PDF Summary:At The Existentialist Café, by Sarah Bakewell

At The Existentialist Café by Sarah Bakewell explores the foundations of existentialism and phenomenology through the lives and ideas of influential 20th-century philosophers. The book delves into the development of these schools of thought, shaped by the turbulent events of World Wars I and II and the social and political turmoil of that era.

Bakewell examines existentialism's embrace of individual freedom and human meaning-making against a backdrop of absurdity. From Husserl's inquiry into conscious experience to Heidegger's exploration of Being itself, the author illuminates core existential concepts. The lasting influence of these ideas is traced across cultures and creative spheres, revealing existentialism's enduring relevance.

(continued)...

The existentialists were instrumental in shaping the political landscape following the conflict.

Sarah Bakewell depicts the existentialists as people deeply engaged in fervent debates and conflicts, grappling with the fears of the Cold War, the terror of nuclear conflict, and the divergent ideologies of Western nations and the Soviet Union following World War II.

During the nuclear era, a widespread sense of disquiet combined with the allure of communism, all taking place in a time defined by the deep-seated mistrust of the Cold War period.

The author explores the deep-seated anxiety that defined the era of the Cold War, especially the existential danger posed by nuclear weapons. The crumbling of conventional belief structures, alongside the dread of nonexistence, prompted numerous thinkers to pursue significance and direction in novel political doctrines, especially Communism.

Despite encountering severe conditions, some individuals perceived the Soviet Union as an emblem of hope for establishing a more just and equal society. Sartre and Merleau-Ponty initially gravitated towards the doctrines of Communism, while Camus, on the other hand, maintained a more questioning approach, emphasizing humanistic values.

Sartre's support for the Soviet Union eventually led to a rift with Camus.

Bakewell vividly depicts the escalating ideological clash that led to a pronounced division, publicly distancing the once allied thinkers, Sartre and Camus. Sartre's transformative experience solidified his determination to blend existentialist philosophy with Marxist ideology, considering the measures taken by the Soviet Union to be unfortunate yet necessary strides towards a brighter tomorrow.

Camus, by contrast, steadfastly championed personal liberty and consistently opposed any ideology that excused violence or oppression. Their relationship's fracture marked a critical juncture in the realm of existential thought.

Other Perspectives

• While existentialism was certainly influenced by the events of the 20th century, it is also rooted in philosophical traditions that predate these events, such as the works of Kierkegaard and Nietzsche, suggesting that its emergence cannot be solely attributed to 20th-century turmoil.
• The claim that existentialist ideas were a direct product of personal experiences during political upheavals could be oversimplified, as these ideas also draw on a broader philosophical discourse that includes abstract reasoning not necessarily tied to immediate social or political contexts.
• The development of phenomenology, while catalyzed by the First World War, was also a response to long-standing philosophical questions about the nature of consciousness and reality, which suggests that the war was not the sole factor in its evolution.
• The impact of Nazism on existentialist philosophers varied widely, and not all existentialists were equally influenced or involved in political events; some maintained a more detached or academic stance.
• Heidegger's association with Nazism is a complex issue, and some argue that his philosophical work should be considered separately from his political affiliations, despite the ethical implications of his actions.
• The decision of Karl Jaspers to stay in Germany could be seen not only as an ethical dilemma but also as a form of resistance or an expression of fidelity to his homeland, which complicates the narrative of regret.
• The rise of existentialism post-World War II can also be attributed to the general disillusionment with traditional values and the search for new forms of individual and collective identity, not just the influence of Sartre and other existentialists.
• The existentialists' role in shaping the political landscape after the war might be overstated, as many other intellectual and political movements were also influential during this time.
• The engagement of existentialists with Cold War politics was not uniform, and some may argue that their influence on the era's political debates was marginal compared to other political figures and intellectuals.
• The attraction to Communism among some existentialists could be critiqued as a failure to foresee the authoritarian tendencies of Soviet-style regimes, which later became apparent.
• The rift between Sartre and Camus over support for the Soviet Union reflects a broader debate within existentialism about the role of political engagement and the ethics of violence, suggesting that the movement was not monolithic in its political views.

The widespread embrace of existentialist thought and its influence on lifestyles.

Sarah Bakewell delves into the core concepts of existentialism, a philosophy that evolved from intellectual debates and infused popular culture, shaping individual life experiences and the sphere of artistic expression.

Personal Lives and Relationships

This section reveals the messy, complicated private lives of the existentialists, showing how they attempted to live out their ideals of freedom, responsibility, and authenticity within their personal relationships.

Sartre and Beauvoir's relationship, characterized by their dedication to maintaining open romantic relationships, reflected their deep-seated belief in the tenet of personal liberty.

Navigating the complexities of romantic and passionate connections while maintaining professional duties.

