PDF Summary:Falling Upward, by Richard Rohr

Falling Upward by Richard Rohr explores the journey of spiritual growth, which encompasses two distinct phases. The initial phase focuses on establishing a solid identity and creating a robust foundation. The subsequent phase involves a shift in perspective and a deeper exploration of one's authentic self.

Rohr emphasizes the importance of external frameworks and boundaries during the early phases of life. However, he cautions against becoming overly attached to these structures, as they can impede spiritual progression. As individuals mature, they often develop self-awareness, embrace their inner complexities, and cultivate a more expansive consciousness. Rohr invites readers to view obstacles and losses as catalysts for growth, leading to a deeper understanding of life's inherent bittersweetness.

(continued)...

• Experiment with relinquishing control in a low-stakes situation. For example, let someone else choose the movie on movie night or decide the restaurant for a group dinner. Pay attention to how it makes you feel and what the outcomes are. This can help you become more comfortable with not always being in the dominant position and appreciate the input and leadership of others.
• Create a "Diversity Book Club" with peers where the goal is to read and discuss books that present perspectives vastly different from your own. By exposing yourself to a variety of worldviews in a structured and social setting, you can gradually become more comfortable with ideas that challenge your own, fostering a more inclusive and less reactive mindset.
• Diversify your news sources to challenge your value biases by regularly reading from outlets that offer different or opposing viewpoints. This exposes you to a broader spectrum of values and can reduce the overemphasis on any single set of values. For example, if you typically read a conservative news site, try also reading a liberal one to understand different perspectives.
• Create a 'Compassion Practice' by volunteering with a diverse group of people. Choose an organization that serves a wide range of communities and commit to regular volunteering. Through this service, you'll encounter a variety of beliefs and values, which can help you develop empathy and see beyond the labels that often divide us.
• Engage in role reversal exercises where you adopt the perspective of someone with a completely different approach to a similar problem or situation. If you're a meticulous planner, try approaching a project with a more spontaneous, flexible mindset. This can help you see the limitations of your usual perspective and explore the benefits of alternative approaches.

As one matures spiritually, there is an expansion of perspective that recognizes the value of life's early frameworks while also progressing beyond them.

Rohr emphasizes the significance of progressing while preserving the wisdom acquired from the early stages of life. The focus isn't on entirely discarding or demonizing the existing rules, traditions, and boundaries. The focus is on acknowledging their inherent shortcomings and realizing that such limitations are insufficient for dealing with life's greater complexities. It involves embracing these principles and developing the wisdom to identify which regulations benefit the collective well-being and which should be scrutinized or potentially disregarded.

In his transformative ministry, Jesus consistently challenged the prevailing religious and societal norms of his era, emphasizing that understanding the law's spirit with empathy and benevolence was more important than strict compliance with rules. The writer suggests that true understanding emerges when we integrate lessons from the early phases of our existence, allowing us to move beyond the limitations of our initial upbringing and embrace a more expansive outlook.

Other Perspectives

• Rohr's emphasis on preserving wisdom from early life stages might overlook the fact that some individuals' early frameworks are fundamentally flawed or harmful, and thus not worth preserving.
• In certain contexts, the preservation of outdated or limiting rules and traditions can impede innovation and adaptation to new circumstances, which might necessitate their removal rather than mere acknowledgment of their limitations.
• The sufficiency of limitations is often context-dependent; what may seem insufficient in one scenario could be perfectly adequate in another.
• The idea of identifying beneficial regulations assumes that individuals have the capacity and resources to discern and choose wisely, which may not be the case for everyone due to differences in education, cognitive abilities, and access to information.
• Jesus' challenges to prevailing norms were not universally accepted and led to significant conflict, suggesting that challenging the status quo can have divisive consequences.
• The idea of moving beyond initial limitations assumes a linear progression of understanding, which may not account for the cyclical or non-linear ways in which some people experience growth and learning.

Recognizing the inherent sorrows of existence is essential.

In their youth, individuals tend to categorize experiences as either positive or negative, and as correct or incorrect.

Rohr suggests that the dualistic mindset often adopted during the initial phases of life, though necessary, offers a limited view of the world. In the early phase of growth, this approach divides everything into distinct categories of good versus evil, right against wrong, and us versus them, providing a sense of order and control that is crucial.

