PDF Summary:Crusaders, by Dan Jones

What transformed a quest to reclaim Jerusalem into a transcontinental crusading movement spanning centuries? In Crusaders, Dan Jones explores the religious conviction, expansionist ambition, and complex political maneuvering that drove history's holy wars.

The text examines the interplay between secular leaders and the church that ignited the crusading spirit. Besides chronicling renowned battles and the establishment of crusader states, Jones scrutinizes how crusading fervor was redirected against perceived foes beyond the Holy Land—including efforts to subjugate pagans along the Baltic shores. As extraordinary conquests solidified crusaders' realms, religious zeal fueled expanding violence, leaving a complex legacy.

(continued)...

• Dive into history podcasts focusing on the Crusades to gain a deeper understanding of the events and their impact on modern society. By listening to podcasts, you can absorb information during your daily commute or while doing household chores, making learning about history convenient and accessible.
• Improve your physical fitness and coordination by engaging in sports that demand agility and quick reflexes, such as basketball or soccer. These activities can help you experience and understand the value of maneuverability in a physical context, which can translate to better spatial awareness and quicker response times in various aspects of life.
• Apply the element of surprise in competitive scenarios by analyzing competitors' expected moves and preparing unconventional responses that can give you an edge, similar to how the unexpected tactics of the Turkish archers caught the Crusaders off guard.
• You can enhance your personal discipline by creating a "formation routine" for your daily tasks. Start by listing your daily activities and then organize them into a structured schedule that mimics a disciplined formation. For example, align your morning routine in a sequence that flows logically from waking up to leaving the house, ensuring each task is completed before moving to the next, just as a Crusader would maintain their position in formation.
• You can enhance your team's performance by forming strategic alliances with other groups that have complementary skills. Just as the Crusaders' victory was amplified by additional forces, you can look for partners or collaborators in your field who can bring new strengths to the table. For example, if you're working on a community project, reach out to local businesses for sponsorship or support, which could provide both funding and expertise.
• Create a themed book club focused on historical conflicts and their modern implications. By gathering a group of friends or like-minded individuals to read and discuss books on similar historical events, you can explore the ripple effects of the Crusaders' actions on today's world. This can lead to a broader understanding of how past conflicts shape current geopolitical landscapes.
• You can enhance your physical fitness by adopting a medieval workout routine that mimics the training of a crusader. Start by researching historical exercises such as sword drills, shield carries, and armored runs. Incorporate these into a weekly fitness plan, gradually increasing intensity to build strength and endurance akin to that of a medieval warrior.
• Develop a personal branding strategy that emphasizes your strengths and unique qualities, akin to the formidable reputation of the Crusaders. Start by listing your top five personal and professional strengths, then create a narrative around these that you can communicate consistently across your social media profiles, resume, and in networking situations. This could involve sharing stories of past successes or testimonials that highlight your capabilities, thereby creating an aura of competence and reliability.

The fall and subsequent loss of Antioch: The Extended Winter Season, Internal Conflicts, and triumphant exploits of Bohemond of Taranto

Jones offers an in-depth exploration of the arduous obstacles faced during the winter blockade of Antioch, underscoring the city's importance due to its formidable defenses. Despite their earlier triumph at Dorylaeum, the crusaders endured a prolonged and harsh siege characterized by scarcity, starvation, and illness. Disputes often emerged among the Frankish leaders, particularly regarding the governance of the city, with Bohemond of Taranto and Raymond of Toulouse both vying for control.

The author highlights the pivotal role of treachery and the decisive actions of an armorer who, by betraying his peers, enabled Bohemond's forces to infiltrate the city undetected, surprising the Turkish guards during the night. The resolute Christian residents joined the crusaders in a brutal slaughter as they rampaged across the cities. The capture of Antioch was a crucial turning point, as Jones emphasizes, allowing the crusaders to secure a defensible position within Syrian territory. The triumph, while significant, only deepened the divisions among the Frankish leaders.

Practical Tips

• Improve your home's security by learning from historical strongholds. Evaluate your home's current security measures and identify potential vulnerabilities. Then, research ancient defense mechanisms and adapt those concepts to modern security, such as creating a well-lit perimeter or ensuring your doors and windows are robust and secure.
• Volunteer with an organization that supports people in crisis to gain perspective on handling scarcity and adversity. By helping others, you can develop empathy and learn new coping strategies. Look for local food banks, shelters, or disaster relief organizations where you can contribute your time and learn from the resilience of those you're helping.
• Enhance your personal security by adopting a 'need to know' policy in sensitive matters. Just as the armorer had access to critical information that led to Antioch's fall, limit the amount of sensitive information you share with others. Start by categorizing the information you typically share into levels of sensitivity and then decide who in your circles should have access to each level.
• Engage in role-playing games or simulations that involve strategy and alliance-building, such as board games or online games that simulate historical battles or political scenarios. Pay attention to how alliances form and what triggers conflict or cooperation. Reflect on these experiences to better understand the complexities of human interactions during times of upheaval.
• Create a 'defensible position' in your finances by establishing an emergency fund. This fund acts as a buffer against unexpected expenses, much like Antioch provided a strategic advantage to the crusaders. Start by setting aside a small amount of money each week or month until you have saved enough to cover at least three to six months of living expenses.
• Practice proactive communication during times of success. When you achieve a win in a team setting, initiate a conversation to discuss how the success can be leveraged for future projects and to address any concerns about the direction moving forward. This can help prevent the success from inadvertently creating divisions by ensuring all team members feel heard and valued.

The taking of Jerusalem: An exhibition of fervent religious devotion, overwhelming military strength, and the severe methods used by the invading troops.

