PDF Summary:Nothing to Envy, by Barbara Demick

Nothing to Envy, by Barbara Demick, provides an in-depth examination of life in North Korea under the dictatorial rule of the Kim dynasty. The first half reveals the government's pervasive indoctrination of its citizens and its ruthless suppression of dissent—fueling a famine in the 1990s that devastated the nation. The second half follows several families navigating this upheaval, shedding light on the ingenuity and resilience of North Koreans amid hardship.

The book's final section uncovers the extreme dangers associated with escaping North Korea and defectors' struggles to assimilate in new societies. This evocative account exposes the profound complexities of human rights violations occurring within the regime's isolated boundaries.

(continued)...

The deep impact that the famine had on North Korea's social structure.

This subsection illustrates the profound impact that the food shortage had on the daily existence of North Korean citizens. Demick offers detailed narratives of the extreme actions individuals resorted to in their struggle to endure, emphasizing the extensive hardship and the mental strain that resulted from enduring prolonged periods of scarcity and hardship.

The most vulnerable populations were severely affected by the scarcity of food.

The nation was engulfed in widespread suffering, with hunger, malnutrition, and starvation becoming rampant. The songbun system's effects were especially severe for the most defenseless individuals, particularly children and the elderly. Hospitals, lacking basic medicines and resources, were overwhelmed with patients, particularly children, suffering from wasting, pellagra, and other ailments linked to malnutrition. In her role as a pediatrician in Chongjin, Dr. Kim faced the devastating reality that numerous children perished despite her care, finding herself unable to answer the desperate pleas of their mothers for assistance she could not provide.

The government's denial of the catastrophe and its attempts to conceal the actual extent of the suffering.

In response to the famine, the government's approach was to deny the disaster's existence and to conceal the extent of the suffering from the global community. The government downplayed the gravity of the crisis and diverted resources intended for emergency assistance towards priorities such as the military, neglecting to provide essential supplies to those most vulnerable. Demick harshly criticizes the government's response, highlighting their disregard for the well-being of the citizens and their relentless commitment to maintaining the facade of an ideal socialist society as millions succumbed to hunger.

Engaging in private trading and market activities turned into a crucial aspect for ensuring an individual's sustenance.

As the government's distribution system fell apart and it could no longer provide necessary items, North Koreans resorted to private commerce and makeshift markets for their survival. The widespread participation in activities that were previously forbidden showcases the tenacity and flexibility of ordinary individuals when confronted with hardship.

Individuals began relying on clandestine trade and their own ingenuity to secure food and essentials.

Throughout the widespread famine, numerous individuals relied on burgeoning informal marketplaces as the primary source for obtaining food, fuel, and essential goods. Demick illustrates the emergence of bustling markets across the country, where an assortment of items such as smuggled rice, Chinese clothing, and counterfeit DVDs of films from South Korea are available. The women of North Korea demonstrated their ingenuity and tenacity by initiating and growing business ventures that had previously been stifled by the country's ideological restrictions. Demick recounts the stories of individuals who started their own business activities, such as Mrs. Song, who began making and selling baked goods, and Dr. Kim, who fabricated false health documents to excuse people from labor in exchange for sustenance.

The authorities cautiously supported and encouraged certain market strategies to alleviate shortages, while maintaining control

During Kim Jong-il's tenure, the state intermittently endorsed and encouraged certain market practices, recognizing the urgent need to alleviate severe food shortages and the growing importance of autonomous markets. Local farmers' markets, which at first only sold their agricultural produce, slowly expanded their offerings to include a wider variety of goods, often without official permission. The policy shift, while tacitly admitting the state's shortcomings in providing for its citizens, also aimed to manage the allocation of goods and maintain an appearance of authority. The government's handling of the economic instability reflects a combination of pragmatic actions and ideological commitment, designed to maintain order and uphold the core tenets of its autocratic governance.