Rohr combines insights from intellectuals such as Miguel de Unamuno with concepts from quantum physics to emphasize that life's journey is not a linear progression toward perfection, but rather a complex interplay of order and disorder, growth and regression, victory and loss. While the binary way of thinking is useful in our younger years, it cannot fully grasp the complexities and inherent contradictions that define our existence.

A perspective that emphasizes clear-cut distinctions is essential during the early phases of development; yet, it may limit an individual's ability to grasp the wider circumstances and navigate intricate situations.

The author suggests that this simplistic approach fails to acknowledge the deep mystery and complexity that is intrinsic to the divine, the universe, and our own motivations. He understands that the ego prefers environments that are organized and controllable, as it struggles with uncertainty and contradictory concepts.

The writer suggests that a widespread attitude, shared by people all over the world and also found in spiritual groups, is frequently limited to this way of reasoning. It provides a sense of security and comfort. Individuals adhering to a dualistic way of thinking are quick to judge others with opposing opinions, maintain certainty in their perspectives, and believe they have the right to impose their beliefs on others. Numerous individuals overlook the significance of personal development, convinced that they already embody the ideal of correctness.

Other Perspectives

• It could instill a fixed mindset rather than a growth mindset, leading individuals to shy away from challenges that do not have clear-cut answers.
• Clear-cut distinctions can actually facilitate understanding by establishing foundational concepts upon which more complex ideas can be built.
• Personal motivations can sometimes be understood through straightforward explanations without delving into deeper complexities.
• There are instances where individuals demonstrate a high tolerance for ambiguity and contradiction, which indicates that the ego's struggle with these elements is not universal.
• The tendency to engage in dualistic thinking might be context-dependent, with individuals applying it in some areas of their lives while employing more complex reasoning in others.
• The ability to judge opposing opinions is not exclusively negative; it can also be indicative of critical thinking skills and the ability to discern and evaluate different viewpoints.
• Believing one embodies correctness doesn't necessarily preclude the pursuit of personal growth; individuals can hold strong convictions while still engaging in self-improvement.

In the advanced phases of life, individuals develop an understanding that embraces life's intrinsic complexities, sorrows, and contradictions, leading to the cultivation of a viewpoint that is enriched with compassion, subtlety, and expansiveness.

Richard Rohr encourages embracing life's intricacies to transcend the limitations imposed by binary thinking. Embracing the complexities of life's later phases means being prepared to recognize and withstand its contradictions, observing its more serious sides without giving in to despair or judgment. It is a recognition that life is not about achieving some kind of perfect order but about learning to dance with chaos, to find meaning amidst the muddle, to see beauty in the brokenness.

He proposes that the more developed forms of global religious beliefs unite in acknowledging a truth that transcends binary thought patterns. This reflective method of understanding transcends the limiting binary of simplistic right-or-wrong perspectives by embracing a holistic view that recognizes the full spectrum of existence. Achieving a more profound spiritual state enables one to discern an underlying oneness that binds everything together, despite obvious disparities and discord.

Other Perspectives

• Binary thinking, while limited, can sometimes provide clarity and simplicity in decision-making, which can be beneficial in certain situations.
• The ability to embrace life's complexities without despair or judgment might not solely be a function of reaching later phases of life; younger individuals can also possess this maturity and perspective.
• Some may argue that life is not so much about learning to dance with chaos, but rather about imposing order on chaos to create a stable and predictable environment.
• The idea of finding beauty in brokenness could be seen as a coping mechanism rather than a true understanding of life's complexities, suggesting a form of escapism rather than engagement with the issues at hand.
• Emphasizing a non-binary truth could potentially undermine religious traditions that rely on clear moral and ethical guidelines, which often are presented in binary terms.
• In certain situations, especially those involving justice or the rule of law, a clear-cut right-or-wrong perspective is necessary to maintain order and protect the rights of individuals.
• A holistic view may sometimes overlook the importance of specialized knowledge and expertise that can be crucial in understanding and solving specific problems.
• The notion of oneness, while appealing, may not be empirically verifiable and could be challenged on the grounds of lacking objective evidence.
• The concept of a unifying truth that transcends binaries might be too abstract or vague for practical application within the diverse practices and doctrines of global religions, which often have specific and concrete teachings and rituals.

Recognizing the intricate dance between success and hardship, as well as the coexistence of light and darkness, is crucial for a deep comprehension of spirituality.

Rohr argues that understanding suffering fully requires embracing what Spanish philosopher Miguel de Unamuno has described as the "Tragic Sense of Life."

