PDF Summary:Jerusalem, by Simon Sebag Montefiore

No city evokes as much passion and longing as Jerusalem, the sacred site for Judaism, Christianity, and Islam—and the centerpiece of a centuries-long battle for dominance between empires and faiths. Author Simon Sebag Montefiore traces Jerusalem's extraordinary history and enduring spiritual significance, celebrating the city's cultural complexity even as it has been repeatedly conquered and divided by conflicts between nations and religions.

From the biblical origins and soaring prophecies of a unified heaven on Earth to the bloodshed and displacement of the Arab-Israeli wars, Montefiore details Jerusalem's dramatic events and iconic figures in resounding detail. The result is a majestic portrait—not polemical, but illuminating—capturing Jerusalem's eternal pull on the human spirit and psyche.

(continued)...

The internal conflicts and dynastic power struggles had a profound influence on Jerusalem's standing in the Islamic world.

Montefiore explores the turmoil and conflicts for dominance that erupted in the Islamic world after the death of Prophet Muhammad, highlighting the way the strife among Sunni and Shia factions, as well as rival caliphates, determined the future course of Jerusalem. The city's vulnerability to conquest and the gradual decline in the tradition of tolerance were often the result of frequent conflicts that led to instability, heightened aggression, and economic decline. The Shia splinter group, known as the Fatimids, established Cairo as their capital and assumed control over Egypt, Palestine, and Syria, thereby supplanting the Sunni Umayyad Caliphate of Damascus. The Abbasid Caliphate, with its center in Baghdad, ultimately fell to Turkoman invaders, who in turn were conquered by the Mamluks from Egypt. Every successive dynasty adopted unique strategies for the administration of Jerusalem's varied religious communities, as Montefiore demonstrates. The Fatimid dynasty, known for their Shia beliefs, were considered to be accepting of others until the moment when Caliph al-Hakim ordered the destruction of the Holy Sepulchre. The Turks were recognized for their stringent enforcement of Islamic laws and for levying substantial charges on pilgrims. During the period when Muslims governed Jerusalem, Montefiore demonstrates that religious motivations and tactical concerns were invariably linked.

The Crusades led to the establishment of a territory under the rule of Christian knights.

Montefiore explores the period of nearly a century when Jerusalem was under Christian rule, known as the Crusades. In 1099, the Crusaders, driven by their quest for riches and redemption, captured Jerusalem, an event characterized by the mass killing of the city's Jewish and Muslim residents, and thereafter partitioned Palestine and the surrounding areas into a number of feudal territories under their dominion. The Crusader kingdom in Jerusalem, enduring for almost two hundred years, was ruled by monarchs who spoke French and whose ancestry could be traced to the initial Crusaders, and it was characterized by relentless strife with the Egyptians and Syrians. Montefiore underscores the establishment of a novel Christian governance system and the cultural strains that emerged from the fusion of Eastern and Western civilizations as a result of the Crusades. He investigates life under Crusader rule, examining the religious and military orders of the Templars and Hospitallers, as well as the societal, architectural, and ceremonial transformations that occurred in the city.

Salah al-Din's victorious reclaiming and subsequent consecration of Jerusalem in the name of Islam.

The city's history reached a critical juncture in 1187 when Salah al-Din seized control, marking the end of the period ruled by the Crusaders. The meticulous documentation of Salah al-Din's rise to power, his expansion of territory, and his adept exploitation of the internal conflicts within the Crusader states is noteworthy. He details the events leading to the conquest, emphasizing the chaos within the ranks of the Crusader command and the skillful diplomatic and military tactics employed by Salah al-Din. After triumphing in the battle at Hattin, the sultan reclaimed Jerusalem, reinstating its Islamic essence and supervising its renewal. The writer contests the romanticized Western view that portrays Saladin as a chivalrous and dignified individual, outshining the barbarous Franks; yet, by the standards of his time, he confirms that Saladin justly acquires his admirable reputation due to his moderation, broad-mindedness, and devout character.

The city's capture by the Mamluks underscored its continued importance as a symbol of victory within the Islamic community.

