PDF Summary:Neither Wolf nor Dog, by Kent Nerburn

In his memoir Neither Wolf nor Dog, author Kent Nerburn documents his journey into the heart of the Native American experience and spiritual tradition. Through dialogues with Dan, Grover, and other Indigenous elders, he uncovers the profound contrasts between white and Native philosophies on land use, cultural values, language, and spirituality. As these elders share their perspectives on colonialism and the systematic oppression of their peoples, a nuanced portrait emerges of Native resilience, cultural preservation, and reverence for the natural world.

Nerburn's work does not portray the Native experience in broad strokes or exaggerated stereotypes. Instead, his narrative unravels as an intimate exploration of Indigenous worldviews—the core principles around communal living, sincere valuation of oral tradition, and symbiosis with the environment that both united tribes historically and fueled their strength amid adversity. Neither Wolf nor Dog illuminates a powerful cultural legacy often overshadowed yet remarkably preserved and adaptive in the modern age.

(continued)...

Indigenous perseverance and defiance against the onslaught of colonial encroachment and control.

The author does not portray Native Americans as passive victims, but rather highlights their courageous resistance and enduring resilience in the face of an overwhelming and hostile force. Despite confronting insurmountable challenges and structured inequities, they bravely protected their land, their kin, and the core of their cultural identity. Despite enduring oppression for centuries, their resilience endured.

Indigenous populations valiantly defended their territories, communities, and cultural heritage, yet were eventually overpowered by the superior military forces of the colonizers.

Dan engaged Nerburn in discussions brimming with tales of native leaders who bravely battled to protect their territory and communities. Chief Joseph, akin to Geronimo, bravely fought to maintain their autonomy and customary lifestyle. They utilized their profound knowledge of the terrain and their steadfast dedication to their cause to execute distinctive strategies in combat. Despite their valiant efforts, the overwhelming numbers and advanced armaments of the U.S. military proved too much for them to withstand. Despite their unwavering resistance, they were compelled to either surrender or face total annihilation.

Natives adapted and maintained their identity and culture despite efforts to assimilate or eliminate them.

Nerburn emphasizes the remarkable fortitude displayed by Indigenous peoples in maintaining their cultural distinctiveness in the face of persistent efforts over centuries to absorb them or erase their existence. Despite being forcibly relocated to areas designated for their confinement and enduring systematic efforts to erase their traditional ways of life, they remained steadfast in maintaining their native tongues, ancestral tales, and the hallowed ceremonies that strengthened their connection to the land, even as they confronted educational systems aimed at obliterating their cultural identity. Their cultural survival is testament to their deep-rooted identity and their creative adaptation in the face of oppression.

The devastating impacts of colonial policies and actions on Native populations.

Nerburn candidly addresses the catastrophic impact of white colonization and settlement on Indigenous American communities. He recounts the horrors of sickness, widespread slaughter, forced relocations, and the intentional destruction of their cultural practices. Through his dialogues with Dan, he uncovers the enduring and profound anguish that Indigenous communities endure, an anguish that echoes across generations.

Disease, massacres, forced relocation, and cultural suppression decimated Native communities.

Nerburn's narrative, enriched by the recollections and tales shared by Dan, meticulously documents the deliberate and harsh tactics used to oppress and relocate Indigenous peoples' communities. Disease, intentionally spread through infected blankets, ravaged their populations. Communities were decimated by massacres, notably the calamity that occurred at Wounded Knee. Forced relocations severed them from their ancestral lands and traditional lifeways. The compulsory integration of children into residential schools was designed to eradicate their native languages and cultural identities.

Indigenous peoples were stripped of their territories, their self-governance, and the ability to engage in their ancestral customs.

Nerburn and Dan both acknowledged the devastating impact of white colonialism, which resulted in the substantial seizure of indigenous territories, the erosion of their self-determination, and the suppression of their customary ways of living. The confiscation of their territory, which was central to their spiritual and cultural essence, severely hindered their capacity to preserve their communities and uphold their customs. This systematic dispossession left them politically marginalized, economically disadvantaged, and spiritually disconnected from their homelands.

