PDF Summary:How Charts Lie, by Alberto Cairo

Modern data visualizations, from charts and graphs to maps and diagrams, shape how people perceive information and form beliefs—yet they also have the capacity to spread misinformation and reinforce biases if not designed thoughtfully. In How Charts Lie, Alberto Cairo examines the power and responsibilities of data visualizers. He details common visualization distortions, explains how to balance aesthetics and functionality, and emphasizes the need for transparency about information sources and their limitations.

Cairo offers guidance on upholding ethics when working with data, ensuring visualizations are accurate and engaging but not manipulative. By considering factors like human cognition, he aims to help chart designers foster an informed public discourse, empowering audiences to critically analyze these influential visualizations rather than falling victim to misleading ones.

(continued)...

Cairo argues that designers must anticipate how visually literate their audience is and adjust their decisions about design accordingly. Clear labeling, legends, and annotations, along with careful consideration of encoding methods and the chart's overall layout, are essential for creating visualizations that can be read and understood correctly by a wide audience.

Other Perspectives

• Some might argue that the effectiveness of a chart is more dependent on the clarity of the data and the story it tells, rather than on adherence to a specific set of symbolic or textual rules.
• Misreading can also result from cognitive overload, where a chart is well-designed according to grammar and semantics, but the amount of information is too much for the reader to process effectively.
• Some individuals may have an innate or learned aptitude for pattern recognition and can intuitively grasp the structure of complex visualizations, including parallel coordinates plots, without prior familiarity.
• The use of connecting lines in scatter plots can actually aid in the interpretation by guiding the viewer's eye and helping to clarify the direction of relationships between data points.
• In some cases, cognitive frameworks may be less about aiding or hindering interpretation and more about providing a necessary foundation for any interpretation to occur at all.
• Fixed conceptions can serve as a foundation for learning, where deviations from the norm are seen as advanced concepts to be understood only after mastering the basics.
• There may be a diverse audience with varying levels of visual literacy, making it challenging to design a one-size-fits-all visualization.
• In interactive visualizations, static labels and legends may be less necessary as users can explore data points directly to get the information they need.
• Overemphasis on encoding methods and layout could lead to an overly simplistic or reductionist design that fails to convey the nuances of complex data.

Principles and Practices for Effective Data Visualizations

This section goes beyond pointing out misleading elements to outlining best practices. Cairo stresses balancing informational accuracy with engaging design, emphasizing accessibility for wider audiences.

Data Visualization: Understanding Human Perception and Reasoning Limits

Cairo argues that effective ways of visually presenting data must account for human perception and reasoning limitations. Our brains tend to seek patterns, make assumptions, and draw hasty inferences before fully analyzing information. This inherent bias can lead to misinterpretations even when data is accurately depicted visually.

Graphs Must Aid, Not Mislead, Audience Cognition

Cairo emphasizes that effectively created charts should aid, not mislead, our cognition. This requires a nuanced understanding of how humans process images and the potential pitfalls that can arise from these processes. For example, our innate tendency to perceive order even in random data might cause us to see spurious correlations and draw misleading connections where none exist.

Designers can mitigate these pitfalls by carefully selecting encoding methods, scales, and framing. Clear labeling, annotations, and supplementary information can guide viewers toward more precise interpretation. However, Cairo acknowledges that perfect objectivity is unattainable, and every visualization involves a degree of subjective decision-making connected to the creator's intent and the target audience.

Practical Tips

• Enhance your presentations by incorporating feedback on your chart designs. Next time you create a chart for a report or presentation, show it to a small group of peers or friends first. Ask them specific questions about their understanding and interpretation of the chart. Use their feedback to make adjustments that aim to eliminate confusion and improve cognitive aid.
• Experiment with creating photo stories using only your smartphone to better grasp the narrative power of visual sequences. Choose a theme or event, like a day in your life or a nature walk, and capture images that tell a story from beginning to end. Pay attention to how the order of images affects the story's flow and the emotions it conveys. Share these stories with friends or on social media to get feedback on how others interpret your visual narrative.
• You can challenge your pattern recognition by keeping a "randomness journal" where you note down events or observations that seem connected and review them later to see if they truly correlate. This practice will help you identify instances where you may be perceiving false patterns. For example, if you notice that you always seem to find a parking spot after playing a certain song, write it down and check over time if the pattern holds true or if it's just a coincidence.
• You can sharpen your critical thinking by playing the "Correlation or Causation?" game with daily news articles. When you read a news piece that suggests a link between two variables, take a moment to jot down alternative explanations for the correlation. For example, if an article claims that people who drink more coffee tend to live longer, consider other factors that might contribute to longevity, such as overall diet, exercise habits, or socioeconomic status.
• Improve your home's functionality by labeling storage containers with icons instead of words. For example, use a simple shoe icon for the box where you keep your footwear or a book icon for your reading materials. This visual encoding method can help you and others quickly identify contents without reading labels, making organization more intuitive.
• Develop a personal filing system for important documents with a clear index and color-coded tabs. This can help you quickly locate financial records, medical documents, or personal identification when needed. For instance, use yellow tabs for tax documents, blue for medical records, and red for personal IDs.
• You can embrace subjectivity by creating a visual journal where you document your daily experiences using sketches, colors, and symbols that resonate with you personally. This practice acknowledges that your representation of reality is filtered through your perceptions and biases, making you more aware of how subjectivity shapes your view of the world.
• Use a mood board to influence your visualization choices by collecting images, colors, and designs that resonate with your current emotional state or the message you want to convey. This can help you understand how your subjective feelings translate into visual elements. For example, if you're feeling energetic and bold, you might gravitate towards bright colors and dynamic shapes, which could then inform the design of a presentation or infographic.
• Enhance your blog posts by incorporating visuals that reflect the interests of your readers. Use free online tools like Canva or Piktochart to create infographics or visuals that align with the topics you're discussing. If your blog is about gardening, for instance, create a visual step-by-step guide on planting a seed, tailored to the novice gardener.