Rohr emphasizes the significance of comprehending life's intrinsic challenges while maintaining an optimistic and trusting perspective. Facing life's difficulties with courage and honesty requires the recognition that pain, obstacles, and disorder are intrinsic to our very being. The book delves into discovering resilience and significance through life's inevitable fluctuations. He suggests that a mature spiritual outlook not only endures challenges but also strives to discover their hidden value and use these experiences as a catalyst for personal growth.

Other Perspectives

• The concept of the "Tragic Sense of Life" could be seen as overly pessimistic, and some might argue that it is possible to have a full understanding of suffering while maintaining a more positive or neutral outlook on life.
• Some may argue that spirituality can be deeply understood through practices like meditation or prayer, which focus more on inner peace and transcendence rather than the interplay of success and hardship.
• While maintaining optimism is generally beneficial, it can sometimes lead to unrealistic expectations and disappointment when outcomes do not match one's hopeful outlook.
• Emphasizing the intrinsic nature of pain and obstacles could overshadow the importance of joy, pleasure, and well-being, which are also fundamental aspects of human experience.
• Enduring challenges and seeking hidden value in experiences might not always lead to personal growth; sometimes, it can lead to burnout or chronic stress if not managed properly.

As individuals mature, they frequently develop self-awareness, accept their inner darkness, and expand their consciousness during their advanced years.

As we enter the later phases of life, the ego's defensive walls start to crumble, allowing for a deeper connection with the previously unrecognized facets of our self and the fundamental motivations that propel our path forward.

Rohr emphasizes the necessity of facing our internal shadows as a crucial step in spiritual progression. Richard Rohr contends that in life's initial stages, we often devote ourselves to building an identity that is presented to others. Our external persona frequently develops from seeking societal validation, striving to align with societal norms, endeavoring to display an aura of achievement, and the desire to mask our perceived flaws and insecurities. Throughout this voyage of self-discovery, we tend to disregard or downplay aspects of our personality that conflict with the idealized image of ourselves we strive for, including traits like our anger, egotism, and darker tendencies. The concealed facets of our personality that we deny are known as our subconscious alter ego.

As we reach our later years, Rohr suggests that the protective barriers we have carefully constructed begin to crumble. The unavoidable difficulties, obstacles, and losses we encounter in life compel us to face the limitations of our outward identity and recognize our hidden characteristics. Previously hidden or denied facets of our character begin to surface, challenging the integrity of what we once believed to be an unblemished identity. Setting out on this journey might initially stir up feelings of modesty or apprehension, yet it is a crucial move in the pursuit of wholeness.

Addressing and resolving our own shadow aspects is essential and encourages humility; it breaks down the illusions of the ego, leading to an authentic comprehension of oneself and the cultivation of sincere modesty.

Rohr portrays the transformative journey as a process in which we must face and integrate the elements of our persona that we previously tried to conceal or dismiss. The book delves into the journey of acknowledging our imperfections, owning up to our mistakes, and becoming aware of the less attractive aspects that constitute our personality. To progress toward our authentic identity, it's essential to confront and accept the shadowy parts of our character, which dismantles the false exterior we show to the world and uncovers our more sincere essence.

Rohr advises paying close attention to your emotional reactions, particularly when they appear to be disproportionate. When you become overly upset, defensive, or critical, it's probable that something has activated your inner shadow. Resist the urge to reject, dismiss, or hold others responsible for these emotions. Investigate the multifaceted elements that make up who you are with an attitude of curiosity and understanding, seeking to gain insight from the experiences they offer.

Other Perspectives

• Some psychological schools of thought argue that focusing too much on one's shadow aspects can be counterproductive and that building on one's strengths can be a more effective path to personal growth and self-improvement.
• The idea of integrating concealed elements of our persona assumes a level of self-awareness and psychological mindedness that not everyone possesses or values, which could make this process irrelevant or unattainable for some.
• There are different paths to self-understanding, and some individuals may find that focusing on their aspirations and potential, rather than their flaws, is a more effective route to genuine self-comprehension.
• For some individuals, maintaining a certain exterior is a necessary coping mechanism or a professional requirement, and thus they may not perceive the dismantling of this exterior as beneficial or desirable.
• Emotional intelligence involves a broad spectrum of skills, not just the recognition of disproportionate reactions, and it may not be appropriate to reduce the concept of self-awareness to the identification of inner shadows.
• Growth can also occur through outward-focused activities, such as community service or creative endeavors, which may not involve an intensive investigation of one's inner self.