Montefiore explores the Mamluk conquest in 1291, marking the end of the Crusader period and the beginning of a long stretch of Ottoman rule over Jerusalem. The Mamluks, a military slave-caste of Turkish origin that ruled Egypt, systematically captured the last strongholds of the Crusaders, culminating in the takeover of Acre, their last stronghold. The invasion led to the total elimination of the Eastern Latin Christian populace. The Mamluk regime, characterized by its strict governance and heavy tax burdens, assumed control of a Jerusalem that had diminished greatly in importance. The author emphasizes that the Mamluks, driven by their Sufi beliefs, highlighted their Islamic ties to the city, which resulted in the improvement of the Noble Sanctuary and the establishment of mosques and educational religious institutions. Concurrently, they curtailed the rights of Christians and Jews, restricted the repair of their holy sites, and subjected them to sporadic bouts of persecution. The Jewish community's yearning for Zion's return grew stronger in the face of severe restrictions.

Following its capture by the Ottomans, Jerusalem experienced a decline in its strategic significance.

Montefiore delves into the significant changes that occurred when the Ottoman Empire took control of Jerusalem in 1517. He chronicles how the Ottoman Empire extended its sway across the Middle East, adopting the caliphal mantle and incorporating Jerusalem into their domain, after inheriting the legacy of the Byzantine Empire and rising to power over the city now known as Istanbul. During the period of Ottoman rule, Jerusalem experienced a relatively peaceful era with a policy of tolerance, continuing the dhimmi status granted to both Jews and Christians. Jerusalem's importance diminished over time, transforming into a disregarded border town where Ottoman officials primarily focused on enriching themselves and their relatives through the imposition of taxes and fees on the religious communities there.

Napoleon's failed invasion and the resurgence of Western colonial aspirations.

Montefiore explores how Napoleon's unsuccessful attempt to conquer Jerusalem during his 1799 Egyptian campaign rekindled the West's interest in both the city and the wider Middle East. Napoleon's drive for grandeur, influenced by the exotic allure of the East, played as crucial a role in his quest to establish a French dominion in the Eastern Mediterranean and weaken Britain's influence there as did his tactical goals. The unsuccessful attempt to capture Acre not only underscored the enduring strength of the Ottoman Empire but also exposed its weaknesses. The incursion led by Napoleon, which received extensive coverage in European press and was celebrated in songs of that time, marked the beginning of a period in the nineteenth century characterized by increased colonial interest and activity by Western powers in the areas of Western Asia.

The city's development was markedly shaped by the British involvement that commenced during the Crimean War.

The narrative of the book emphasizes how European engagement in the affairs of the Middle East grew, particularly highlighting the significant role that Britain played in shaping Jerusalem's destiny. He elucidates that Britain's primary objective of restraining Russian expansion and protecting the Ottoman Empire unintentionally resulted in its involvement with the complex interplay between governance and the various religious factions in Jerusalem. The combination of intense religious passion and imperial strategic interests from Britain played a pivotal role in transforming Jerusalem. Montefiore recounts the story of Britain's engagement starting from the Crimean War, introducing a cast as diverse and vibrant as the history of Jerusalem itself, with characters such as the bold statesman Palmerston, the benevolent religious leader Shaftesbury, and the courageous Sir Moses Montefiore. Palmerston, the quintessential diplomat of the 19th century, known for his astute political acumen and wandering gaze, determined that the strategic enhancement of the Jewish community would best serve Britain's goals, thereby positioning Britain as the protector of Jerusalem's Jewish inhabitants. Shaftesbury, an ardent philanthropist, fervently encouraged the Jewish community to adopt Protestant values. In the 19th century, the British had a twofold goal that greatly shaped Jerusalem's evolution: they endeavored to deliver redemption to the Jewish populace and simultaneously attempted to alter their spiritual beliefs.

The competition between Britain and France for supremacy in Jerusalem and the wider Middle East.

