychological burden that the educational system imposes on learners, as well as the pressures experienced by parents who are driven to meticulously orchestrate the educational trajectories of their only children.

The relentless pursuit of excellence in university entrance exams places a significant strain on the psychological health of students, while also cultivating an obsession with securing the highest test scores possible.

Hessler underscores the profound pressure associated with the gaokao, an exam crucial for entry into university, which significantly influences the educational trajectories and forthcoming opportunities of students in China. This crucial assessment, taking place in the final year of secondary education, shapes their entire scholastic trajectory, creating an atmosphere characterized by rigorous study, heightened tension, and steadfast dedication to securing top grades.

The significance of the gaokao is highlighted by the fact that the results of this sole test are the key factor in deciding university placements, with little consideration given to the pupils' cumulative academic achievements, recommendation letters, or extracurricular participation. This results in a profoundly unsettling environment in which a multitude of students disclose enduring both physical and psychological distress, along with insomnia and, at times, considerations of self-harm. Hessler's anthology, which includes essays written by his pupils, often reveals through a sharp and inquisitive tone the deep concerns associated with the gaokao, highlighting how this pressure detrimentally affects their mental and emotional well-being.

Other Perspectives

• The pressure to excel in entrance exams can foster a competitive spirit that, when channeled positively, can lead to innovation and progress within a student's chosen field of study.
• In some educational systems, standardized testing provides a clear and uniform metric for assessing students from diverse backgrounds, potentially leveling the playing field.
• The emphasis on the gaokao's influence might overshadow the importance of lifelong learning and the fact that education and personal development extend beyond formal schooling and entrance exams.
• The single-minded pursuit of excellence in the gaokao might also cultivate resilience and perseverance, qualities that are essential for overcoming challenges in various aspects of life beyond education.
• The gaokao's role as the primary criterion for university placement is sometimes mitigated by alternative pathways such as international programs or colleges that admit students based on other standardized tests or criteria.
• In some educational systems, the emphasis on a single exam is intended to reduce the complexity and cost of the admissions process, making it more straightforward for both applicants and institutions.
• The pressure associated with the gaokao may not solely be a result of the exam itself but could also stem from societal and parental expectations, which would persist with or without the exam.
• There may be a selection bias in reporting, where only the most extreme cases of distress related to the gaokao are highlighted, which does not accurately represent the experiences of the majority of students.

Students employ various tactics, such as a unique typeface from Hengshui, to secure a competitive advantage, illustrating the widespread culture of relentless self-improvement.

Hessler explores the high-pressure environment of the gaokao, observing that students employ a range of distinctive and sometimes strange strategies to improve their test results, often at the expense of a well-rounded education. Peter Hessler comments on the broad adoption of a penmanship form that emerged from a renowned institution, known for its exceptional gaokao performance, that prioritizes speed and legibility over aesthetic qualities, designed to leave a notable impact on the exam assessors.

These strategies illustrate the sensation of being ensnared in a continuous competitive loop that leads to increasingly reduced benefits. Students work diligently to hone abilities that might appear insignificant, competing to gain the slightest advantage over their peers, often at the expense of their leisure, creative pursuits, and the broadening of their minds. Hessler's insights emphasize the detrimental effects of an intense emphasis on rivalry, pointing out how the gaokao system pressures students to value limited and frequently impractical abilities at the expense of a broader educational perspective.

Other Perspectives

• Adopting a unique typeface from Hengshui might not be a universally effective strategy, as exam assessors may not uniformly reward the legibility or speed that the typeface is designed to enhance.
• The focus on self-improvement could be seen as a response to systemic pressures rather than a true culture among students; it might be more of a necessity than a voluntary cultural adoption.
• Specialized strategies for test preparation can be seen as a form of adaptability and resourcefulness, which are valuable skills in both academic and professional settings.
• Emphasizing speed and legibility could potentially compromise the development of students' personal writing styles, which can be important for their identity and expression.
• The focus on a particular style of penmanship may detract from other critical skills that are necessary for success on the gaokao and in further academic pursuits.
• The drive to improve, even in small increments, can lead to innovation and excellence.
• The pursuit of competitive advantage can itself be a broadening experience, exposing students to new knowledge and skills.
• The emphasis on competition in the gaokao could be seen as a reflection of real-world challenges, preparing students for the competitive nature of the job market.
• Mastery of certain skills, even if they seem limited, can provide a foundation for more advanced or diverse learning in the future.