Practical Tips

• You can deepen your understanding of Indigenous history by creating a personal reading list that includes works by Native authors, focusing on narratives that highlight Indigenous perspectives on history. By reading these accounts, you'll gain a more nuanced view of the events and can compare them with the mainstream historical narrative, which often overlooks or misrepresents Indigenous experiences.
• Start a habit of supporting Indigenous businesses and artists to foster economic empowerment and cultural preservation. Purchasing from Native-owned businesses, whether it's art, clothing, or food, helps sustain their economic independence and encourages the continuation of cultural practices and traditions.
• Engage in reflective journaling to explore your own biases and assumptions about Indigenous peoples and their history. Regularly writing down your thoughts after learning about Indigenous issues can help you identify and challenge any preconceived notions you might have, leading to personal growth and a deeper appreciation for the complexities of Indigenous experiences.

Indigenous American communities have a profound connection that is both spiritual and ecological with the planet and its natural systems.

In his journey with Dan, Nerburn emphasizes the deep reverence and significance that Native American customs assign to the planet and its ecological processes. He grew to recognize that the land transcends mere economic value, embodying a sacred and vibrant entity that provides nourishment and knowledge, and is inextricably linked with their sense of self and well-being.

The land should not be seen simply as a commodity for use, but rather honored for its hallowed attributes.

Dan frequently emphasizes the deep connection that Indigenous peoples have with the land, viewing it as a living being worthy of reverence and careful stewardship, instead of merely a means for financial exploitation. The land provides nourishment, serves as a dwelling for ancestral spirits, is essential to their spiritual beliefs, and imparts profound lessons on existence. Nerburn grows to appreciate the land, seeing it not just as a scenic setting or a means to an end, but as a vital element that contributes its own rhythm, manifestations, and vitality to the dance of life.

Indigenous cultures perceive their existence as intertwined with the natural environment, rather than separate from or superior to it.

Dan explains that Native Americans view their lives as being in harmony with nature, as opposed to separate from it or exerting control over it. Their values, social structures, and comprehension of their role within the cosmos are all influenced by their deep connection to nature. They perceive a familial connection with all creatures, the forests, the waterways, and every living entity on the planet. Nerburn acknowledges that Western culture's focus on human superiority and interference with nature has created a dangerous separation, leading to ecological devastation by instilling an attitude of control.

The land is deeply interwoven with the indigenous rituals, stories, and beliefs.

In their exchanges, Nerburn gains a more profound comprehension, recognizing that Native American rituals, tales, and convictions are profoundly intertwined with the earth and its seasonal rhythms. Their ceremonies are conducted in locations that are connected to stories of their forebears or events of great spiritual importance. Their relationship with the environment and its fauna is revealed in the stories that explain their origins. Their understanding of time is molded by the natural cadence of seasonal changes, the habitual activities of wildlife, and the steady rhythms inherent in the natural world.

Respect, harmony, and reciprocity with nature are core Native values.

Dan consistently underscored the importance of respect, equilibrium, and mutual engagement as fundamental aspects of Indigenous American traditions in their relationship with the environment. They view themselves as custodians tasked with the care of the land and its resources, rather than as proprietors. Their behavior toward the environment is driven by a duty to preserve equilibrium and safeguard the prosperity of future generations. Nerburn notes a stark difference between these values and the common inclination among white communities to pursue instant satisfaction, utilize resources, and demonstrate indifference towards the environmental repercussions.

Indigenous people see themselves as guardians tasked with the preservation of Earth and its natural bounty.

Nerburn highlights the profound contrast between the Indigenous principle of stewardship, which mandates the protection of the earth, and the colonial mindset that grants people the right to exploit and profit from the planet's bounty. Dan imparts the conviction that our natural surroundings are a shared legacy, bestowed upon us by the Creator to be revered and treasured, ensuring its preservation for future generations. The fundamental disagreement arises from the differing viewpoints of the two cultures regarding guardianship over the planet.

Indigenous peoples extract only the necessary resources from the environment, ensuring minimal waste and disturbance.

