PDF Summary:Consumed, by Aja Barber

The fashion industry's exploitative practices have their roots in the colonial era, as Aja Barber reveals in Consumed. She explores how overconsumption, fueled by insecurity and marketing, drives environmental destruction and worker exploitation in the Global South.

Barber examines the psychological factors that enable our disconnect between purchases and their human costs. She illuminates the industry's reliance on overproduction and planned obsolescence, fostering a disposable culture that disproportionately burdens developing nations with waste.

(continued)...

Other Perspectives

• Overconsumption is a symptom of broader systemic issues, such as income inequality and the lack of access to sustainable products, rather than the primary driver of demand for cheap clothing.
• Some argue that the presence of the garment industry can lead to infrastructure improvements and skill development among the local workforce.
• The statistic does not account for the possibility that Americans might also donate or recycle clothing at a higher rate, which could mitigate the impact of their consumption.
• Brands may argue that they are participating in a competitive market where consumers expect low prices, and in order to stay in business, they must find ways to reduce production costs.
• Some brands might have had legitimate reasons for withholding payments, such as receiving products that did not meet quality standards or contractual terms.
• The responsibility for legal protections and binding contracts may also lie with the local governments, which should create and enforce such regulations to protect their workers.
• It is possible for fast fashion companies to engage in ethical practices by implementing fair trade policies, improving working conditions, and paying living wages, thus the business model itself may not be inherently exploitative.
• Large global companies often have corporate social responsibility (CSR) programs aimed at improving workers' conditions, suggesting a concern for human well-being alongside profit.

The Fast Fashion Industry: Exploitative and Environmentally Damaging

This section of Barber's book uncovers the unethical and unsustainable practices behind the fast-fashion business. She delves into how brands' relentless demand for more affordable and faster production leads to unsafe labor environments, environmental degradation, and a pervasive culture of disposability.

Brands' Demands Drive Faster, Cheaper Manufacturing

Barber demonstrates how brands' increasing demands for lower prices, faster turnaround times, and higher production volumes create a perfect storm for exploitation throughout the fashion industry's supply chain. She illustrates how the constant pursuit of low-cost labor pushes production to countries with weaker regulations and lower wages, sacrificing human and environmental well-being for profit.

Unsafe Conditions, Poverty Wages, and Environmental Damage in Garment Factories

By dissecting the inner workings of the manufacturing process, Barber reveals the competition to offer contracts at ever-lower costs, often leading to dangerous work environments and poverty pay for those making the clothes. She shows that the pressure to fulfill large orders within very short timeframes compels manufacturers to outsource to unregulated facilities, where worker abuse and child labor are rampant. The author points to the tragic collapse of Rana Plaza in Bangladesh as a prime example of the deadly consequences caused by this system.

This downward spiral, she argues, is a direct consequence of companies prioritizing profit over humans and ecological concerns. Their deliberate choices to exploit labor in unregulated markets create conditions that leave clothing employees vulnerable to mistreatment and abuse. She further emphasizes that this race causes a devastating environmental toll as unregulated manufacturers frequently release toxic substances into local waterways, impacting entire communities.

Practical Tips

• You can choose to buy from companies that are transparent about their labor practices. Look for businesses that provide detailed information about their manufacturing processes and worker conditions. This might include companies that have third-party certifications for labor practices or those that share regular, detailed reports about their factories and employees.
• Engage in mindful consumption by buying less but choosing higher-quality items that are made ethically. This approach can reduce the demand for mass-produced goods that are often linked to outsourced, unregulated labor. Before making a purchase, ask yourself if the item is necessary and if there is an alternative that aligns better with ethical labor standards.
• Start a social media campaign to raise awareness about the impact of toxic waste on waterways by sharing images and stories of affected communities. Use hashtags, create shareable content, and tag local representatives to spread the message. This can lead to increased public pressure on companies and policymakers to enforce stricter regulations on waste disposal.

Brands Exploiting Workers and Nature Due to Absence of Oversight and Protections

Barber further exposes brands' attempts to distance themselves from the consequences of their actions by invoking contracts that aren't legally binding and claiming ignorance of subcontracting methods. She argues that brands are complicit in this system, as their demands for cheaper production create the conditions for exploitation. The author also criticizes the industry's reliance on "corporate social responsibility" pages as a smokescreen for unethical behavior, highlighting how these often amount to little more than greenwashing and wokewashing. She urges readers to carefully scrutinize brands' claims and hold them accountable for the real consequences of their practices.