Montefiore delves into the intensifying rivalry between Britain and France as they vied for dominance and sway over Jerusalem. The determination of Russia to protect the rights of its Orthodox citizens further intensified the historical conflict, already worsened by the ambitions of kings on crusades and Napoleon's pursuit of dominance. The principal nations pursued their goals by engaging in diplomacy, creating alliances, and providing support to the different Christian factions situated in the heart of Jerusalem. The emergence of Zionism as a global political force and its establishment as a nationalist entity in the region was a turning point, despite causing considerable unrest among the indigenous Arab populations. During the First World War, as Britain had a foothold in Egypt, a series of specific events and influential figures, along with the nation's strategic goal to control Palestine, enabled the convincing of British leaders by their Jewish partners and Protestant advocates that supporting the Jewish return to their ancestral land was justifiable on moral grounds and beneficial in terms of imperial strategy. Establishing a Jewish state under British guardianship was seen as a strategy to not only solidify backing from Jewish communities in Russia and the United States but also to curb Ottoman power and neutralize French ambitions of extending their sway over Jerusalem.

The issuance of the Balfour Declaration marked the rise of Political Zionism.

Montefiore documents the emergence of Zionism as a significant political movement, leading to a crucial juncture when, through the Balfour Declaration of 1917, the commitment was made to create a homeland for the Jewish population in Palestine. He examines the motivations of the key figures - Theodor Herzl, visionary founder of political Zionism; Chaim Weizmann, dashing Russian-Jewish chemist and skilled diplomat; David Lloyd George, the romantic Welsh Baptist prime minister; and Arthur Balfour, the frivolous foreign secretary who came to embrace the cause - as well as exploring the complex context of Jewish persecution in Eastern Europe and the growing global sympathy for Jewish return to Zion. Herzl believed that the creation of an independent nation for the Jewish people was essential for their freedom and safety, and he developed a contemporary, non-religious blueprint to gain backing from powerful bankers and nobility, such as the Rothschild family. The primary objective of the United Kingdom was to achieve triumph in the First World War. Lloyd George, influenced by the biblical narratives of his formative years and supported by other British leaders who held Jewish culture in high regard, found Weizmann's arguments compelling, believing that Britain, due to its 'Biblical' heritage, should support the Return as a morally just and strategically advantageous action. This would accelerate the coming of the Messianic age and ensure support from the American Jewish community, which was vital given the recent entry of the United States into the war and the possibility of Russia exiting the conflict.

During the British Mandate period, both Jewish and Arab populations were embroiled in intensifying conflicts, with the Arab community instigating a rebellion.

Montefiore examines the complexities of the British Mandate, explaining that distinct governance systems set up for Jewish and Arab communities contributed to the rise in tensions between the two groups. He delves into the surge of Jewish settlers moving into the area, their land purchases, the growing influence of Zionist organizations such as the Haganah, and the rise of Jewish paramilitary operations, including the group led by the future Prime Minister of Israel. He explores the reaction of Arab communities, their unease with the increasing prominence of Jews, and the emergence of a unique Palestinian identity. He emphasizes the succession of clashes, such as the 1929 turmoil over Jewish access to the Western Wall, the uprising led by Grand Mufti Amin al-Husseini, and the Zionist revolt against British governance, which collectively forced the British to abandon their mandate in Palestine. Montefiore emphasizes the pivotal influence of prominent individuals, pointing out that the inadequate and prejudiced decisions of British authorities not only intensified hostilities but also laid the groundwork for the calamity that befell the Palestinians and the transient victory of the Hashemite leader, dubbed 'the Hasty,' whose impetuous decisions resulted in his short-lived dominion over Jerusalem.

The founding of Israel, the division of Jerusalem, and the initiation of hostilities in 1948.

The narrative details the succession of pivotal events that led to the establishment of Israel in 1948, events which sparked the Arab-Israeli conflict and resulted in the division of Jerusalem. The Palestinian leadership rejected the United Nations' proposal for a state divided into separate parts, considering it unfeasible. Upon proclaiming its sovereignty, Israel was immediately attacked by the united armies of the surrounding Arab nations. The Jewish forces, despite being outnumbered, achieved a surprising victory that precipitated a catastrophic occurrence known as Nakba, which led to the Palestinian people experiencing widespread displacement and a forced exodus from their homes.

