PDF Summary:Buried, by Alice Roberts

In Buried, Alice Roberts demonstrates how a multidisciplinary approach can shed light on the mysteries of the past. She shows how physical evidence like skeletal remains, artifacts, and isotopic analysis can reveal intimate details about ancient lives—from health and migration patterns to social hierarchies and cultural beliefs.

Roberts examines how burial practices evolved in Britain over the ages, reflecting shifting worldviews on death, the afterlife, and emerging religious ideas like Christianity. By studying artifacts found in graves, she traces how diverse cultures interacted through trade and migration, shaping the complex ethnic identities that emerged in post-Roman Britain.

(continued)...

Other Perspectives

• It could be argued that without explicit written records or clear contextual evidence, the interpretation of these burials is largely speculative and may not accurately reflect the intentions or beliefs of the people who practiced them.
• While historical texts and archaeological findings may suggest humility or piety, they could also be interpreted in various other ways due to the subjective nature of archaeological interpretation.
• The evidence for decapitation in Roman Britain might be more accessible or better-preserved, leading to a perception of higher prevalence compared to other territories where organic materials, including human bones, might not have survived.
• The perception of divergence could be a result of our limited understanding of the past, and as more evidence comes to light, these practices may be reinterpreted as variations rather than deviations.
• These theories may be influenced by contemporary biases and interpretations, which could lead to misrepresenting the intentions and beliefs of ancient societies.

The way infants were interred offers a window into historical views on pregnancy, childbirth, and the prevalent mortality rates among children.

Roberts conducts a thorough examination of the cultural implications surrounding the burial of infants, addressing challenging inquiries regarding the act of infanticide and the perspectives of ancient communities on the premature passing of children. Alice Roberts cautions against jumping to conclusions about the use of infanticide as a birth control practice in Roman times, especially considering the historically high natural infant mortality rates. Roberts emphasizes the range of feelings, from indifference to profound grief, that can be triggered by the passing and interment of young ones, illustrating the complex web of human responses to loss.

Practical Tips

• Engage with local historians or cultural experts to gain a firsthand understanding of ancient communities' views on infanticide. Reach out to local universities, museums, or cultural centers and ask if they can provide a talk or a workshop on the topic. This direct interaction can offer a nuanced perspective that goes beyond written accounts and helps you grasp the complexities of past moral frameworks.
• Encourage nuanced historical discussions with friends or in online forums. When a topic like historical birth control methods comes up, guide the conversation towards considering multiple factors that influenced people's choices in the past, such as social norms, economic conditions, and available knowledge, rather than settling on a single, oversimplified explanation.
• Develop a small, private ritual to honor the concept of infant passing, such as lighting a candle or planting a tree. This act of remembrance can serve as a personal way to acknowledge the emotions tied to infant loss and can be a therapeutic outlet for expressing grief and finding closure.

Tombs indicative of considerable wealth, influence, and elevated societal standing.

Luxurious burial artifacts and their role in delineating social hierarchies

This section explores the role that the location of prestigious burial grounds plays in creating social hierarchies. Roberts delves into how the elaborate items found with the deceased in their final resting places reflect the social status, wealth, and influence they held during their lifetime and took with them into the afterlife. The discovery of items like weapons, elaborate clasps, and uncommon objects such as a Byzantine bucket at Breamore reveals the social standing of the interred individuals and highlights the distinct differences in status evident from archaeological excavations.

Practical Tips

• Start a conversation with friends or family about the topic using a hypothetical scenario. Ask them where they would choose to be buried in a prestigious cemetery and why. This can lead to discussions about the value of location in social perception and personal preferences regarding burial.
• Start a journal documenting the significance behind your possessions, focusing on those you value most. This activity not only serves as a reflection on what you deem important but also provides context for anyone looking at your belongings in the future. For instance, write about the story behind a family heirloom, the effort it took to acquire a particular piece of art, or why a book is meaningful to you.