Jones masterfully narrates the story of Jerusalem's extended and fierce blockade, which reached its peak in July 1099. Despite the exhaustion from their arduous journey, their commitment to capturing the holy city for Christianity remained steadfast, evidenced by their penitential acts and firm conviction in carrying out what they saw as divine instruction. The author also highlights the sophisticated tactics employed by the crusaders, including their deployment of complex siege equipment, exemplified by a towering edifice topped with a golden cross, which was instrumental in defeating the Fatimid adversaries.

However, Jones does not shy away from describing the horrific acts of brutality that ensued after the victory. He offers a detailed portrayal, drawing from direct narratives, of the massacre of Jerusalem's inhabitants, the desecration of holy sites, and the forced renunciation of their beliefs by the surviving Jewish and Muslim residents. Jones contends that the capture of Jerusalem was a pivotal event in the history of the crusades, highlighting the potent combination of religious fervor and the brutal nature of combat in the name of a sacred cause.

Practical Tips

• Improve your crisis management abilities by participating in simulations that mimic the pressures of a siege. Engage in activities like escape rooms or survival challenges that force you to work under constraints and limited resources. These experiences can teach you to stay calm and make critical decisions under pressure, drawing parallels to historical events without the need for specialized knowledge or skills.
• You can explore the impact of fervent dedication by committing to a personal project with a clear, meaningful goal. Choose something you're passionate about, set a deadline, and dedicate a specific amount of time each day to work on it. This mirrors the crusaders' devotion and allows you to experience the power of focused commitment in achieving an objective.
• Develop a creative thinking workshop for your peers using the concept of complex siege equipment as a metaphor for innovation. Encourage participants to design their own 'siege equipment' for overcoming obstacles in personal projects, fostering a mindset that looks for inventive solutions rather than conventional ones.
• Create a personal blog or social media campaign highlighting historical and contemporary instances of religious coercion. Sharing stories and information can raise awareness among your peers and encourage a dialogue about the importance of maintaining religious liberties in society.

The establishment, persistence, and eventual collapse of the domains established by the Crusaders.

The creation of the Crusader States marked the inception of new territories and the solidification of political authority.

This section delves into the methods used by the Frankish newcomers to assert dominance and govern the newly conquered lands amidst the volatile conditions of the eastern Mediterranean. The author focuses on the era during which Baldwin I founded the Latin kingdom of Jerusalem, followed by the reign of Fulk and Melisende, which was marked by significant expansion of the crusader territories across the Holy Land. Jones emphasizes that despite initial triumphs, the inherent fragility of the crusader states was destined to lead to their eventual collapse.

Baldwin I's reign in Jerusalem was marked by the creation of a dominion reminiscent of Western European governance, despite encountering a multitude of challenges both internally and from neighboring territories.

Dan Jones highlights the significance of Baldwin I's governance in Jerusalem, especially the influence of Norman crusaders who gained prominence in the emerging Latin kingdom due to their participation in the First Crusade. Baldwin, drawing on the triumphs of his brother Godfrey, adeptly established dominance over the lands surrounding Jerusalem, overcoming obstacles posed by the Egyptian Fatimid forces and the volatile political landscape within the regions held by the crusaders. The writer highlights how the reign of Baldwin was marked by a fragile balance of power among various Frankish factions, which in turn weakened the kingdom's overall might.

Context

• He established legal institutions and courts based on European models, which helped in administering justice and maintaining order within the kingdom.
• The Normans, along with other Western European crusaders, introduced Western European cultural and religious practices to the region, which affected local customs and the administration of the kingdom.
• He built and reinforced castles and fortifications, such as the Tower of David in Jerusalem, to protect against invasions and assert dominance over key territories.
• The constant threat from the Fatimids required Baldwin to maintain a strong military presence, which strained the limited economic resources of the nascent Kingdom of Jerusalem.
• The presence of various Christian sects and the need to manage relations with the local Eastern Christian populations added another layer of complexity to maintaining internal harmony.

During the reign of Fulk and Melisende, there was an equitable distribution of authority and a nurturing of cultural interactions, alongside a broadening of the Crusaders' dominion in the Holy Land.

Jones provides a thorough analysis of the era during which King Fulk and Queen Melisende jointly governed in the central years of the twelfth century. In 1129, Fulk traveled from Anjou to enter into marriage with Melisende and rise to a position of influence, yet he quickly sought to reduce his wife's influence and the authority of the established nobility in preference for the entourage he had accompanied from Anjou. Melisende, a woman of sharp intellect and unwavering determination, successfully overcame these obstacles and solidified her position as the co-ruler of Jerusalem.

Jones contends that, despite inherent tensions, the alliance ultimately led to positive outcomes for the realm. Drawing on Fulk's knowledge of military defense and administrative governance, Melisende guided their path, leading to a cultural revival characterized by the construction of magnificent edifices, the founding of spiritual centers, and the creation of ornately adorned manuscripts. The writer highlights that the Latin states, notwithstanding their successes, were compelled to shift from an expansionist approach to a defensive posture in response to the increasing threats posed by Turkish figures such as Zengi.

Context

• The tension between Fulk and Melisende could have led to initial instability in the realm, requiring careful negotiation and compromise to maintain effective governance and stability in the kingdom.
• Melisende's successful co-rule set a precedent for female leadership in the region, influencing future generations and demonstrating the potential for women to wield power effectively in a male-dominated society.
• The construction projects and cultural activities likely stimulated the local economy, providing jobs and encouraging trade within and beyond the Crusader states.
• The cultural revival under Melisende included significant architectural projects, such as the expansion of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem, which became a major pilgrimage site.
• The construction of edifices during this time often reflected a blend of Western European and local architectural styles, incorporating elements such as Romanesque and Gothic features alongside Islamic and Byzantine influences.
• The production and ownership of ornately adorned manuscripts were often associated with wealth and status. Commissioning such works was a way for rulers and nobles to display their piety, power, and cultural sophistication.
• The Crusader states were surrounded by powerful Muslim territories, and the rise of leaders like Zengi posed a direct threat to their survival. This necessitated a focus on building stronger defenses and alliances to withstand potential sieges and attacks.