Montefiore suggests that the inevitable conflict arose due to the unwavering dedication of both Jewish and Arab communities to their own assertions of sovereignty over Jerusalem and the surrounding areas; he observes that although there were considerable divisions within Arab factions, the unity of the Israelis was solidified when Menachem Begin merged the Irgun with the IDF, which resulted in the Lehi faction being subdued. He offers an in-depth narrative of the fierce and chaotic conflicts that occurred around Jerusalem. Abdullah of Jordan took command of the Old City and then proceeded to annex the West Bank into his Hashemite Kingdom. Jerusalem was divided into distinct sectors, with a barbed wire line marking the separation. The Israeli Parliament assembled within the facilities of the Jewish Agency on King George V Avenue to announce the establishment of the State, an act that left Palestinians with profound resentment as their hopes were thwarted and the city eluded their control.

The Six Day War marked a crucial turning point that resulted in the unification of Jerusalem, highlighting its importance in the current political landscape of the Middle East.

Montefiore offers an in-depth examination of the military conflict in 1967, highlighting the Israeli forces' occupation of the primarily Arab East Jerusalem and their subsequent endeavors to unify the city. The expansion of territory and rise to a key role in Middle Eastern geopolitics for Israel stemmed from a remarkable victory against Jordan and Syria. The belief that Jerusalem would always be a unified city had become firmly entrenched in the hearts of Israelis and Jews worldwide. The author highlights that Moshe Dayan, serving as Israel's Defence Minister, implemented a policy designed to alleviate the worries of the Arab community about the holy site, by permitting the Muslim Waqf to manage the Temple Mount and simultaneously banning Jewish religious activities there.

Over time, the Israeli desire to perform religious rituals at the Temple Mount faced increasing opposition, with Palestinians fearing that these actions could indicate intentions to reconstruct the historic Temple. The status of Jerusalem has evolved throughout history, influenced by conflict and the determined actions of key individuals, with the Six Day War representing another critical juncture. This event, which the author details with clarity, also spelled disaster for Jordan's youthful monarch, King Hussein. Despite Dayan's repeated cautions against getting involved in the skirmish with Egypt, King Hussein felt compelled to participate to prevent alienation from his Arab counterparts, a choice that led to the forfeiture of his portion of the revered city. The king was deeply troubled by the realization that he no longer held sway over Jerusalem during his reign.

The persistent struggle between Israelis and Palestinians highlights how Jerusalem is fundamentally pivotal in terms of geopolitical, spiritual, and enigmatic influence.

Montefiore explores the elements that maintain Jerusalem's consistent position at the heart of the Israeli-Palestinian dispute. He examines the methods by which Israel strengthens its grip on the city through the construction of Jewish neighborhoods and the restriction of Palestinian access, while also delving into the Palestinian endeavors to establish their presence in East Jerusalem with the goal of proclaiming it their capital, Al-Quds. The collapse of peace talks and the escalation of conflict among the factions are detailed, alongside a recognition of moments when leaders from the conflicting parties made efforts to find common ground.

The account by Simon Sebag Montefiore extends to the onset of the 21st century. He emphasizes that major global events, such as the rise of Islamic extremism after 1979 in Iran and the September 11th horrors, alerted the United States to the parallels between its own struggle with militant Islamic groups and Israel's ongoing fight against terrorist assaults carried out by various Arab organizations, leading President George W. Bush to commence the ill-advised military campaign in Iraq.

Montefiore chronicles the evolution of the Jewish populace and the shifting global power dynamics that continue to shape Jerusalem's future, consistent with historical trends. Russia is reasserting its traditional role as the guardian of Eastern Christianity and is making efforts to establish itself as the preeminent power in the Middle East as the influence of the United States wanes. China has surfaced as a new actor in the spheres of diplomacy and development in this region. He illustrates that the persistent barrier to achieving agreements such as the Oslo and Camp David accords stems from the joint reluctance of both sides to engage in discussions concerning the future of Jerusalem.

He also traces the evolution of Yasser Arafat, often compared to a contemporary leader reminiscent of the historical figure at the forefront of the PLO, who transitioned from a notorious hijacker to a symbolic representative of the Palestinian pursuit of self-governance during the Intifada.

Montefiore sheds light on the complex endeavors to address the sensitive matter of the region Jews refer to as the Temple Mount, highlighting the way various groups employ archaeological discoveries to support their frequently divergent assertions regarding the city's history.

