PDF Summary:Letter to the American Church, by Eric Metaxas

In today's climate of growing secularism and moral relativism, Letter to the American Church author Eric Metaxas issues an urgent call: The American Church must reignite its commitment to boldly proclaim and embody biblical truths. He draws parallels to the tragic silence and compromises of the German Church under Nazi rule, warning the modern American Church against similar passivity in confronting injustice, self-preservation over adherence to God's commands, and fear of backlash rather than obedience to divine will.

Metaxas inspires believers to reject empty ritual and traditions, embrace the kind of unwavering courage modeled by Dietrich Bonhoeffer, and reclaim their prophetic role as a courageous, compassionate voice for truth. He argues that only such conviction and pursuit of righteousness can fortify the Church—and the nation—from collapsing under societal pressures and government overreach.

(continued)...

Errors within Church teachings that hinder its progress.

This section of the text pinpoints specific theological misunderstandings that could lead to passivity and compromise, thus diminishing the Church's capacity to fulfill its intended role. The author challenges these misunderstandings and call for a resurgence of the bold and robust faith exemplified by individuals such as Bonhoeffer.

Reductive views on the concept of faith lead to a superficial version of religious observance.

Metaxas argues that while the emphasis on justification through faith, as highlighted by Martin Luther, corrected a tradition overly dependent on actions, an excessive focus on this principle might lead to a reductive perception of faith that neglects the importance of active engagement and guidance.

Belief requires a dedication that transcends simple agreement in thought; it calls for a complete and unwavering dedication.

Metaxas cautions that faith extends beyond simple concurrence with doctrinal assertions, drawing on wisdom from the Epistle of James and the teachings of Dietrich Bonhoeffer. The author illuminates the deceptive alternative to genuine salvation, a concept Bonhoeffer described as "inexpensive forgiveness." It diminishes and misrepresents the true essence of Faith, transforming it into a mere intellectual exercise rather than a profound dedication to Jesus Christ. Simply concurring in thought without genuine remorse and heartfelt compliance is a hollow facsimile of true faith. A belief system lacking substance, which fails to translate into actions and bears no fruit in the believer's life.

Seeking justification before God by means of declaring doctrines and affirming one's faith.

Eric Metaxas draws a parallel between the notion of "cheap grace" and the biblical narrative where Adam and Eve use fig leaves to conceal their nudity. Attempting to justify our actions, we often dress them up in the trappings of religious doctrine, formal proclamations of faith, and hallowed rituals, much as the first humans sought to hide their wrongdoing behind simple coverings. Our lives must be a true reflection of our beliefs, otherwise we are merely concealing ourselves from God with the superficial trappings of religious practice.

Prioritizing the task of spreading the faith over the broad spectrum of scriptural responsibilities is akin to idol worship.

The writers argue that the Church's responsibilities go further than just spreading the Gospel. They contend that concentrating solely on individual conversions, while neglecting other biblical responsibilities, may distort the fundamental tenets of Christianity and reduce its impact.

The mistaken belief that evangelism is the sole or primary mission of the church.

Metaxas warns that while spreading the message of the Gospel, the Church should also remain attentive to the other scriptural instructions that form the entirety of its sacred duty. While it's essential to communicate the teachings of Christianity, this is not the sole or primary function of the church. The Church has a duty to confront unfairness, support those who are less fortunate and on the fringes of society, and demonstrate divine compassion through benevolent deeds. The writers emphasize the crucial role that the Church plays in engaging with different areas of society, often creating opportunities to share the Christian faith and lead people towards a deeper connection with God.

The tendency to avoid controversial issues to prevent offending potential converts

Metaxas challenges the notion that the Church should avoid controversial issues to keep from turning away individuals who might be exploring faith. He argues that this fear-based method is not just futile but also contradicts the principles taught in the Bible. Jesus, the ultimate model for evangelism, did not shy away from speaking truth, even when it was controversial or offensive. In fact, His daring challenges to the spiritual and governing authorities of His time ultimately led to His crucifixion. The Church is obligated to address difficult subjects, even if it means potentially alienating some individuals. Metaxas argues that a courageous declaration of the truth often draws people towards Christ and encourages them to reflect on Christian doctrines.