The Crusading forces' failure to capture Aleppo highlighted their diminishing influence in an era that transitioned from territorial expansion to maintaining control.

Jones highlights the instability of the Frankish rule in the eastern Mediterranean during the 1120s by analyzing the failed endeavor to capture Aleppo. The city, governed by a collection of conflicting Seljuq emirs, was an alluring prize, leading to a series of military expeditions aimed at taking over, which ultimately led to the calamitous confrontation that occurred in June 1122, culminating in a catastrophic loss for the crusaders in the encounter that became known as the Field of Blood, inflicted by the Turkish atabeg Ilghazi.

The author emphasized the profound influence the struggle exerted on the Franks, which enhanced their military capabilities and strengthened their resolve. Despite the arrival of additional troops from the West, Baldwin II's subsequent endeavors to seize Aleppo did not succeed, prompting the Latin crusaders to recognize their limitations in power and concentrate on consolidating their presence along the coastlines.

Context

• The failure to capture Aleppo was part of a larger pattern of declining Crusader influence in the Levant, as Muslim forces gradually regained territories and the initial zeal of the Crusading movement waned over time.
• By the 12th century, the Seljuq Empire had fragmented into smaller, semi-independent states or emirates. This fragmentation often led to internal conflicts and power struggles among local rulers, known as emirs.
• Ilghazi was the Artuqid ruler of Mardin and a prominent military leader who played a crucial role in the battle. His forces were instrumental in the defeat of the Crusaders at the Field of Blood.
• The experience gained from these battles contributed to the evolution of medieval warfare, influencing tactics and military organization in Europe.
• The Seljuq Turks were a formidable force in the region, with skilled cavalry and knowledge of the terrain, which gave them an advantage in defending against Crusader advances.
• The focus on coastal consolidation marked a strategic shift from aggressive inland expansion to defensive fortification, reflecting a pragmatic approach to maintaining their existing territories.

A new cadre of knights came into prominence. The formation of military orders and the evolution of the crusades into a conflict sanctioned officially by the church.

This section explores the crucial evolution of the crusades, underscoring the emergence of martial brotherhoods and the creation of a unique chivalric code dedicated to sustained, structured engagement in holy wars. The author focuses on how the Templars were founded and grew, as well as Bernard of Clairvaux's influence in defining their objectives and convictions.

Hugh of Payns was the founder of the Templars, marking the beginning of a perpetual religious conflict.

The author describes the evolution of a small group of knights who vowed in 1119 into the Templars, a groundbreaking band of warriors committed to the protection of pilgrims journeying through the sacred territories of the Holy Land. They led a life of monastic discipline, intertwining their combat prowess with solemn commitments to live without personal wealth, remain celibate, and follow orders, all while being mentored by the esteemed Hugh of Payns from Champagne. Jones emphasizes the innovative nature of this "new knighthood," widely acclaimed throughout Western Europe for launching a succession of unyielding crusading endeavors.

Context

• Their headquarters were located on the Temple Mount in Jerusalem, a site of immense religious significance to Christians, Jews, and Muslims, which contributed to their name.
• The vow of celibacy was intended to keep the knights free from familial obligations and distractions, allowing them to dedicate themselves entirely to their religious and military duties.
• Hugh of Payns traveled extensively across Europe to recruit members and secure funding, significantly expanding the order's influence and resources.
• They established a network of fortifications and commanderies across Europe and the Middle East, which helped sustain their military campaigns and logistical operations.
• The Templars were unique in that they combined the roles of monks and knights, living under a strict religious rule while also engaging in military activities, which was a novel concept at the time.

The Hospitallers evolved from a role dedicated to aiding travelers on religious journeys to one centered on martial protection.

The writer also examines the evolution of the Hospitallers as well as the Templars. The Hospitallers, initially established to offer medical assistance to pilgrims in their Jerusalem hospital, expanded their mission to include the armed defense of the Holy Land. Jones argues that the crusader states saw a marked improvement in their military capabilities around the middle of the twelfth century, thanks to the vital contributions of the two orders in strengthening frontier defenses, providing seasoned warriors to the crusader forces, and offering essential support to leaders like Baldwin II. Jones portrays their way of life as emblematic of the increasing importance of structured military operations in the East, underscoring the imperative of perpetual preparedness for combat to counteract dangers from outside their frontiers.

Other Perspectives

• The Hospitallers' initial establishment for medical assistance was not solely for pilgrims; they also served to aid the sick and poor locals of Jerusalem.
• The expansion of the Hospitallers' mission may not have been as clear-cut as a shift from aid to military defense; it could have been a gradual integration of martial duties alongside their caregiving roles.
• The effectiveness of the Hospitallers and Templars can be partly attributed to the financial and logistical support they received from Europe, suggesting that their impact was not solely due to their own martial prowess.
• The term "seasoned warriors" could be misleading, as it implies a level of experience and skill that may not have been uniformly present among all members of the orders.
• The focus on the orders' support to Baldwin II might overshadow the contributions of other groups or individuals who were also instrumental in the defense and administration of the crusader states.
• The notion of improvement could be subjective; what constituted an improvement in military capabilities could vary depending on the metrics used to assess military strength.
• The importance of structured military operations may be overstated, as the fluid and often unpredictable nature of warfare in the East sometimes required more adaptable and less structured approaches.
• A state of continuous combat readiness can lead to the neglect of diplomatic avenues for conflict resolution, which can be more sustainable and less costly than military engagement.

