PDF Summary:Belonging, by Toko-pa Turner

In our modern age, many struggle with a sense of disconnection, longing to experience genuine belonging. In Belonging by Toko-pa Turner, the author explores this pervasive feeling of estrangement and offers ways to cultivate meaningful connections—to oneself, to communities, and to nature itself.

Turner examines how ingrained societal beliefs, past traumas, and the digital age contribute to alienation. She proposes that by embracing vulnerability, honoring creativity and symbolism, participating in rituals, and fostering reciprocal bonds with the environment, individuals can heal inner wounds and find their authentic place in the world.

(continued)...

• Philosophers like Viktor Frankl argue that meaning is often found through suffering and overcoming difficulties, suggesting that obstacles can lead to a deeper sense of purpose.

Our feelings of loneliness and disconnection often stem from the narratives and beliefs that our family, culture, and social surroundings have ingrained in us.

Turner maintains that each individual is born into families and communities with their own unique perspectives and values. We internalize these belief systems through the mediums of cultural traditions, linguistic expression, and the creation of art. Society can often make us feel inferior for having traits or characteristics that differ from what is considered standard. We might experience a sense of fragmentation, feeling obliged to dismiss or exile parts of ourselves deemed unwelcome. During their younger years, a person may be mocked for their imaginative or delicate disposition, which can lead to the internalization of these adverse critiques, forming similar obstacles inside themselves.

Practical Tips

• Create a "Traits I Value" collage using images and words from magazines or printed from online sources that represent the unique qualities you appreciate in yourself and others. This visual representation serves as a daily reminder to celebrate diversity in traits and can help reinforce a positive self-image that is independent of societal standards.
• Start a 'fragmented self' journal where you dedicate pages to different parts of yourself, especially those you feel compelled to reject. On each page, write about why you feel that way, where those feelings might come from, and list three positive attributes or contributions that aspect brings to your life.
• Engage in role-playing exercises with a trusted friend where you practice responding to mockery or criticism in a constructive manner. Take turns playing both the critic and the individual with imaginative traits. This can help you prepare for real-life situations, build resilience, and ensure that your delicate traits are not overshadowed by fear of ridicule.

To cultivate belonging, it is essential to embody and celebrate one's true, creative self, shedding any false or limiting beliefs about oneself.

To mend our inner wounds stemming from life's harsh lessons, it's imperative to recognize the unconscious incantations influencing us. Turner suggests that our dreams have the power to reveal the falsehoods in the narratives we've adopted, particularly by exposing the shallow sense of connection we may have settled for that drains our vitality. Acknowledging the compromises we have made allows us to reclaim the lost pieces of ourselves and embark on a path toward wholeness and a sense of connection with others.

Developing the resilience to embrace vulnerability and bravely confront obstacles and dismissals is of utmost importance.

Turner coins the term "vulnerabravery" to highlight the courage necessary to remain authentic, especially in settings that frequently overlook the importance of sensitivity. To enhance our understanding and connection with our own limitations, the struggles of others, and the global difficulties, it is essential to bolster our resilience. Toko-pa Turner suggests that true belonging emerges from our readiness to embrace vulnerability and that accepting all parts of ourselves, the bright and the dark, is crucial for attaining wholeness.

Other Perspectives

• The focus on courage to remain authentic might inadvertently imply that those who choose to protect their sensitivity or conceal it in hostile environments are less courageous, which could be an unfair judgment of their coping strategies.
• Focusing on resilience might also shift the responsibility for coping and adapting onto individuals, potentially overlooking the societal and structural changes needed to alleviate the struggles and challenges in the first place.
• The idea of embracing all aspects of oneself, including the negative, might not resonate with everyone, especially if it conflicts with personal values or the pursuit of self-improvement.

We must seek out mentors and knowledgeable people who mirror our entirety rather than proposing a sense of inclusion dependent on specific stipulations.