Context

• The Songbun system in North Korea is a classification system based on one's family background and behavior, dividing citizens into different social categories that determine their access to opportunities and resources. It influences aspects like education, employment, and political involvement, with higher status given to those with revolutionary backgrounds and lower status to those with perceived negative associations. The system reflects the Communist regime's efforts to reshape society by prioritizing loyalty to the state and penalizing those with historical ties to perceived opposition groups.
• Pellagra is a disease caused by a deficiency of vitamin B3 (niacin). It leads to symptoms like inflamed skin, diarrhea, dementia, and mouth sores. The condition primarily arises from a diet lacking niacin or issues with niacin absorption in the body. Treatment involves niacin or nicotinamide supplementation.
• Kim Jong-il's tenure refers to the period when Kim Jong-il served as the supreme leader of North Korea from 1994 until his death in 2011. He succeeded his father, Kim Il Sung, and during his rule, North Korea faced significant economic challenges, including a famine in the 1990s. Kim Jong-il implemented policies that strengthened the military's influence in society, known as the "military-first" or Songun policies. His tenure was marked by repressive governance and continued food scarcity issues.
• Autocratic governance is a system where power is concentrated in the hands of a single leader or a small group, typically without meaningful checks and balances. Decisions are made unilaterally, often without input from the general population. This form of governance prioritizes control and authority over individual freedoms and democratic processes. Autocratic leaders have significant control over the government and society, with limited accountability to the people.

The varied experiences, social differences, and personal relationships that young individuals navigate within the Democratic People's Republic of Korea.

This section explores the complexities of social relationships in a society deeply shaped by political forces and scrutinizes the challenges encountered by young individuals navigating a changing environment. Demick's account highlights the resilience and adaptability of the youth in Chongjin as they navigated through the extreme hardships of a famine and the collapse of the rigid social structure that previously governed their lives.

The economic downturn and subsequent food shortages profoundly altered the dynamics within households and across the broader society.

The widespread famine and economic crisis of the 1990s deeply affected the previously unified and government-supporting citizens in the Democratic People's Republic of Korea. As traditional support structures failed, people and their families adopted survival strategies that often conflicted with governmental regulations.

The disintegration of traditional community support systems required the creation of survival strategies on an individual and family basis.

The public distribution system played a pivotal role in shaping the social hierarchy in North Korea, fostering a sense of security and reliance on the state. The collapse required people and families to come up with their own survival strategies. Demick emphasizes the pivotal role of women, known as ajummas, in this new reality, as they became the primary breadwinners for many families, engaging in entrepreneurial activities to obtain food and resources. When faced with hardship, the people of North Korea developed unique methods of persevering that often contradicted the government's official policies, demonstrating their tenacity and ingenuity.

The widening disparity between the benefits enjoyed by the elite and the struggles endured by the vast majority.

The crisis in food supply exacerbated social disparities, highlighting the significant differences in privileges between elite individuals with advantageous songbun and the general population, who endured severe hardships. Demick observes that while some families benefited from connections with the ruling class or possession of international currency, Mrs. Song and her kin endured extreme difficulties, contending with pervasive famine, illness, and the devastating deaths of loved ones. The increasing inequality planted the roots of dissatisfaction and a growing sense of betrayal towards the ruling elite, undermining the once widespread conviction that the nation was a bastion of socialist equality.

The narrative follows the path of young people navigating a changing society while departing from North Korea.

This subsection delves into how young individuals attempt to comprehend their existence within a nation experiencing significant upheaval. Demick explores the challenges encountered by North Korea's youth, highlighting their aspirations molded by food shortages and their impressive ingenuity and resolve in the face of hardship.

The challenges faced by young people in accessing education, finding employment, and pursuing personal aspirations

Young people in North Korea encountered considerable obstacles in their quest for education, job opportunities, and the fulfillment of their dreams. As resources dwindled, the educational system faced challenges, with teachers remaining uncompensated and learning prospects waning, affecting even those from favorable social backgrounds. The economic downturn severely limited job opportunities, compelling young individuals to either join the armed forces or settle for stagnant positions with no opportunity for growth. Demick recounts the challenges Mi-ran, Oak-hee, and their siblings encountered in achieving educational and professional aspirations, which were hindered by their family's social status, known as songbun, in the context of the country's collapsing support structures.

