PDF Summary:Building Thinking Classrooms in Mathematics, by Peter Liljedahl

What if classrooms were designed to stimulate students' analytical thinking? In Building Thinking Classrooms in Mathematics, Peter Liljedahl proposes reshaping traditional classrooms into learning environments that facilitate critical thinking and collaboration. From rearranging classroom layouts to overhauling teaching practices, he introduces methods to boost students' active mental engagement.

His framework details how incorporating exploratory tasks, flexible group formations, and supportive facilitation roles can immerse students in problem-solving processes. Liljedahl also advocates assessment tools that measure conceptual growth over test scores, fostering a culture of persistent learning.

(continued)...

• By circulating, teachers can provide immediate feedback, which is crucial for correcting misunderstandings and reinforcing learning in real-time.
• Regularly assessing students' understanding through informal methods allows teachers to identify specific needs and adjust their strategies to support each group's unique learning journey.
• Tailoring the difficulty of tasks to meet the diverse needs of students is a key aspect of differentiated instruction, which aims to optimize learning for all students by addressing their individual strengths and weaknesses.
• Incorporating tools that help students visualize and understand abstract concepts, making it easier to grasp difficult mathematical ideas.

Crafting lessons that enable a smooth transition from phases of productive struggle to those directed by the teacher.

Liljedahl suggests an instructional structure that harmonizes the self-directed investigation of captivating problems by students with intervals during which the educator orchestrates the synthesis of learning. This equilibrium is essential for stimulating thought and for transforming shared comprehension into personal insight.

Practical Tips

• Partner with a friend or colleague for a 'Role Reversal' exercise where you teach each other something new, alternating between the roles of student and teacher. When you're the teacher, focus on guiding without giving direct answers; when you're the student, practice seeking clarity and understanding through your own analysis. This will help you experience and appreciate the balance between autonomy and guidance from both perspectives.

Fostering an educational environment that motivates students to actively engage in and assume responsibility for their learning journey.

Creating a learning space and employing teaching techniques that nurture self-reliance and responsibility in learners is crucial, especially in the context of a classroom aimed at encouraging analytical thought. Students not only participate actively in their learning process but also take charge of their educational path.

Learners steering their educational journey and making use of accessible tools.

The author highlights the importance of fostering independence among students and their ability to utilize available resources.

Encouraging the exchange of ideas and cooperative work among student teams.

Liljedahl proposes methods to foster self-directed learning in students throughout their educational journey. This entails fostering a dynamic interchange of thoughts among groups instead of depending exclusively on the instructor for direction. Educators cultivate a cooperative atmosphere where students are motivated to solicit feedback, investigate different methods, and compare their answers with those of their classmates, thus leveraging the collective intellect of the classroom. This approach promotes independence, diminishes the sense of defeat, and reinforces the concepts linked to learning collaboratively.

Practical Tips

• Use social media to initiate a weekly challenge that prompts your network to share innovative solutions to common problems. For example, you could post a problem like reducing food waste, and ask for creative strategies. This encourages a collective brainstorming session online, fostering a community-driven approach to problem-solving.
• Utilize online platforms to find additional educational resources related to your course. Websites like Coursera, Khan Academy, or even YouTube have a wealth of information that can supplement your learning. By actively seeking out these resources, you're diversifying your learning materials and not relying solely on your instructor's guidance.
• Pair up with someone who has different strengths or perspectives for a mutual mentoring session. Spend an hour each week discussing challenges and offering each other advice. This practice can lead to a deeper understanding of cooperative dynamics and the value of diverse skill sets in problem-solving.
• Volunteer to teach a topic you're studying to someone else, which will force you to explore different ways of explaining the material and thus, different methods of understanding it. For instance, if you're learning a new language, try teaching basic phrases to a friend using visual aids, and then switch to using music or games in the next session to see which method is more effective.
• Use a collaborative online document, like Google Docs, to compile a shared class study guide. Each student can contribute their answers to a collective document, which allows everyone to see various approaches to the same problems. This method not only helps in comparing answers but also in creating a comprehensive resource that benefits the entire class.
• Start a personal project that requires learning a new skill, such as building a piece of furniture, gardening, or coding a simple website. By taking on a project from start to finish, you'll rely on your resourcefulness and decision-making, reinforcing your self-sufficiency.
• Develop a habit of verbalizing positive outcomes from difficult situations to friends or family. By articulating the silver linings or lessons learned, you reinforce the idea that defeat is not absolute. For instance, if you didn't get a job you interviewed for, tell someone about the interview skills you improved or the clarity you gained about what you're looking for in your next role.
• Start a virtual study group with friends or colleagues to tackle a new subject together. Use a platform like Discord or Slack to create a dedicated space for sharing resources, discussing concepts, and asking questions. This encourages active participation and allows members to learn from each other's perspectives and insights.