Artifacts denoting elevated social standing were accompanied by foreign goods and emblems indicative of power.

Alice Roberts highlights how society's elite demonstrated their substantial social and economic dominance through the presence of precious burial artifacts, rare commodities, and symbols of authority in their graves. The uncovering of such artifacts underscores the broad trade connections that Britain maintained with various regions throughout Europe and the Mediterranean area. The uncovering of Baltic amber beads, ivory from the African Rift Valley, and a beaver tooth with origins in Scandinavia at the Scremby burial site is evidence of the far-reaching commerce and connections sustained by these people. The discovery of a belt signifying Roman status in a fifth-century burial site at Dorchester-on-Thames, coupled with the excavation of a brooch displaying Scandinavian characteristics in an adjacent burial, suggests that Roman impact continued even amidst the emergence of fresh political and cultural allegiances.

Practical Tips

• Develop a personal logo or crest that incorporates symbols or icons that represent your personal values or accomplishments. Use this logo on your personal stationery, website, or social media profiles. This is a modern take on the use of symbols of power. For example, if you value education and knowledge, your logo might include a book or a lamp of knowledge. This not only personalizes your brand but also communicates your values to others in a subtle yet impactful way.
• Create a personal time capsule with items that represent your achievements and values, and bury it in your backyard. By selecting objects that symbolize your personal milestones or beliefs, you're engaging in a modern interpretation of the ancient practice of burying artifacts with significance. For example, you might include a USB drive with your digital journal, a medal from a marathon you ran, or a piece of jewelry that has been passed down through generations.
• Craft a small personal museum display using items from around your home. Gather objects that represent different cultures or regions, such as spices, textiles, or artwork, and arrange them in a display. Label each item with its origin and a fun fact about its history or how it might have been traded in the past. This hands-on activity helps you appreciate the diversity and interconnectedness of cultures through trade.
• Develop a taste for historical trade by cooking recipes from the regions Britain traded with. Look up traditional dishes from various European and Mediterranean countries that would have been Britain's trading partners. As you prepare these meals, consider the ingredients that would have been traded, such as spices from the East or wines from the Mediterranean, and reflect on how these exchanges influenced British cuisine and culture.
• Engage in language exchange meetups to foster direct personal connections with individuals from diverse backgrounds. Learning new languages can open doors to understanding different cultures and their ways of commerce, much like the British elite did. These meetups can be found through local community boards or language learning apps that connect you with native speakers for mutual learning experiences.
• Engage in a small-scale barter experiment within your community. Offer a skill or item you have in exchange for something you need, without using money. This personal experience will give you insight into the value and challenges of trade-based economies and the social interactions that come with them.
• Explore local history by visiting a nearby museum with artifacts from different eras to understand the evolution of status symbols in your region. By examining items such as jewelry, clothing, or weaponry, you can gain insight into how social status was displayed historically in your own community, similar to the Roman belt found at the Dorchester-on-Thames burial site.
• Create a themed treasure hunt for friends or family that incorporates elements of historical discovery. Design clues and challenges that encourage participants to learn about the historical era or cultural aspects related to the Scandinavian brooch. For example, you might include a riddle that leads to a mock archaeological dig in your backyard, where participants can find replicas of historical artifacts.
• Engage in a cultural exchange with someone from a different background. Find a pen pal, join an international online forum, or participate in a cultural exchange program. Through conversations, learn how their culture's history has influenced their modern-day practices and compare it with your own. This direct interaction can provide insights into the enduring impact of historical cultures on current societies.

By examining the physical remains, we can follow the evolution of ethnic and cultural identities in Britain following the Roman period, along with the cultural exchanges and economic connections.

The exchange of concepts, along with the transportation of goods and people, demonstrates how various cultures are interlinked through their tangible artifacts.