Turner notes that the lack of guidance from elders in modern society significantly contributes to our feeling of being cut off from the ancestral knowledge and guidance that used to lead us. Guidance from elders is crucial in helping us recognize our true selves and align with our life's purpose. Elders personify the essence of community by continually nurturing bonds among its members and imparting their wisdom to the upcoming generations through their actions and presence. Turner advocates seeking mentors who mirror our complete selves instead of insisting on adherence to a singular perspective.

Other Perspectives

• Seeking mentors who mirror our entirety might limit exposure to diverse perspectives and hinder the development of critical thinking skills, as it could create an echo chamber.
• The concept of "elders" as the primary source of guidance is culturally specific and may not apply universally. In some societies, peer learning and horizontal knowledge sharing are equally valued.
• In some cases, adherence to traditional elder wisdom without critical examination can perpetuate outdated or harmful practices that may not align with modern values or scientific understanding.
• It could be argued that the focus should be on the quality of the mentorship and the knowledge being imparted, rather than on how closely a mentor mirrors the mentee's identity or life experience.

Cultivating a feeling of inclusion is intricately linked to appreciating artistic expression, understanding the importance of symbolism, and caring for our internal worlds.

The symbolic life, which encompasses myths and dreams, is essential in reestablishing a person's sense of belonging.

Exploring the substance within our dreams can be a powerful approach to tap into the deep core that infuses life with significance and purpose.

Turner passionately supports the idea that delving deeply into our dreams can significantly lead us to a feeling of oneness. Toko-pa Turner suggests that dreams hold biological importance, serving as channels that allow the sacred aspects of the natural world to impart essential wisdom and guide our lives, ensuring our well-being. Turner regards dreamwork as a valuable tool for enhancing our physical and mental well-being, and she considers it a way to reconnect with a broader framework of meaning; it serves as a channel through which we can engage with the nuanced and symbolic expressions of a higher wisdom that provides understanding surpassing our usual realm of existence.

Other Perspectives

• The concept of oneness is philosophically and spiritually loaded, and not everyone may resonate with or seek such an experience from their dreams.
• The essential wisdom attributed to dreams could be subjective interpretations of the dreamer rather than an objective source of guidance, as there is no empirical evidence to suggest that dreams contain universal truths or knowledge.
• Mental well-being is a complex construct, and while dreamwork might offer benefits for some individuals, it may not be effective or could even be distressing for others, depending on their psychological state and personal experiences.

Through engaging in diverse creative activities, we can foster our inherent untamed traits, which in turn helps us establish a profound connection with our authentic position in the world.

Turner believes that our innate voice within each person is expressed through our creative impulses. Our distinct essence, which is wild and interwoven with our ancestry, the planet, and the mysterious nature of our bond with these aspects, characterizes who we are. To recognize and harness the skills we've previously ignored, thereby realizing our innate potential for creation, we must delve into the wild realm of creativity, which is crucial for uncovering our true selves. Turner suggests that we first draw inspiration from our surroundings, immerse ourselves in creative endeavors that incorporate a spectrum of colors and a variety of sounds, and give voice to the dreams we hold inside.

Other Perspectives

• The idea that creativity is the primary means of expressing our innate voice may overlook the role of logic and analytical thought processes in shaping personal expression and identity.
• The emphasis on a bond with the planet and ancestry might overlook the influence of technological and digital environments on modern identity formation.
• Focusing solely on ignored skills may lead to the neglect of developing existing strengths, which could also be crucial for realizing one's creative potential.
• The concept of a "true self" is philosophically contentious; some argue that the self is constantly evolving and cannot be definitively uncovered.
• Relying heavily on external stimuli like colors and sounds might actually distract some people from their creative process rather than enhance it.
• Voicing dreams without a plan or action can lead to frustration or disillusionment if those dreams remain unfulfilled.

Attaining a state of completeness and unity is closely linked to balancing what are commonly seen as masculine and feminine energies, as well as acknowledging the importance of the frequently overlooked feminine characteristics.