Students should take the initiative to evaluate their own learning progress and identify specific aspects that require further comprehension.

Students should transition from a passive role to actively engaging in their own evaluation process. Students continuously evaluate their understanding, acknowledging their strengths and pinpointing areas that need further enhancement, while simultaneously considering their future learning goals.

Context

• Acknowledging strengths helps students develop self-awareness, which is crucial for effective learning. It allows them to understand what strategies work best for them and how they can leverage these strengths in different contexts.
• Future learning goals enable students to tailor their educational experiences to align with their interests and career aspirations, fostering a more personalized approach to learning.

Learners progressively take on greater accountability for their educational process.

Liljedhal champions the deliberate shift in accountability towards the students to truly cultivate a classroom atmosphere that highlights active cognitive engagement. This process requires scaffolding and a gradual increase in student ownership.

Learners engage in tasks designed to assess their comprehension.

The author suggests replacing traditional "homework" with questions aimed at evaluating each learner's understanding. The inquiries mirror those found in conventional practice exercises. The activities aim to give students opportunities to enhance their understanding and identify specific areas where their learning can be improved, instead of being used as tasks for assessment. Liljedahl suggests supplying questions along with their answers to enable students to immediately gauge their understanding, emphasizing that these tools are designed for more than just the teacher's use.

Context

• This approach aligns with constructivist educational theories, which advocate for learning as an active, constructive process where students build new knowledge upon their existing understanding.
• Ensuring that questions are similar to practice exercises helps maintain alignment with curriculum goals and learning objectives, reinforcing key concepts and skills.
• Knowing that they can check their answers immediately can reduce anxiety and pressure associated with traditional homework, making learning a more positive experience.
• Tutors can use these tools to better tailor their sessions to the specific needs of students, providing targeted assistance based on the areas where students struggle the most.

Students should be motivated to take charge of recording their own notes and assimilating the knowledge they have gathered.

Peter Liljedahl recommends a transformative approach to teaching that encourages students to independently develop meaningful notes, rather than adhering to the conventional practice in which the teacher directs the note-taking process. The notes are created by the students for their own future reference, instead of merely transcribing what is displayed on the boards. This method encourages students to convert collaborative learning into individual understanding by inspiring them to extract key concepts, create original examples, and enrich their notes with insightful reflections.

Practical Tips

• You can enhance your teaching methods by incorporating storytelling into your lessons, using narratives to explain complex concepts. By crafting a story around a mathematical problem or a historical event, you engage students' imaginations, making the material more memorable and relatable. For example, when teaching about the Pythagorean theorem, create a tale about a character who needs to determine the right distance to safely reach a point, using the theorem as the solution.
• Use technology to enhance your independent note-taking by utilizing apps that allow for voice-to-text functionality. As you read or listen to lectures, speak your notes into the app, and then later, organize them into coherent summaries. This can help you engage with the material more actively and make the note-taking process more dynamic.
• After finishing a chapter, challenge yourself to teach the core concepts to a friend or family member without notes. This exercise forces you to distill the information into its most essential parts and can highlight areas where your understanding is lacking, prompting further review.
• Try using flashcards with a twist: on one side, write down key concepts from your studies, and on the other, attach a personal anecdote or example that illustrates the concept. This method not only aids in memorization but also encourages you to connect the material to your own experiences, making it more relevant and easier to recall.
• Implement a 'note expansion' routine at the end of each day. Set aside 10 minutes to revisit your notes and expand on them with additional thoughts, questions, or connections to other topics. This habit not only reinforces the day's learning but also encourages the practice of regular reflection, making it a natural part of your study process.
• Create a knowledge integration journal where you reflect on new information daily, connecting it to what you already know. By writing down how new concepts relate to your existing knowledge, you create a web of understanding that reinforces learning. For example, after reading about historical events, you might note similarities with current events or draw parallels with personal experiences.
• Encourage students to create their own note-taking symbols and abbreviations. By developing a personal shorthand system, students can take notes more efficiently and in a way that makes sense to them. For example, they might use "&" for "and," "w/" for "with," or create symbols for frequently used terms in their courses.

Equipping students with tools to monitor their progress and identify areas for improvement.

Liljedahl underscores the significance of guiding students to acknowledge where they stand in their educational journey and the trajectory they are on as they approach the final stage of autonomous learning. This involves equipping learners with tools that facilitate their self-assessment of progress toward specific educational goals and their capability across different levels of challenge. The instruments provide a framework that assists students in self-assessing their performance on different evaluations, including quizzes and exams, which promotes recognition of their capabilities, potential growth areas, and overall progress.