This part highlights how artifacts are crucial for comprehending the history of cultural interactions, including the complex network of commerce and the movement of groups along with their ideas over diverse landscapes. Roberts highlights how the discovery of artifacts at burial locations provides irrefutable evidence of the relationships between communities, demonstrating how these connections influenced the emergence of distinct cultural characteristics.

Artifacts, including fasteners and a variety of metal items like buckets, undergo thorough analysis and distribution.

Roberts underscores the importance of analyzing the distribution and unique configurations of certain artifacts, such as a range of metallic items and fastenings, to understand the broad scope and influence of different cultural traditions. Alice Roberts highlights Toby Martin's meticulous study of cross-shaped brooches, underscoring their progression from Roman predecessors, the emergence of a distinctive British style, and their spread across England, which could indicate the early visual identity of the Angles. The unearthing of an ornately decorated Byzantine bucket featuring images of unusual animals and Greek lettering at the Breamore site, accompanied by more typical regional stave-built buckets, underscores the influence of both local traditions and international exchanges on burial practices.

Practical Tips

• Organize a 'metal scavenger hunt' in your home or community to identify and categorize different types of metal items. Make a list categorizing items by their use, such as fasteners, decorative elements, or tools, and then research their distribution channels – how they got from the manufacturer to the end user. This activity will highlight the complexity of supply chains and the ubiquity of metal items in our lives. For instance, you might discover that the screws holding your bookshelf together were manufactured in a different country and distributed through multiple companies before reaching your local hardware store.
• Design your own brooch inspired by historical styles using craft supplies. Look for DIY jewelry kits or visit a craft store to pick up materials like metal pieces, decorative stones, and tools. Experiment with combining elements from Roman and British designs to create a unique piece that reflects the historical progression.
• Start a local history project by researching and documenting the burial sites and practices in your local area. Use online resources, visit local libraries, or speak with historians to gather information. This can give you a deeper appreciation for how your community's past has been shaped by both local traditions and external influences, akin to the findings at the Breamore site. Share your findings through a blog, a small publication, or a social media page dedicated to local history enthusiasts.
• Enhance your understanding of iconography by starting a sketch journal dedicated to drawing animals and letters in the style of ancient cultures. Use online resources or library books to find examples of Byzantine or Greek art, and practice replicating the styles and motifs you see. This will help you develop a personal connection to the art and improve your drawing skills.
• Start a DIY project to create a simple wooden bucket or container using traditional techniques. This hands-on experience will give you a practical understanding of the craftsmanship that goes into stave-built items and the effort required to produce them.
• Create a visual timeline of a particular fashion or design trend using social media. Pick a style element that has evolved over time, such as the design of wristwatches or the cut of jeans, and post images of these items from different periods. Use hashtags to categorize your posts by decade or style, and engage with others who share your interest to expand your understanding of the trend's development.

Isotopic and genomic techniques have illuminated the origins and migrations of human populations.

Roberts emphasizes that isotopic and genomic research can offer a deeper insight into historical human migration, contributing an essential dimension to the overall narrative that artifacts and physical remains disclose. Analyzing the unique isotopic patterns found in human bones and teeth can reveal the individual's history of geographic movement across different landscapes. The examination of burial sites at Llanbedrgoch has revealed through isotopic analysis that the individuals laid to rest there originated from far-off regions, such as Scandinavia or Scotland, and were placed without ceremony in a trench. Genomic research probes into our history by examining old DNA to uncover our lineage, kinship ties, and the widespread movements of human populations over time.

Context

• By combining isotopic and genomic data, researchers can construct detailed maps of ancient human movements, showing not just where people traveled, but also how populations mixed and interacted over time.
• Oxygen isotopes can provide information about the climate and altitude of the region where a person lived, as they are influenced by local water sources and weather patterns.
• This is an archaeological site located on the Isle of Anglesey in Wales. It has been a significant site for understanding the interactions and movements of people during the early medieval period.
• Recent improvements in DNA sequencing technology have made it possible to analyze even small and degraded samples, providing more accurate and comprehensive insights into ancient human history.
• These scientific methods can uncover evidence of cultural exchange, such as the spread of technologies or practices, which might accompany the movement of people across regions.
• Isotopic analysis is often used alongside other archaeological methods, such as artifact analysis and radiocarbon dating, to build a more complete picture of past human behaviors and movements.