Bakewell explores the distinctive and lasting connection shared by Sartre and Beauvoir, marked by their collective pursuit of insight and an open exploration of love and sexuality. They both rejected traditional perspectives on establishing family and marital ties, opting for a relationship founded on the values of freedom and openness.

Bakewell demonstrates that their dedication to liberty resulted in a mix of profound happiness and difficult disputes, as they steered through complex liaisons with additional romantic partners. Their story is a testament to their commitment to living philosophy concretely, even when it meant confronting the messy contradictions of human desire and the anxieties that often accompany freedom.

Merleau-Ponty. Welcoming the uncertainties of existence and the delight found in dance.

The book delves deeper into issues of flirtation and fidelity, intertwining psychological aspects with philosophical exploration.

The author depicts Merleau-Ponty as the existentialist whose philosophy is the most applicable to everyday life, a person who accepted life's intricacies without giving in to the apprehensions associated with Sartre or the enigmatic nature of Heidegger's thinking. Sarah Bakewell is depicted as a person who reveled in the delight of dance, was recognized for her friendly disposition, and possessed the capacity to relish intellectual delights alongside sensory ones.

He successfully maintained a fulfilling domestic life alongside his scholarly pursuits, and was open to romantic dalliances and participated in extramarital affairs. His significance has been cemented by his joyful acceptance of life's intricacies and unwavering commitment to intellectual integrity, even though his influential role within existential philosophy frequently goes unnoticed.

Camus wrestled with the concept of absurdity and found meaning by opposing it.

Bakewell offers an in-depth depiction of Camus, emphasizing his captivating charm, wit, and the profound complexity of his feelings, which are markedly different from the detached protagonist in his novel "The Stranger." She attributes the complexity of his personality to a variety of influences, such as growing up in poverty in Algeria, struggling with tuberculosis, and managing the cultural rift as someone of both French and Algerian descent.

Algeria's sunlight, emblematic of both stark reality and comforting solace, repeatedly emerges as a motif throughout his creations. Bakewell highlights Camus' unwavering commitment to humanist values, showing how his own experiences shaped his firm opposition to violence, injustice, and radical beliefs, especially when confronted by the inherent meaninglessness of life.

Existentialism Across Cultural Contexts

Bakewell demonstrates how the deep-seated influences of existentialist philosophy, which emerged in Europe, have permeated various cultural terrains, such as those in the United States, Britain, and Czechoslovakia. The intellectual movements shed light on ideas of alienation, the quest for authentic individuality, and the desire for freedom within diverse social and political structures.

The philosophy of existentialism gained significant traction in the United States.

The writer explores the intricate manner in which existentialism was interpreted and reshaped within the cultural milieu of post-war America. Existentialist ideas, highlighting individual freedom and the quest for meaning, struck a chord with a generation facing the strains of the Cold War, a growing tendency towards uniformity, and racial inequalities.

In the city of Paris, Richard Wright embarked on a quest to understand the essence of Black identity.

Sarah Bakewell delves into the underlying factors that drew African American author Richard Wright to the philosophical works of Sartre and Beauvoir. He recognized the importance of recognizing an individual of African descent in a society predominantly shaped by white cultural norms.

Wright moved to the capital of France in pursuit of personal and artistic liberation. He intertwines themes of existentialism with his racial experiences, emphasizing his quest for authenticity. The author, Sarah Bakewell, observed that Wright faced criticism from his African American literary peers for embracing concepts from European philosophical traditions.

The Beat Generation wrestled with the difficulty of conveying their true selves while underscoring the importance of genuineness.

The author illustrates the infusion of existentialist philosophy into American literature and film, which sparked the bohemian counterculture and intense quests for authenticity that defined the 1950s and 60s. The Beat Generation's literature delves into topics that resonate with existentialist thought, such as feelings of alienation, a defiant attitude, and a search for meaning.

Films like "Rebel Without a Cause" explore the internal conflict that arises from the pressures to conform to society, contrasting this with the pursuit of a more authentic existence. Existentialism's core concepts fascinated a wide range of individuals, many of whom might not have directly interacted with Sartre's or Camus's writings.

Existential philosophy gained prominence in Britain, notably shaped by Iris Murdoch's work and the emergence of the disenchanted collective referred to as the Angry Young Men.

Existentialism received a more measured reception in Britain, unlike the enthusiastic embrace it experienced in America. She highlights the cultural barriers that limited its appeal, including the English preference for understated pragmatism over dramatic notions of angst and revolt.

Colin Wilson's contributions have been instrumental in forming the New Existentialism.

The author explores the extraordinary rise and eventual fall of Colin Wilson, a British autodidact whose influential book "The Outsider" broadened existentialist ideas within British society. Wilson, a charismatic and somewhat arrogant outsider, addressed individuals who were pursuing liberation and significance outside the bounds of traditional societal standards.

