PDF Summary:Maniac, by Harold Schechter

Harold Schechter's Maniac unravels the chilling story behind one of America's deadliest school massacres. The book details the humble upbringings and slow unraveling of Andrew Kehoe, an initially promising man whose resentments fester into an unthinkable act. Schechter investigates the Bath Township community, painting a picture of normalcy that would be shattered by Kehoe's meticulously planned assault on the local consolidated school in 1927.

Delving into Kehoe's psyche, Schechter considers how financial hardship, rejection from society, and mental instability fueled Kehoe's growing bitterness—culminating in a horrific bombing that claimed the lives of 44 people, most of them children. While providing historical context, this account sheds light on this seminal American tragedy and the motives behind such shocking violence.

(continued)...

Schechter reveals that Kehoe's resentment intensified while he struggled with mounting debts and fiscal pressures that emerged due to the post-war decline in the farming sector. His opposition intensified as the recently sanctioned educational levy, to which he was vehemently opposed, was ratified. He perceived the tax as an unjust imposition by a society he grew more and more to believe was plotting his downfall.

As the planned attack drew nearer, there was a growing recognition that Kehoe's conduct, characterized by his extreme and alarming treatment of both people and animals, was escalating.

Kehoe's conduct became increasingly erratic and concerning as he grappled with mounting financial stress. He displayed sudden and intense outbursts of anger, targeting not only individuals who obstructed his economic endeavors but also animals.

Schechter narrates an instance of Kehoe's sheer indifference to animal suffering, describing a savage incident in which he slaughtered a horse that failed to function correctly with a fertilizer spreader and callously terminated the life of a dog, beloved by someone living nearby, simply because it buried a bone near the edge of his property. His growing aggression and retreat from social engagement were early indicators of a burgeoning wickedness, the grave implications of which were only understood later on.

Kehoe's personality, marked by self-absorption, distrust of others, and disregard for social norms, coupled with his sense of grievance, drove him to commit violent deeds.

Kehoe's escalating resentment convinced him that the wider community and its inhabitants were deliberately engineering his difficulties. His sense of victimhood fueled his paranoid delusions, leaving him increasingly isolated and alienated. Schechter emphasizes several characteristics that could have intensified Kehoe's psychological deterioration. He suggests that the domineering disposition and harshness attributed to Kehoe sparked tense relations with many community members and peers.

He frequently lost his temper, especially during social events, which resulted in a rigid demand for rule-following and a low tolerance for errors, causing others to generally avoid his company at such gatherings. Kehoe's self-centeredness was characterized by an inflated view of his importance coupled with a lack of empathy, which resulted in his denial of any shortcomings resulting from his deeds. He was psychologically fragile and firmly believed that society had mistreated him, which led to his fantasy of violent retribution that eventually manifested in a catastrophic act of vengeance.

Andrew Kehoe planned the attack with great care and detail.

Kehoe meticulously amassed a substantial amount of explosives and orchestrated a detailed scheme to distribute these volatile substances within the school building's structure.

Schechter reveals that Kehoe's descent into madness culminated in a carefully planned massacre. He surreptitiously gathered a substantial quantity of an explosive initially developed for military purposes and subsequently discounted for agricultural applications, while also securing additional dynamite, ultimately amassing hundreds of pounds. Kehoe gained unrestricted access by impersonating the person in charge of maintaining the school. He spent several weeks carefully arranging explosives throughout the school's basement, which were set to be activated by a mechanism synchronized with an alarm clock, resulting in the explosion.

Schechter emphasizes Kehoe's careful and intentional preparation for his atrocious deed, refuting the notion of it being an impulsive surge of madness.

Before the assault on the school, Kehoe perpetrated the atrocious deed of murdering his spouse and additionally devastated his homestead.

Schechter's investigation uncovers that Kehoe's plot extended beyond the horrific act of slaughtering the town's children in the school bombing. He initiated a relentless pursuit to destroy his belongings and remove all traces of his former life. Kehoe executed a concluding act of devastation by rigging his farmhouse and other buildings with explosives and setting them off. He brutally beat his spouse to death and then burned her remains in a transport vehicle commonly used for transporting pigs. In his depiction of the brutal murder of Nellie, whom the community saw as a kind and innocent person, Schechter exposes the depth of Kehoe's malevolence and the unyielding, ruinous drive that led him to annihilate his surroundings.

