PDF Summary:Get the Picture, by Bianca Bosker

In Get the Picture, Bianca Bosker lifts the curtain on the exclusive and enigmatic world of fine art. She uncovers the societal dynamics, gate-keeping practices, and economic forces that shape the art scene.

From the cliquish behaviors of galleries and museums to the financial opacity and insider networks that govern art valuation and collecting, Bosker navigates the contradictory forces at play. She examines how pressures for commercial viability and reinforcement of elite status can inhibit true artistic expression and marginalize lesser-known artists. Ultimately, Bosker prompts us to reconsider art's significance and societal impact.

(continued)...

Bosker argues convincingly that engaging in imaginative endeavors, like using opaque watercolors, assembling art from discovered materials, or taking on the role of a renowned dancer on social platforms, can significantly transform the experiences of both the artist and the viewers. Artists often employ their artistry to navigate through the terrain of trauma, articulate deeply rooted emotions, and delve into different facets of their individual identity. Interacting with art, particularly when it defies traditional norms or convictions, can unsettle the usual expectations of viewers, allowing them to face unsettling truths, broaden their perceptions of what is beautiful, and cultivate a deeper and broader connection with the realm of visuals.

Artists often face exploitation and insufficient backing within the artistic community.

The writer describes the ways in which the business of selling and promoting art often exploits the artists, highlighting the financial struggles and institutional obstacles they face in their efforts to stay true to their creative principles while also achieving the level of commercial viability needed to support themselves with their craft.

Many artists typically seek additional sources of income because solely relying on their creative work does not ensure financial security.

The idealized view of a solitary, hardworking master conflicts with the strict requirements needed to keep an art studio operational. Bosker encountered various individuals in the creative sector who balanced multiple roles to make ends meet, such as overseeing artwork collections, teaching, engaging in culinary professions, and assisting prominent artists. People who lack financial independence frequently have to reconcile their artistic principles with the demands of achieving commercial success due to monetary uncertainty.

The art community's emphasis on sensationalism, limited access, and the pursuit of profit often leads to artists feeling overwhelmed and disheartened.

As Bosker immersed herself in various facets of the art industry, such as working in galleries, attending exhibitions, and visiting artists' studios, she encountered numerous artists who were overwhelmed and stressed, finding their natural curiosity waning in the face of the commercial pressures that dictate how their art is promoted and distributed. The emphasis on high-stakes, unique, and expensive pieces of art, coupled with the widespread competition between various art dealers and supporters, could detrimentally affect the mental health of emerging artists, which might cause them to give up on their artistic endeavors.

Artists often lack the resources and institutional support necessary to sustain their creative practices

Artists, particularly those living in expensive cities like New York, frequently struggle to locate affordable studios, a challenge that impedes their ability to create large-scale art, experiment with different mediums, and progress in their artistic careers. Adding to these difficulties is a lack of affordable, reliable healthcare. Artists frequently find themselves postponing necessary medical procedures or opting for insurance plans that fail to address their specific needs due to the substantial costs associated. Artists often find their commitment to creative endeavors hampered by a lack of support from the wider community and the arts sector.

