PDF Summary:Giving Up the Ghost, by Hilary Mantel

From a traumatic childhood in an impoverished village, to battling chronic pain and dismissive doctors, to finding solace in storytelling, Hilary Mantel's memoir Giving Up the Ghost offers an intimate look at the experiences that shaped her worldview and perspective.

Mantel reflects candidly on her difficult upbringing in a bleak English community, the haunting supernatural encounter that left a lasting impact, and her struggles to reconcile her ambition with her working-class family's expectations. She charts her lifelong battle with mysterious physical afflictions and the frustrations endured due to misdiagnoses and inadequate psychiatric treatment. Throughout, Mantel explores how writing became a means of processing her suffering, piecing together fragmented family narratives, and developing a nuanced understanding of health and the imperfect human body.

(continued)...

• The role of a grandfather can be pivotal in a child's life, offering a different perspective and wisdom gained from a lifetime of experiences.
• This term often refers to a person who exudes calmness and resilience, offering support and wisdom without needing to be overtly assertive or dominant.
• The intricate family dynamics described may have influenced Mantel's interest in historical narratives and character-driven stories, as she often explores the interplay of personal and historical forces in her novels.

Clashes Between Author's Ambition and Family's Expectations

As Mantel matures, her intellectual curiosity and ambition clash with her relatives' limited expectations. Her passion for stories, her fascination with history, and her desire to pursue a professional career are met with skepticism and a lack of comprehension. Her grandparents, while supportive, are steeped in the traditional values of their working-class background, where education beyond the basics is seen as unnecessary and ambition beyond one's station is viewed with suspicion. Mantel's mom, burdened by unfulfilled aspirations of her own, seems both envious and resentful of her child's intellectual pursuits. Jack, focused on providing for the family,dismisses Mantel's interests as frivolous and impractical. The author recounts, with a mix of humor and pain, how Jack predicted she'd end up in a lab job if her math skills didn't improve, highlighting his limited vision for her future. This clash between ambition and expectation contributes to Mantel's sense of alienation and her determination to forge her own path, regardless of familial pressures.

Context

• In many working-class communities, there was a strong emphasis on practical skills and immediate employment, rather than academic or intellectual endeavors.
• Economic constraints often meant that any pursuit not directly linked to financial gain was viewed with skepticism, as families prioritized immediate economic survival.
• There was a cultural expectation that individuals should not aspire beyond their social class, which could lead to discouragement of ambitions perceived as unrealistic or overly ambitious.
• The grandparents' support could manifest in providing emotional or financial stability, allowing Mantel the freedom to explore her interests, even if they don't fully understand or agree with them.
• For women, in particular, there was an expectation to prioritize domestic roles over professional ambitions, which further influenced perceptions of the necessity of education beyond basic schooling.
• Older generations, having lived through different economic and social conditions, might have a more conservative view on ambition, valuing security over risk-taking.
• The mother's envy and resentment could stem from a mix of pride in her daughter's abilities and a reflection on her own unfulfilled potential, creating an emotional conflict.
• Jack's views could reflect a generational mindset where traditional jobs were valued over creative or academic pursuits, which were often seen as less reliable.
• Prevailing gender roles of the era often limited women's career options, which might have contributed to Jack's narrow vision for Mantel's future.
• Access to higher education was expanding, but for working-class families, it was still a significant financial and cultural leap, often seen as unnecessary or unattainable.
• The pressure to conform to family expectations can lead to feelings of isolation and drive a stronger desire for independence, as individuals seek to assert their identity and pursue personal goals.

Storytelling and Family History's Role in Identity

Mantel's fascination with storytelling is deeply intertwined with her exploration of familial background. She sees stories, both fictional and familial, as a means of making sense of the past, of piecing together fragmented narratives, and of connecting with her roots.

Family Mementos: Cherished Links to Bygone Times

Family mementos, such as photographs, old books, and other objects imbued with personal significance, become cherished links to the past for Mantel. She describes how these objects evoke powerful memories and offer tangible connections to her family history, providing a sense of continuity and belonging. These mementos become more than just objects; they represent the stories and experiences that have shaped her life and identity. Mantel recounts the discovery of her cousin Beryl's old history book among Jack's belongings, packed away years before. She pores over the book, noting its annotations and the faded inscription on the inner cover, feeling a visceral connection to her family's past through this tangible artifact. These mementos serve as anchors to her past, reminding her of the individuals and what has shaped her worldview and her sense of self.

