PDF Summary:Football for a Buck, by Jeff Pearlman

The 1980s saw an ambitious attempt to challenge the mighty NFL with a springtime football league, the United States Football League (USFL). But while flush with big-name talent and promising TV deals, the league was plagued by overspending, in-fighting among owners, and the disruptive force of Donald Trump's ambitions.

In Football for a Buck, Jeff Pearlman chronicles the USFL's unlikely rise and precipitous downfall. Through detailed accounts of behind-the-scenes turmoil, flawed decision-making, and Trump's fateful plan to move the USFL to fall, Pearlman exposes how poor leadership and hubris brought down a league that captured America's imagination—if only fleetingly.

(continued)...

The Washington Federals epitomized the most conspicuous weaknesses of the USFL, finding it difficult to secure a strong foothold. Jeff Pearlman describes the struggles of the team as originating from a group of coaches who were not adequately qualified, a roster filled with players who were inexperienced and not well-known, and an owner whose enthusiasm diminished, leading to a complete loss of support from the football fans in Washington D.C. The Federals were doomed to fail because their owners hesitated to spend on talented players and did not grasp the importance of fostering team cohesion. The book depicts their collapse as a warning to the league's management, underscoring the importance of skilled leadership and governance.

Despite pouring substantial funds into assembling a skilled team by acquiring costly players, the Los Angeles Express was unable to increase spectator numbers or generate considerable enthusiasm among supporters, particularly in a metropolis teeming with other entertainment options.

Bill Oldenburg's time at the helm of the Los Angeles Express stands as a cautionary tale of excessive ambition and the oversight of essential market attractiveness factors. Pearlman depicts an owner whose misguided choices led to spending millions on creating an elite squad in a metropolis that demonstrated scant enthusiasm. The writer portrays Oldenburg as a tragic figure, driven by a powerful desire to outspend his rivals in the United States Football League, yet overlooking the fact that Los Angeles had an abundance of professional sports teams and a wide array of entertainment choices. The Express became a financial quagmire, rapidly draining funds due to substantial player wages, remuneration for the coaching team, and an uninspiring pre-game show by the Beach Boys that failed to retain the audience until the evening's end.

The financial turmoil and disorganized management of the San Antonio Gunslingers, highlighted by Clinton Manges's atypical leadership style, serve as a prime illustration of the widespread economic precariousness, as evidenced by their regular experiences with bounced checks and unpaid financial obligations.

The San Antonio Gunslingers epitomized the chaos that was synonymous with the USFL, their operations more akin to a circus act than that of a conventional professional football team. The United States Football League provided a team like no other that was perfectly suited for cinematic portrayal, highlighted by the extraordinary stories uncovered by the writer. The engagement of a coach with only seven fingers, the enlistment of a ranch-hand for punting responsibilities, the enthusiastic promotion of the placekicker to garner media interest, the relentless occurrence of dishonored checks, the brawls, the deceptions, and the outlandish uniforms—all are chronicled in a narrative that would elicit pride in both Barnum and Bailey. Pearlman highlights how the allure of potential riches and fame can attract attention to endeavors that might seem ludicrous, exemplifying this with the case of the Gunslingers.

Practical Tips

• You can learn from past financial missteps by tracking your personal spending with a budgeting app that uses gamification to encourage frugality. By setting up challenges within the app, you can reward yourself for staying under budget in various categories, much like a team would aim to stay under a salary cap. For example, if you spend less than your set limit on dining out for a month, the app could unlock a new level or provide a digital badge as a form of recognition.
• Develop a better understanding of economic strategies by playing a simulation game that requires you to manage a sports team's finances. Through the game, you'll have to make decisions on player salaries, marketing, and expansion, mirroring the complexities team owners face. This hands-on approach can help you grasp the consequences of financial decisions without real-world risks. For instance, if you choose to spend heavily on a star player, you might see the impact on team morale and financial stability within the game's ecosystem.
• Enhance your decision-making skills by starting a fantasy sports league with friends where you rotate management roles weekly. This will give you a taste of the diverse strategies and challenges involved in running a team, including managing resources and making trade decisions. As you take turns, you'll experience different perspectives and approaches, which can translate into a broader understanding of managing real-life projects or teams. For example, one week you might focus on building a strong defense, while the next you could prioritize scoring, each time observing the outcomes and adapting your strategy.