Montefiore contends that the future of Jerusalem remains uncertain. However, he argues that the most viable route to harmony could involve the establishment of two sovereign nations, with the stewardship of the city's ancient heart possibly managed by international entities. While acknowledging the deep spiritual and emotional connections that Israelis and Palestinians share with the city, he underscores the necessity of psychological compromise: only by recognizing and respecting each other's historical and religious claims, can a harmonious and equitable resolution in Jerusalem come to fruition through the celebration of their cherished narratives and customs.

Practical Tips

• You can deepen your understanding of Jerusalem's historical significance by creating a visual timeline. Start by researching key events mentioned, such as the siege by Nebuchadnezzar or the Six Day War, and plot them on a timeline. Use online tools or a simple poster board to visually represent how these events have shaped Jerusalem's history. This will help you grasp the chronological flow of the city's complex past and its impact on the present.
• Explore the diverse spiritual heritage of Jerusalem by reading texts from Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. Select passages that reference Jerusalem, such as Psalms from the Hebrew Bible, the Gospels in the New Testament, and the Night Journey in the Quran. Reflect on how each religion views the city and consider writing a comparative analysis or journal entry about your findings to appreciate the shared and unique aspects of its spiritual significance.
• Engage with the cultural fusion of Jerusalem by trying out recipes that reflect its diverse history. Look for traditional dishes that have been influenced by the various cultures that have ruled or lived in Jerusalem, such as Jewish, Christian, Muslim, and Armenian cuisines. Cooking these dishes will give you a taste of the city's rich cultural tapestry and the way historical events have influenced its culinary traditions.

Jerusalem's multifaceted nature encompasses cultural, spiritual, and enigmatic elements.

The narrative explores how the holiness of Jerusalem is reflected through different cultural forms such as literature and mysticism, highlighting how biblical stories shape its image and the attempts by various faiths to engage with its spiritual core by means of mystical practices and veneration of holy relics. Montefiore underscores the significant influence that unwavering faith in scriptural predictions, the veneration of altruistic deeds, and the expectation of a cataclysmic finale have played in igniting historical conflicts that are both religious and political in nature.

The significant impact that holy texts have exerted on Jerusalem.

The book delves into the significant influence that the Bible, a holy scripture revered in both Judaism and Christianity, has had on the destiny and perception of Jerusalem. The writer explores the manner in which biblical stories, predictions, and rich imagery have cemented Jerusalem's unique position in the annals of world history. The focus is on the enduring influence that the texts have exerted on the perception of Jerusalem, spanning from their inception to the modern era.

The narratives held in its holy scriptures profoundly influenced the city's destiny.

Montefiore suggests that holy scriptures provide a chronological narrative concerning Jerusalem, highlighting its deep and lyrical connections with the Jewish people, starting from King David's time and continuing through to the Babylonian captivity. The Scriptures, crafted by numerous unnamed writers who honed their texts across different periods, are not primarily designed to chronicle historical events. Understanding the profound significance of Jerusalem requires recognizing that its historical importance and continued influence are shaped by the stories recorded in this book. The meticulous documentation of the Temple's sacrificial ceremonies has been crucial in preserving the recollection of the Temple, which no longer stands. The design it offered fueled the Jewish people's hopes for reconstructing the Temple and creating an independent nation within Jerusalem, thereby keeping alive their desire to return to Zion.

Furthermore, the spread of Christianity across the Roman Empire and its eventual expansion to Europe, America, and other regions, coupled with the deep veneration for the scriptures found in Protestantism and evangelicalism, has not only heightened the status of the Bible but also significantly enhanced the stature of Jerusalem, establishing both as universally esteemed holy scripture and city, honored by many countries and various faiths. As a result, the desire to fulfill its prophecies and prophecies of its own prophecies, and to recover the treasures and relics recounted in the Bible, has motivated many an event in the history of the city from the construction of new Jewish and Christian Temples, via the Crusades and to Monty Parker's 'Ark of the Covenant' escapade.

In the era of Solomon's reign, the scriptures depicted the city as an exemplar of flawlessness.

Simon Sebag Montefiore portrays the creators of the biblical scriptures, who crafted their texts long after Solomon's time, as presenting his Jerusalem as a magnificent city symbolizing a kingdom favored by the divine. The writer aimed to inspire his contemporaries who were confronting the unyielding growth of the Assyrian and Babylonian empires by presenting an impressive historical example. From then on, the image of Solomon's Temple in the scriptures, shining atop a grand rise and embellished with precious metals, established the benchmark for subsequent conceptions of the city. The specifics may not correspond with the historical accounts, but they significantly influenced the beliefs of Christians and Jews alike.

