PDF Summary:Cheer Up Love, by Susan Calman

In Cheer Up Love, comedian Susan Calman offers an open and honest chronicle of her lifelong struggles with depression. She recounts formative experiences from her youth that shaped her mental health journey, pivotal realizations that enabled her to confront her challenges, and strategies she developed for managing bouts of profound sadness and anxiety.

Calman's narrative explores the complexity of depression—how the condition manifests uniquely for each individual across a spectrum of severity. She shares personal methods for overcoming obstacles, like personifying her negative thoughts, and discusses the impact mental health issues can have on relationships and social identity.

(continued)...

It is essential to recognize that the condition varies greatly and is unique to each individual.

Calman underscores the multifaceted nature of depression, highlighting that it manifests and is conveyed in different ways, with no singular approach universally acknowledged as the definitive one. The author emphasizes the significance of acknowledging that the disorder varies in severity, duration, and triggering circumstances, and that it lies on a spectrum. She urges understanding and empathy towards those struggling with the condition, acknowledging that even individuals with outwardly successful lives can experience deep inner turmoil.

Creating personalized approaches to manage times of low mood.

Susan Calman humorously describes her distinctive approach to overcoming obstacles, which she whimsically names her "Crab of Hate" technique. She envisions her pessimistic thoughts and emotions as a separate being, a crab perched on her back, murmuring disheartening words into her ear. She employs personification as a means to distinguish her depression from her own identity, which simplifies the process of facing and controlling it.

Incorporating activities, distractions, and mindset shifts to alleviate symptoms

Calman discusses a variety of strategies she implements to manage her depression, highlighting the importance of finding what works for each individual. She emphasizes the value of engaging in activities that provide fulfillment and purpose, including delivering comedy performances or savoring the uncomplicated pleasures of life, such as drinking tea, watching favorite movies, or valuing time spent with loved ones.

She also advocates for taking proactive steps to manage the condition, such as seeking professional help through therapy or medication, adopting a healthier lifestyle that includes regular exercise and nutritious eating habits, and finding ways to challenge negative thought patterns through techniques like cognitive behavioral therapy. Calman also stresses the importance of engaging in activities that demand focus and distract from rumination, offering creative solutions like setting “mystery box” cooking challenges for herself. She advocates for nurturing oneself and embracing activities that provide happiness and solace.

Other Perspectives

• While personalization of strategies is important, there may be a risk of individuals becoming too self-reliant and not seeking or adhering to evidence-based treatments for depression.
• The "Crab of Hate" technique, while useful for some, might not be effective for everyone and could potentially trivialize the experience of those with severe depression.
• Activities and distractions can be helpful, but they may also serve as temporary fixes rather than addressing the underlying causes of depression.
• The emphasis on individual strategies might overlook the importance of systemic factors, such as social support networks and access to healthcare, which can significantly impact one's ability to manage depression.
• The suggestion to adopt a healthier lifestyle and challenge negative thought patterns, while beneficial, may be oversimplified and not easily attainable for individuals facing complex mental health issues or those in challenging life circumstances.
• The focus on understanding and empathy, while important, does not necessarily translate into concrete actions or policies that can help alleviate the societal impact of depression.
• The idea that engaging in fulfilling activities can manage depression might not account for the fact that depression itself can sap the joy out of activities that were once fulfilling, making this strategy less viable for some.
• The text may not sufficiently address the role of medication in managing depression, which for many individuals is a critical component of treatment.
• The narrative could inadvertently contribute to the stigma against using medication for mental health by emphasizing personal management strategies over medical interventions.

Depression's influence on one's social interactions, intimate relationships, and overall social existence.

This part examines how Calman's personal and social life were impacted by depression. Susan Calman explores the intricacies involved in sustaining personal bonds and friendships when managing the condition, providing thoughtful advice on how to maintain robust relationships.

Navigating the challenges of depression within romantic partnerships and friendships

Calman candidly addresses the impact of her depression on her relationships with both friends and romantic partners. She acknowledges her tendency to distance herself from others, while also depending too much on them for emotional stability, and resorting to detrimental habits such as overindulgence in alcohol. She recognizes that her challenges in expressing herself, along with frequent periods of uncertainty and mistrust, played a role in the failure of many of her relationships.

Addressing the strain on relationships caused by depressive behaviors and withdrawal

Calman underscores the importance of openness and honesty in relationships, highlighting that this candor is essential for individuals grappling with depression and those who support them. She underscores common misunderstandings, such as the assumption that one's silent thoughts and feelings are transparent to others, or failing to recognize how deeply their own battles with mental health can affect their loved ones. She emphasizes the need for clear and direct communication, urging people to articulate their personal needs and expectations while also taking into account the needs of their friends and supporters.

She underscores the value of a companion who grasps the intricacies of depression and stands ready to provide emotional support as well as practical assistance. She emphasizes the importance of open communication, patience, and empathy in her relationship while discussing the strategies she and her partner have adopted to manage challenges.

Examining the author's experiences with her sexuality and societal perceptions

In her book, Susan Calman delves into how her battle with depression is intertwined with her lesbian identity, highlighting the challenges posed by societal perceptions of her sexual orientation. She shares her experiences of feeling isolated, facing discrimination because of her sexuality, and grappling with ingrained self-critical thoughts, which have all intensified her feelings of loneliness and a profound dislike for herself.

Overcoming internalized stigma and embracing her identity

She describes how acknowledging her sexual orientation and the support she found within the LGBTQ+ community helped her to confront and change negative views she held about herself, leading to a deeper recognition of her own value. The disclosure of her own sexuality by Susan Calman was more than just an admission of whom she cherished; it signified liberation from the apprehension of judgment and an embrace of her true self. Susan Calman's journey toward improved mental well-being was marked by her embracing her true self, which in turn bolstered her confidence and solidified her sense of identity as she progressed.

Practical Tips

• You can foster better relationship dynamics by creating a 'communication pact' with your partner, where both of you commit to regular, structured conversations about your mental health and its impact on your relationship. Set aside a specific time each week to discuss how you're feeling, any challenges you're facing, and how you can support each other. This ensures that both partners are heard and that mental health is consistently addressed in a supportive environment.
• Develop a personalized 'relationship toolkit' that includes activities and resources tailored to your needs and those of your partner, which can be used when depression affects your relationship. This might include a list of mood-boosting activities you can do together, contact information for a couples therapist familiar with mental health issues, and educational materials about depression to help your partner understand your experience. Having this toolkit ready can help prevent distancing and dependence, and encourage healthy coping mechanisms.
• Create a 'self-identity map' to explore and affirm your identity, which can include aspects like sexual orientation, hobbies, values, and goals. Use this map to identify areas where you might seek additional support or communities that align with your identity, such as local or online LGBTQ+ groups. By actively engaging with these communities, you can build a support network that understands your unique experiences, which can be especially empowering if you're dealing with feelings of isolation or discrimination.