Context

• "Cheap grace" is a concept introduced by theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer. It describes the idea of receiving forgiveness without genuine repentance or transformation. It emphasizes the danger of treating forgiveness as a commodity that requires no real change in behavior or commitment to faith. Bonhoeffer argued that true grace demands a response of discipleship and a radical change in how one lives out their faith.
• Dietrich Bonhoeffer, a German theologian, introduced the concept of "cheap grace" in his writings. This term describes a superficial form of forgiveness that lacks true repentance and transformation. Bonhoeffer emphasized the importance of genuine commitment and sacrifice in faith, contrasting it with a shallow understanding that does not lead to a profound change in one's life. "Cheap grace" warns against a belief system that merely pays lip service to religious doctrines without embodying the core values of Christianity.
• The parallel drawn between Adam and Eve using fig leaves and justifying actions with religious trappings highlights how humans often try to cover up their faults with superficial appearances, akin to how Adam and Eve used fig leaves to hide their shame. This comparison underscores the tendency to mask shortcomings with external displays of faith or religious practices, rather than addressing the underlying issues sincerely. It serves as a caution against substituting genuine repentance and transformation with mere outward displays of religious adherence. The analogy emphasizes the importance of authenticity and true spiritual growth over superficial acts of piety.

The Church must courageously declare the truth.

The passage underscores the urgency with which the Church must confront evil, regardless of any possible repercussions. The author draws inspiration from the courage of figures like Bonhoeffer, who stood firm against the pressures exerted by society and government. They insist that compromise and fear are unacceptable responses in the current climate.

The church must stand firm and speak out against injustices and wrongdoing, irrespective of the possible sacrifices that may come with such actions.

The author emphasizes that speaking out against injustice and evil is not optional for the Church but is a fundamental aspect of its identity and mission.

The Church must voice its stance on issues like abortion, the inviolability of life, and matters pertaining to human sexuality to preserve its essence and purpose.

Eric Metaxas underscores the duty of religious congregations to actively participate in crucial conversations about topics like abortion, sexuality, and the value of life, even in the face of possible opposition from powerful social or government bodies. The concerns we face go beyond the political realm and are deeply rooted in the moral and spiritual principles that form the essential design for humanity. The Church has a grave duty to speak up for the voiceless and to oppose injustice, regardless of potential repercussions.

The Church should not hesitate to engage in political matters when its biblical duties are jeopardized.

Metaxas argues that it is essential for the Church to engage in political conversations, highlighting the risk and contradiction to scriptural directives when religious convictions are omitted from public discussions. Faith influences all facets of existence, politics included. The Church has a solemn duty to speak out against injustices when those in authority enact measures that fail to uphold equity and might contemplate engagement in political actions. Metaxas underscores the critical role that Christians play in shaping political affairs to align with divine intentions, citing the endeavors of figures like Wilberforce in the crusade against slavery, the resistance of Bonhoeffer to the tyranny of the Nazis, and Reagan's challenge to the supremacy of the Soviet Union.

The Church must model the self-sacrificial love and courage of figures like Bonhoeffer

The author calls upon the Church to reignite its commitment to emulate the courageous actions of figures like Dietrich Bonhoeffer, who valiantly stood against evil with steadfast moral principles, even to the point of giving his life for those beliefs.

The Church should be willing to risk its comfort, reputation, and very survival to remain faithful to the edicts of the Divine.

Metaxas emphasizes that true discipleship involves more than simply attending church and professing belief in Jesus Christ. Embracing the path of Christ demands the bravery to endure, despite potential sacrifices to one's reputation, comfort, and possibly even one's life. Eric Metaxas argues that this profound commitment originates from a passionate devotion to God and an ardent enthusiasm for His realm, not from a desire for earthly recognition or fear of divine punishment.

Remaining passive when confronted with today's challenges is not an acceptable option.

The author strongly denounces any tendency to justify misconduct or remain passive in the face of injustice, underlining that such attitudes are completely unacceptable for communities claiming to follow Christ's teachings. Concerns about fear are argued to erode confidence in one's convictions and are contrary to the genuine essence of courage. The Church, invigorated by the Holy Spirit, must bravely challenge wickedness, confident in the assured victory that is God's alone.