Bakewell explores the impact of Wilson's contributions on a generation that was ready to embrace a new viewpoint on existentialist thought, even though his interpretations of key texts sometimes contained errors and misconceptions. His subsequent fall from grace, fueled by critical attacks and public ridicule, illustrates how enduring elitist attitudes in the intellectual sphere and the concerns that often emerge as a result of efforts to demystify complex philosophical ideas for a wider audience can impact an individual's reputation.

Existentialist philosophy played a significant role in Czechoslovakia by igniting opposition, leading to the inception of the Charter 77 movement, and supporting the endeavors of Václav Havel.

Bakewell reveals the pivotal role that phenomenology and existentialism played in sparking political opposition within Communist Czechoslovakia. She demonstrates how these European philosophical movements established a foundation for acknowledging and challenging oppression, while also bolstering personal freedom when faced with autocratic governments.

Jan Patocka's Private Seminars nurtured a communal spirit among individuals deeply touched by hardship.

Bakewell recounts how Jan Patocka, a Czech philosopher, continued to impart knowledge on phenomenology through clandestine means once he was barred from academic institutions by the Communist regime, even though his intellectual growth was shaped by Husserl and Heidegger's philosophies. The playwright known as Václav Havel committed himself to the coordination of secret seminars, being noted for his dissent.

Patocka underscored the special bond that developed between individuals whose lives were unsettled due to political unrest, a fellowship that emerged from shared upheaval. His depiction reveals that a genuine emphasis on self-examination, combined with the foundational tenets of phenomenology, carries significant political implications, demonstrating its potential to foster dissent.

Other Perspectives

• While existentialism emphasizes personal freedom, critics argue that it can lead to excessive individualism and neglect of community and social responsibilities.
• Some argue that existentialism's focus on authenticity and personal choice may not adequately address systemic issues and inequalities that limit individual agency.
• Critics of Sartre and Beauvoir's open relationship model might suggest that it could lead to emotional distress and instability for the individuals involved.
• Existentialism's embrace of life's uncertainties can be seen as a lack of commitment to finding concrete solutions to life's problems.
• The philosophy's preoccupation with the absurd and the search for meaning might be criticized for potentially leading to nihilism or inaction.
• The application of existentialist ideas in different cultural contexts may not always account for the specific historical, social, and political factors at play in those environments.
• The adoption of existentialism by the Beat Generation and other countercultural movements could be critiqued for romanticizing disenfranchisement and rebellion.
• Colin Wilson's interpretations of existentialism have been criticized for inaccuracies and oversimplifications, which could misrepresent the philosophy to a broader audience.
• The political applications of existentialism, such as in Czechoslovakia, might be challenged on the grounds that philosophical ideas alone are insufficient to enact political change without accompanying social and economic reforms.
• The focus on individual philosophers' lives and choices might be criticized for overshadowing the broader philosophical discourse and the contributions of other thinkers.
• Some may argue that existentialism's influence on lifestyle and culture has been overstated or that its impact is less significant compared to other philosophical or intellectual movements.

The lasting influence of existentialist thought.

Sarah Bakewell examines how the concepts of existentialism and phenomenology continue to influence philosophical dialogue and remain relevant to modern-day challenges and issues.

The evolution and diversification of phenomenological research.

The passage explores the development and transformation of phenomenology, highlighting the distinct approaches taken by Husserl and Heidegger, along with the lasting impact of Merleau-Ponty's insights.

Husserl's thinking evolved considerably from its initial phase to his later years of intellectual maturity.

The transition from introspective idealism to a domain emphasizing the primacy of existence and its tangible expressions.

Bakewell maps out the evolution of Husserl's philosophical concepts, highlighting his transition from an initial emphasis on introspective awareness to a final insistence on the concrete, experiential world. Bakewell's narrative illustrates the way in which his engagement with the critical matters of his time, such as the rise of political ideologies and the increasing unrest in European societies, shaped the change in emphasis.

Later in his career, as portrayed by Bakewell, Husserl expanded his viewpoint, recognizing that the core of our being is shaped by our bodily existence, social interactions, and the impactful aspects of our cultural and historical contexts. She emphasizes the importance of this change as it deepens our understanding of the complexities inherent in human existence.

Heidegger's divergence in the realm of phenomenological philosophy from his peers.

The retreat from engagement and the concealment of the fundamental nature of being.

The author emphasizes that Heidegger's later work progressively diverged from the trajectories of his peers in the field of phenomenology. Diving into the nature of human experience and morality, philosophers like Merleau-Ponty and Levinas investigated the lived elements of awareness, and Heidegger's transition to a philosophy of "letting-be" guided him to a more enigmatic perspective that reduced the emphasis on human aspects.