Context

• For many, these objects are integral to personal identity, as they embody the experiences and values that have influenced their development and worldview.
• Objects from the past can offer a glimpse into the historical period they originate from, providing context about the social, economic, and political environment of the time.
• They can facilitate conversations between generations, providing a tangible way to share stories and experiences with younger family members.
• The act of finding and examining a relative's possessions can symbolize the ongoing influence of past generations on one's identity and values.
• Annotations and inscriptions can help verify the authenticity and provenance of an object, confirming its origins and the identity of its previous owners.
• Mementos can help individuals construct personal narratives, offering tangible evidence of life events and milestones that contribute to their life story.

Piecing Together Fragmented Family Narratives Through Writing

Mantel's passion for writing is fueled by a desire to piece together the fragmented stories of her familial past. She sees writing as a method for exploring the untold stories, the silences, and the contradictions that shape familial relationships. Through writing, she attempts to make sense of the past, to understand the motivations and the experiences of those who came before her, and to create a coherent narrative from the often-disparate fragments of her family's past. Mantel describes her persistent attempts to understand the reasons behind her grandfather's heroism in World War I, why he never spoke about the comrade he saved, and why no stories about that pivotal event appear to survive within her family. This desire to unearth and reinterpret family narratives through writing is a driving force behind her memoir, highlighting how the act of writing can become a powerful tool for self-discovery and for connecting with one's roots.

Other Perspectives

• Others might contend that focusing on piecing together a family's past could overshadow the importance of creating and valuing new stories and experiences in the present.
• While writing can be a method to explore and understand the past, it is inherently limited by the writer's perspective and the availability of accurate historical information.
• The process of selecting which fragments to include in a narrative can introduce bias, as the writer may unconsciously prioritize certain stories or interpretations over others.
• The idea that no stories survive could be challenged by the existence of public records, military documents, or other historical archives that Mantel may not have accessed or considered.
• The process of writing a memoir, while it can certainly involve connecting with one's roots, might also be driven by the need to tell one's own story, which could be independent of family narratives.
• In some cases, the pursuit of self-discovery through writing can become a self-absorbed endeavor, detracting from the communal and relational aspects of understanding one's family and heritage.

The Author's Chronic Health Struggles, Diagnoses, and Treatment

Mantel's memoir is a powerful and candid exploration of her lifelong struggle with enduring pain and disease. She details the mysterious physical afflictions that plagued her from an early age, the frustration she endured due to misdiagnoses and dismissive medical attitudes, and the traumatic experiences she had with psychiatric treatment and medication.

Mysterious Physical Afflictions That Defy Medical Understanding

From childhood, Mantel experienced a range of physical ailments that defied easy medical explanation. She describes these symptoms as a constant presence in her life, impacting her ability to function and causing her significant distress.

Symptoms of Migraines, Joint Pain, and Other Conditions

Mantel's memoir details the debilitating symptoms she experienced throughout her life, including migraines, joint pain, nausea, and exhaustion. These symptoms often manifested in unpredictable ways, sometimes appearing in clusters and other times lingering for extended periods. The author recounts how her migraines often included visual disturbances, making it difficult to focus or read. She describes the joint pain as a persistent ache that made walking or standing for extended periods difficult. The unpredictable nature of her symptoms and the lack of a clear diagnosis added to her anxiety and frustration, making it even harder to cope with the physical discomfort.

Practical Tips

• Engage in low-impact exercise to improve overall well-being. Start with gentle activities like walking, swimming, or yoga, which can help increase your energy levels and reduce pain without putting too much strain on your joints. Consistent, moderate exercise can boost your mood and help manage physical symptoms.
• Adjust your reading environment to reduce visual strain by using soft, indirect lighting and anti-glare screens for digital devices. This can help minimize the impact of visual disturbances on your ability to focus and read. For example, place a lamp behind you when reading a book or use a monitor filter that reduces glare and blue light when working on a computer.
• You can alleviate joint pain by incorporating anti-inflammatory foods into your diet, such as turmeric, ginger, and omega-3 rich fish. These foods contain natural compounds that may reduce inflammation and joint pain, making daily activities like walking or standing more comfortable.