North Korean youth continue to exhibit remarkable tenacity, inventiveness, and passion, even under the strict constraints imposed by their government.

Despite the daunting challenges, Demick highlights the tenacity and ingenuity of the young people from Chongjin in North Korea, who were compelled to adjust to a world that was becoming less structured and more volatile. As the state's ability to support its population diminished, individuals were compelled to become more practical and independent to secure their existence. Hyuck's experiences stand as a powerful tribute to the resilience and ingenuity of a cohort of youngsters who were compelled to become self-reliant, scavenging for food and adopting extraordinary strategies to survive. Additionally, the changing environment of Chongjin created opportunities for enterprising individuals, among them Oak-hee, who defied conventional standards and carved out their own paths within the burgeoning markets.

The formation of close relationships and the search for love amidst the stringent confines of North Korea.

This section explores the impact of food shortages and shifting societal standards on intimate bonds and the quest for love in North Korea. Demick highlights the ingenuity of young people in forging bonds with each other, despite the stringent societal constraints enforced by the regime.

Individuals frequently employed covert and deceptive strategies to circumvent the limitations on social engagements enforced by the government.

Young individuals, who were forbidden from displaying intimate gestures in public, engaging in premarital relationships, and holding personal gatherings, had to rely on their cleverness and discretion to navigate these restrictions. The clandestine romance between Mi-ran and Jun-sang, nurtured through covert correspondence and discreet encounters, exemplifies the lengths to which people had to go to shield their personal affairs from the intrusive surveillance of the government. The shared secrecy fostered intimacy and created a bond of understanding, yet it also paved the way for complications and misunderstandings as fears of betrayal and political repercussions began to affect their relationship.

The influence of cultural products and media from South Korea on altering attitudes and actions.

The influx of illegal DVDs and radio broadcasts, which altered perceptions and behaviors, thwarted the government's attempts to limit the intake of foreign media. The portrayal of love and personal relationships through media from South Korea stood in stark contrast to the strict constraints imposed by the regime, sparking a desire for transformation and resistance. Foreign media, although its influence was limited, provided North Koreans with glimpses of an alternate reality, challenging their long-held beliefs and contributing to a growing sense of discontent toward the authorities, particularly among younger citizens.

Practical Tips

• You can foster resilience in your community by starting a neighborhood barter system where residents exchange goods and services without money. This encourages cooperation and helps people get what they need during tough economic times. For example, someone could trade homegrown vegetables for a neighbor's skill in fixing household items, promoting a sense of unity and self-reliance.
• Create a digital storytelling project to capture and share the experiences of young people overcoming adversity. By using social media or a simple blog platform, you can encourage individuals to submit their stories of tenacity and creativity in facing challenges. This not only provides inspiration to others but also creates a repository of real-life strategies for navigating difficult circumstances.
• Engage in cultural exchange by organizing an online book or film club focused on international works, including those from South Korea. This can broaden perspectives and foster understanding of different societal influences. Participants can discuss the impact of cultural products on their own beliefs and behaviors, thus gaining insight into the power of media on personal and societal change.

North Korean defectors encounter difficulties in assimilating into new communities and dealing with issues related to their human rights.

The book's final section emphasizes the challenging choices faced by North Koreans when they make the choice to depart from their homeland and the hurdles they encounter in adapting to a culture that is significantly different. Demick's narrative sheds light on the dangers and sacrifices linked to escaping and the difficulties encountered while adjusting to a different existence, thereby exposing the complex realities of life outside North Korea while emphasizing the ongoing human rights crisis within its territory.

Individuals facing the dangers and obstacles of fleeing North Korea often endure numerous hardships.

Escaping from North Korea, a task already perilous, became increasingly treacherous during the famine as border security was heightened. The narrative vividly portrays the dangers and obstacles faced by North Koreans as they attempt to escape a life marked by extreme hardship and authoritarian control.

The dangers associated with crossing into China, as well as the subsequent challenges and mistreatment encountered by those escaping their native country.