Bernard of Clairvaux played a pivotal role in establishing key doctrines and spiritual rules for the military monastic orders.

The author explores the pivotal role played by Bernard of Clairvaux in laying the foundational ideological and structural framework for the military-monastic orders. Dan Jones details Bernard's crucial involvement in establishing the foundational rules for the Templars at the 1129 Council of Troyes. Bernard, guided by his Cistercian values, commended the military orders for their pious devotion and combat prowess, endorsing their martial endeavors as a holy duty to vanquish God's adversaries.

Jones contends that Bernard was instrumental in the crusading endeavors, serving both as a recruiter of participants and as a significant intellectual and theological influence, especially in relation to the Second Crusade. His writings provided a religious rationale that depicted the military orders as strong representations of Christianity's inherent combative nature, justifying their aggressive behavior.

Context

• Bernard's involvement in the Second Crusade (1147-1150) included preaching and rallying support, highlighting his role in promoting and sustaining the crusading movement through religious fervor.
• This was a significant ecclesiastical council held in 1129, where the formal recognition and endorsement of the Knights Templar took place. It was convened by Pope Honorius II and attended by prominent church leaders, which gave the Templars legitimacy and a formal rule to follow.
• The Cistercian order, known for its emphasis on austerity, simplicity, and piety, influenced Bernard's vision of the military orders, promoting a disciplined and devout lifestyle even within the context of warfare.
• His advocacy was crucial in gaining the support of European monarchs, such as King Louis VII of France and Emperor Conrad III of Germany, who led the crusading forces.
• While Bernard's views were influential, they also sparked debate and criticism, both in his time and later, regarding the morality and ethics of using violence in the name of religion.

The Waning of Crusader-Controlled Regions: From Weakening Leadership to Overwhelming External Threats

This section of the text explores the factors that precipitated the eventual downfall of the territories governed by the crusaders. The writer scrutinizes the turmoil that ensued due to internal discord and feeble leadership after the conclusion of the Second Crusade. He underscores the crucial role played by individuals such as Nur al-Din and Saladin in unifying the Muslim states against the incursions of the Franks and details the severe consequences faced by the crusaders in their failed attempt to expand their control into Egypt.

Internal Divisions and the Erosion of Authority Among the Franks: The Perils of Succession Disputes and the Destabilizing Impact of the Ensuing Crusader Campaigns.

Jones argues that the political situation within the crusader states in the middle of the twelfth century was fundamentally precarious, characterized by a significant escalation of internal conflicts and splits among different groups. He underscores the strife and ambitions within the noble class, highlighting the acrimonious ties between King Fulk and Queen Melisende, along with the persistent rivalries among noble families vying for control of Jerusalem, Antioch, and Tripoli. The author documents the disastrous consequences ensuing from the end of the Second Crusade, which instead of reinforcing the Latin states, led to a devastating military defeat that exacerbated tensions with the Byzantine allies.

Jones contends that this event marked a pivotal transformation in the structuring of the military forces of the crusader states. The disintegration of the Second Crusade underscored the inherent weakness of relying on sporadic support from the West, compounded by the increasing disputes within the ranks of the Frankish leaders in the East, which left them ill-equipped to face the mounting threat of the Islamic revival.

Context

• The vast distance between the crusader states and their European supporters made communication and coordination difficult, leading to delays and misunderstandings.
• The lack of clear succession laws often led to disputes over leadership, as multiple claimants could vie for power, leading to civil wars and instability.
• The noble class was not homogenous; it included individuals from various European regions, each bringing their own customs and rivalries, which could exacerbate tensions.
• King Fulk of Anjou married Queen Melisende of Jerusalem in 1129, creating a union meant to strengthen the Kingdom of Jerusalem. Fulk was a seasoned crusader and a powerful noble from France, while Melisende was the daughter of King Baldwin II of Jerusalem, ensuring her strong claim to the throne.
• Control of key cities like Jerusalem, Antioch, and Tripoli was not only a matter of political power but also economic gain. These cities were important trade hubs, and controlling them meant access to wealth from trade routes connecting Europe, Asia, and Africa.
• The defeat highlighted the limitations of relying on external crusading forces, prompting a shift towards more localized military strategies and alliances, which were often undermined by internal disputes and lack of cohesion.
• The journey from Europe to the Holy Land was perilous and lengthy, involving crossing hostile territories and difficult terrain. This made the mobilization of large armies challenging and often resulted in significant losses before even reaching the Levant.
• The cost of maintaining armies and fortifications in the East was immense, and disputes over resources and trade routes further weakened the financial stability of the crusader states.

Nur al-Din and Saladin played a pivotal role in unifying Islamic territories in the Middle East by advocating for a sacred war.

Jones emphasizes the rise to prominence of Nur al-Din and Saladin as key figures in the Islamic realm. In the twelfth century, the fervent and ambitious Nur al-Din, a descendant of Zengi, skillfully unified his power over an extensive region of Syrian land, taking advantage of the disunity among the Frankish leaders and successfully mobilizing the call for jihad to unite opposition to the crusaders. Saladin extended the reach of the Ayyubid dynasty by annexing Egypt and, following his succession to Nur al-Din, he managed to consolidate one of the largest Islamic realms in the Near East under his leadership.