The USFL was marked by the involvement of prominent and controversial individuals like Donald Trump, who sought to challenge the well-established National Football League.

The narrative section scrutinizes how USFL owners, contrary to their initial claims, viewed the organization as a transient chance to further their own goals. The book delves into how Donald Trump's tactics, marked by their disruptive nature and lack of concern for long-term stability, set the stage for the collapse of the USFL.

Donald Trump's disruptive and ambitious behavior stemmed from his aspiration to possess an NFL franchise.

The author portrays Donald Trump, a rising real estate tycoon from New York with an unquenchable thirst for notoriety and riches, as the central character whose choices led to the collapse of the United States Football League. You'll find out that Trump's relentless drive to shift the league's games to the fall season demonstrated a disregard for its established equilibrium and conventional operational practices. Pearlman suggests that Trump's destructive actions stemmed from his self-centered ambition to acquire an NFL franchise, which impaired his decision-making and led to the league's collapse through a series of dishonest acts, exaggerations, and secret dealings.

The book examines the era when Trump was at the helm of the New Jersey Generals, emphasizing his contentious style and the strain it created with Commissioner Simmons, along with his emphasis on recruiting star players and extravagant spending that threatened the league's equilibrium.

Donald Trump was the central figure in transforming the USFL into what an observer likened to a calamity for professional football. Pearlman depicts the era under Trump as characterized by egocentric and self-centered governance, culminating in a disastrous legal strategy that doomed the league. Donald Trump managed the New Jersey Generals more like a remote manipulator than an involved owner, demonstrating little interest in the league's well-being from the moment he took ownership until the team's final game. The author highlights Trump's penchant for clashing with the league's chief officer, showcasing his penchant for the spotlight by enlisting prominent athletes with hefty salaries, exemplified by the Generals' lavish offer to NFL linebacker Lawrence Taylor, which played a role in inflating player salaries and destabilizing the league's finances.

The book highlights the conflict between Trump's personal ambitions and the league's foundational goals, emphasizing his relentless push to shift the USFL's schedule to the autumn season, setting the stage for a direct confrontation with the NFL, a move that was driven by his desire to possess a franchise in the NFL.

Trump's ultimate goal, shared only in confidence, was to use the spring football league as a stepping stone to gain entry into the exclusive circle of NFL team owners. He consistently pushed for moving the games to the fall season, using a blend of charisma, exaggeration, and convincing arguments to influence the team proprietors enticed by the prospects of higher revenue and more lucrative TV deals. Pearlman depicts this shift as the moment when the organization decidedly pivoted from a measured growth approach to embarking on ventures with significant risks.

Investigating the intricate dynamics between Bassett's resistance to Trump's lavish expenditures and his concept for autumn football, which ultimately steered the league's path.

Pearlman emphasizes the clear divergence in principles between John Bassett and Trump, with Bassett's commitment to integrity clashing with Trump's pursuit of personal gain, a conflict that played a major role in shaping the league's future path. Bassett regarded Trump as a novice in pursuit of the spotlight, intent on exploiting the USFL for personal gain. The author emphasizes Bassett's crucial support for a football season in the spring, offering a compelling option to Trump's suggested profitable fall football season. Ultimately, the deteriorating health and subsequent passing of Bassett halted any attempts to curb the expanding influence wielded by the league's most powerful owner, paving the way for rash and unviable choices.

The USFL enticed top-tier players by offering lucrative contracts, thereby raising the general salary levels across the league.

The passage emphasizes how the USFL attracted up-and-coming collegiate stars and experienced NFL players by offering attractive monetary rewards, and it also points out the league's shift toward a fiscal strategy that ultimately led to its financial downfall and internal chaos.

The moment when Jim Kelly was pursued by the Houston Gamblers, underscoring Jerry Argovitz's intertwined positions as the owner and his previous role as an agent, marked a significant turning point that resulted in higher salaries for athletes.

The author depicts the moment when Jim Kelly opted for the USFL over the NFL as a critical juncture for the league, demonstrating its attractiveness to up-and-coming athletes who previously had limited negotiating alternatives. Jerry Argovitz, the owner of the Houston Gamblers and former player representative, orchestrated a strategic move by offering Jim Kelly, a college quarterback with bright prospects in the NFL, especially with the Buffalo Bills, an attractive five-year contract valued at $3.5 million, successfully persuading him to join the team. The strategy of the USFL to attract top talent by offering more attractive financial terms than the NFL demonstrated its commitment but also paved the way for its eventual collapse.