Frustration With Doctors' Dismissive Attitudes and Misdiagnosis

Mantel's frustration with the healthcare field is a recurring theme in her memoir. She recounts how her symptoms were often dismissed by doctors, who attributed them to stress, anxiety, or simply her gender. This dismissive attitude, combined with repeated misdiagnoses, deepened her sense of isolation and reinforced her distrust of medical authority. Mantel describes how, as a teenager, she was repeatedly told that her "period pains" would clear up after she had a baby and how, as an adult, her chronic pain was attributed to "scar tissue" or a vivid imagination. She highlights the tendency of doctors to prioritize physical examinations over listening to the patient's lived experience, contributing to her feeling of being unheard and invalidated.

Practical Tips

• Seek a second opinion from another healthcare professional if you feel uncertain about a diagnosis. Having another expert review your case can provide a fresh perspective or confirm the initial assessment. To do this, gather all your medical records and share your health journal to give the new doctor a full understanding of your situation.
• Engage in peer support groups to share experiences and gather diverse perspectives on managing health issues. Look for local or online groups focused on your specific health concerns and participate actively. Sharing stories and solutions with others who have similar experiences can provide emotional support and practical advice that might not be covered in a typical medical consultation.
• Experiment with creative expression as a form of pain management. Engage in activities like painting, writing, or playing music to see if channeling your focus into a creative outlet can alleviate your perception of pain. This could help you determine if part of your pain is influenced by psychological factors, as creative expression is known to be therapeutic.
• Create a personal health journal to document symptoms, treatments, and interactions with healthcare providers. By keeping a detailed record, you can ensure that you have all the necessary information at hand during medical appointments. This can help you articulate your concerns more effectively and provide evidence if you feel your concerns are being dismissed.

Traumatic Experiences With Psychiatric Treatment and Medication

Mantel's experience with psychiatric treatment and medication is particularly harrowing. She describes being misdiagnosed with mental illness, prescribed powerful drugs that caused debilitating side effects, and labeled as "difficult" or "delusional" when she questioned the diagnosis or expressed her discomfort with the prescribed course.

Misdiagnosis of Mental Illness and Struggling With Psychiatric Drug Reactions

Mantel recounts how her ongoing pain and other physical symptoms were misattributed to mental illness, leading to a cascade of misdiagnoses and inappropriate treatments. She describes being prescribed antidepressants and tranquilizers that not only failed to address her underlying physical problems but also caused debilitating side effects, including blurred vision, akathisia (a state of intense restlessness and anxiety), and disturbing thoughts. She vividly describes the experience of akathisia as a "killing fear" that compelled her to move constantly and made her feel confined in a state of unrelenting panic. Mantel highlights how the medications' side effects mimicked the signs of mental illness, further confounding the diagnosis and deepening her sense of confusion and hopelessness.

Practical Tips

• Engage in mindfulness or relaxation techniques if you experience disturbing thoughts as a side effect. Practices like guided meditation, deep breathing exercises, or progressive muscle relaxation can help manage these thoughts and reduce their impact on your daily life.
• Create a calm environment in your living space to counteract feelings of panic. Introduce elements like soothing colors, comfortable seating, and plants to promote relaxation. Play ambient sounds or calming music to help stabilize your mood during times of anxiety.
• Schedule regular consultations with a pharmacist. Pharmacists are trained in understanding medication side effects and can offer valuable insights. By discussing your medications with a pharmacist, you can get a professional perspective on whether your symptoms may be medication-related.

Other Perspectives

• The side effects experienced from medication can vary widely from person to person, and many individuals use these medications successfully with manageable or minimal side effects.

Impact of "Medicalization" and Loss of Bodily Autonomy

Mantel's experience with psychiatric treatment highlights the negative impact of "medicalization" - the tendency to view all human experiences, including emotional distress, through the lens of medical diagnosis and treatment. She argues that this approach often fails to address the underlying social, economic, and personal factors that contribute to suffering, and instead prioritizes control over understanding. This emphasis on control, she argues, often leads to a loss of bodily autonomy for the patient, who is treated as an object to be managed rather than as a subject with agency and experience. The author recounts feeling silenced and invalidated by medical professionals who, despite her protests, insisted on attributing her physical symptoms to psychological causes. She describes how she was repeatedly told to stop writing, highlighting how her attempts to express herself were pathologized and seen as evidence of her instability. Mantel's experience is a powerful critique of the medicalization of human experience, emphasizing the need for a more holistic and compassionate approach to health and disease.