Bakewell illustrates that the increasing challenges other philosophers faced when engaging with Heidegger's contributions were due to his emphasis on an impersonal notion of being and his retreat from engaging in political conversation after his involvement with the Nazi party. Heidegger's approach to philosophy significantly diverges from the core concerns that are pivotal to existential thought.

Merleau-Ponty made a profound contribution to the domain known as 'embodied cognition'.

The body functions as the central point where individual experiences and interactions with the surroundings intersect.

Bakewell underscores the enduring influence of Merleau-Ponty's ideas, especially his concentration on the body's immediate experiences and the significance of deciphering sensory data. His insights have significantly shaped contemporary fields like cognitive science and psychology, nurturing an increased understanding that cognition is intricately connected with the body's physiological condition.

Merleau-Ponty challenges the traditional dichotomy between mind and body, advocating for a holistic approach that considers human experience to be a seamless and interconnected entirety. Bakewell presents his ideas as offering a more nuanced and "liveable" understanding of human existence compared to the views of Sartre and Heidegger.

The enduring relevance of existentialist philosophy in contemporary society.

The tenets of existentialism, as interpreted by Bakewell, remain illuminating in the context of modern dilemmas, political events, and the advancement of technology today.

The discomfort of modern society, the necessity to make decisions, and the trepidation associated with liberty.

A genuine search for purpose and a commitment to identifying one's true calling.

Bakewell observes that despite contemporary tendencies to ascribe human behavior to genetic or environmental influences, the exploration into the essential aspects of our being persists. She argues that in contemporary society, the sheer multitude of choices for consumers, the incessant pressure to succeed, and the common experience of isolation can amplify the feeling of being overwhelmed by freedom.

Living authentically continues to garner interest, evidenced by the widespread appeal of practices such as yoga, mindfulness, and retreats designed to break away from technological distractions. Bakewell suggests that these inclinations reveal a desire to reconnect with meaningful and concrete experiences, especially in an era characterized by the instability of traditional sources of meaning.

Heidegger's perspective posits that the advancement of technology poses a considerable challenge.

The outcome is the conversion of individuals into simple assets, stripping them of their personal space.

The writer delves into the idea that the rise of digital connectivity, particularly through the advent of the World Wide Web, presents a unique and possibly unprecedented test within the framework of Heidegger's philosophical thought. Digital technologies, they emphasize, could result in reduced privacy and a more fragmented attention, while also potentially reducing people to mere numbers, a concern initially raised by the philosopher Martin Heidegger.

The author examines the intricate ways in which the vast network of digital information and interconnectivity, despite its benefits, can also promote a collective identity that reduces opportunities for authentic self-determination. She suggests that the omnipresence and interlinkage of contemporary technology could hinder our capacity for deep contemplation, a process that Heidegger alongside Merleau-Ponty considered essential for living a genuine human existence.

Existentialism's lasting importance is evident.

What defines the core of our existence? How should we proceed?

Bakewell concludes her book by returning to the core questions that consumed existentialist thinkers in the 20th century: "What defines our true nature?" How ought we to act? Sarah Bakewell argues that the lasting impact of existentialism is more effectively shown through the questions it raises than through the particular answers given by individual philosophers.

Sarah Bakewell emphasizes the need to revisit the contributions of those who pondered existence, not to fully embrace their philosophies or ideas, but to recognize how their insights continue to challenge us to confront the innate uncertainties, contradictions, and possibilities that define what it means to be human. She encourages us to engage in this continuous dialogue, utilizing their wisdom to navigate the intricacies of our contemporary era.

Other Perspectives

• The influence of existentialism and phenomenology may be overstated, as other philosophical movements have also significantly shaped modern thought.
• Husserl's work, while influential, may not be as central to contemporary philosophy as other figures or schools of thought.
• Heidegger's divergence and retreat from political engagement could be seen as a failure to address crucial ethical issues of his time.
• The concept of embodied cognition, while valuable, is not without its critics who argue for a more nuanced understanding of the mind-body relationship.
• The relevance of existentialist philosophy in contemporary society is contested, with some arguing that newer philosophical developments have superseded it.
• The discomfort of modern society and the challenges of decision-making may not be uniquely addressed by existentialist thought and could be equally informed by other philosophical or psychological frameworks.
• The pursuit of living authentically and reconnecting with meaningful experiences might be criticized as a luxury of the privileged rather than a universal solution to contemporary issues.
• The critique of technology from a Heideggerian perspective might be seen as overly pessimistic, failing to fully acknowledge the benefits and positive transformations brought about by digital advancements.
• The importance of existentialism in questioning the core of existence could be challenged by those who find more structured or empirical approaches to understanding human nature and behavior more compelling.