Practical Tips

• You can start a blog or social media page dedicated to discussing contemporary issues from a perspective that aligns with your values. By consistently posting your thoughts and engaging with followers, you create a platform for dialogue and awareness. For example, if you're passionate about the inviolability of life, share articles, create infographics, and write posts that explore this topic from various angles, encouraging respectful conversation and education.
• Volunteer with local organizations that align with your principles to actively participate in community change. This hands-on approach allows you to embody the values you stand for, such as self-sacrificial love and courage. For instance, if human sexuality matters are important to you, look for groups that educate and support individuals in this area, offering your time to help with their programs or events.
• Develop a personal code of ethics that outlines how you will respond to injustices and wrongdoing in your daily life. This could include commitments to speak up when you witness discrimination, to support businesses that align with your ethical stance, or to use your vote to back candidates and policies that reflect your values. For example, if you encounter a company that uses unethical practices, choose to boycott their products and explain your choice to others to spread awareness.

Prioritizing faithfulness and adherence to divine will over human authority.

The discussion emphasizes the significant issue of fear and how it can paralyze the faith community. The writers stress the importance of relying on the divine benevolence and moral integrity, particularly when confronted with challenging choices and the possible outcomes that may follow. They argue that perceiving God as a nurturing guardian rather than a strict judge encourages us to undertake courageous deeds.

The Church should embrace a view of God as a compassionate and forgiving protector, instead of a harsh judge.

Metaxas contends that misconceptions about the divine nature are what lead to fear. Perceiving God predominantly as a harsh adjudicator, intent on penalizing our errors, could lead us to eschew risks and adhere to familiar paths, even if it means compromising with sin. God is portrayed in the Scriptures as a kind and gentle protector, always ready to offer mercy and forgiveness to those who turn to Him. Our understanding that the divine essence frees us from fear empowers us to take bold actions, confident that even in the face of our mistakes, we are surrounded by divine presence and grace.

Living in perpetual fear of divine retribution instead of wholeheartedly accepting faith is essentially equivalent to a lack of faith.

Metaxas challenges the notion that prudence is a noble and pious approach, arguing instead that it reveals a lack of trust in the goodness and compassion of the Divine. He illustrates his point by referencing the biblical story where servants are given talents to manage. The servant who faced rebuke for concealing his talent out of fear of his master's response, rather than risking its forfeiture, is admonished for a lack of faith. The book commends individuals who bravely employ their skills and acknowledges their bravery and dedication.

Genuine faith encourages courageous commitment to personal principles, rather than a sanctimonious type of spiritual observance.

The author stresses that genuine belief goes beyond merely avoiding sin or clinging to safe, traditional behaviors; it's about advancing with assurance and obedience, particularly when confronted with obstacles or uncertainties. Genuine belief prioritizes deepening our commitment to the Divine over reducing the dangers we encounter. Our readiness to set aside our personal ambitions and accept the divine direction for our existence is what defines this characteristic, particularly when it guides us into unfamiliar realms.

The Church is called to act boldly and bravely when beckoned by a higher power, in a manner reminiscent of figures such as Reagan.

The writer illustrates the instance when, against the typical guidance of his advisors, Ronald Reagan bravely called for the Soviet Union to tear down the Berlin Wall. They use this historical example to illustrate the importance of courage and risk-taking in confronting evil.

The Church must remain active and not succumb to the advice of individuals who counsel caution for reasons not rooted in spirituality.

Metaxas warns that the often-praised approach of "pragmatic knowledge," which advocates for caution and compromise, might actually mask a hidden fear, a lack of strong beliefs, and a tendency to preserve the status quo. He encourages the Church to dismiss advice rooted in apprehension and to place their confidence in divine direction, even when it appears hazardous or nontraditional.

Occasions arise when it becomes necessary to challenge those in power who disregard hallowed values, as demonstrated by the deeds of Rahab.

Eric Metaxas uses the tale of Rahab, who misled the authorities to protect the Israeli scouts, to show that sometimes, resisting unethical directives from leaders is an essential demonstration of religious conviction. He argues that blind compliance with unjust laws or submission to malevolent authorities represents a moral failing rather than a commendable act. Eric Metaxas emphasizes the importance of the Church courageously standing against governmental decrees when they conflict with God's commands.

