PDF Summary:All That Glitters, by Orlando Whitfield

Few have gained such an intimate look into the elite art world as Orlando Whitfield, who worked closely with notorious art dealer Inigo Philbrick. In All That Glitters, Whitfield describes the shocking rise and fall of Philbrick, detailing his rapid ascent to prominence through shady transactions and elaborate ruses. The account lays bare the underbelly of the art industry: a sphere plagued by secrecy, manipulation, and vast sums exchanged through loopholes and illicit channels.

Yet there's more to the story than Philbrick's duplicity. Whitfield also illuminates the grueling challenges of surviving as a smaller gallery, the exploitive dynamics between artists and dealers, and his own role within Philbrick's machinations. This exposé pulls no punches in revealing the insular art world's shady inner workings.

(continued)...

The art market's traits, which are mysterious and scarcely regulated

Whitfield, drawing on over a decade of expertise in art dealings, reveals the secretive nature, the lack of transparent procedures, and the danger of fraud within today's art commerce.

The realm of fine arts frequently operates via confidential transactions, secretive activities, and non-transparent methods.

Orlando Whitfield characterizes the art market's operations as influenced by a tradition of secrecy and discretion, resulting in a marketplace where transparent pricing is rare, owners often hide their identities, and deals are usually sealed on the basis of shared trust and reputation instead of official agreements. This lack of transparency, while appealing to certain collectors seeking privacy and tax advantages, also makes the market susceptible to manipulation and fraud.

The author illustrates this opaqueness through anecdotes of discreet viewing rooms, hush-hush negotiations, and the use of intermediaries to maintain anonymity in high-value transactions. Orlando Whitfield underscores the art market's dependence on a complex network of trust and personal relationships, which facilitates not only the smooth exchange of valuable artworks but also creates opportunities for exploitation by unscrupulous characters.

The art market's susceptibility to economic tampering and the conduct of dishonest individuals

The author exposes the art market's vulnerability to practices that are speculative and manipulative, showing that the worth of artworks is more often swayed by current trends, powerful individuals, and the whims of a select few rather than their intrinsic value. The susceptibility of the market to significant swings is increased by traders aiming to enhance their earnings by inflating prices and manipulating supply and demand.

Whitfield delves into the trend of the early 2010s known as flipping, where artworks from emerging artists were quickly traded on the secondary market, often resulting in higher prices that did not often benefit the artists or their agents financially. He describes this period as a time of prosperity for merchants like Philbrick, who took advantage of the rampant speculation to amass a significant wealth, thereby hastening the collapse of the market, which led to the untimely cessation of many budding careers in the art industry.

The industry of fine arts is riddled with unscrupulous practices.

Whitfield delves into the ethically questionable elements of the art industry, drawing on his personal experiences and professional knowledge to expose questionable behavior, power disparities, and the industry's complicity in enabling immoral activities.

Art pieces serve as channels for money laundering and other illicit financial activities.

The author exposes how the art sector is prone to being entangled in money laundering and numerous illicit fiscal activities, as pieces of art are commonly used to move and conceal large sums of money across international borders. He underscores the allure of the art industry for those seeking to cleanse unlawfully obtained money, given its lack of stringent regulation, common cash transactions, hidden ownership structures, and the presence of tax havens.

The book scrutinizes the case of Ely Sakhai, Andre Sakhai's father and an acquaintance of Inigo's client, who was legally challenged for distributing fake Impressionist paintings accompanied by genuine certificates of authenticity. He explains Sakhai's method of exploiting the complex characteristics of the art market and the lack of rigorous authentication procedures to sustain a long-running fraudulent operation.

The art sector's exploitative practices originate from the power imbalance between artists, art collectors, and galleries.

Whitfield illuminates the imbalanced power relations in the art world, emphasizing that emerging artists eager to display their creations frequently end up being vulnerable to the sway of prominent dealers and collectors. He emphasizes the power disparity that often results in creators being pressured into unfair agreements, stripped of their rightful income, and exploited by those who dominate the gateways and financial influence.

The author offers insights into how the prominent trader adeptly navigated between collectors and artists to his advantage. He explained that Philbrick distorted the market through price control and by hiding crucial information regarding the provenance and documentation of sales, frequently resulting in harm to the artists and their colleagues.

Other Perspectives

• The art market's lack of transparency can be seen as a protection of privacy for collectors and artists who may not want public exposure of their transactions.
• Confidential transactions and non-transparent methods are not unique to the art market and can be found in various sectors, such as real estate and private equity.
• Trust and reputation-based deals can foster a sense of community and mutual respect among collectors, artists, and dealers, which might be lost in a more regulated market.
• The value of art is inherently subjective, and while trends and influential individuals play a role, they can also bring attention to overlooked artists and movements.
• The art market has begun to adopt more transparent practices, with online platforms and databases providing more information on provenance and pricing.
• Not all art transactions are used for illicit activities; many are legitimate and contribute positively to cultural exchange and the economy.
• There are many galleries and dealers who operate ethically and support artists' careers, ensuring fair agreements and promoting artists' work.
• The power imbalance in the art world is not absolute; some artists successfully navigate the market independently or through artist-run initiatives that challenge traditional gallery models.

The narrative style of the author is shaped by his firsthand involvement in the realm of art.