Ethnic and cultural identities, with their intricate and evolving nature, challenge the overly simplistic narratives of complete population replacements.

This section of the book examines the reductive narratives of total population replacement, exploring the intricate evolution and metamorphosis of cultural and ethnic identities through the ages, and particularly investigates the traditional views on the advent of the Anglo-Saxon era. Roberts underscores the dynamic character of cultural identity, shaped by the interplay between various communities.

Regional traditions persisted with vigor, incorporating elements from various cultures while maintaining their unique local character.

Roberts emphasizes the persistence of local cultural distinctions even while incorporating new cultural aspects, demonstrating how emerging concepts and practices were selectively embraced and modified within existing cultural norms. The incorporation of new cultural elements into established British practices is evidenced by the fact that, although the emergence of Anglo-Saxon material culture in England could imply a significant influx of people, local customs endured, such as the continued interment in ancient burial mounds and the maintenance of inhumation rites in Anglo-Saxon graveyards. Monarchs such as Cynegils, whose names have Celtic roots, exemplify the fusion of diverse cultural influences.

Practical Tips

• Create a fusion recipe that combines your family's heritage with local traditions. If your family has Italian roots and you live in an area with a strong Mexican culinary tradition, you could experiment with making a salsa verde spaghetti. This not only honors both cultures but also creates a unique dish that represents the blending of traditions.
• You can explore cultural fusion in your daily life by integrating a new cultural practice into your routine. Start by researching a cultural tradition that intrigues you, such as a Japanese tea ceremony or Spanish siesta, and adapt it to fit your lifestyle. For example, if you're drawn to the mindfulness aspect of the tea ceremony, you might create a daily quiet moment for reflection with your favorite beverage.
• Start a small-scale "innovation exchange" with friends or colleagues where you share and discuss emerging trends or practices. Each participant could bring a new concept they've discovered and discuss how it might be adapted or merged with existing practices. This could be done through a casual monthly meetup or an online group chat, fostering a collaborative environment for practical innovation.
• Engage with your community by starting a book or film club focused on the theme of cultural synthesis. Each month, select a book or film that showcases the blending of different cultures. This could be a historical novel set in Anglo-Saxon England or a modern movie that depicts cultural integration. Discuss with your group how these stories reflect the coexistence and merging of traditions.
• Create a digital photo journal of ancient burial mounds you visit, noting their features and any personal reflections or feelings they evoke. This activity allows you to document your experiences and share them with others who might be interested in the historical significance of these sites.
• Create a small garden or art project inspired by Anglo-Saxon inhumation rites. Use plants that were native to the Anglo-Saxon era or create artwork that represents artifacts typically found in their grave sites. This hands-on activity will help you internalize the cultural significance of these rites through a creative process.
• You can explore your own name's history to connect with diverse cultural influences. Start by researching the etymology of your first and last name using online databases or contacting a local historical society. This can reveal the linguistic and cultural origins of your name, similar to how monarchs' names reflect cultural fusions. Share your findings with family or friends to spark conversations about heritage and identity.

The formation of early cultural identities, particularly the entity often referred to as "Anglo-Saxon," was greatly shaped by the combination of spiritual practices, forms of interaction, and the employment of various artifacts.