The Oklahoma Outlaws' acquisition of Doug Williams, who was the first African American quarterback to secure a Super Bowl victory, underscored his exit from Tampa Bay due to contractual disagreements and highlighted the USFL's capacity to attract experienced players from the NFL.

Doug Williams' choice to sign with the Oklahoma Outlaws, securing a five-year deal worth $3 million, highlighted the USFL's rise as an attractive alternative for athletes who realized that NFL teams were not offering equally lucrative salaries. Pearlman highlights the significance of this agreement, particularly in light of Williams's past encounters with racial discrimination and contract disputes during his tenure as the leading quarterback for the Tampa Bay team. Williams's decision to join the USFL highlighted the organization's dedication to providing players with fair opportunities and illustrated its increasing appeal to seasoned NFL athletes seeking both financial security and acknowledgment.

The Pittsburgh Maulers' prearranged pick of Mike Rozier in the USFL Draft highlighted their approach to attract Heisman Trophy recipients and simultaneously raised questions about their commitment to fair play.

The Pittsburgh Maulers adopted a provocative approach to drafting, under the guidance of league authorities aiming to garner extensive press coverage, by choosing Mike Rozier, a running back and the second Heisman Trophy awardee to join the USFL. Pearlman describes how the league's tactical decisions ultimately led to Rozier's signing, showcasing a willingness to overlook moral boundaries to secure premier players. The choice, while beneficial for commercial interests, led to doubts about the league's commitment to honesty and transparency. The author evaluates the potential long-term effects on the league's reputation due to the continuous enlistment of high-profile athletes.

Other Perspectives

• The USFL's collapse cannot solely be attributed to Donald Trump's actions; other factors such as overall league management, economic pressures, and competition with the NFL also played significant roles.
• Trump's push for a fall schedule could be seen as an attempt to maximize visibility and profitability for the league, rather than a simple personal ambition to own an NFL franchise.
• The narrative that Trump's behavior was disruptive may overlook the possibility that his business tactics were common in the high-stakes world of professional sports ownership.
• The portrayal of Trump's management style as egocentric and self-centered could be challenged by the argument that strong leadership and a clear vision are necessary for success in any business venture, including sports.
• The assertion that Trump's spending threatened the league's equilibrium might be countered by the view that investing in star players is a legitimate strategy to increase the league's competitiveness and marketability.
• The conflict between Trump and Commissioner Simmons could be interpreted as a clash of differing but valid visions for the league's future rather than a straightforward case of personal ambition undermining collective goals.
• The USFL's strategy to offer lucrative contracts to players could be defended as an innovative way to challenge the NFL's dominance and improve conditions for players.
• The signing of high-profile athletes like Jim Kelly and Doug Williams could be seen as a successful tactic to raise the league's profile and competitiveness, rather than a precursor to financial downfall.
• The criticism of the Pittsburgh Maulers' draft strategy might be countered by the argument that all teams use strategic means to secure the best possible players within the rules set by their leagues.

The decision to schedule games in the fall, which put it in direct competition with the NFL, led to the downfall and eventual disbandment of the USFL.

This section outlines the disastrous decision to switch to a fall schedule, its immediate consequences, the fleeting victory the league achieved in its antitrust lawsuit against the NFL, and the ultimate disintegration of a league that began with significant promise.

The shift from one season to the next and the disastrous consequences that followed

In this part of the book, Pearlman offers an in-depth exploration of the factors that influenced the owners to shift the USFL's playing season to the fall, emphasizing the allure of Trump's promises and the significant apprehension that prompted them to deviate from the original plan established by Dixon. The author depicts this choice less as a deliberate commercial strategy and more as a risky leap into uncharted territory.

The narrative details the process by which USFL executives were persuaded to transition their games to the autumn season, emphasizing the role of Trump's persuasive but ultimately misleading reasoning, along with apprehension and the mirage of prospects, in shaping their choices.