Context

• The pharmaceutical industry plays a significant role in medicalization by promoting medications as solutions to a wide range of human experiences, often influencing how conditions are perceived and treated.
• Life events such as job loss, divorce, or bereavement can cause significant distress. Medicalization might reduce these experiences to mere symptoms, neglecting the need for social support and coping strategies.
• Critics argue that it can lead to over-diagnosis and over-treatment, where normal variations in human behavior and emotion are pathologized, potentially leading to unnecessary medical interventions.
• Common examples of medicalization include the treatment of normal aging processes, childbirth, and mental health issues as medical problems requiring intervention, rather than natural or socially influenced phenomena.
• Holistic and patient-centered care models emphasize treating the patient as a whole person, considering emotional, social, and spiritual factors alongside physical health.
• Medical jargon and complex terminology can create communication barriers, making it difficult for patients to fully understand their diagnosis or treatment options. This can lead to feelings of being dismissed or not taken seriously.
• This is a phenomenon where a patient's physical symptoms are overlooked or misattributed to a mental health condition, often leading to inadequate treatment.
• Certain groups, including women and minorities, have historically been more likely to have their expressions pathologized, reflecting broader societal biases.
• The medicalization process often involves a power imbalance, where medical professionals hold authority over patients, potentially marginalizing the patient's voice and personal understanding of their own experiences.
• Encourages collaboration among various healthcare professionals, including doctors, psychologists, and social workers, to provide a more rounded and effective treatment plan.

Embracing Physical Limitations and the "Imperfect" Body

Mantel eventually learns to embrace her physical limitations and to challenge societal expectations of the "perfect" body. She develops a more holistic and nuanced understanding of health and illness, recognizing that the human form isn't merely a machine to be fixed but a complex and dynamic system that is constantly adapting and evolving.

Developing a Holistic Perspective on Health and Disease

Through her protracted struggle with chronic pain and illness, Mantel develops a holistic perspective on health and sickness. She understands that our physical selves aren't machines to be fixed but complex and interconnected systems that are constantly adapting and responding to internal and external pressures. This holistic perspective emphasizes the importance of listening to signals from the body, understanding the interplay between physical and emotional well-being, and acknowledging the limitations of a purely medical model of health and disease. Mantel recognizes the need to move beyond the simplistic dichotomy of "ill" and "well," embracing a more nuanced understanding of health as a dynamic and ongoing process that involves both limitations and possibilities.

Context

• Viewing health as a dynamic process acknowledges that it can fluctuate due to various factors, including lifestyle, stress, and environmental influences, rather than being a static state.
• Recognizing the body as a complex system underscores the importance of preventive health measures, which aim to maintain balance and prevent disease before it occurs, rather than just treating symptoms.
• Hormones like insulin and glucagon regulate blood sugar levels, adapting to food intake and energy needs.
• By tuning into bodily signals, individuals can become more self-aware and empowered to make informed decisions about their health, fostering a sense of agency and control over their well-being.
• Research indicates that emotions can influence immune responses. Positive emotions may boost immunity, while chronic stress or negative emotions can weaken it.
• Many people find relief through practices like acupuncture, meditation, and herbal medicine, which are not always included in conventional medical models.
• Modern healthcare increasingly values patient experiences and narratives, which often reveal complexities beyond simple diagnoses.
• Health needs and conditions can change over time, requiring flexibility and adaptation in health management approaches.
• Diet, exercise, sleep, and stress management are crucial in shaping health outcomes. Making informed lifestyle choices can mitigate limitations and enhance possibilities for better health.

Reclaiming Control and Narrative Over Her Experiences Through Writing

Writing becomes a powerful tool for the author to take back control and narrative over her experiences with long-term health issues. She uses writing to process her pain, to challenge the dismissive attitudes she encountered, and to articulate a more nuanced and complex understanding of her physical being and her lived experience. Through writing, she resists the tendency to reduce her to being diagnosed or labeled, asserting her agency and reclaiming her story. Mantel emphasizes the importance of finding language to articulate the often-unspeakable realities of persistent pain and disease, highlighting how writing can become a form of resistance against the silencing and invalidation that often accompany medicalization. She views writing as a means of reclaiming her body and identity, asserting her right to speak her truth, and finding meaning and purpose amidst adversity.

Note:

• Idiopathic: Relating to or denoting any disease or condition that arises spontaneously or whose cause is unknown.

Practical Tips

• Develop a habit of questioning the 'why' behind unexplained phenomena in your daily routine. Whenever you encounter something that doesn't have an obvious cause, take a moment to brainstorm possible explanations or factors that might be at play. This practice can sharpen your critical thinking skills and may lead to a deeper understanding of your environment and experiences.