The author suggests that Saladin effectively positioned himself as the defender of Islam, skillfully channeling religious fervor to consolidate support among Muslims, which in turn positioned him as a formidable opponent to the increasingly fragmented and isolated Crusader states. The unification of Muslim forces under the command of a significant figure such as Saladin, Jones proposes, would have significant negative consequences for the Christian territories in the Holy Land.

Context

• The call for jihad was not only a military strategy but also a way to invoke religious duty and unity among Muslims. It was a powerful tool to inspire and legitimize the efforts to reclaim lands considered sacred in Islam.
• He was known for his patronage of Islamic scholars and the construction of religious institutions, which helped legitimize his rule and promote Sunni Islam as a unifying force in the region.
• Nur al-Din was adept at forming strategic alliances with other Muslim leaders and tribes, which helped him exploit the divisions among the Crusaders and strengthen his own position.
• Nur al-Din was the son of Imad ad-Din Zengi, a prominent Turkish atabeg who initially captured Edessa, a key Crusader stronghold. This legacy provided Nur al-Din with a foundation of military and political influence.
• The annexation provided Saladin with access to Egypt's wealth, including its agricultural output and the ability to levy taxes, which were crucial for funding his military campaigns against the Crusader states.
• The Ayyubid dynasty, established by Saladin, was a Sunni Muslim dynasty of Kurdish origin that ruled large parts of the Middle East during the 12th and 13th centuries.
• Saladin's leadership and victories, especially the recapture of Jerusalem in 1187, became legendary in Islamic history, enhancing his reputation as a chivalrous and just leader, which was important for maintaining morale and support among his followers.
• A unified Muslim front under Saladin could negotiate from a position of strength with European powers, potentially isolating the Crusader states diplomatically and reducing their support from Europe.

Amalric I's aggressive campaigns to gain dominion over Egypt underscore the tense and often lethal interactions between the Crusaders and the Ayyubids.

During the reign of King Amalric I, the author explores the intensifying strain between the Crusader states and Fatimid Egypt, particularly during the concluding decades of the twelfth century. Amalric initiated multiple campaigns to seize control of lands within the Nile Delta, capitalizing on Egypt's vulnerability and its significance as a pillar of Ayyubid strength. His strategy, while initially yielding success, eventually led to unintended negative consequences.

Jones highlights the complex web of alliances and trickery that characterized the period, focusing on how Shawar skillfully played Amalric and Nur al-Din against each other to further his own political ambitions. Ultimately, however, the aggressive territorial ambitions of Amalric culminated in disastrous events, paving the way for Saladin's rise to power in Egypt and setting the stage for the disastrous defeat at Hattin, which was succeeded by the capitulation of Jerusalem in 1187.

Context

• The interactions between the Crusaders and the Ayyubids were not only military but also deeply rooted in religious and cultural conflicts, as both sides viewed the struggle as a holy war.
• The Nile Delta was a fertile and economically vital region, crucial for agricultural production and trade routes, making it a valuable target for any power seeking control over Egypt.
• Amalric I's campaigns initially succeeded due to Egypt's internal political instability and the weakening of the Fatimid Caliphate, which made it vulnerable to external threats.
• Shawar's shifting alliances were part of a broader strategy to play larger powers against each other, ensuring that neither could dominate Egypt completely, thus preserving his own authority.
• Nur al-Din was a powerful Muslim leader in Syria who sought to unify Muslim territories against the Crusaders. His involvement in Egyptian affairs was partly a response to Amalric's campaigns.
• Shirkuh led several military campaigns in Egypt on behalf of Nur al-Din. After Shawar's assassination, Shirkuh briefly became the vizier of Egypt, paving the way for Saladin's succession.

The lasting impact of the Crusades and the dangers linked to their exploitation by radical factions.

The impact of the Crusades stretched far, influencing areas that spanned the entire Mediterranean and reached as far as the shores of the Baltic Sea.

The study delves into the transformation of the crusades' initial goal, initially aimed at liberating Jerusalem from Muslim rule, into conflicts with various opponents across multiple settings. Dan Jones's narrative delves into the military campaigns of Norway's Sigurd I, explores the Sicilian incursions into North African lands, discusses how Pope Innocent III broadened the scope of crusading, and examines the Teutonic Knights' territorial advancement into the Baltic area. The scope of activities associated with crusading expanded, leading to greater intricacy and division, underscoring the complex and highly situational character of these expeditions.

Sigurd I of Norway embarked on a voyage that was both a pious crusading endeavor and an expedition with military objectives.

Jones highlights the fluctuation between devout zeal and the quest for riches within the crusading movement by detailing King Sigurd I of Norway's pilgrimage to holy lands from 1107 to 1111. Sigurd, fueled by intense religious passion and the essence of Viking exploration, led a fleet of longships across Europe, initiating assaults and plundering Islamic communities during their passage through Iberia, before finally arriving in Palestine. He worked closely with King Baldwin I of Jerusalem, significantly contributing to the surrounding and subsequent capture of Sidon.

The writer argues that the savagery of Sigurd's campaign does not correspond exactly with the actions that would subsequently be defined as a crusade. Sigurd did not formally pledge himself as a crusader, nor did he heed a call to arms from the Pope. Rather, he was driven by personal ambition, a desire to demonstrate prowess, and the prospect of rich plunder. Jones portrays Sigurd's exploits, emphasizing the indistinct boundaries between typical Viking incursions into non-Christian territories, the act of crusading, and the notion of an armed pilgrimage.