The author emphasizes the cunning tactics utilized by Trump to influence his peers during the decision-making processes about the seasonal changes. Owners concerned about the league's future were drawn in by his captivating promises of a fierce battle over broadcast rights, the potential collapse of the NFL, and the promise of substantial riches for those backing his proposal. Pearlman emphasizes the strategic psychological maneuvers employed by Trump, involving the use of exaggeration, commendation, and coercion, which aimed to tip the scales to his advantage but instead brought about disastrous outcomes that doomed the league.

The analysis highlights the detrimental effects of Trump's aggressive strategy, which originated from his dismissal of the recommendations made by the consultancy McKinsey & Company, which suggested a schedule for the spring.

Trump deliberately minimized the significance of a costly study by the esteemed consulting firm McKinsey & Company to sway the results. Pearlman scrutinizes the report's concluding evaluation, which posits that maintaining operations during the spring might pave the way for a steadier footing and the opportunity to capitalize on the expected labor disagreements within the NFL, juxtaposing this with the enticing assurances offered by Trump. The author depicts how the individual often ignores inconvenient truths by demonstrating his approach to challenging and attempting to undermine those who present rational counterarguments, emphasizing the dangers associated with a leadership style that prioritizes charisma and forceful strategies over meticulous analysis and strategic foresight.

The unveiling of the autumn schedule led to a noticeable drop in supporter excitement, the departure of key players to rival organizations, and heightened skepticism regarding the league's durability.

The decision by the USFL to transition to a fall schedule resulted in a marked decline in public enthusiasm and support, along with a swift decrease in fan fervor. Pearlman underscores the negative impact of the league's alterations, pointing out the significant drop in audience attendance and the shift of talented players to the NFL, along with increasing rifts between team proprietors. The author argues that when the league's demise appeared certain, fans generally favored their local NFL franchises over the regional USFL teams when it came to choosing which to support. The initial enthusiasm and fresh appeal that captured attention at first gradually subsided as people became cognizant of the league's precarious future.

The legal triumph of the USFL over the NFL turned out to be more emblematic than consequential.

In this segment, Pearlman delves into the complexities surrounding the USFL's legal battle against the NFL, which was based on antitrust laws, a struggle that many thought would rescue the league but ultimately hastened its demise because of Trump's inflated ego and misguided legal strategies. You'll uncover a situation that seemed simple but eventually descended into farce, with a worth that dwindled to just a single dollar.

The initiation of a lawsuit against the NFL by the USFL was significantly influenced by strategies largely orchestrated by Trump, with the goal of either combining the two leagues or obtaining a significant financial settlement, highlighting the strategic and legal arguments used during the court case.

Driven by his unwavering determination to become one of the NFL team owners, Trump took legal steps with the goal of either merging with the NFL or securing a significant monetary compensation that would allow him to purchase an existing team. Pearlman explains that Trump used his growing influence to advocate for an aggressive legal strategy, which the author believes relied more on Trump's personal assertion that the NFL deliberately sabotaged the USFL, thereby impeding his prospects for victory. The legal action challenged the National Football League's sole contracts with the three main television broadcasters, which were characterized as tactics that stifled competition and hindered other companies.

The book points out that the legal strategy of the United States Football League was significantly weakened by its focus solely on Trump and Myerson during the trial, while overlooking other key figures.

Pearlman depicts the USFL's legal team, led by the costly Harvey Myerson, who earned the moniker "Heavy Hitter Harvey," as a disastrous mix of arrogance and poor decisions, overshadowed by Trump's self-promotional tactics. The author depicts Trump as resolute in his decision to be the USFL's lone advocate in court, despite opposing suggestions from Argovitz and other team owners who advocated for a collective approach. The author argues that this approach eroded the persuasiveness of the league's case, transforming a potential story of daring entrepreneurs challenging a well-entrenched monopoly into a ludicrous display overshadowed by a single egocentric promoter. The author portrays the strategy as self-defeating, allowing the NFL's lawyer, Frank Rothman, to portray Trump as someone motivated by self-interest, lacking in charm and dependability.

The book delves into the disastrous outcomes stemming from the USFL's lawsuit against the NFL, emphasizing how it led to the league's closure and the dispersal of its teams and athletes.