Turner emphasizes the importance of nurturing a harmonious relationship with the often-overlooked feminine aspect in societies where masculine values prevail. She suggests that people possess a blend of traits typically identified as masculine and feminine, but in numerous modern historical settings, qualities linked to femininity have been undervalued and overlooked. Turner encourages us to accept our inherent "Eros," which includes our tenderness, intuitive knowledge, compassion, and the insights that arise out of our physical existence.

Overcoming challenges like the quest for perfection and the habit of comparing oneself to others, while fostering authentic creative expression, can greatly enhance the affirmation of one's own sense of belonging and connection.

To genuinely master the art of tapping into the wellspring that nurtures our feeling of inclusion, we are obliged to overcome the unconscious obstacles that restrict us. For example, the relentless pursuit of perfection can become a debilitating force. Toko-pa Turner inspires us to take cues from the natural world, which consistently shows that beauty is often accompanied by the unforeseen. She also warns that comparing ourselves to others may diminish our individuality and plunge us into cycles of uncertainty, ultimately cutting off our link to our true selves and the special gifts we are eager to offer.

Context

• Different cultures may have varying expectations regarding success and individuality, influencing how people perceive perfection and comparison.
• Psychological studies suggest that perfectionism is associated with mental health issues such as depression, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and eating disorders, highlighting its potentially harmful effects.
• Natural processes, like the changing of seasons or the weathering of rocks, demonstrate that transformation and unpredictability are inherent to growth and beauty.
• Constant comparison can also strain relationships, as it may lead to jealousy, resentment, or a lack of genuine connection with others.
• Personal identity is shaped by self-reflection and understanding one's values and beliefs. Avoiding comparison allows for a clearer development of this identity, leading to a more fulfilling life.

Creating handmade objects or shaping the stories of our lives enhances our bond to the natural world, highlighting our cultural legacy and the importance of reciprocal sharing.

Turner suggests we acquire traditional skills such as basket weaving, culinary arts, horticulture, or various manual crafts. By reawakening these latent abilities, we reinforce our connection with our ancestors and enhance our recognition of the inherent value and beauty inherent in the commonplace objects we employ. This "slowness," a practice of deliberate focus, not only nurtures the mind's capacity for inventive awareness, it also restores a once lessened profound admiration. Our understanding grows as we recognize the interdependent bond with nature, thus strengthening our commitment to protect the essential components of our well-being.

Other Perspectives

• There might be a lack of resources or access to learn these skills, especially in urban environments where space and nature are limited.
• The assumption that manual crafts and traditional skills are latent abilities within all individuals is debatable; not everyone may have an inherent or ancestral skill set to reawaken.
• In some contexts, speed and efficiency are valued and necessary, and the ability to quickly adapt and make decisions can be seen as a form of inventive awareness.
• Understanding can sometimes be hindered by an overly romanticized view of nature, which may ignore the complexities and challenges of natural processes and ecosystems.
• The concept of what constitutes "essential components of well-being" can vary greatly among different cultures, societies, and individuals, making a universal approach to protection challenging.

Cultivating a sense of belonging arises from our active participation in community life, our shared experiences in communal ceremonies, and deepening our connection with nature.

Belonging requires cultivating abilities that bolster community through the promotion of shared values, reciprocal exchange, and the preservation of cultural traditions.

Cultivating an attitude that recognizes and validates others is crucial for nurturing a feeling of inclusion.

Turner notes that many individuals long for community inclusion, yet the dominant social structure has become increasingly alienated from understanding and practicing communal living. Simply partaking in shared meals from time to time does not suffice; it's essential to participate in the community's support system by extending genuine warmth and attentively acknowledging and responding to the requirements of fellow members. Being allowed into someone else's personal space is a privilege that develops as we create a welcoming atmosphere for that individual. Turner highlights the importance of creating a nurturing space where active listening and mutual exchange are prioritized, where individual gifts are held in high regard, and where a person's passions are encouraged over a focus on their 'usefulness' or achievements.