Roberts explores the ways in which spirituality, the evolution of interaction, and the creation of physical cultural objects have collectively shaped distinctive identities, focusing especially on the emergence of the identity often known as "Anglo-Saxon." Archaeological discoveries suggest a scenario more intricate than the traditional narrative of a vast migratory wave that supplanted Britain's original population, revealing a gradual shift, the intentional adoption of new cultural elements, and a blending of British and Germanic traditions. Roberts emphasizes the need for careful consideration when using the phrase "Anglo-Saxon," highlighting its deep historical implications and how it has been co-opted by racist beliefs.

Practical Tips

• Engage in mindful reading by pausing to reflect on the language used in current news articles or books, especially when historical terms are mentioned. When you encounter a term like "Anglo-Saxon," take a moment to consider whether it's being used accurately or if it might be perpetuating misconceptions. This habit will sharpen your critical thinking skills and encourage you to question the narratives presented to you.

Other Perspectives

• The focus on spirituality, interaction, and artifacts might overlook the role of language and literature in shaping the "Anglo-Saxon" identity, as these are also crucial elements of culture that contribute to shared identity and social cohesion.
• The term "mass migration" itself may be a simplification, as migrations occur over time and can involve multiple waves of people, not a single, uniform movement.
• Some aspects of cultural change could have been resisted by local populations, suggesting that the process was more complex and not entirely about intentional adoption and blending.

The customs linked to interment and the accompanying artifacts mirror the intricacies of hierarchical dynamics and the creation of political alliances.

Funerary artifacts, along with the sites of graves, were deliberately used to assert territorial control and strengthen power.

The segment of the book delves into how customs related to funerals and the accompanying artifacts serve as powerful tools to assert territorial dominance and strengthen political authority. Roberts highlights the deliberate choice to locate Anglo-Saxon graves in proximity to age-old barrows, suggesting a significant connection with long-deceased forebears and reinforcing claims to control over particular lands. The discovery of weapons and emblems of status in the graves of elite figures highlights how combat skill and social position were crucial in establishing power, reflecting the emerging hierarchical systems in the territories governed by the Anglo-Saxons.

Other Perspectives

• The association between grave sites and territorial claims might not be universally applicable across different cultures or time periods, suggesting that such practices may not be a consistent indicator of power dynamics.
• The proximity of Anglo-Saxon graves to ancient barrows could be coincidental, given that ancient barrows were often located in prominent landscapes which were also desirable for new settlements and burials.
• The interpretation of grave goods as indicators of a hierarchical system may be an oversimplification, as it does not account for the possibility of egalitarian or other forms of social organization that might have valued such items differently.

The interplay between local and regional entities and the expansive systems of commerce and sway.

Roberts explores the complex interplay between local societies, wider regional exchanges, and extensive trade and influence networks that shaped Britain's cultural landscape following the period of Roman control. Alice Roberts demonstrates how Britain's cultural ties with continental Europe and the wider Mediterranean area are reinforced through the spread of cultural artifacts, traditions, and practices. The formation of early England's cultural identity was shaped by a diverse array of influences, which is demonstrated by the belts that signified status at Dyke Hills in Dorchester, the discovery of a Byzantine bucket at Breamore, and the Scandinavian-style brooches excavated in Scremby. The relationships were marked by substantial migrations and the persistent exchange of ideas, traditions, and objects across various eras and locales.

Context

• Objects like belts, buckets, and brooches are not just functional items but also carry symbolic meanings, reflecting the social status, cultural affiliations, and artistic influences of the time.
• Linguistic influences, seen in the adoption of Latin and later the integration of Norse and Norman words, reflect the broader cultural interactions with Europe and beyond.
• After the Roman withdrawal from Britain, the remnants of Roman infrastructure, such as roads and forts, continued to influence local governance and trade, facilitating connections between different regions.
• The discovery of a Byzantine bucket in Breamore, Hampshire, suggests long-distance trade or gift exchanges, highlighting connections between Britain and the Eastern Roman Empire, known for its rich artistic and cultural heritage.
• The blending of different cultural elements, such as Roman, Celtic, and Germanic traditions, led to unique cultural practices and artifacts in Britain.