Balancing Scientific Rigor, Art, and Ethics in Visualizing Data

Cairo argues that creating visualizations for the public requires balancing scientific rigor, artistic sensibilities, and ethical considerations. To be effective, charts must accurately display data, have engaging designs, and be mindful of the potential consequences on viewers.

Thoughtful Encoding Choices, Communicating Color and Sizing Usage, Context, and Unknowns

Cairo offers guidance on how to balance these considerations by making thoughtful encoding choices that are appropriate to the type of data and the message the chart intends to convey. He emphasizes the importance of using color and size thoughtfully, avoiding manipulations that might exaggerate or downplay trends. He also stresses the need to provide enough context and information for viewers to understand not just what the visual depicts but also what it doesn't depict, including unavoidable uncertainties.

Cairo encourages designers to strive for a clarity that is both visually appealing and informative, avoiding gratuitous beautification or aesthetic choices that potentially obscure or misrepresent the underlying data. Ultimately, Cairo believes that ethical data presentation fosters understanding and empowers viewers to make informed decisions and engage in meaningful debate.

Practical Tips

• Improve your social media posts by applying thoughtful data encoding to increase engagement. Before posting, think about what data or statistics you want to share and how they relate to your message. Use an online infographic maker like Canva to turn your data into an eye-catching graphic. For example, if you're sharing fitness progress, instead of just stating the numbers, create a visual graph that shows your improvement over weeks or months.
• Volunteer to create a presentation for a local community group or club, focusing on a topic like fundraising results or membership growth. Apply restraint in your use of color and size to ensure the data's integrity. For instance, if you're showing annual growth, use a single color with varying shades to represent different years, and keep the scale of your graphs proportional to the actual changes in data to avoid misleading viewers.
• Implement a 'one-week clarity challenge' where for each day, you take a piece of visual information that you find confusing or cluttered, such as a bill, a product label, or a website, and sketch out a clearer version. Focus on stripping away unnecessary elements and highlighting the essential information. This daily exercise will train you to identify and eliminate superfluous design elements, fostering a habit of creating clarity-focused designs.

How Data Visualizations Shape Perceptions and the Need For Transparency About Limitations and Uncertainty

This section addresses the broader societal impact of visualizing data, focusing on how visualizations can subtly shape beliefs and reinforcing the need for transparency.

Charts Shape Beliefs About Presented Information

Cairo argues that visual representations can powerfully shape beliefs about information, emphasizing the human tendency to favor visualizations that confirm prior opinions. This section explores the susceptibility of viewers to visual manipulation and the critical role of source transparency in mitigating these risks.

Designers Must Know Cognitive Biases That Make People Accept or Distort Visualizations Uncritically

Cairo delves into how cognitive biases such as motivated reasoning, confirmation bias, and the desire for cognitive consistency influence how people interpret charts. Viewers are likelier to accept easily digestible visualizations that align with their existing worldviews, even if these visualizations oversimplify, distort, or omit crucial information. Designers, he argues, must be aware of these biases and strive to create visualizations that promote critical thinking, prompting viewers to question assumptions and analyze data thoughtfully.

The author encourages designers to consider the ethical implications of their choices, recognizing that visualizations, despite their appearance of being objective, are often subjective representations shaped by the creator's intent and choices. By understanding how cognitive biases shape perception and encouraging critical engagement with data, Cairo argues that designers can create visualizations that facilitate more informed and nuanced discourse.