The rise of an industry dedicated to supplementary education has led to children's timetables being filled to the brim and placed the responsibility on parents to steer through a highly competitive environment.

Hessler delves into how the pursuit of academic success and the pressures associated with the "gaokao" have led to the proliferation of a thriving tutoring sector, now integral to the educational system. Parents often sense the obligation to provide their only child with every possible advantage, leading them to fill their child's schedule with additional classes from an early age.

The culture of "buxi" places a significant burden on family members and their descendants, leading to youngsters overwhelmed with numerous tasks, exhausted guardians, and a narrowing of life prospects beyond academia. Hessler notes that this regimen scarcely allows for spontaneous activities, relaxation, or basic downtime spent in the company of loved ones. The intensity of the gaokao instills heightened stress in young learners, fostering a perception that their entire teenage years are dedicated to excelling in this crucial test.

Other Perspectives

• The industry's growth could be seen as a response to a demand for more diverse educational opportunities, not just a means to fill up children's schedules.
• Some argue that the responsibility should not be placed on parents alone, as children, especially as they grow older, can take on increasing responsibility for their own educational choices and time management.
• The expansion of the tutoring industry could also be attributed to broader educational reforms and the opening up of the market to private enterprises, rather than the pressures of the "gaokao" alone.
• The focus on providing every possible advantage academically may neglect the development of other aspects of a child's life, such as social skills, creativity, and physical health.
• The structure and routine of "buxi" can provide a sense of security and predictability for children, which some may find reassuring in an otherwise chaotic and unpredictable world.
• The notion of being overwhelmed might be subjective and culturally influenced; what is considered overwhelming in one culture may be seen as a normal level of challenge in another.
• Some guardians might actually find a sense of fulfillment and purpose in actively engaging with their child's education, which could mitigate feelings of exhaustion.
• The narrative that academia narrows life prospects overlooks the personal satisfaction and fulfillment that can come from academic achievements and the pursuit of knowledge for its own sake.
• Some students may thrive under a routine and find it less stressful than having to manage spontaneous or unplanned activities.
• The increasing awareness of mental health and well-being might be leading to a shift in how teenagers, parents, and educators perceive the role of the gaokao, potentially challenging the idea that it dominates the entirety of teenage years.

The author's understanding of the way in which national identity and political forces influence the daily experiences of people in China is derived from his personal experiences while residing and employed there.

Hessler's narrative offers a perceptive examination of the transformation within China, observed from the perspective of someone who has spent more than two decades residing and employed in the nation. Upon his return after a considerable time, he observed significant transformations in both the infrastructure and societal operations of Chengdu. Exploring the complex tapestry of existence in China, he grapples with the evolving political scene and observes how the burgeoning sway of nationalism shapes the daily lives of the people.

Hessler's observations, particularly during the global health crisis, highlight the escalation of political tensions and the resulting decrease in chances for dialogue and cooperation, with diplomatic channels for engagement between China and the United States growing increasingly narrow. He chronicles his interactions with various individuals, including scholars and state representatives, offering a discerning analysis of how political influence, the control of information, and growing nationalistic zeal shape educational frameworks, personal relationships, and the potential for cross-cultural understanding.

A perspective on its transformation from beyond China's borders.

As an international author and teacher, Hessler explores profound observations about the transformative shifts altering China's landscape in "Other Rivers." Peter Hessler acknowledges the remarkable growth in the country's economic landscape and the significant improvement in the standard of living for its citizens, but he also scrutinizes the negative aspects of this advancement, highlighting the social and environmental consequences that often accompany rapid modern development. His perspective is shaped by the considerable duration he has lived within China's borders, the deep connections forged with former students, and his meticulous observation of the ways ordinary people navigate a society marked by progress as well as ongoing challenges.

Hessler scrutinizes the considerable transformations, balancing detachment with engagement, and sheds light on the deep-seated hopes and worries inherent in the evolving cultural landscape. As an outsider to China, he has a unique viewpoint that allows him to notice patterns and contradictions that may escape the notice of those fully immersed in the cultural context. His analysis offers a profound insight into the complex forces that are forming China today, highlighting the way in which modernization, cultural legacy, and state intervention sculpt the lives of the nation's inhabitants.

Upon returning, he noticed considerable transformations within the nation's physical, social, and economic landscapes that unfolded over two decades.