Practical Tips

• You can enhance your emotional intelligence by keeping a journal to reflect on your interactions with others, noting any tendencies toward judgment or superiority. This self-awareness exercise helps you identify patterns in your behavior that may be similar to Kehoe's scorn for those who didn't meet his expectations, allowing you to work on becoming more empathetic and less judgmental.
• Develop a safety checklist for your home and workplace to ensure that all electrical systems are secure and up to code, inspired by Kehoe's aptitude for electrical systems. This proactive approach not only improves safety but also familiarizes you with the basics of electrical safety, which can be useful in preventing accidents.
• Create a stress management plan that includes regular physical activity, relaxation techniques, and a support network to help cope with financial pressures or personal setbacks. This strategy is aimed at mitigating the kind of stress that seemed to contribute to Kehoe's deteriorating mental state, helping you maintain mental well-being during challenging times.

The consequences and subsequent events following the attack

Schechter's portrayal is a poignant depiction of the profound grief and mental anguish that the Bath Consolidated School calamity inflicted upon the local populace. Schechter narrates the intense search for survivors amid the wreckage and the heart-wrenching instances when parents identified their lifeless or injured children.

The events of the attack and its immediate aftermath

Kehoe executed a sequence of blasts on the day in question, initially annihilating his own farmstead before triggering the bombs he had secreted within the educational facility.

Schechter meticulously describes the rapid and brutal realization of Kehoe's heinous scheme that occurred on the disastrous Tuesday of May 17, 1927. On the morning of the incident, Kehoe was observed engaging in his typical routine and casually chatting with locals and members of the educational panel, without betraying any hint of his malevolent intentions, after sending off a package containing educational materials and a note that nonchalantly mentioned his impending departure from his role on the educational committee. At approximately 9:45 AM, as the majority of pupils were absorbed in their studies, the meticulously placed explosives detonated, resulting in the total obliteration of the Bath Consolidated School's northern wing.

The explosion's power generated a thunderous boom that reverberated throughout the town, with sufficient intensity to shake houses and shatter glass. The blast destroyed the roof of the north wing, causing it to cave in over the classrooms and ensnaring many students and teachers beneath a substantial pile of rubble. As the explosions occurred, Kehoe's farmhouse and the surrounding buildings were rapidly consumed by fire. During that time, a notably heinous chapter of criminal activity was being written across the American landscape.

The explosion claimed the lives of over 40 people, mostly children, and inflicted injuries on many, standing out as an exceptionally atrocious instance of mass murder in American historical records.

Schechter details the chaotic scene at the schoolhouse where rescuers convened, frantically sifting through the rubble from the collapsed northern section. The building's southern section, which remained unscathed, served as a sanctuary for terrified students, some of whom were injured by broken glass and assorted rubble. Following the blast that rendered the school's electric bells inoperative, Emory Huyck took action to guarantee the safe evacuation of the remaining students and to maintain calm.

As the dust settled, the vast extent of the devastation became unmistakably clear. Many children, whose identities were obscured by their injuries, lay lifeless among the wreckage of the buildings that had once been their schools. Numerous individuals were saved from the rubble, suffering from serious wounds that included fractured bones, cranial fractures, and deep cuts. In the final moments, the explosion claimed the lives of thirty-eight young students and three adults, among them Huyck, custodian Glenn Smith, and the respected community member Nelson McFarren, as it detonated, subsequently setting off Kehoe's truck bomb laden with shrapnel. Hazel Weatherby and her colleague Blanche Hart both passed away due to their sustained injuries. Another student, Beatrice Gibbs, succumbed to her injuries three months later, bringing the total number of deaths to forty-four.

Efforts to rescue individuals were hindered by the widespread devastation and the discovery of additional unexploded ordnance in the lower levels of the educational building.

Schechter depicts a community struggling to come to terms with an event beyond their comprehension. In the midst of chaos and destruction, dedicated rescuers carefully searched the debris to move the injured to makeshift medical facilities and offered solace to distressed parents desperately looking for their offspring. In the school's boundaries, a shocking discovery was made: a large amount of unexploded dynamite and pyrotol, linked to a timing device, suggested that Kehoe's plans for devastation were much more extensive than initially believed.

If the explosion had occurred as intended, the schoolhouse would have been obliterated, with no survivors inside. Understanding the motivations for Kehoe's actions was deeply unsettling, as it illuminated the malevolent purpose of his plan.

The community's response and the subsequent inquiry

The small town of Bath was plunged into mourning as the attack left hardly a family untouched by sorrow.