Practical Tips

• You can challenge your own design assumptions by swapping projects with a colleague for feedback. By having someone else review your work, you'll get fresh perspectives that can highlight your cognitive biases. For example, if you're designing a website, let a colleague from a different department use it and ask for their honest impressions. Their feedback might reveal if you've been unconsciously favoring certain design elements that align with your own preferences rather than user needs.
• Challenge your own beliefs by creating a 'Belief Map' where you visually represent your current beliefs and the evidence that supports them. Start by drawing a simple chart with two columns: one for beliefs and one for supporting evidence. For each belief, actively seek out and note down visualizations or data that contradict your current understanding. This exercise will help you to recognize when you're favoring information that confirms what you already think and encourage you to consider alternative perspectives.
• Implement a "Reverse Engineering" day once a month where you pick a device or system you use regularly and map out its design on paper, then brainstorm ways it could be misleading or improved. For instance, take apart a mechanical clock and consider how its design influences your perception of time, or map out the interface of a social media platform and discuss how it might manipulate user behavior. This activity pushes you to dissect how design shapes understanding and to think of ways it could be redesigned for clarity and honesty.
• Use a random image generator to challenge your interpretation skills. Find an online tool that generates random abstract images, and spend a few minutes each day interpreting what you see. Write down your thoughts and consider how your current mood, experiences, and intentions might be influencing your interpretation. This exercise can help you become more aware of the subjective nature of visual perception.
• Develop a habit of seeking diverse feedback on your visualizations to uncover potential ethical blind spots. Reach out to individuals from different backgrounds and ask for their perspectives on your designs. This could be as simple as showing your work to a friend from a different field or posting it on a forum with a diverse user base. Pay attention to whether your design might inadvertently mislead or exclude certain groups and adjust accordingly.

Disclosing Data Sources Is Vital for Informed Discourse

Cairo reiterates the importance of data source transparency for fostering informed discourse. This section explores the potential dangers of incomplete or inaccurate data and the ethical obligation for those who make charts to be honest about data limitations and uncertainties.

Visualizations Should Convey Data Certainty, Biases, and Qualifications

Cairo emphasizes the need to clearly communicate data certainty levels, potential biases, and any relevant qualifications, empowering viewers to critically assess the details shown. Omitting or downplaying uncertainty can make data seem more precise than reality, potentially misleading viewers into accepting claims that are less definitive than they appear.

Cairo argues that designers need to aim for an equilibrium between simplification and completeness in their visualizations, avoiding both oversimplification that misrepresents the underlying data and overwhelming complexity that inhibits understanding. By acknowledging data uncertainty and providing contextual information, Cairo encourages designers to create visualizations that are both accurate and informative while empowering audiences to engage in meaningful debate and make informed decisions.

Practical Tips

• When posting on social media about topics that involve data, such as political opinions or product reviews, use a simple visual cue system to indicate the certainty of your information. For example, use a green checkmark for data you're confident in, a yellow question mark for data you're somewhat sure about, and a red exclamation mark for data you're uncertain of. Accompany these symbols with a brief explanation, like "green checkmark: based on three different sources," to foster a culture of data literacy and responsibility among your followers.
• Develop a habit of asking "What's the evidence?" whenever you encounter a claim, whether in conversation, advertising, or social media. This encourages a mindset that looks for the substantiation behind assertions. If someone tells you a certain product will improve your life dramatically, probe for studies, user testimonials, or data that back up this claim.
• You can refine your visual storytelling by creating a dual-layer infographic. Start with a basic layer that anyone can understand at a glance, then add an optional interactive element, like a hover-over or click-to-expand feature, that reveals more detailed information for those who want to delve deeper. This approach respects the viewer's time and interest level while providing a gateway to more complex data for those who seek it.
• Use a two-column approach when taking notes to balance simplicity and complexity. On one side, jot down simplified bullet points of the information you're processing. On the other, note any questions or complexities that arise. This method encourages you to distill information to its essence while also acknowledging areas that require deeper understanding. For example, if you're reading about a historical event, the left column could contain key dates and figures, while the right could list the economic, social, and political nuances that influenced the event.
• Start a data journal where you track personal metrics, such as fitness or budgeting, and note down the factors that could affect these measurements. For example, if you're tracking your daily steps, also record variables like weather or mood that might impact your activity level. Over time, this will give you a personal understanding of how context influences data, and you can use this insight to make better decisions based on your metrics.
• Create a "Decision Deck" of cards, each featuring a common logical fallacy or cognitive bias. Use this deck to play a game with friends or family where you discuss a topic and identify instances of these fallacies or biases in each other's arguments. This game will help you and your peers become more aware of the pitfalls in reasoning that can lead to uninformed decisions. For instance, if someone uses an ad hominem attack during a debate on education reform, you could play the corresponding card to highlight the fallacy.