Context

• Students are encouraged to engage in reflective practice, regularly considering what they have learned and how they can apply it to future challenges.
• By understanding their progress, students can feel more in control of their learning journey, which can increase motivation and engagement in the subject matter.
• Tools for self-assessment can include rubrics, checklists, reflective journals, and digital platforms that provide instant feedback. These tools help students understand criteria for success and measure their performance against these benchmarks.
• Digital platforms or apps can provide visual representations of progress over time, such as graphs or charts, which help students see their development and areas needing attention.

Assessment strategies ought to be crafted to nurture the development of individual understanding.

In an educational environment that emphasizes the mental activities of learners, the methods used for assessment and evaluation must be transformed to align with the goals and principles of such a setting.

Utilizing assessment methods that emphasize outcomes and the evaluation of data.

The author advocates for a transition from traditional point-based grading systems to alternative assessment strategies that emphasize learning outcomes, student growth, and mastery through a thorough examination of educational data.

Creating assessment standards collaboratively with students to gauge attributes like perseverance and collaborative effort.

Liljedahl advocates for the creation of uniform standards to evaluate student attributes like persistence, readiness to embrace risks, and collaborative skills. The evaluation framework, developed in partnership with students, emphasizes the significance of these skills and provides a basis for teacher evaluations and for students to gauge their own progress. Incorporating student voices and emphasizing clear, observable indicators transforms these tools into potent elements that foster a learning environment that encourages the evolution of a culture of thought.

Practical Tips

• Engage in role-playing scenarios to boost your risk-taking readiness. Imagine different situations where taking risks is necessary, such as pitching an idea to a group or trying out a new hobby that seems daunting. Act out these scenarios either alone or with a partner, and navigate through the decision-making process. This exercise can help you become more comfortable with uncertainty and develop a mindset that embraces calculated risks.
• Use a goal-setting app to set and track personal objectives that align with the standards you wish to achieve. Choose an app that allows you to break down your goals into actionable steps and provides reminders and motivational features to keep you on track. If your goal is to become more physically active, you could set standards for weekly exercise frequency, types of activities, and duration, then monitor your adherence to these standards over time.
• Organize a student-led conference where they present their understanding of the assessment criteria. This gives students the opportunity to articulate what they've learned about the indicators and how they apply to their work. It also provides a platform for them to share their insights and suggestions for improving the assessment process.
• Encourage family or friends to engage in structured debates on topics of mutual interest to practice defending and critiquing ideas. Organize a casual debate night where each person comes prepared to discuss a topic. Before the debate, agree on rules for constructive engagement and criteria for evaluating arguments. This activity can sharpen everyone's ability to think critically and articulate their thoughts while respecting different viewpoints.

Developing instruments that provide thorough understanding of students' educational advancement.

Liljedahl promotes the utilization of instruments that bolster the learning journey and simultaneously offer a mechanism for continuous evaluation, as well as assisting students in monitoring their own advancement. The instruments provide a thorough examination of academic outcomes and the complexity of their challenges, allowing learners to pinpoint their strengths and the aspects that need enhancement. Students are enabled to guide their own learning process, identify aspects needing enhancement, and track their progress through this form of feedback.

Context

• By using these instruments, students develop metacognitive skills, which involve thinking about their own thinking processes, helping them become more aware of their learning strategies and outcomes.
• These tools often utilize data analytics to provide insights into student performance trends over time. This data can help identify patterns and inform instructional decisions, ensuring that teaching methods are responsive to student needs.
• Unlike summative assessments, which evaluate student learning at the end of an instructional period, formative assessments are ongoing and provide immediate feedback to help students improve during the learning process.

Shifting the focus in assessment methods from a point-accumulation system to one that prioritizes data gathering.

Liljedahl champions a substantial shift in assessment methods, transitioning from an emphasis on accumulating points to a framework that prioritizes the gathering of information. This necessitates a significant departure from the traditional methods typically used to evaluate student learning, focusing on:

Emphasizing the growth and skill mastery of students rather than just the accumulation of scores.

The method of collecting information emphasizes the accumulation of proof that demonstrates the spectrum of student understanding across various educational objectives and their associated intricacies. This methodology enhances the precision and depth of insight into student progress, recognizing development and proficiency instead of penalizing initial misconceptions or concentrating exclusively on examination results.