Nerburn learns that within Native American customs, it is considered both discourteous and unwise to extract from nature more than what is needed or to create unnecessary waste or disruption. This concept, which emerges from their comprehension of the intricate web of life and their reverence for nature's fragile equilibrium, is starkly opposed to the pursuit of profit, the exhaustion of resources, and the harm caused to the environment that is often seen in Western ideologies.

The profound effects of white colonization and utilization of the environment.

Kent's conversations with Dan and Grover are filled with deep sorrow and vexation as they reflect on the impact of white colonization and the ongoing exploitation of the environment. Nerburn recognizes the deep sorrow felt by individuals who see their sacred sites desecrated and destroyed.

The native inhabitants could only watch while their revered land endured harm and disregard.

Nerburn and Dan jointly convey their deep distress over the ecological devastation that followed the European settlers' colonization. In their conversations, Nerburn develops a deep understanding of the suffering caused by the continuous encroachment on lands that are deeply revered, all for the sake of economic progress or expansion. Dan describes the catastrophic reduction in the numbers of the once-abundant bison, coupled with extensive deforestation and the pollution of rivers and streams, all driven by a quest for wealth and dominance by those who seemed to disregard the profound spiritual and ecological consequences of their actions.

Indigenous peoples felt a deep severance from their spiritual and cultural origins due to being stripped of their ancestral territories.

Nerburn underscores the profound effect on the spiritual practices and traditional ways of Indigenous peoples stemming from the appropriation of their lands and the disruption of their age-old lifestyles. Their disconnection was not only from a means of survival, but also from the core of their spiritual essence and traditional customs. He notes that this imposed division resulted in societal problems, alcohol dependency, and an all-encompassing feeling of sorrow and mourning.

Practical Tips

• You can deepen your connection to nature by adopting a daily practice of outdoor mindfulness meditation. Choose a natural setting, like a park or garden, and spend a few minutes each day sitting quietly, observing the sights, sounds, and smells around you. This practice can help you develop a more profound appreciation for the natural world and its rhythms, similar to the connection indigenous communities maintain with the earth.
• Start a personal tradition of giving back to the earth by planting native species in your area. Research plants that are indigenous to your region and contribute to the local ecosystem by planting them in your yard or community spaces. This act of nurturing the land aligns with the indigenous principle of reciprocity with nature and supports local biodiversity.
• Create a "use what you need" challenge for yourself, focusing on reducing waste in your daily life. For one month, make a conscious effort to use only the resources you truly need, such as water, food, and energy. Keep a journal to reflect on the experience, noting how this practice affects your consumption habits and awareness of resource use, mirroring the sustainable practices of indigenous peoples.

The enduring essence, traditions, and selfhood of Indigenous peoples persist in spite of a past marked by suffering and unfairness.

Nerburn highlights the persistent vigor and cultural integrity that Native American spirit and identity have maintained, despite a past marked by hardship and deprivation. He emphasizes the persistent efforts by the community to maintain their traditions, assert their autonomy, and protect their heritage for future generations.

Native resilience and adaptability in preserving their cultural heritage.

Nerburn acknowledges that the indigenous communities in America actively safeguard their cultural heritage, instead of being mere historical casualties. He admires their steadfast commitment to preserving their cultural heritage in the face of relentless pressure to assimilate or vanish. He credits both the strength of their cultural identity and their ability to find creative ways to adapt their traditions to a new and unforgiving reality.

Indigenous peoples maintained their languages and traditions, persisting in their unique cultural ways despite numerous attempts to obliterate their historical identity.

In his dialogues, Nerburn grows to understand the systematic and intentional attempts to obliterate the cultures of Indigenous peoples, which encompassed the state's strategy of forcing children from these communities into boarding schools. Despite the attempts tantamount to cultural annihilation, numerous Indigenous communities succeeded in preserving their languages, traditional narratives, spiritual practices, and fundamental principles. They preserved their cultural heritage clandestinely, sharing their tales through spoken word in resistance to the educational standards enforced upon them, and continued to nurture their sacred bond with the earth despite being uprooted from their traditional territories.