Other Perspectives

• There is a risk that emphasizing validation of others could lead to performative actions rather than genuine inclusion, where the underlying issues of exclusion are not truly resolved.
• The rise of global issues and movements has led to the formation of international communities united by common causes, suggesting that communal living may be expanding in scope rather than diminishing.
• For some individuals or cultures, shared meals are a primary way to celebrate community and inclusion, and their importance should not be underestimated.
• Genuine warmth cannot be mandated or artificially created; it must arise naturally, and efforts to enforce it can lead to insincerity or superficial interactions.
• Constantly responding to the needs of others might prevent a community from encouraging resilience and self-sufficiency among its members.
• Some individuals may have cultural or personal boundaries that mean they do not perceive the sharing of personal space as a privilege, regardless of the atmosphere created.
• Prioritizing active listening and mutual exchange can sometimes lead to decision-making paralysis, where too much discussion prevents timely action.
• Valuing individual gifts highly may not be sufficient for fostering inclusion if it is not accompanied by structural changes that address systemic barriers preventing full participation of all community members.
• Encouraging passions without a balance of focus on achievements might not prepare individuals for the competitive nature of many aspects of society, such as the job market or higher education.

Participating in time-honored ceremonies and synchronizing with the natural world's cadences can anchor a person within a wider story and a web of relationships.

Turner underscores the importance of ritual in providing a concrete shape to the experiences and transitions of life, ensuring that they receive recognition. Turner suggests that rituals act as tangible expressions of the changes within us, highlighting their importance in our lives. The narrative is further empowered by the observation of these events by onlookers. By recognizing our own difficulties, like suffering, apprehension, or perplexity, and extending a helping hand to our peers during their times of struggle, we fortify our communal bonds and learn to navigate life's complexities in ways that solitude cannot match.

Other Perspectives

• While participating in time-honored ceremonies can provide a sense of belonging, it may also inadvertently exclude or alienate individuals who do not share the same cultural or religious background, potentially creating a sense of otherness rather than unity.
• Some individuals may find grounding and a sense of belonging in other ways that do not involve the natural world, such as through digital communities, urban environments, or human-made systems.
• The assumption that rituals are necessary for recognition of life's transitions overlooks the possibility that informal, spontaneous, or personal acknowledgments can be equally meaningful.
• The internal changes within an individual can be highly personal and complex, and a ritual might oversimplify these changes, failing to capture the nuances of personal growth or transformation.
• Observing rituals can sometimes perpetuate narratives that are harmful or exclusionary to certain groups of people, especially if those rituals have historically been used to reinforce oppressive social structures.
• In certain contexts, the constant focus on difficulties might reinforce a negative group identity centered around suffering, which could overshadow other aspects of communal life and individual identity.
• While extending a helping hand can fortify relationships, it can also create a sense of dependency if not balanced with encouraging self-reliance.
• Communal support may not always be available or adequate for all individuals, making it necessary to find alternative ways to manage life's challenges.

Establishing a reciprocal and engaging bond with nature is essential for genuine belonging.

Nurturing a bond with the natural environment, grounded in the conviction that our surroundings are home to spirits and otherworldly beings, assists in healing the modern disconnection from nature.

Turner underscores our deep dependence on the natural world, recognizing the consequences of regarding the gifts from our planet as mere resources for unlimited exploitation. Toko-pa Turner underscores the necessity of re-establishing equilibrium in our reciprocal bond with the planet to authentically feel a connection of belonging. She describes how pre-colonial communities thrived by fostering a "gift economy" with the natural world, harmonizing their way of life with the rhythms of the environment and consistently giving back more than they took. She conveys deep regret in her writing as the modern emphasis on materialism results in a catastrophic disconnection, which in turn leads to an unparalleled rate of species loss and deterioration of the environment.

Turner encourages us to strengthen our connection with our environment by mastering the language of the terrain we occupy, tuning in to its age-old stories, honoring its inherent cycles, and tending to its needs, regardless of whether our own "grove" is simply a small area of vegetation in a city setting. Finding this kind of belonging requires us to step away from our anxieties about how to 'get ahead' and surrender to the slow, humble apprenticeship of nature.