The trek over the Tumen River into China is fraught with danger due to the rapid currents, freezing temperatures, and the constant threat of capture by the vigilant border guards of North Korea. Individuals who manage to cross into China frequently face dangers including being taken advantage of, forced into labor, and the threat of human trafficking. Demick recounts the harrowing challenges Oak-hee and other defectors confront, highlighting the extreme hardships they face during their escape and the precariousness of their existence in a country that regards them as illegal foreigners.

The government enforces measures that punish family members of those who escape the country.

The North Korean government employs stringent measures to discourage and punish defectors by bolstering border security, collaborating with Chinese authorities to capture those who flee, and subjecting the defectors' family members to harsh consequences. This approach, based on the idea of "tainted blood," often leads to the imprisonment of family members, highlighting the state's extreme measures and steadfast determination to maintain control, while completely ignoring basic human rights.

Individuals fleeing North Korea encounter considerable challenges as they adapt to the social customs and way of life in South Korea.

This subsection explores the significant challenges faced by individuals who have fled North Korea and are building new lives in South Korea, highlighting the complex journey of adapting to a society with vastly different cultural norms, economic systems, and political ideologies.

The adjustments in culture, economy, and psychology necessary for adapting to a society that is markedly different

Defectors face a multitude of challenges such as cultural, economic, and psychological adjustments in their efforts to integrate into South Korean society. For those accustomed to North Korea's direct and structured societal norms, adapting to the complex social hierarchies present in South Korea can present challenges. Demick recounts the experiences of Mrs. Song, highlighting her sense of displacement, solitude, and alienation in settings that were once foreign to her.

Government-led programs and support systems are vital in helping integrate those who have fled their country of origin.

South Korean officials have established numerous initiatives and support systems to assist North Korean defectors in adjusting to life in the South, which includes creating Hanawon, a facility focused on providing language lessons, cultural orientation, and job skills training. While these initiatives offer essential assistance, the path to integration is filled with challenges for individuals escaping their native country, as they struggle with feelings of guilt, embarrassment, and a profound longing for the family members they were forced to part from.

Efforts to increase awareness and advocate for change stem from the lack of concern for human rights demonstrated by the North Korean leadership.

This section emphasizes the ongoing human rights challenges in North Korea, highlighting the government's extensive infringements and the necessity of continuous assistance for its citizens, including defectors.

The regime's use of force, mandatory labor, and imprisonment for political motives to suppress dissent and maintain its control.

North Korea is widely acknowledged as having one of the most repressive regimes in the world, known for its extensively recorded human rights violations. Demick describes how the government systematically employs torture, coerced labor, and incarceration for political reasons to quell opposition and retain its grip on power. Hyuck's experiences illuminate the severe tactics used by the authorities in North Korea to quell opposition, as seen through the reality of life inside the kyohwaso detention centers.

The international community persists in its fight against violations of human rights occurring within North Korea's territory.

North Korea's regime continues to uphold its policies, even in the face of international disapproval, partly due to China's reluctance to confront its ally. Demick highlights the importance of focusing on the violations of basic human rights within the borders of the Democratic People's Republic of Korea, stressing the work done by activists, academics, and defectors to encourage change and hold the government accountable for its actions.

Practical Tips

• You can raise awareness by creating digital art inspired by the stories of North Korean defectors and sharing it on social media platforms. Use your artistic skills to depict the emotional and physical journey of escape, aiming to capture the attention of your audience and spark conversations about the human rights situation in North Korea.
• Start a virtual book club focused on novels and memoirs written by North Korean defectors to deepen your understanding of their experiences. By discussing these stories with others, you can foster empathy and a more nuanced perspective on the challenges faced by defectors, which can lead to supportive actions such as fundraising or advocacy.
• Engage in micro-volunteering by offering online language tutoring to North Korean defectors. Many organizations look for volunteers to help defectors improve their language skills, which is crucial for their integration into new societies. This can be done through video calls, and even a small commitment can make a significant difference in a defector's life.