Acknowledging the darker aspects of oneself aids in the development of a more expansive awareness that moves beyond the dualistic thinking typical of early life phases.

Rohr suggests that by exploring the darker aspects of our personal psyche, we can increase our ability to be tolerant, accepting, and empathetic. This expanded awareness sharpens our insight, enabling a more comprehensive and inclusive understanding of ourselves and those around us. It interrupts the habit of categorizing others into allies or adversaries, which leads to assigning blame and forming judgments, and encourages a limited and inflexible perspective on life.

Rohr emphasizes the importance of facing our personal dark sides to not only advance individually but also to cultivate a society that is marked by increased justice and understanding. By acknowledging the darker aspects of ourselves, we reduce the likelihood of projecting them onto other people. We start to recognize the shared characteristics that unite us as human beings, going beyond the differences in our convictions, cultural backgrounds, and worldviews.

Practical Tips

• Use a 'mood tracker' app to record your emotional state at different times of the day. By analyzing the data over time, you can identify what triggers certain emotions and how they influence your perception of yourself and your interactions with others.
• Create a 'challenge journal' where you document instances when you felt inclined to categorize someone as an ally or adversary. For each entry, write down alternative ways to view the situation that don't rely on dualistic thinking. Reflecting on these moments can increase your awareness of your thought patterns and encourage more nuanced interactions with others.
• Engage in role-reversal storytelling where you write or tell a story from the perspective of a person you have negative feelings towards. This can help you explore and understand the qualities you dislike in others and may discover they are aspects of yourself that you've been ignoring.
• Create a "Shared Experiences" photo album on your phone or a social media platform where you capture moments that display universal human experiences, such as laughter, frustration, or acts of kindness. This visual collection will serve as a reminder of the commonalities that exist across different cultures and backgrounds.

This expanded awareness cultivates a profound sense of oneness, compassion, and a readiness to embrace life in all its complexity and contradictions.

Rohr argues that embracing our inner darkness requires a shift in focus from the pursuit of perfection to the recognition and acceptance of the inherent flaws within ourselves and others. He suggests that a mature spiritual outlook seeks not to eradicate the shadows but to integrate them with the brightness, recognizing that wholeness includes both elements.

This wider perspective, he suggests, allows you to appreciate the splendor in the broken, recognize strength in the delicate, and cherish life in its complex and disordered authenticity. Richard Rohr interprets this shift as moving from a position of defensiveness and combativeness to a posture of acceptance, welcoming the world as a whole, with all its imperfections and contradictions.

Practical Tips

• Create an 'imperfection art piece' using materials you have at home, like paper, paint, or clay, to represent your perceived flaws in a physical form. This could be an abstract painting with clashing colors or a sculpture with uneven shapes. The act of creating something that is intentionally imperfect can help you embrace the beauty of imperfection in yourself.
• Create a 'Strength in Delicacy' playlist with music that features instruments or compositions that sound fragile but convey powerful emotions, such as a solo violin piece or a gentle piano melody. Listening to this playlist can help you internalize the concept that delicate forms can hold immense strength and depth.
• Create an 'Embrace the Mess' day once a month where you deliberately avoid planning your activities. Allow the day to unfold naturally, making spontaneous decisions about what to do next. This can help you experience the joy of unpredictability and learn to find contentment in the absence of control.

The theme of "falling upward" through losses and failures

As individuals progress into the advanced phases of life, they frequently perceive challenges, losses, and inevitable hardships as opportunities for personal growth and transformation.

Rohr advises viewing losses as chances for growth, perceiving failures as moments for gaining wisdom, and considering suffering as a catalyst for profound change. He argues that the obstacles we frequently seek to evade are in fact pivotal agents that accelerate our development and deepen our understanding of both ourselves and our surroundings.

Rohr depicts later life stages as an opportunity to ascend through apparent decline, suggesting that a crisis can be pivotal in deconstructing the rigid structures formed during one's youth, thus clearing the way for a more expansive and authentic way of living. He encourages you to cultivate a mindset that embraces new experiences, to reconsider established beliefs, and to welcome novel perspectives with an open heart. He proposes that through turmoil, loss, and unforeseen interactions, we are beckoned onward by a divine invitation towards a more abundant existence.

Obstacles once seen as impediments are now recognized as catalysts for deeper inquiry.