Other Perspectives

• While art production can be emotionally taxing and solitary, collaborative art forms and community projects demonstrate that art-making can also be a shared, socially engaging process.
• Some artists successfully integrate their creative vision with practical concerns without compromising their artistic integrity, indicating that balance is achievable and not always a struggle.
• Not all artistic methods involve high levels of experimentation and iteration; some artists work with well-defined plans and achieve their desired outcome with minimal revisions.
• There are artists who manage to maintain personal and financial security while pursuing their creative work, suggesting that sacrifice is not a universal requirement in the art world.
• The role of artists in challenging societal norms is significant, but other figures such as scientists, activists, and educators also play crucial roles in societal change and understanding.
• While art can be a powerful medium for social commentary and political activism, not all art serves this purpose; some art is created for aesthetic enjoyment or personal expression without an overt social agenda.
• The idea of what constitutes art is constantly evolving, and not all groundbreaking ideas come from the art world; innovation and unique perspectives are also found in other fields like technology and science.
• Artistic expression can be transformative, but not all encounters with art lead to deep personal change; some viewers may not connect with or be affected by certain artworks.
• While exploitation and insufficient backing are real issues, there are also numerous grants, residencies, and supportive communities that provide resources and support for artists.
• Many professionals in various fields seek additional sources of income, not just artists; having multiple income streams is a common economic strategy in a diversified economy.
• The art community's emphasis on sensationalism and profit can be seen as a reflection of broader societal values, and some artists find success and fulfillment within this system.
• While artists in expensive cities may lack resources, there are also initiatives and programs aimed at providing affordable workspaces, and some artists choose to work in less expensive areas to mitigate these challenges.

The shifting definitions and perceptions of what constitutes "art"

This part explores the fluid and ever-evolving idea of "art," challenging the idea that it represents a clearly defined category with standards for assessment that are universally acknowledged and unbiased. It encourages readers to reconsider their assumptions and to embrace the often messy and subjective experiences with the unexpected.

Art's significance is perpetually shifting and remains deeply personal.

In her exploration, Bosker discovers that the question of "What is art?" remains without a clear resolution, despite considerable philosophical debate. Her perspective asserts that the nature of art isn't determined by inherent qualities, but is instead shaped by the norms of society and the preferences of influential figures in its institutions. This subjective bias creates a skewed environment that elevates art forms like sculpture while diminishing the significance of areas such as craft, design, and performance art.

Individuals with influence have a substantial impact on shaping the criteria for what is recognized as art.

Bosker highlights the significance of selectivity by exploring the methods through which art institutions and exhibition spaces organize their exhibits, as well as the pronouncements of art commentators and the purchasing tendencies of renowned art collectors. Items chosen for exhibition, discourse, and collection in these cultural institutions reflect the preferences and influence of those in positions of power.

The line between "fine art" and other forms of creative work such as craft and design is often unclear and a subject of contention.

Bosker's research meticulously explores the widely recognized distinction between fine art and other creative realms such as craft and design. Modern artists often challenge the traditional 18th-century European ranking that placed painting and sculpture at the pinnacle, by merging elements of craftsmanship and elevating everyday items to a status that garners museum-level esteem.

The categorization of certain works as "art" can often reflect the inherent prejudices present in societal and cultural norms.

The designation of certain creations as "art" frequently uncovers biases tied to social status, gender, and ethnicity. The rise of fine art within a realm predominantly controlled by white males, coupled with the persistent disregard for artistic contributions from historically marginalized communities, underscores the persistent role of art guardians in upholding traditional power structures.

Engaging with artwork can elicit a wide range of emotional and cognitive responses, given that such encounters are profoundly personal.

Bosker champions the idea of personally interpreting and actively engaging with art, as opposed to simply revealing a predefined significance. Individual backgrounds, innate tendencies, and the unique situations in which someone engages with an artwork can result in a diverse spectrum of responses to the same piece.

Viewers interpret artwork through the lens of their personal experiences, preconceptions, and anticipations.

The interpretations Bosker collected while guarding Beuys’s sculpture "Virgin" illustrate this concept. While she considered the pieces of art to be mysterious and saw them as few, visitors made sense of the sparse exhibition by connecting it to their own life experiences and relationships. A chemistry student in Hungary envisioned an interrogation room from the Soviet era; meanwhile, a woman from Russia pictured a child being reprimanded by a caregiver; a young person from Colombia interpreted it as an encouragement to defy indoctrination. Each reading was valid, shaped by the individual’s personal lens and unique perspective.

The environment in which art is showcased, be it a museum's interior or a gallery's space, significantly shapes the observer's interaction with and interpretation of the artworks.