Schechter powerfully depicted the profound shock and intense sorrow that engulfed the community in the aftermath of the explosion. In a town of only three hundred inhabitants, almost every family had been directly impacted by the tragedy. In the local community center, which had been converted into a temporary morgue, a harrowing scene unfolded as parents identified their lost children, leading to scenes of mothers overwhelmed by grief and fathers crying unrestrainedly.

The community united in mourning, paying tribute to the cherished young individuals and educators through a succession of memorial services held over several days. The heinous acts perpetrated by Kehoe brought grief to nearly every resident of Bath, as they mourned the loss of children, relatives, or acquaintances.

The factors and underlying motivations for Kehoe's attack remained unclear after the investigation.

Schechter clarifies that while the investigation didn't fully elucidate Kehoe's underlying reasons for his actions, insights from those who knew him offered a clearer view of his mental state. His demeanor grew increasingly morose and he became more reclusive as the incident approached. His growing bitterness was stoked by financial difficulties, a succession of perceived wrongs, and escalating paranoia.

The jury ultimately concluded that Kehoe had the capacity to distinguish between ethical and unethical behavior, confirming his mental soundness, yet they admitted that comprehending the complexities of his psyche was beyond their grasp. Kehoe's final communication, a sign bearing the cryptic phrase "Criminals are shaped by their surroundings, not by their lineage," offered little insight into the specific motivations for his atrocious deed. However, it underscored the prevalent conviction that the very society he sought to destroy had indeed been the catalyst for his transformation into a monstrous being.

The lasting impact of the disaster that struck Bath School continues to be substantial.

The Bath School incident, while not widely known for a considerable time, is currently recognized as a precursor to the prevalent trend of mass violence in the United States.

Schechter points out that the Bath School Disaster was reported extensively throughout the nation. Public interest quickly turned to Charles Lindbergh's extensively reported solo journey across the Atlantic. Schechter suggests that this characteristic accelerated the disappearance of the deadliest school massacre in America from collective memory.

The catastrophe of the Bath School Disaster, which remained primarily within the scope of local history and the memories of those who lived through it, did not receive widespread recognition for a considerable time. Kehoe's atrocious act began to resurface in discussions and reports across the media in the United States, especially as acts of mass violence, including those at schools, began to happen more frequently.

Kehoe pioneered the use of a vehicle for assembling an explosive device, a technique that would later be adopted in subsequent acts of terrorism.

Schechter underscores the uniquely horrific character of the Bath School Disaster within the historical record of school tragedies and comments on its ominous warning of future mass violence, which is linked to Kehoe's intentional accumulation of explosives, his meticulously planned attack, and his ultimate act of self-annihilation by detonating an explosive in his car.

Schechter emphasizes that Kehoe's heinous acts foreshadowed the tactics used by people like the one responsible for the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing, underscoring the unsettling similarities between individuals who commit random mass violence.

No subsequent incident of school violence in the United States has resulted in more fatalities than the Bath School Disaster, which holds the grim distinction of being the most lethal.

The Bath School Disaster continues to serve as a grave reminder of the persistent trends of violence within American society, despite its lack of widespread recognition. Kehoe’s crime, Schechter reminds us, surpassed even the Columbine and Virginia Tech massacres in terms of its sheer death toll. The shocking brutality exhibited by someone who seemed unremarkable, their methodical and intentional actions, and the deep impact these had on a close community highlight the enduring potential for malevolence that can lurk within even the most peaceful and isolated settings.

Practical Tips

• You can enhance your awareness of emergency protocols by visiting your local school to inquire about their current safety measures and how they address the risk of unexploded ordnance. Understanding the procedures in place can help you become a more informed and prepared member of your community. For example, ask about the school's evacuation plans, how they communicate with parents during an emergency, and if they conduct regular safety drills that include scenarios like unexploded ordnance.
• Create a personal safety checklist for your home that includes regular checks for any hazardous materials or conditions that could lead to accidents or injuries. This proactive approach ensures that you're taking steps to prevent potential disasters in your own environment. Your checklist might include inspecting household chemicals, ensuring smoke detectors are functional, and creating an emergency plan with your family.
• Volunteer with a local grief support group or initiative to help those dealing with loss, as a way to contribute to community healing similar to what might have been needed in the aftermath of the Bath School Disaster. By offering your time and empathy, you can provide comfort to individuals who are mourning. Look for opportunities at community centers, religious organizations, or online platforms that connect volunteers with people in need of support.