Whitfield narrates his passage through the upper echelons of the art community, candidly discussing his times of fellowship and business partnerships with Inigo Philbrick, the challenges he encountered in operating an independent art space, and his eventual disillusionment with the realm of fine arts.

The author's collaboration and commercial alliance with Inigo Philbrick.

This part of the story explores the complex and evolving relationship between Whitfield and Inigo Philbrick, charting their progression from art history enthusiasts to business partners in the art world, culminating in the disintegration of their friendship as ambitions grew, trust eroded, and goals diverged.

The author's connection to Inigo evolved from a close friendship into a growing sense of disillusionment.

Whitfield candidly acknowledges his admiration for Philbrick and is keen to replicate the early successes Philbrick achieved while also learning from his personal experiences. He fondly recalls the stimulating conversations they shared, their shared passion for creative pursuits, and their early, somewhat naive ventures into the business side of the art scene. He also conceded that matching Philbrick's swift rise proved difficult, resulting in a growing divergence in their career paths and a subsequent feeling of disillusionment while witnessing Philbrick's increasingly dubious behavior.

The author reflects on the period when they united their efforts to acquire a piece of Banksy's art from a London scooter shop, highlighting the various tactics that marked the onset of their partnership. Philbrick entered the partnership with steadfast assurance and a readiness to skirt regulations, whereas Whitfield was daunted by the intricacies and possible dangers, presaging the divergent viewpoints that would eventually lead to the disintegration of their collaborative endeavor.

The author's entanglement in Inigo's ingenious scheme led to personal consequences.

Whitfield narrates his initial enthusiasm for joining Modern Collections, eager to play a role in the gallery's achievements. Orlando Whitfield's main duty is described as managing the creation of thematic exhibits that showcase the artworks acquired by Philbrick, often disregarding their artistic merit or the unity of the collection. Whitfield's unease intensified as the scope of the fraudulent activities expanded, exploiting vulnerabilities in the market.

Whitfield played a key role in securing a significant artwork from Christopher Wool, which Philbrick purchased at a substantial cost, underscoring the ethical dilemmas he faced. Philbrick's intentional postponement in clearing his financial obligations significantly undermined and ultimately harmed his standing with his customers, which negatively impacted Whitfield. The ordeal, described as a distressing narrative of monetary peril and deceit, made Whitfield feel manipulated and taken advantage of, underscoring the individual repercussions of his association with Philbrick's deceptive schemes.

Operating a standalone gallery presents unique challenges within the complex structure of the community dedicated to art.

Whitfield provides an in-depth look at the fierce competition within the modern art world, in addition to reflecting on the obstacles he encountered while managing Hunter/Whitfield, the independent gallery he co-founded with his friend Ben Hunter.

The difficulties in securing clients and competing with established, well-connected dealers

The author details the difficulties of attracting clientele and creating a significant presence in a domain dominated by well-resourced and extensively connected established galleries. He recounts the obstacles in setting up shows that often fail to draw purchasers, the struggle to compete with established galleries offering an extensive selection of services and access to sought-after artists, and the sobering truth of operating in an industry that favors the wealthy and influential.

Whitfield delves into the challenges of increasing sales within the context of art fairs, where collectors have grown accustomed to the ease of buying from expansive, international galleries offering an all-encompassing purchasing experience. He contrasts this by highlighting the challenges faced when operating a modest, self-reliant art space, where drawing in purchasers frequently requires a vast network, tailored services, and an eagerness to exceed expectations in satisfying the whims and specific requirements of those who acquire art.

The challenges of operating a modest gallery within a marketplace controlled by influential entities.

The author highlights the financial precariousness inherent in operating an art venue of moderate size, particularly in light of the substantial expenses tied to the central area of London. He describes the challenges of securing affordable venues, managing ongoing expenses, and competing with established galleries that possess the financial support and institutional connections essential for drawing in artists.

The story of Hunter/Whitfield's move initially to Clerkenwell and then to St. James's from Marylebone illustrates the continuous financial strategizing required to maintain their position in an industry dominated by powerful groups. He delves into the difficulties of attracting art lovers to galleries in lesser-known locales, the importance of participation in costly art fairs, and the inevitable compromises that come with navigating a system that often favors the wealthy and renowned.

Other Perspectives

• Whitfield's narrative may be subjective, and his perspective might not fully capture the complexity of the art world or the intentions and actions of other individuals involved.
• The commercial alliance with Inigo Philbrick could be seen as a learning opportunity, and the dissolution of their partnership might have provided valuable business lessons rather than just a source of disillusionment.
• The evolution from friendship to disillusionment with Inigo could be interpreted as a natural progression in any competitive business environment, not unique to the art world.
• Whitfield's involvement in Inigo's scheme might be critiqued for a lack of due diligence or personal responsibility in the business dealings.
• The challenges of operating a standalone gallery could be framed as part of the entrepreneurial risk inherent in any business venture, not just the art industry.
• The difficulties in securing clients and competing with established dealers might be countered by the argument that innovation, niche marketing, and leveraging unique strengths can overcome these challenges.
• The challenges of operating a modest gallery in a marketplace controlled by influential entities could be seen as an opportunity for smaller galleries to differentiate themselves and create a new market or appeal to a different set of clients.