In partnership with Amanda Alfieri, also recognized by her moniker AllFIRE, Bosker observed that the venue of her acts, particularly those that showcased the buttocks, had a substantial impact on audience response. Visitors to the Haul gallery, many with deep connections to the realm of art, exhibited discomfort and confusion about her act that included face-sitting, while Amanda's Instagram audience displayed an unusually intense enthusiasm. The environment of the art exhibition space, together with its implicit codes of conduct and cognitive structures, seemed to constrain the audience's comprehension, emphasizing that the setting for displaying artwork can become seamlessly integrated with the artworks themselves.

Contemporary artwork challenges traditional notions of beauty and taste, prompting viewers to reassess their fundamental understanding of what constitutes art.

Bosker observed a pronounced snobbery in valuing art more for its aesthetic allure than for its capacity to captivate visually in a region where many galleries showcased provocative pieces. In the sophisticated social circles she frequented, the pursuit of beauty was deemed trivial and not deserving of recognition, particularly in settings committed to the promotion of art. Her dialogue with Curtis, combined with what she noticed in the grocery store and her experiences with color, prompted her to question the commonly accepted notion. She might suggest that the very charm is what seizes our focus, leading our minds to stray from their anticipated trajectory as soon as we begin to observe and understand. The concept of beauty defies a single, all-encompassing definition. In our daily routines, certain objects stand out with striking clarity against the backdrop of the ordinary, be it a child's sketch, an artifact of historical significance, or a flawlessly assembled egg sandwich.

The value and significance of art defy simple quantification.

Bosker's investigation highlights the intrinsic challenge of determining a definitive worth for artwork. Collectors of art often assess the worth of a piece by its prestige and the possibility of monetary gain, rather than its distinctiveness or cultural importance. Artworks often derive their worth from their capacity to provoke emotional reactions, inspire fresh perspectives, and challenge the norms of our traditional boundaries.

The monetary value attributed to a piece of art frequently does not mirror its significance in terms of culture or artistry.

Artworks have fetched prices amounting to millions of dollars at the Art Basel event in Miami Beach. Bosker felt a growing sense of dissonance. Collectors' willingness to invest hefty amounts appeared disconnected from any discernible benchmark of artistic merit or enduring cultural importance, yet it influenced the perceived "market value" associated with a particular artist. The values she encountered were markedly shaped by prevailing trends, strategic actions of those in the know, and a sense of rarity maintained by an exclusive group of esteemed art dealers and wealthy collectors.

The art community's emphasis on exclusivity, prestige, and status can distort the public's perception of an artwork's true importance.

The art world's intentionally exclusive ambiance, marked by arcane jargon, restricted access, and steep expenses, distorts how the broader population perceives the genuine value of art. Gaining access to the most exclusive works of art requires the right connections, understanding, and, crucially, significant monetary investment, relegating many would-be aficionados to the role of spectators, effectively barred from exploring the deep experiences that art offers.

Evaluating art's value is a complex task due to the inherently subjective nature of art appreciation, which makes it challenging to establish universally accepted criteria.

The inquiry conducted by Bosker into the characteristics that elevate art to a status of "high quality" ended, as one might expect, with outcomes that were not clearly defined. Her journey through various galleries, studios, and museums led to a deep respect for the intimate engagement with artwork, a practice that stands in stark contrast to the typically detached and academic approaches favored by art historians and critics. The notions of "best" and "good" are flexible, shaped by personal tastes, individual understanding, and the emotional reactions provoked by an artistic piece.