Practical Tips

• Implement a 'concept application challenge' where you take a new concept learned and find a way to apply it in a real-world scenario within a week. For example, if you're learning a new mathematical principle, try to use it in a practical situation like budgeting or DIY projects. This hands-on approach reinforces learning and provides a deeper understanding of the material's relevance and application.
• Start a peer recognition group with friends or colleagues where you meet monthly to share and celebrate each other's accomplishments. This could be as simple as a group chat or a coffee meet-up where each person shares something they've improved on or learned recently. It fosters a supportive environment and encourages acknowledgment of progress among peers.
• Implement a 'two-question rule' in conversations to avoid penalizing misconceptions. Whenever someone expresses a view that you believe is a misconception, ask two genuine questions to understand their perspective before offering your own insights. This approach promotes a culture of curiosity and learning, rather than one of correction and penalty.
• Volunteer for an organization or cause that resonates with your values to gain practical experience and skills that exams don't measure. Look for opportunities in your community where you can contribute and learn, such as helping at a local shelter, participating in environmental clean-ups, or assisting in community-driven projects. This hands-on experience can provide a sense of accomplishment and personal growth that complements academic achievements.

Incorporating a range of evidence, including firsthand observations and engaging conversations, is crucial to the evaluation process.

To enhance the accuracy and relevance of evaluating student outcomes, Liljedahl suggests incorporating diverse forms of evidence into the assessment approach. This involves a detailed analysis of the outcomes of student assessments as well as a meticulous monitoring of their thought processes and conversations in a setting that fosters active intellectual participation.

Other Perspectives

• The emphasis on a range of evidence could inadvertently devalue the importance of mastery of content, which is often best assessed through traditional testing methods.
• Firsthand observations can be subjective and may not always accurately reflect a student's abilities or knowledge.
• Engaging conversations are time-consuming and may not be practical as a primary assessment tool within the constraints of a typical school term or semester.
• Some forms of evidence, particularly subjective ones like conversations, may introduce bias into the evaluation process.
• The pressure of detailed analysis could contribute to assessment anxiety among students, which may negatively impact their performance and thus the accuracy of the evaluation.
• Focusing too much on thought processes could lead to subjective evaluations, as different observers may interpret the same thought process in different ways.
• The dynamics of a conversation can be affected by groupthink, where a desire for harmony or conformity in the group results in an irrational or dysfunctional decision-making outcome.

The foundational components and necessary aspects to create and implement a "Thinking Classroom"

To successfully apply these methods, Liljedahl recommends a structured strategy aimed at creating a learning atmosphere that supports and encourages critical thinking.

A systematic approach to implement the framework designed for the cultivation of Thinking Classrooms.

The structure underpinning "Building Thinking Classrooms" is carefully designed to foster a setting that is favorable to reflection and learning. This framework is not merely an assortment of practices; it is a carefully developed sequence aimed at enhancing student engagement, mental processes, and academic achievements, all of which are supported by thorough research and empirical evidence.

The foundational set of tools includes the development of key elements like assignments, collaborative group structures, and designated workspaces.

The core strategies necessitate a thorough transformation of the educational environment's framework and the creation of new routine practices. The modifications aimed to transform the educational environment and change how students view their role in the learning process.

Other Perspectives

• Focusing solely on these elements might overlook the importance of technology integration, which is increasingly seen as a critical component of modern education.
• A thorough transformation might be resource-intensive and not feasible for all institutions, suggesting a need for scalable and adaptable strategies.
• The emphasis on new routines might overlook the value of tradition and the benefits of established practices that have proven effective over time.
• A focus on environmental transformation may overlook the importance of individualized student support and the role of teachers in facilitating learning.
• There is a risk that modifications could be perceived as top-down impositions, potentially leading to resistance rather than a change in how students view their role.

Enhancing the array of instructional techniques, which includes the manner in which questions are presented and the provision of assessments and synopses of learned content, is essential.

The second collection of instruments aims to improve teaching techniques and stimulate increased participation from learners, thus preserving and nurturing their cognitive functions. Educators must consciously adapt their roles and interactions to prioritize fostering students' cognitive growth rather than simply conveying knowledge.

Context

• Synopses provide concise summaries of what has been learned, helping students consolidate their knowledge and reflect on key concepts. This can aid in long-term retention and understanding.
• Designing a physical and emotional classroom space that is welcoming and inclusive can make students feel safe to express their ideas and participate without fear of judgment.
• Educators provide temporary support structures to assist students in reaching higher levels of understanding, gradually removing these supports as students become more independent.
• Connecting learning to real-world contexts can make content more relevant and engaging, helping students see the practical value of their cognitive efforts.