Every envisioned portrayal of Jerusalem, from the hopes of Jewish rebels seeking a fresh beginning while opposing Roman rule to the seventeenth-century English pilgrims escaping religious persecution to create their 'city on a hill,' has consciously or unconsciously sought to mirror the metropolis founded by Solomon. Contemporary audiences might view the depiction of Solomon's reign in the Bible as a validation of absolute theocratic governance. Its interpretation, however, may vary. The Holy Scriptures convey a message that is both unambiguous and specific. Solomon, for all his wisdom, wealth and power - he had everything - still made mistakes! Like all individuals, he possessed his own set of flaws. Ultimately, Solomon's fate was shaped by divine influences, underscoring the moral lessons inherent within his narrative. Every ruler and individual who has aspired to control Jerusalem or impose their personal ideals on the city should take note of this lesson.

The lyrical and expressive portrayals of Jerusalem are vividly depicted in Lamentations, Isaiah, and other biblical texts, in addition to the poetic verses found in the Book of Psalms.

Montefiore explores the deep symbolic meanings present in various sacred writings, including the Psalms and Isaiah, which collectively forge the distinctive spirit of Jerusalem. He underscores that these texts not only encapsulate Jerusalem's visual charm but also its deep holiness, often employing personification to portray the metropolis as a beloved feminine figure who has occasionally been failed. The Psalmists praised Zion, referring to it as the mountain hallowed by God. Isaiah, who served as a prince, priest, and political advisor during a time when the Assyrian influence was expanding, envisioned Jerusalem as a worldwide spiritual center, elevated on the mountains to serve as a guiding light where "all nations shall flow to it," an idea that holds significance for followers of Judaism and Christianity alike.

The city, likened to a 'widow' in the Lamentations following its devastation by the Babylonian conquest, encapsulated a profound sense of mourning that stirred among Jews and subsequently Christians the aspiration for renewal and the anticipation of a Messiah's arrival. The city's story was profoundly shaped by sacred texts that instilled enduring principles regarding the divine and humanity. From the earliest adherents of the Christian faith to prominent modern Israeli authors and political leaders, people have found ongoing inspiration and connection with these ancient stories.

Other Perspectives

• The interpretation of Jerusalem's holiness through cultural forms may not be universally accepted, as different cultures and faiths may have varying perspectives on what constitutes holiness.
• The role of biblical stories in shaping Jerusalem's image could be seen as one of many factors, with geopolitical and historical events also playing a significant role.
• The assertion that unwavering faith in scriptural predictions ignites historical conflicts might overlook other causes of conflict, such as economic, social, or territorial disputes.
• The impact of holy texts on Jerusalem's destiny could be challenged by secular historians who might emphasize the influence of political and military power dynamics over religious texts.
• The idea that biblical stories and predictions have cemented Jerusalem's unique position in history could be contested by those who believe that the city's strategic location and political significance are equally important.
• The narrative connecting Jerusalem with the Jewish people through holy scriptures may not acknowledge the city's significance to other religions and cultures, such as Islam and Christianity, in equal measure.
• The notion that the Bible's documentation of the Temple's ceremonies fuels hopes for its reconstruction might not resonate with those who prioritize a secular or multicultural vision for Jerusalem's future.
• The spread of Christianity and its veneration for scriptures might be seen as just one aspect of Jerusalem's enhanced stature, with others pointing to the city's historical and political developments.
• The depiction of Solomon's reign as flawless could be criticized for potentially glossing over historical complexities and the realities of ancient governance.
• The portrayal of Jerusalem in sacred writings as a feminine figure might be interpreted differently in contemporary feminist or gender studies, which could offer alternative readings of these texts.
• The idea that sacred texts instill enduring principles regarding the divine and humanity might be challenged by those who argue for a more humanistic or secular understanding of ethics and morality.
• The manifestation of Jerusalem's spiritual importance in rituals and respect for personalities might not account for the diverse ways in which people of different faiths or no faith at all may experience and value the city.