Other Perspectives

• While art's significance may shift, there are historical and cultural works that maintain a relatively stable significance across time and cultures.
• Not all individuals with influence agree on what constitutes art, and there are numerous examples of art recognized against the preferences of the powerful.
• There are established criteria and techniques that differentiate fine art from crafts and design, which are taught in art education and recognized by professionals in the field.
• While societal prejudices can influence the categorization of art, there are also objective elements such as technique, innovation, and impact that play a role in defining art.
• Personal interpretation is important, but there is also value in expert analysis and historical context when engaging with art.
• While personal experiences shape interpretation, there is often a shared cultural or symbolic language in art that can be understood more universally.
• The environment's influence can be mitigated by the viewer's knowledge and experience, allowing for a more objective appreciation of the artwork.
• Traditional notions of beauty and taste have endured because they resonate with human aesthetics and psychology, which can be as valid as contemporary challenges to these notions.
• Art's value can be quantified to some extent by its historical importance, technical skill, and influence on other works, not just by personal or emotional responses.
• The monetary value of art can sometimes reflect its historical significance, rarity, or the technical skill involved in its creation.
• The exclusivity of the art community can serve to preserve the quality and integrity of art by ensuring that it is evaluated by knowledgeable and experienced individuals.
• While subjective, there are methodologies and frameworks within art criticism and history that provide a more structured approach to evaluating art's value.

The business and monetary aspects associated with buying, trading, and collecting works of art.

The final section of the book examines the transformation of art into a tradable asset, exploring the methods used for acquiring, amassing, and exchanging artworks, in addition to the impact these activities have on the artists and the broader cultural context. This part of the book examines the skewed dynamics between those who produce art and the art market, highlighting the market's opacity, its vulnerability to manipulation, and how these factors influence societal values.

The art market is known for its lack of transparency, rampant conjecture, and imbalanced distribution of influence.

The author portrays the world of art commerce as an opaque, speculation-driven environment where the priorities of investors often overshadow those of the artists on their creative path, with the entrenched power dynamics of this system limiting opportunities for artists outside a privileged group.

Art pieces often derive their worth from aspects that go beyond their intrinsic value.

Bosker's conclusion that art valuation lacks consistency and impartiality was influenced by her involvement with different art spaces, active engagement in showings, and her scrutiny of the fervent buying behaviors at events like the ones held in Miami. The standing of the establishments showcasing the artists' work often eclipses concrete aspects like the costs of production and materials, influenced heavily by the artists' social ties, their background, and most notably, their track record of sales at auction.

The actions and preferences of investors, along with those of art collectors, substantially shape the priorities and stories that emerge in the art world.

Collectors significantly shape the ecosystem by being the primary buyers, influencing not only the trajectory of an artist's career but also the diversity of art pieces that are produced, exhibited, and enter into public discourse. Bosker observes that galleries, driven by economic incentives, often tailor their exhibits and the pieces acquired by museums to the tastes of wealthy art patrons.

The art world's dependence on a few influential dealers, along with auction houses, creates barriers for new entrants and diminishes the dynamism of competition.

A select group of influential individuals governs the contemporary art scene, posing significant obstacles for emerging artists and galleries striving to break into the esteemed networks. The concentration of authority intensifies existing inequalities and limits the range of work available to a broader audience.

Building a collection of art can often present challenges that deter individuals from beginning the process.

Bosker's exploration revealed that the path to acquiring art is not just about ownership but involves mastering a complex and demanding route that necessitates particular skills, entrenched social networks, privileged access to insider knowledge, and significant economic means, underscoring the select and closed nature of the art collecting domain.

Collectors must traverse a complex network of social ties, privileged information, and monetary assets to acquire the most sought-after artworks.

Everyone can enter a museum's halls, but to acquire the most sought-after contemporary pieces of art, one must navigate a complex process that involves waiting in line at galleries, building relationships with art dealers, and showcasing one's knowledge and appreciation of the arts. Over three years, the Icy Gays transitioned from aficionados of thrift market finds to highly regarded connoisseurs of fine art, earning acclaim through meticulous research, forging key relationships, and passionately supporting both artists and cultural institutions. Their tale emphasizes the considerable commitment and time needed to accumulate art of such high quality.

The emphasis on the provenance, distinctiveness, and the esteemed position that artworks hold in the art community can create obstacles for newcomers to the art collection field.