The author calls for systemic change, arguing for stronger regulations and legal protections for clothing workers. She highlights the importance of consumer awareness and activism, emphasizing the role that buyers have in demanding transparency and fair labor practices from companies. She advocates for supporting initiatives such as the #PayUp movement, which calls on brands to fulfill their financial obligations to factories and workers.

Practical Tips

• You can scrutinize the supply chain of your favorite products by using online tools and databases that track the ethical practices of companies. By entering the brand name into these platforms, you'll get a report on their subcontracting practices and any known issues. This empowers you to make informed decisions about which brands to support based on their transparency and ethical standards.
• Use social media to engage with brands and seek clarification on vague claims. Draft a set of clear, concise questions that you can post on a brand's social media page or send via direct message. Inquire about specifics when a brand makes broad statements like "eco-friendly" or "socially responsible." For instance, ask them to provide details on how their products are eco-friendly or what actions they take to ensure social responsibility.
• You can influence brand accountability by creating a social media filter or frame that promotes the #PayUp movement. By designing a simple graphic overlay that can be added to profile pictures or shared in posts, you encourage your network to show solidarity with the cause. This visual support can increase awareness and pressure brands to honor their commitments to workers.

Overproduction, Obsolescence, and Throwaway Culture in Fashion

In this section, Barber exposes how fast fashion's overreliance on trends and constant new releases fosters a culture of disposability, generating massive amounts of waste and contributing significantly to global environmental problems.

Industrial Waste and Pollution

The author demonstrates how the fast fashion model, reliant on overproduction and planned obsolescence, generates massive amounts of textile waste. Citing data about garment production and disposal, she highlights the environmental burden created by the industry's unsustainable practices, including landfill accumulation, incineration, and the environmental costs associated with the transportation and sorting of discarded clothing. She draws attention to the disproportionate impact of this waste on nations in the developing world, especially highlighting the situation faced by Kantamanto Market in Ghana, where mountains of unsold clothing from affluent countries end up polluting the environment and displacing communities.

She further illustrates the environmental toll of the economy related to materials, focusing on extraction, production, delivery, and disposal. She argues that a linear process like this, reliant on constantly extracting resources and discarding products, is inherently incompatible with a limited Earth. Barber criticizes brands' reliance on recycling as a solution, arguing that it often serves as a promotional tactic rather than an authentic effort to reduce waste. She points to the inherent limitations of recycling, particularly given the sector's vast production capacity. She also emphasizes the need for systemic solutions that address the root cause of waste from textiles—overproduction.

Practical Tips

• You can create a personal "capsule wardrobe" to minimize your clothing purchases and waste. Start by selecting versatile pieces that you love and that can be mixed and matched to create multiple outfits. This approach reduces the need to buy new clothes frequently and helps you resist the lure of fast fashion trends.
• Create a 'mend and repair' kit for your home to extend the life of your clothes. Include basic sewing supplies, fabric glue, and iron-on patches. By fixing minor damages yourself, you prevent garments from being discarded prematurely and reduce the demand for new clothing production.
• Create a 'Zero-Waste Challenge' for yourself where you aim to reduce your household waste each week by finding alternatives to single-use products. Begin by identifying the most common disposable items in your home and seek out reusable or sustainable alternatives. For instance, switch to beeswax wraps instead of cling film, or use a refillable water bottle instead of buying plastic ones.
• You can scrutinize product labels to identify if recycling claims are substantiated by credible certifications. Look for labels that indicate third-party certification, such as the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) for paper products or the Global Recycle Standard (GRS) for textiles. This helps you support products that are genuinely committed to sustainable practices rather than those using recycling as a marketing gimmick.
• Engage with local businesses to encourage the adoption of a take-back program for their products. You can do this by writing to companies or speaking with local store managers, suggesting they implement systems where consumers can return used products for proper disposal or recycling, thus ensuring the materials are handled responsibly.

The Fashion Model Is Unsustainable and Harmful to Earth

Barber highlights how the fast fashion industry's reliance on synthetic fibers, derived from fossil fuels, directly contributes to the climate crisis. She emphasizes that although companies frequently boast about their sustainable products and eco-friendly initiatives, these often amount to greenwashing, as they represent only a tiny fraction of their overall production. The author argues that the sector's focus on growth and perpetually increasing profits is fundamentally incompatible with genuine sustainability. She calls for a radical shift in the industry's model, demanding that brands prioritize reducing their production volumes, using more sustainable materials, and extending how long clothing lasts.

Beyond its contribution to landfill waste, Barber explores the industry's role in polluting water and depleting resources. She delves into how microplastics released from synthetic fibers during washing contaminate waterways and ultimately enter the food chain. She criticizes brands for not taking responsibility regarding the environmental harm caused by their manufacturing processes, particularly in the southern hemisphere. The author emphasizes the role of fashion companies in perpetuating a culture of disposability where garments are viewed as fleeting trends rather than valuable and long-lasting items. She concludes that the sector's current trajectory is unsustainable and demands a fundamental shift in its approach to production and consumption.