Context

• During his time in the Holy Land, Sigurd formed alliances with local Christian rulers, such as King Baldwin I of Jerusalem, which were crucial for the success of his military endeavors.
• These expeditions facilitated cultural and technological exchanges between the East and West, impacting European society in areas such as science, medicine, and trade.
• The use of longships by Sigurd's fleet was a hallmark of Viking military strategy, allowing for swift raids and coastal assaults. This technology played a crucial role in the success of his campaign across Europe.
• Baldwin I was the first King of Jerusalem, ruling from 1100 to 1118. He was a key figure in consolidating the Crusader states in the Levant, having previously been Count of Edessa. His reign was marked by efforts to strengthen and expand the Christian territories in the region.
• These were feudal states established by Western European crusaders in the Levant during the Middle Ages. The capture of cities like Sidon was crucial for their defense and economic stability.
• A key feature of a crusade was the formal endorsement by the Pope, often accompanied by spiritual incentives like indulgences. Sigurd's journey lacked this official papal sanction, distinguishing it from recognized crusades.
• Those who took the crusader vow often wore a cross on their clothing as a symbol of their commitment. This was a visible sign of their status as crusaders, which Sigurd did not adopt.
• The promise of acquiring wealth through plunder was a significant motivator for many leaders of the era. Successful campaigns could bring back valuable goods, which were crucial for maintaining the economy and rewarding loyal followers.
• Unlike traditional pilgrimages, which were peaceful journeys to holy sites, armed pilgrimages involved traveling with military force. Participants might have spiritual goals but were prepared to engage in combat, reflecting a blend of religious devotion and martial readiness.

Roger II and George of Antioch implemented a unique and pragmatic approach to their martial campaigns in Ifriqiya throughout the Sicilian Conquests.

The author details how Roger II systematically extended his Sicilian realm into North African lands, highlighting the court's notably pragmatic approach in their pursuit of crusading objectives. Roger, inheriting the Norman penchant for conquest and incorporating aspects of Arab administration, leveraged his formidable maritime capabilities to establish Sicilian dominance over Ifriqiya's shoreline municipalities, thereby acquiring trading locations and obliging the shoreline communities to pay regular dues. George of Antioch, who hailed from Syria, became the foremost advisor and the commander of the naval forces under Roger, playing a pivotal role in the military affairs of the island while remaining a follower of Orthodox Christianity.

Jones argues that Roger's intense military campaigns in Ifriqiya were propelled by more than just religious zeal. Their objective was to broaden and solidify Sicily's influence across the central Mediterranean, reflecting the island's unique blend of Latin, Greek, and Muslim cultural elements. Jones suggests that the flexible doctrines associated with the crusading efforts underscore their capacity to align with diverse economic and political goals, going beyond the typical boundaries of holy warfare.

Context

• Roger II's court was known for its cultural diversity, incorporating Latin, Greek, and Arab influences. This multicultural environment allowed for a more adaptable and pragmatic approach to governance and military strategy, which was reflected in their campaigns.
• Roger II was the King of Sicily from 1130 to 1154. His reign was marked by the consolidation of Norman power in the Mediterranean, and he was known for his administrative acumen and cultural patronage.
• Under George's command, the Sicilian navy became one of the most formidable maritime forces in the Mediterranean. He introduced advanced shipbuilding techniques and strategic innovations that were crucial in securing Sicilian dominance over the seas.
• George of Antioch was originally from the Byzantine Empire, which was predominantly Orthodox Christian. His background in this region would have provided him with a unique perspective on both Eastern and Western Christian traditions.
• The conquests in Ifriqiya had a lasting impact on the region, influencing the political and cultural landscape of the Mediterranean. Roger II's rule is often seen as a precursor to later European colonial and expansionist endeavors in Africa.
• The integration of diverse military tactics from different cultures, such as the use of both cavalry and naval forces, allowed the Normans to conduct effective campaigns across the Mediterranean, including in Ifriqiya.

Pope Innocent III expanded the definition of holy warfare to encompass not only conventional foes but also groups deemed heretical and those who posed a political threat.

The author emphasizes that Pope Innocent III played a crucial role in expanding the definition of a crusade to encompass a range of new foes, including those arising from within the Christian faith itself. Innocent, a skilled lawyer and political tactician, understood the potent appeal of the crusading zeal and utilized it to confront those who threatened the authority of the papacy, such as the heretical factions in southern France and secular authorities who defied his mandates.

Jones portrays Innocent as having a broader and more widely applicable concept of crusading than his predecessor did. He adeptly portrayed the crusades as a tactical tool for the Vatican, promoting their deployment against foes beyond the ecclesiastical jurisdiction and against threats within, thereby demonstrating their utility in advancing the church's wider objectives.

Context

• Heretical groups, like the Cathars and Waldensians, were seen as threats to the Church's doctrinal authority. Innocent III's policies aimed to suppress these movements, which were gaining followers and challenging the Church's teachings.
• Originally intended to reclaim Jerusalem, the Fourth Crusade was diverted to Constantinople, leading to the sacking of the city in 1204. This event highlighted the complex interplay of religious and political motives in Innocent's era.
• The use of crusades as a tool for political and religious control had long-term effects on the relationship between the Church and secular rulers, often leading to tensions and power struggles as the papacy sought to assert its dominance.
• Innocent III, trained in canon law, provided legal and theological justifications for these expanded crusades, framing them as necessary for the defense of Christendom and the papal authority.

Hermann von Salza was instrumental in establishing a state in the Baltic region governed by the Teutonic Knights and committed to the crusading cause.