Rohr proposes viewing the difficulties and struggles that have disrupted your equilibrium, challenged your beliefs, or inflicted suffering as potential calls to embark on a more profound exploration. Disruptions, such as falling, failing, and relinquishing control, are the circumstances through which Rohr contends we acquire our deepest understanding.

He exemplifies this concept by emphasizing the paradox within the Gospel, where triumph is attained through the savior's experience of crucifixion and demise. He regards embracing suffering and the significant transformation it can induce as a sharp contrast to the youthful tendency to avoid, deny, or attempt to eliminate pain and challenges.

Other Perspectives

• The idea that struggles lead to deeper understanding could be misinterpreted as romanticizing or glorifying suffering, which could potentially minimize the real pain and hardship that people experience.
• While disruptions can lead to growth, they can also exacerbate existing mental health issues, leading to negative outcomes rather than positive transformation.
• Suffering without reflection or support may not lead to transformation but to a sense of hopelessness or despair.
• Some philosophical perspectives argue that triumph can be achieved through joy, success, and positive experiences rather than through suffering and demise.
• Avoiding, denying, or attempting to eliminate pain can be a valid survival strategy, and in some cases, it is a necessary step towards self-care and mental health preservation.

Encountering setbacks and imperfections does not signify weakness but instead acts as portals to a wider, humbler, and more interwoven life.

Rohr emphasizes that our genuine power is manifested through our openness to being vulnerable and accepting our imperfections. He contends that embracing our failures and acknowledging our flaws and limitations demonstrates bravery rather than a lack of strength. During life's difficult times, we learn the significance of letting go of our need to dominate, leading us to discover a deeper reality and revealing a path that embodies authenticity and humility.

Rohr asserts that to surmount challenges, one must tread the journey with assurance, fortified by the understanding that even in our most difficult moments, we are accompanied. He suggests that through our mistakes, we are consistently offered divine assistance, which provides both compassion and guidance, enabling us to emerge with greater wisdom and fortitude.

Other Perspectives

• Genuine power can also be demonstrated through resilience and the ability to overcome imperfections, not just by accepting them.
• Acknowledging flaws and limitations might sometimes be seen as a sign of self-awareness rather than bravery, as it does not always require overcoming significant fear or risk.
• Authenticity and humility can also be achieved through other means, such as self-reflection, empathy, and the pursuit of personal excellence, without necessarily relinquishing control or dominance.
• In some cases, uncertainty rather than assurance can be beneficial, as it may encourage a more cautious and thorough approach to problem-solving.
• Some may argue that attributing overcoming challenges to divine assistance diminishes the role of personal agency and the human capacity for resilience and problem-solving.
• The concept that mistakes lead to wisdom can sometimes be used to downplay or dismiss the real harm caused by those mistakes, especially when they affect others.

The subsequent stage is characterized by an awareness of bittersweetness, blending happiness with sadness, which cultivates deep understanding and creative expression.

As people advance through their later years, they encounter a deep fusion of happiness and grief, which Rohr characterizes as a radiant sadness. As we age, our capacity to accept life's full range, with its victories and losses, joy and sorrow, expands within our increasingly open hearts.

The author, Richard Rohr, explores the concept of fully experiencing the range of human emotions, beyond simply wallowing in sadness, which he describes as a radiant form of melancholy. One comes to realize that the deep and splendid moments of life are often intertwined with periods of sorrow, unease, and impermanence. It entails letting go of the urge to rectify, control, or guarantee that everything is precisely arranged. Life's mysterious essence, encompassing everything from joy to sorrow and triumphs to obstacles, must be wholeheartedly accepted.

Other Perspectives

• Not all individuals in their later years experience a blend of happiness and grief; some may find that they experience predominantly one emotion over the other.
• Cognitive decline in some elderly individuals can affect emotional processing and regulation, potentially limiting their capacity to fully experience and accept a range of emotions.
• Some cultural viewpoints may not align with Rohr's approach, as they may prioritize collective well-being and harmony over individual emotional experiences, especially those that involve dwelling on sadness.
• Life's deep moments can also be experienced in times of stability and permanence, suggesting that depth is not exclusively tied to sorrow or impermanence.
• In certain situations, such as in crisis management or emergency response, the need to control and guarantee outcomes is critical and can save lives.
• The idea of embracing all aspects of life could be seen as a form of passivity or fatalism, potentially discouraging individuals from striving to change or improve their circumstances.