Other Perspectives

• The longevity and durability of some synthetic fibers might lead to less frequent need for replacement, potentially reducing overall consumption and waste.
• There may be an argument that green initiatives serve as a testing ground for new methods that, if successful, could be implemented on a larger scale within the company's production processes.
• A focus on profits can drive innovation in the circular economy, where the life cycle of products is extended through reuse, repair, and recycling.
• Focusing solely on the production side ignores the role of consumers in driving demand for fast fashion; consumer behavior change is also necessary for a significant impact.
• While the fashion industry does contribute to landfill waste, water pollution, and resource depletion, advancements in recycling technologies and circular fashion models are being developed to mitigate these issues.
• Consumer behavior, such as the use of washing bags designed to catch microfibers, can play a role in reducing the number of microplastics that enter water systems from household laundry.
• Some brands are actively working to reduce water pollution by changing their dyeing processes and using less harmful chemicals.
• The concept of trends and changing styles is a form of creative expression and can be a driver for innovation and cultural diversity in fashion.
• The concept of sustainability is complex and multifaceted, and there may be other industries that contribute more significantly to environmental degradation, thus warranting more immediate attention.

Psychological and Cultural Factors Driving Fashion Overconsumption

This part of the book explores the individual and societal factors that drive overconsumption of fashion, highlighting the interplay between personal insecurities, identity construction, social pressures, and marketing tactics.

Insecurity, Social Pressure, and Self-Perception Fueling Compulsive Fashion Consumption

Barber examines how the apparel business manipulates consumers' anxieties surrounding self-worth and belonging to generate sales. She argues that fast fashion preys upon our ingrained insecurities, offering endless "new" trends as a means to fill voids and achieve fleeting validation.

Marketing Exploits Inadequacy to Drive Excessive Buying

Barber reveals how marketing and advertising strategies are carefully crafted to exploit consumers' vulnerabilities. She points out the ubiquitous messages in marketing that make us feel we aren't good enough as we are. Ads often suggest that happiness, success, and social acceptance are attainable through buying fresh apparel. This relentless bombardment of messaging fuels our desire to consume, creating a dependency loop where we constantly seek validation from our possessions.

The author connects this marketing manipulation to the rise of social networks, especially image-based platforms like Instagram. The desire to present a curated version of ourselves online, fueled by influencers and trend cycles, contributes to a culture of constant comparison and compels us to follow the latest styles, driving even greater consumerism.

Other Perspectives

• Not all marketing exploits vulnerabilities; some campaigns promote positive messages and encourage empowerment and self-acceptance.
• Social acceptance is a multifaceted issue that can be influenced by personality, values, and social skills, not just by the apparel one purchases.
• Consumers have agency and the ability to make informed choices; they are not merely passive recipients of marketing messages.
• Image-based platforms like Instagram can be used as tools for self-expression and creativity rather than merely as a means for comparison.
• Some users may engage with influencers and trends in a way that is conscious and critical, using these sources as inspiration rather than prescriptive models for their own online presence.
• Consumerism is not solely driven by comparison and trends; it is also influenced by a variety of factors including economic conditions, personal needs, technological advancements, and cultural shifts.

Cultural Narratives: Valuing Material Wealth and Newness in Style Dynamics

Barber explains how society's emphasis on material wealth and constant novelty exacerbates overconsumption. She shares personal anecdotes about her own struggle with feelings of inadequacy stemming from being immersed in affluence during her childhood. These experiences led her to associate material possessions with worthiness, fueling her own overconsumption of fast fashion as an adult.

The author also examines how cultural narratives perpetuate harmful stereotypes, such as associating women with shopping. This reinforces the societal expectation that women are responsible for fulfilling their role as caregiver through acts of consumption, acquiring new items for themselves and their families. Such deeply ingrained beliefs contribute to the normalization of overconsumption, making it hard for individuals to escape the pattern.