Jones details the development of the Teutonic Order, highlighting their significant contribution to the Crusades that ultimately led to the establishment of a powerful state in the Baltic, governed by a blend of monastic and military principles. Hermann von Salza, who took the helm of the order in 1210, skillfully steered the group to new areas of engagement after acknowledging the limited sway of Western European powers in the Holy Land following the Fifth Crusade. Von Salza, through his skillful diplomacy and strategic expertise, secured backing from both Frederick II Hohenstaufen and Pope Gregory IX, which enabled the Teutonic Knights to launch a major crusade against the pagan Prussians beginning in 1230.

Dan Jones illustrates how the group's forceful and triumphant tactics in taking control of Prussia, which involved mandatory Christianization and the eradication of native populations, exemplify the enduring consequences of the crusades' brutal conduct in different contexts. The establishment of the Teutonic Knights' ordensstaat, as underscored by Jones, marks a crucial example of the lasting impact of the crusades, signifying a major transition away from their initial focus on the holy lands of Jerusalem.

Context

• Hermann von Salza, as the Grand Master, was pivotal in transforming the order from a small group focused on the Holy Land into a significant political and military power in Europe.
• The order's influence waned after defeats such as the Battle of Grunwald in 1410, and their territories were eventually secularized, but their legacy persisted in the cultural and historical narratives of the region.
• The term "ordensstaat" refers to the state-like entity governed by the order, where they implemented a centralized administration combining religious and military leadership to manage territories and populations.
• As a result of these limitations, European powers began to shift their focus to other regions, such as the Baltic, where they could exert more influence and achieve tangible results.
• The establishment of a monastic state by the Teutonic Knights in Prussia was a unique blend of religious and secular governance, influencing the region's development for centuries.
• Frederick II was the Holy Roman Emperor known for his ambitions to consolidate power in Europe and the Mediterranean. His support for the Teutonic Knights was part of a broader strategy to extend his influence in the Baltic region, which was seen as a frontier for Christian expansion.
• The Prussians were a group of Baltic tribes with their own polytheistic beliefs and practices, living in what is now parts of modern-day Poland and the Kaliningrad region of Russia.
• The aggressive expansion and forced conversions contributed to long-standing tensions and conflicts in the Baltic region, influencing the area's history for centuries.
• The conquest led to significant cultural and demographic changes. Many native Prussians were killed, displaced, or assimilated, leading to the decline of indigenous languages and traditions.
• The conversion of the Prussian pagans was often enforced through coercion and violence, reflecting the broader pattern of forced conversions during the Crusades.
• The Teutonic Knights were originally founded in the late 12th century as a military order during the Third Crusade, primarily to aid Christians in the Holy Land and Eastern Europe.

The Political and Ideological Manipulation of Holy Wars: An Examination of How the Legacy of the Crusades Has Been Employed Since the 1300s.

The examination explores the different ways in which memories of the crusades have been employed and altered to support various political and ideological agendas from the fourteenth century to the present day. Jones emphasizes the transformation of Frederick II Hohenstaufen from Jerusalem's would-be liberator to a target of the papal-endorsed crusades, the decline of the Eastern Christian martial endeavors, and their replacement with the tenets of chivalry, as well as the troubling rise of extremist terrorism that twists the crusaders' history to justify violent actions.

Frederick II Hohenstaufen's enigmatic legacy includes initial acclaim for liberating Jerusalem, only to later find himself at the center of a Papal Crusade.

Jones explores the captivating heritage of Frederick II Hohenstaufen, who skillfully negotiated the return of Jerusalem to Christian control in 1229 without waging war, yet paradoxically, he was excommunicated by Pope Gregory IX and thus became a target for crusaders. The author details the extended struggle between Frederick and the church authorities, highlighting the dangers that emerge when crusading zeal is intertwined with political aspirations. Frederick, despite his zealous commitment to his Christian beliefs and the defense of his territory against Muslim foes, ultimately faced censure for his resistance to the directives issued by the Pope.

In the thirteenth century, Jones proposes that the act of crusading transformed into a tool for the papal authority to establish political control, as opposed to being merely a pursuit for religious reasons. Granting special advantages to those who fought alongside Frederick, a Christian leader who secured a significant victory against the Ayyubids for the first time in years, represents a clear deviation from the original purpose of the crusading movement.

Practical Tips

• Develop a habit of researching and understanding the history and background of issues before entering discussions or negotiations. This knowledge can help you propose informed and respectful solutions that acknowledge all parties' interests. For instance, before a meeting to discuss a contentious community project, research the project's history, stakeholders' interests, and previous attempts at resolution to propose a well-informed plan that could be acceptable to all.
• Explore the impact of social ostracism by journaling your feelings after a day of deliberately avoiding social media and communication apps. This self-imposed exile can give you a personal sense of the isolation experienced by historical figures like Frederick II and help you understand the emotional consequences of being cut off from a community.
• Develop empathy for historical figures by creating a fictional dialogue between yourself and Frederick II Hohenstaufen. Imagine a conversation where you discuss the pressures of leadership and the experience of being targeted by adversaries. This can help you relate to the emotional and psychological aspects of historical events, fostering a deeper understanding of the human element in history.
• Practice assertive communication in low-stakes situations to build your confidence in expressing dissent. Start with scenarios where the consequences are minimal, like choosing a restaurant with friends when you have a different preference. Explain your choice clearly and respectfully, and observe the group's response.
• Develop a critical eye for political rhetoric by listening to speeches or reading statements from contemporary leaders and identifying language that could be aimed at consolidating power. Pay attention to how leaders frame their missions or enemies, drawing a parallel to how crusading rhetoric was used for political control. For example, when a politician speaks about a "war on crime" or a "battle against corruption," consider how these narratives may serve to rally support and strengthen their authority.
• Engage with local history by volunteering at a museum or historical society, focusing on uncovering the lesser-known motivations behind your community's historical events. As you learn and share these stories, you'll gain a deeper appreciation for the complexity of historical motivations and the ability to communicate these nuances to others.
• Create a mentorship program within your community or workplace that pairs individuals who have shown commitment and support with experienced mentors. This provides them with a special advantage in their personal or professional growth, akin to the rewards given to loyal supporters in historical contexts. It's a way to give back and ensure that their dedication is met with opportunities to advance.
• Develop a game plan for personal goals by studying historical battles and their tactics, then create a step-by-step strategy for achieving your objectives. Just as military leaders plan their moves, you can break down your goals into smaller, manageable tasks, anticipate potential obstacles, and devise contingency plans, thereby increasing your chances of success.
• Reflect on your personal or professional projects to identify where they may have strayed from their original goals. Write down the initial objectives and compare them to the current state of affairs. If there's a deviation, brainstorm steps to realign with the original purpose.