Indigenous peoples devised innovative methods for transmitting their narratives, traditions, and customs to succeeding generations.

Nerburn greatly respects the creative methods that have safeguarded Indigenous American traditions, securing their cultural heritage for the benefit of future generations. Their culture flourished, finding expression in close-knit assemblies where stories and values were exchanged, by integrating their indigenous beliefs with Christian doctrines, through the modification of their rituals to suit changing situations, and by showing that culture maintains a vibrant essence that endures through deliberate and respectful manifestation.

The ongoing struggle to assert Native sovereignty and rights.

The historical trauma and injustices inflicted upon Native Americans, as Nerburn discovers, continue to reverberate through generations. Despite no longer enduring the blatant aggression and cultural oppression of bygone eras, they continue to confront obstacles in affirming their autonomy, endeavoring to regain control over ancestral territories, and addressing the persistent stereotypes and misrepresentations that shape their identity in the perspective of the prevailing society.

Natives fought to reclaim their land, self-governance, and ability to practice their culture freely.

Nerburn grows to realize that the struggle for self-determination among Native Americans and their rightful restoration into American society persisted past what is commonly referred to as the frontier era. They are diligently pursuing the reclamation of their ancestral territories through legal means, endeavoring to achieve autonomy within their territories, and continuously endeavoring to preserve their customary ways and protect their distinct cultural identities from external influences.

Natives continue to battle against stereotypes, misrepresentation, and the legacy of oppression.

Dan frequently expressed his irritation to Nerburn about the persistent stereotypes and misconceptions that shape the perception of Native Americans among white individuals. Their intricate past is often oversimplified into romanticized stories and exaggerated stereotypes, casting them as either unfortunate alcoholics or enlightened sages. Nerburn acknowledges the continuous struggle against confining and often demeaning portrayals, endeavoring to reclaim their narrative as an integral part of America's history and contemporary culture.

The importance of knowledge that is handed down through generations by Native elders.

Nerburn underscores the vital importance of elders in preserving the cultural identity and legacy of Indigenous American communities. He recognizes them as living libraries of knowledge, keepers of essential stories, traditions, and spiritual understanding. He observes how the inter-generational transmission of this wisdom is essential for cultural continuity and the strength of future generations.

Elders hold a position of deep respect for their role as custodians of vital cultural and historical wisdom.

Dan, Grover, and Annie serve as custodians of a profound legacy of cultural and historical wisdom. They hold memories reaching back to times when their customary lifestyle remained intact, and through withstanding forced assimilation and cultural supremacy, they offer a unique perspective on the challenges faced by the younger generations. Nerburn recognizes the deep respect given to the elders and emphasizes their crucial role in transmitting essential knowledge, traditions, and values to the next generation, thus ensuring the continuation of their cultural heritage.

Sharing stories, rituals, and values across generations is essential for maintaining Native identity.

Nerburn recognizes the crucial importance of transmitting traditions in maintaining the cultural identity of Indigenous peoples. He learns that the stories and traditions passed through earlier generations are not just nostalgic relics; they serve as essential links that bind them to their ancestors, their land, and their cultural identity. This continuity nurtures a feeling of community, direction, and resilience, equipping them with essential skills to traverse a society that persistently overlooks and sidelines their distinct viewpoint.

Practical Tips

• You can learn and use a few phrases in an indigenous language to foster appreciation and awareness. Start by downloading a language learning app that offers indigenous languages or find online resources dedicated to these languages. Practice daily, and try to use the phrases in appropriate contexts, such as greeting friends or signing off emails. This small act can demonstrate respect for the language and may inspire others to engage with it too.
• Create a personal art project that reflects the themes of indigenous struggles and resilience. Use any medium you're comfortable with, like drawing, painting, or digital art, to depict what you've learned about the fight for sovereignty, rights, or cultural practices. Share your artwork on social media with a brief explanation to raise awareness and encourage conversations among your network.
• Engage with indigenous content creators by following them on social media, subscribing to their channels, or reading their blogs. By actively seeking out and supporting their work, you contribute to the fight against stereotypes and misrepresentation. Share their content with your circles to help amplify their voices and narratives.