The third toolkit incorporates strategies to promote student autonomy and responsibility.

The third toolkit focuses on developing students' ability to guide their own educational journey and take responsibility for their learning outcomes. In this structured approach, students are encouraged to chart their own course in learning, utilize available resources, and take charge of their progress.

Practical Tips

• Develop a feedback loop with peers where you regularly exchange work or learning progress for critique. This encourages you to be accountable for your learning as you're not just presenting to yourself but to others who expect progress. For instance, if you're studying graphic design, you could share your latest project with a friend every two weeks and discuss areas for improvement.
• You can create a personalized learning plan by identifying your goals and breaking them down into smaller, manageable tasks. Start by writing down what you want to achieve in your learning journey, whether it's mastering a new language or understanding quantum physics. Then, set weekly or monthly milestones that will help you track your progress. For example, if you're learning a new language, your first milestone could be to learn 50 basic words, and the next could be to construct simple sentences using those words.
• Create a resource map of your educational environment to visually identify and locate resources you might not be aware of. Start by listing all the places and people in your school or university that offer help, such as tutoring centers, libraries, career services, and professors' office hours. Then, use a campus map to mark these resources, creating a visual guide that you can refer to whenever you need support.
• Develop a habit tracker in a notebook or digital app to monitor the frequency of your study sessions or the time spent on specific subjects. By tracking your habits, you can identify patterns, optimize your study schedule, and ensure consistent effort towards your educational goals.

Integrating methods designed to evaluate and measure learning into the fourth collection of instruments.

The final collection of instruments includes techniques for evaluating and assessing student advancement in a manner that aligns with the goals of a thinking classroom. This entails transitioning to an evaluation system that prioritizes educational achievements, utilizes criteria created through teamwork, and incorporates diverse sources of evidence.

Practical Tips

• Use a free online survey tool to gather feedback on your learning from peers or mentors. After completing a learning project or presentation, create a simple survey with questions that focus on the effectiveness of your knowledge application. Share the survey with individuals who observed your work or with whom you've discussed the topic. Their feedback can provide insights into areas where your understanding is strong and where it might need further development.
• You can create a personal achievement portfolio to showcase your educational milestones and learning experiences. Start by collecting certificates, awards, and any other evidence of your educational achievements. Then, organize them into a digital or physical portfolio. This can be used for job interviews, career advancement, or personal reflection to remind yourself of your accomplishments and the knowledge you've gained.
• You can create a shared digital board for your team to collaboratively develop evaluation criteria. Use a platform like Trello or Asana where each member can contribute ideas, vote on them, and discuss them in real-time. This ensures that everyone has a voice in the process and can see the evolution of the criteria from inception to finalization.
• Start a 'diversity of evidence' journaling practice to improve critical thinking. Each week, choose a topic you're interested in and write down different types of evidence related to it, such as scientific research, news articles, podcasts, and social media discussions. Reflect on how each source adds to your understanding of the topic and note any biases or gaps in the information.

The method evolves annually, beginning with the creation and progressing towards the rejuvenation of an environment that cultivates critical thinking.

To preserve the advancement of a setting that fosters analytical reasoning in mathematics, continuous refinements and enhancements are crucial.

Employing established norms to ease the integration of the new framework with those who are just beginning.

Teachers can apply their understanding of the current framework and established norms to facilitate the integration of thinking classroom strategies tailored to diverse student groups annually. Students need some time to get used to an environment that necessitates deep thinking and active engagement, but the teacher's expertise and the existing structures facilitate a smoother transition.

Context

• Teachers often work within established educational frameworks that outline curriculum goals, teaching methods, and assessment standards. Familiarity with these frameworks allows teachers to adapt new strategies in a way that aligns with existing educational objectives.
• Teachers with experience in traditional and innovative teaching methods can anticipate student challenges and provide targeted support, making the transition to new learning environments less daunting for students.

Students progressively take charge and assume greater responsibility for their educational progression.

Educators should annually focus on gradually nurturing increased independence and responsibility within their student body. Students must take greater initiative in monitoring their personal growth, identifying their own areas for enhancement, and seeking out pertinent feedback proactively.

Practical Tips

• You can foster independence in young people by assigning them a "Project Day" each week where they choose what they want to learn or create. This could be anything from a science experiment to an art project, and they must plan it, execute it, and present their results or creation. This encourages self-directed learning and accountability.
• Create a personal growth dashboard using a free online tool like Google Sheets to track your progress in different areas of your life. Start by identifying key areas you want to improve in, such as academic skills, health, or personal relationships. Set specific, measurable goals for each area and update your dashboard weekly with your progress, challenges, and reflections.