Context

• Shared activities in natural settings, such as community gardens or conservation projects, can strengthen social bonds and create a sense of community belonging.
• In various mythologies and folklore, spirits and otherworldly beings are often depicted as guardians or embodiments of natural features, symbolizing the interconnectedness of humans and the environment.
• The natural environment provides essential resources such as clean air, water, food, and raw materials. These are fundamental for human health, economic activities, and overall well-being.
• Overuse of resources undermines efforts to create sustainable systems that balance human needs with environmental health.
• The industrial revolution and subsequent technological advancements have accelerated the exploitation of natural resources, leading to a detachment from the natural world and its cycles.
• The gift economy with nature promoted sustainability, as it encouraged taking only what was needed and giving back to the environment, ensuring resources were available for future generations.
• Unlike the traditional linear economy, a circular economy aims to eliminate waste and continually use resources. This involves designing products for longevity, repairability, and recyclability, ensuring that materials are returned to the environment in a beneficial way.
• Materialism contributes to pollution through the production and disposal of goods. Manufacturing processes release pollutants into the air and water, while non-biodegradable waste accumulates in landfills and oceans, harming wildlife.
• Engaging with nature's language involves being present and mindful, allowing individuals to experience the environment fully and develop a deeper appreciation and connection.
• Recognizing and respecting these cycles supports biodiversity, as many species rely on specific environmental cues for breeding, migration, and other life processes.
• Educating oneself and others about environmental issues and the importance of conservation can lead to more informed decisions and actions that benefit the planet.
• Reducing the focus on success can alleviate anxiety and improve mental health, leading to a more balanced and connected life.
• Learning from nature can inspire sustainable practices, such as permaculture, which mimic natural ecosystems to create self-sustaining agricultural systems.

Modern individuals can deepen their bond with nature and their ancestral heritage by respecting and upholding the traditions and insights of indigenous cultures.

Turner praises the global customs and heritages that have preserved a deep reverence for ecological variety, manifested through the mutual exchange and appreciation characterizing daily activities such as gathering and hunting, as well as ceremonial festivities. Toko-pa Turner suggests that people today can improve their existence by fostering profound gratitude and a strong appreciation for nature as well as the complexities found within their own unique life stories. Our sense of belonging is also shaped by difficult and painful experiences, which add to the wider narrative of our connectedness.

Turner advocates for the revival of traditional crafting techniques, including basket weaving, metalwork, and gardening, to preserve the heritage bequeathed by our forebears through storytelling. We also mend broken bonds and pay tribute to the essential offerings that arise spontaneously from our being, as we cultivate the art of creating beauty from the earth and harness the wisdom found in our own skilled workmanship. Engaging with age-old traditions and conversing with the diverse locales, societies, and beings that share our planet could be essential for our authentic integration and might prove vital for the continued existence of humankind.

Context

• Many indigenous languages contain unique concepts and terms that reflect a deep connection to the land and its cycles. Preserving these languages can help maintain the cultural heritage and ecological knowledge embedded within them.
• Ceremonies in various cultures often serve to reinforce the community’s connection to nature, marking seasonal changes, harvests, or other ecological events, and are integral in passing down ecological knowledge.
• Recognizing the interconnectedness of all life forms can lead to a more holistic understanding of one's place in the world, fostering a sense of belonging and purpose.
• Engaging with painful experiences can be a path to healing and reconciliation, both personally and collectively, allowing for the integration of these experiences into a cohesive life story.
• Reviving traditional crafts can create economic opportunities, particularly in rural or indigenous communities, by providing a source of income through the sale of handmade goods.
• Creating beauty from the earth emphasizes a sustainable relationship with nature. It involves using natural materials responsibly, which fosters an understanding of ecological balance and the importance of conservation.
• Many indigenous and traditional cultures emphasize a holistic worldview, where humans are seen as part of a larger natural and spiritual ecosystem. Adopting such perspectives can lead to more balanced and ethical decision-making.