The author depicts the jury's verdict to grant the USFL only a single dollar as a symbolic victory, suggesting it was less a reason for jubilation and more a sign of the league's impending collapse. Pearlman narrates the chaos that ensued after the unexpected outcome, focusing on the shock that spread among the USFL's proprietors, Myerson's erratic and irrational outbursts, the flurry of reporters scrambling to update their stories, and the intense joy experienced by the top brass of the NFL. The author emphasizes the symbolic significance of the token $1 fee, which served to counter claims of intentional disruption directed at the NFL and, with no significant financial benefit involved, essentially determined the destiny of the league.

The USFL's lasting influence continues to be significant.

The final segment of the conversation highlights the lasting legacy the USFL has on football, showcasing its contributions to the introduction of innovative rules and the development of talented players who later gained fame in the NFL. The author explores the profound but often overlooked impact on those whose sporting careers ended in disillusionment and dissatisfaction when the league ceased to exist.

The USFL's impact on professional football is clear from the innovative rules it introduced and the influx of talented players it contributed, many of whom achieved Pro Bowl and Hall of Fame status, thus elevating the competitive standard in the major professional football league in the United States.

Pearlman suggests that the legacy of the USFL still resonates within the sport, even though it was a fleeting rival to the entrenched leagues. The NFL eventually embraced the tactics of pursuing a two-point conversion and challenging plays through instant replay, both of which introduced more thrill and tactical depth to the game, countering earlier critiques of its sluggish tempo and cautious strategy. The resolution of the legal dispute opened doors for numerous athletes to showcase their abilities on a prominent platform, opportunities that may have eluded them in other circumstances.

The enduring legacy and charm of the USFL made an indelible mark on all participants, underscoring the excitement, unique stories, and persistent bonds formed within the league, despite its ultimate downfall.

Pearlman highlights the lasting sentimental importance that the USFL maintains in the hearts of those who were intimately involved with it, long after it ceased to exist. The writer's memories of the vibrant and chaotic league, from his 1990 high school project to his 2016 trek across San Francisco in pursuit of Greg Fields, stand as enduring evidence that, for many fans, the United States Football League was more than just a mere sports entity. The people who provided their perspectives for this volume, encompassing everyone from the front office staff to the personnel responsible for orchestrating the events of match day, consistently characterize the team as an exceptional group, similar to a close-knit family, with an experience that went beyond the usual limits and left a lasting impression marked by both sadness and profound gratitude.

Donald Trump's tenure as an owner within the United States Football League highlighted his unwavering method of team management, business dealings, and political maneuvering, all characterized by choices driven by his own benefit.

Pearlman offers a retrospective that is both enlightening and unsettling, portraying the period when Trump led the USFL as an ominous precursor to subsequent occurrences, while examining a past that often encounters criticism, focusing on a businessman and future political figure known for challenging conventional standards. His relentless self-promotion, disdain for well-established facts, and his lofty disregard for those who resisted his dominance, coupled with his skillful use of exaggeration, need for constant praise, and his strategic orchestration of public perception, were all contributing factors to the collapse of a sports organization that he played a key role in disassembling. The author suggests that Trump's dismissal of the USFL as inconsequential revealed a key aspect of his personality, an aspect that has grown more apparent on a broader stage over time.

Other Perspectives

• The decision to schedule games in the fall was a risk that could have paid off if not for other factors, such as poor execution or broader market conditions.
• Trump's reasoning for the shift to a fall schedule may have been based on a vision to elevate the USFL to a level of competition with the NFL, which could have been innovative if successful.
• The dismissal of McKinsey & Company's recommendations might have been a strategic choice, aiming to differentiate the USFL from other leagues and capture a share of the lucrative fall football market.
• The decrease in supporter excitement and player departures could also be attributed to the natural ebb and flow of a new league's popularity, rather than the change in schedule alone.
• The legal battle against the NFL, while ultimately unsuccessful, could be seen as a bold move to challenge a monopoly and might have set important legal precedents.
• Focusing the legal strategy on Trump could have been a calculated decision to leverage his high profile for public and media attention.
• The outcome of the lawsuit, while financially disappointing, did result in a moral victory and recognition of the NFL's monopolistic practices.
• The USFL's impact on professional football, while significant, might be overstated, and its innovative rules and player contributions could be seen as part of the natural evolution of the sport.
• The enduring legacy of the USFL might be romanticized, and while it left a mark on participants, its overall impact on the sport could be considered marginal.
• Donald Trump's tenure in the USFL, characterized by self-benefit-driven choices, could also be viewed as an example of a business leader making tough decisions in a competitive environment.