Practical Tips

• Engage in a "material wealth audit" by evaluating your possessions and their impact on your happiness. Over a weekend, go through your belongings and categorize them based on how much joy they bring you and how often you use them. You might discover that some items you thought were essential to your happiness are rarely used, prompting you to reconsider future purchases in a similar category.
• Create a 'Value Visualization' board by collecting images and quotes that represent personal values and aspirations unrelated to material wealth, such as family, creativity, or knowledge. Place this board somewhere you'll see it daily to remind yourself of the diverse forms of worthiness in your life. For instance, a picture of a family dinner or a quote about lifelong learning can serve as daily affirmations of your non-material values.
• Create a conversation jar at home or work filled with topics that go beyond traditional gender roles. Whenever you're with family or colleagues, draw a topic and use it to spark discussions that explore varied interests and perspectives, thereby diluting the prevalence of stereotypes in casual conversation.
• Initiate conversations with peers about caregiving without consumption. Start discussions with friends or family members about the ways they provide care that don't involve buying things. Share ideas and strategies for showing care that are more focused on personal interaction, shared experiences, or skill-sharing, rather than material goods. This can help build a community of support that challenges the narrative linking caregiving with consumption.
• Create a shared family expense tracker to involve all family members in the decision-making process for new purchases. By doing this, you encourage transparency and collective responsibility. Use a simple spreadsheet or a free budgeting app where each family member can add items they believe are necessary, and then discuss as a group which items should be prioritized based on need and budget.
• Identify and challenge one limiting belief each week by writing it down and actively seeking evidence that contradicts it. For example, if you believe you're not good at public speaking, join a local speaking club and track your progress to see improvements, which will counteract the belief.

Disconnect Between Purchases and Their Human, Environmental Costs

This section of Barber's book investigates the psychological disconnect between our individual purchases and their broader consequences for those who produce garments and the environment. She explores how distance, privilege, and cognitive dissonance enable consumers in wealthy nations to take part in a framework that perpetuates exploitation and environmental degradation.

Distance Between Global North Consumers and Realities Faced by Garment Workers

The author examines how physical and psychological distance allows consumers in wealthy nations to detach from the realities faced by people working in the garment industry in less economically developed regions. The lack of personal connection makes it easier to ignore the human cost of cheap clothing, allowing us to justify our participation in a framework that perpetuates poverty and exploitation. She encourages readers to pause and visualize the person making the clothes on their back, and to consider their working conditions and living standards.

Barber further explores NIMBYism and highlights its role in the used clothing market. Although often well-intentioned, giving away clothes allows us to displace the consequences of our overconsumption onto others. We readily donate clothes that we deem unworthy of ourselves, assuming they will be of benefit to someone else, while ignoring the burdens on ecosystems and societies these often create in the places they end up.

Practical Tips

• You can create a "Garment Worker's Day" in your calendar to regularly educate yourself about the lives of garment workers. Set aside this day to watch documentaries, read articles, and listen to podcasts that focus on the lives of garment workers. This will help bridge the psychological distance by making their realities a part of your regular routine.
• Start a "swap don't shop" group with friends or neighbors to exchange goods and services without money changing hands, thereby stepping out of the traditional consumer framework. This could be as simple as trading books, clothes, or even skills like tutoring for gardening help, reducing the demand for new products and the associated exploitation.
• Create a "Clothing Journey" journal to document the origins of your new clothing purchases. When you buy a new item, take a moment to write down the brand, the country of manufacture, and any information available about the factory or artisans who made it. This practice encourages mindfulness about the supply chain and the human effort that goes into each garment.

Mental Conflicts and Denial in Harmful Systems Participation

Barber delves into the psychology of cognitive dissonance, highlighting how consumers reconcile their ethical concerns with their desire for inexpensive and trendy clothes. We utilize defense mechanisms like denial and rationalization to justify our participation in an arrangement that clashes with our principles. This disconnect, she argues, allows us to continue consuming without facing the inconvenient truth about the consequences of fashion produced quickly.

She further explores how our collective obsession with rapid clothing consumption obscures the real human and environmental costs associated with it. We readily embrace brands' eco-friendly and wokewashing efforts, clinging to reassuring narratives about their sustainability initiatives or ethical practices. However, she stresses that true change requires recognizing the full extent of the issue and its connection to our personal purchasing patterns.

Practical Tips

• Engage in a monthly "Ethics Audit" with a trusted friend or mentor. Discuss situations where you've felt conflicted about your actions, and explore the underlying reasons together. This dialogue can provide an external perspective, helping you to identify when you're using defense mechanisms and how to align your actions with your principles more effectively.
• Develop a habit of supporting small, local businesses that practice sustainability. These businesses often have a smaller carbon footprint and more transparent practices. Start by visiting farmers' markets, local craft fairs, or independent bookstores, and engage with the owners to learn about their sustainable practices.
• Track your spending with a focus on ethical consumption by using a dedicated budgeting app that categorizes purchases based on their environmental and social impact. This will help you see which areas of your spending are contributing to the issues you're concerned about. For example, you might find that a significant portion of your budget goes to companies with poor labor practices, prompting you to seek out alternatives.