The continual misappropriation of the chivalric campaigns from the 14th Century to rationalize the violent actions of extremists.

The author details the decline in Western Europe's zeal for extensive crusading efforts to the Holy Land following the fall of Acre in 1291. He examines the rise of chivalric principles and the creation of institutions such as Boucicaut's Order of the White Lady of the Green Shield, which marked a shift toward personal commitment and secular recognition rather than participation in far-off conflicts with infidels. The author depicts Henry Bolingbroke's path to the English throne as King Henry IV, emphasizing his participation in military campaigns with the Teutonic Knights in Prussia and his deeply personal pilgrimage to Jerusalem. Jones suggests that Bolingbroke's journeys represent a contemporary form of crusading that blends spiritual zeal with the quest for chivalric adventures.

However, Jones also underscores the troubling legacy of these ancient religious conflicts, scrutinizing how their memory has been appropriated by radical groups to justify modern acts of violence. The author highlights the way in which nationalist movements in the 19th and 20th centuries utilized the symbolism of crusades to support their goals of territorial expansion, noting that during World War I, both the German Emperor and the British employed crusading rhetoric to garner broad support for their military campaigns in the Middle East.

Practical Tips

• Create a personal journal to reflect on how historical narratives influence your own beliefs and actions. As you encounter stories or symbols from history in your daily life, write down your initial reactions and thoughts. Over time, this can help you become more aware of the subconscious impact of historical narratives on your decision-making and worldview.

Other Perspectives

• The fall of Acre in 1291 may not have been the sole reason for the decline in crusading zeal; economic factors, political changes, and the evolving nature of warfare could have played significant roles.
• The focus on personal glory and adventure within these orders could be criticized for romanticizing war and combat, which can have devastating consequences for societies.
• The pilgrimage to Jerusalem could be interpreted as a strategic act of piety designed to enhance Bolingbroke's reputation and political influence rather than a purely spiritual endeavor.
• The emphasis on chivalric adventures might romanticize Bolingbroke's military campaigns, which, like all military actions, would have involved violence and suffering that are not typically associated with the ideals of chivalry.
• The legacy of ancient religious conflicts can also be seen in a positive light, such as fostering interfaith dialogue and understanding by acknowledging past mistakes and striving for reconciliation.
• The leaders of the time might have used the language of crusades as a rhetorical device to evoke a sense of duty and honor among troops, which could be a common motivational strategy in military history.

The perils linked to invoking the memory of the Crusades and its ongoing misuse as an insidious signal for extremist ideologies.

Jones concludes his book by providing an in-depth analysis of the dangers inherent in remembering the Crusades, drawing a definitive link between the historical notion of holy wars and contemporary instances of violence directed at Muslim communities, exemplified by the attacks in Christchurch, New Zealand. He outlines the manifesto of the assailant, which alarmingly endorses white supremacist ideologies and declares the assailant's explicit desire to avenge past injustices dating back to the time of medieval holy wars. Jones underscores the person's profound admiration for crusade symbolism, as shown by the significant conflict dates from that era inked on his skin and his deep veneration for key historical characters such as Bohemond of Taranto.

The author emphasizes that modern terrorist groups such as al-Qaeda and Islamic State skillfully distort the history of the crusades to garner support and justify assaults on Western targets, depicting the current conflict as a continuation of a longstanding religious war. Jones argues that the long-lasting impact of the crusades serves as a powerful historical emblem, which extremists may manipulate to advance their detrimental and destructive goals. He contends that the lasting impact of the crusades is the stark caution they represent regarding the potential for savagery when religion is twisted to endorse conflicts considered holy.

Practical Tips

• Engage in active listening when encountering diverse perspectives to challenge your own preconceptions. Whenever you have a conversation with someone whose background or beliefs differ from yours, focus on truly understanding their point of view without immediately reacting or judging. This practice can foster empathy and reduce the likelihood of harboring unfounded biases.

Other Perspectives

• The historical notion of holy wars is not the only or even the primary catalyst for contemporary violence against Muslim communities; socio-political and economic factors also play significant roles.
• The focus on Bohemond of Taranto and specific conflict dates could be a reflection of a selective and possibly misguided fascination with medieval history rather than a comprehensive veneration of the Crusades.
• The narrative that terrorist groups are primarily inspired by historical events like the Crusades might oversimplify the complex and often personal reasons individuals join such groups, which can include a search for identity, purpose, or community.
• The idea that extremists manipulate the memory of the Crusades could imply a passive role for audiences, underestimating the agency of individuals who may engage with historical narratives in diverse and critical ways, not always leading to destructive ends.
• The notion that religion is twisted to endorse conflicts considered holy could be seen as a biased interpretation, as it assumes that religious texts and teachings are inherently peaceful and that violence is always a perversion of religious intent.