Other Perspectives

• The view of God as solely compassionate and forgiving may overlook the aspect of divine justice, which is also a significant theme in many religious texts.
• Fear of divine retribution can be a powerful motivator for moral behavior and is a traditional aspect of many religious teachings.
• Prudence and caution can be seen as virtues in religious life, promoting wisdom and discernment rather than a lack of faith.
• Bold and brave actions should be balanced with humility and the recognition that human understanding of divine will is limited.
• The advice of individuals counseling caution may be rooted in a deep understanding of complex situations and should not be dismissed outright as fear-based or non-spiritual.
• Challenging those in power must be done with careful consideration of the consequences and the potential for misinterpreting what constitutes "hallowed values."
• The actions of historical figures like Reagan, while bold, may not always be the best model for religious behavior, which often calls for peace and reconciliation.
• The story of Rahab, while illustrating a point about challenging authority, also raises complex ethical questions about lying and disobedience to civil law.

The urgent call for initiative within the American Church.

The book's concluding section emphasizes the critical juncture at which American churches find themselves, as they encounter increasing societal and governmental resistance to the scriptural foundations of their ethical teachings. The author encourages the Church to take up its mantle, inspiring it to achieve its prophetic destiny through boldly proclaiming and exemplifying the divine truth.

The United States church finds itself at a crucial juncture, facing challenges reminiscent of those encountered by the German church.

Metaxas paints a grim picture of the current state of American society, highlighting the growing influence of secular ideologies and the notion that moral values are not steadfast or immutable. Eric Metaxas argues that the challenges facing the American church today are reminiscent of those faced by the German Church in the 1930s, with potentially even greater consequences.

Secularism, Marxism, and moral relativism present a considerable danger to the country's well-being.

Metaxas contends that America's core values are at grave risk due to prevailing secular, Marxist, and morally relative societal forces, which also jeopardize the freedom of the Church to proclaim truths of a divine nature. Eric Metaxas argues that these groups are actively eroding traditional values and are stifling the freedom to express dissenting views and to practice one's faith.

The American Church must intensify its commitment to fulfilling its holy mission.

Eric Metaxas presents a compelling and urgent call to churches throughout the United States. The gravity of our present circumstances calls for an acknowledgment that will shape our conduct by reflecting on past missteps made by the church in Germany, thus rising to the occasion to boldly proclaim and live out the truths of Scripture. The Church must remain vigilant, courageous, and proactive.

The American Church bears the responsibility and privilege of serving as a beacon of guidance in these times.

The writers underscore the crucial influence that the American Church can exert as a key voice of prophecy during this essential period in history. Each individual within the Church is intentionally placed in this specific era and location to fulfill a unique role.

Passivity and self-preservation were considered inappropriate reactions.

Eric Metaxas reproaches the American Church for its passivity and prioritization of self-preservation in the face of its present challenges. He argues that when we place our own comfort, societal approval, or personal safety above all else, we are essentially turning our backs on the core messages of the Gospel and relinquishing the bravery and freedom that Christ has granted us.

The American Church must courageously proclaim and exemplify the truths that are contained within the Scriptures.

Metaxas urges believers to accept the consequences associated with their convictions, boldly declaring and embodying biblical principles, irrespective of any personal sacrifice involved. The author calls for a resurgence of a Christianity that goes beyond what Bonhoeffer imagined, characterized not just by ritual observance and doctrinal repetition, but by a passionate and courageous commitment to live out the teachings of Jesus. Churches throughout the United States are currently confronted with an urgent need to take action. It is a summons to action, a call to reclaim its prophetic voice, and to embody the self-sacrificial love and courage of Jesus Christ.

Other Perspectives

• The comparison between the American Church's situation and the German Church in the 1930s may be seen as an overstatement, as the historical contexts are significantly different.
• The assertion that secularism, Marxism, and moral relativism are threats could be challenged by the view that these ideologies also promote positive values such as inclusivity, equality, and critical thinking.
• The idea that the American Church must intensify its commitment might be met with the argument that the Church should also adapt and modernize its approach to remain relevant in a changing society.
• The call for the Church to be a guiding beacon could be countered with the perspective that guidance should also come from a diverse array of voices and institutions in society, not solely from religious organizations.
• The criticism of passivity within the Church might overlook the nuanced and varied ways in which different congregations are engaging with societal issues.
• The encouragement for the Church to proclaim and exemplify biblical truths might be balanced with the idea that the Church should also foster open dialogue and respect for differing beliefs within a pluralistic society.
• The call for believers to accept consequences for their convictions could be met with the counterargument that faith should also be about finding a harmonious balance between one's beliefs and the ability to coexist with others who may not share those beliefs.