For affluent individuals who are not well-versed in the fine arts, acquiring coveted artworks entails more than just a significant monetary exchange. To attain success, a collector must have a deep comprehension of current art movements, a sharp perception of what is deemed "quality" by key players, and develop a wide-reaching social circle that provides chances to obtain coveted works of art. Background, respect, and expert insight serve to deter novices and preserve the artistic community's characteristic exclusivity.

The art world's treatment of collectors as esteemed VIPs emphasizes its exclusivity and hierarchical nature.

The degree to which collectors are catered to by art venues and displays underscores their prominent status within this pecking order. The art community's hierarchy is inherently exclusive and conscious of social standing, as evidenced by the stratified access granted to select individuals, favorable pricing, and the high regard given to the views of purchasers, regardless of the depth of their understanding of the artwork.

The commerce surrounding art profoundly affects both creators and the wider cultural environment.

The author emphasizes the significance of prioritizing people above monetary gain in the realm of art and its commercial aspects, as such emphasis profoundly affects the protection of authentic artistic creativity, the encouragement of emerging talent, and the broader community.

The emphasis on financial gain and commercial considerations in the art world can restrict creative liberty and genuine artistic expression.

While a variety of galleries purport to champion a wide range of artistic endeavors, the economic necessities tied to the art market may negatively influence the choices of artists and risk compromising their commitment to their artistry. Bosker observed that emerging artists were being prompted by galleries to create works that are visually captivating, uncomplicated, and in harmony with prevailing trends. This commercial imperative can stifle experimentation, limit artistic freedom, and ultimately hinder the production of more radical, challenging, or conceptually-driven work that might struggle to find an audience in the marketplace.

The amassing of riches and power by a small elite can lead to the marginalization of less prominent artists and perspectives.

The author discovered a realm predominantly influenced by a limited spectrum of perspectives within the realm of art. Despite numerous assertions from prominent museums, art commentators, and curators regarding their dedication to expanding the range of recognized art, the true diversity of artists and the makeup of those in powerful positions reveal that there is still significant progress required to transform the prevailing norms of the art industry. The art market's intrinsic disparities related to the distribution of wealth and access can contribute to the continuation of existing societal biases.

Ongoing conversations and assessments continue to explore how the realm of art contributes to maintaining social inequalities and exclusion.

Numerous creators and display organizers have expressed to Bosker their growing disillusionment with the industry's reliance on opaque funding sources for survival, particularly when it comes to obtaining the necessary backing for their creative endeavors. The myriad of moral and pragmatic challenges arise from the imbalance between individuals with significant buying influence and the creators whose contributions form the foundation of the entire industry. The quandary stems from the reality that the fine arts sector often relies on white-collar crimes, tax evasion, and questionable business practices for its economic sustenance, which raises the question of whether art's ability to foster social change is compromised by its reliance on the very issues it seeks to challenge.

Other Perspectives

• The art market's lack of transparency can be seen as a protection of privacy for collectors and a safeguard against market manipulation.
• High art valuation based on factors beyond intrinsic value reflects the subjective nature of art and its cultural significance.
• The influence of investors and collectors can be a force for good, driving innovation and supporting the arts financially.
• Barriers created by influential dealers and auction houses can ensure that only high-quality art is promoted and valued.
• The complexity of building an art collection ensures that collectors are dedicated and knowledgeable, which can enhance the overall quality of collections.
• Exclusivity in the art world can be a means to maintain high standards and a sense of prestige, which can increase the value of art.
• Treating collectors as VIPs can be a way to acknowledge their crucial role in sustaining the art market and artists.
• Commercial considerations can provide artists with a sustainable income, allowing them to continue their work.
• The concentration of wealth and power in the art world can be seen as a reflection of broader societal structures, not unique to the art industry.
• The art industry's role in maintaining social inequalities can also be viewed as a platform for challenging and discussing these very issues.