After being away for an extended time, Hessler recounts the feeling of being out of place when he came back to China. The landscape has been transformed considerably, with areas like Fuling, where he once taught, now featuring towering skyscrapers, a greater quantity of bridges, and expansive suburban regions that have replaced what used to be farming communities. The transformations in society and economy are unmistakable, with issues that were once linked to poverty now giving way to the hurdles of a society characterized by increased wealth and heightened competitive spirit.

He uses photography as a tool to capture the transformation, placing earlier images alongside more recent ones to highlight the environmental shifts and the community's changing emotions through the years. The rapid pace of societal progress underscores the disappearance of longstanding traditions and accentuates the discomfort felt by many who struggle to keep up with or fully grasp the significant transformations occurring within their own lifetimes.

Context

• Traditional practices and communal lifestyles have been impacted by modernization and globalization. There is a tension between preserving cultural heritage and embracing new, often Westernized, ways of life.
• Rapid urbanization and industrialization in China have raised environmental concerns, including pollution and loss of agricultural land, which are critical issues in regions undergoing such transformations.
• Economic development has also brought environmental challenges, such as pollution and habitat destruction, which were less prevalent when the economy was less industrialized. These issues add complexity to the societal challenges faced by a wealthier nation.
• In fields like journalism and anthropology, photography is often used to complement written narratives, providing a more comprehensive understanding of social and environmental issues.
• The introduction of new technologies can change how people interact with their environment and each other, often reducing the reliance on traditional methods and crafts.
• Rapid technological progress can create a digital divide, where those who are not tech-savvy may feel left behind or overwhelmed by new technologies that permeate daily life.

As an individual hailing from beyond China's borders, one encounters a wide spectrum of cultural differences and acquires unique viewpoints, while also confronting many preconceived ideas.

Hessler contemplates the distinct challenges and viewpoints associated with his status as a foreigner in China. He experiences moments of confusion, cultural disparities, and sporadic bias, especially during times when nationalistic fervor or governmental strains intensify. He shares tales of his encounters with security personnel who followed him, police interrogations, and the intense examination he faced from fervent nationalists on digital platforms. The narrative highlights the welcoming and friendly nature of many individuals in China who welcomed him into their world, sharing their stories and enabling him to comprehend their perspectives and life journeys.

His status as an outsider enables him to connect the internal and external aspects of the customary limits. His unique position provides a platform for contemplation and analysis, yet also exposes him to the complex and sometimes contradictory dimensions of existence in the Chinese setting.

Context

• The concept of "face" (mianzi) is crucial in Chinese culture, influencing social interactions and business dealings, and can be challenging for foreigners to fully grasp and respect.
• Foreigners may face preconceived notions based on stereotypes, which can affect interactions. These biases might stem from historical events, media portrayals, or lack of exposure to diverse cultures.
• The presence of security personnel and police interrogations can be part of broader efforts to maintain social stability and control over foreign influence within the country.
• While there are governmental restrictions and surveillance, individual interactions often transcend these barriers, as personal relationships and face-to-face interactions can be more open and genuine.
• His position encourages a deeper empathy and understanding of cultural nuances, as he must navigate and adapt to a society different from his own.
• Outsiders are more likely to question practices and beliefs that locals might take for granted, leading to deeper inquiry and understanding.
• The integration of technology in daily life, from mobile payments to social media, contrasts with traditional ways of living, highlighting the dynamic nature of Chinese society.

The emergence of nationalism has influenced societal interactions, contributing to the emergence of a faction called the Little Pinks and impacting the intricate dynamics of relations between China and the United States.

Hessler delves into the surge of nationalistic sentiment in modern China, examining its intricate nature and assessing its impact on interpersonal interactions, the political landscape, and discourse within the realm of digital communication.

Context

• Nationalism can affect cultural expressions, including art, literature, and media, often promoting themes of national pride and historical achievements.
• The Little Pinks often engage in cultural debates, defending Chinese culture and values against Western influence, which they perceive as a threat to national identity.
• Rapid economic development in China has fueled national pride, contributing to a sense of superiority and a desire to assert China's place on the world stage.
• Nationalistic policies can affect trade relations, as seen in tariffs and trade wars, impacting global markets and economic stability.
• Digital platforms can create echo chambers where nationalistic views are reinforced, leading to increased polarization and a more divided public opinion on global issues.