PDF Summary:A Rift in Time, by Raja Shehadeh

In A Rift in Time, Raja Shehadeh narrates the upheavals his family endured due to the political turbulence in the Levant region during the transition from Ottoman to British rule. Through the lens of his forefather Najib Nassar's experiences, the author provides insights into the cultural and geographical landscape before and after the collapse of the Ottoman Empire.

Shehadeh delves into the displacement of Palestinians during the establishment of Israel, tracing his own roots and emphasizing the enduring impact of dispossession. He chronicles his journey across the ever-changing terrain, reflecting on the act of reimagining an unfragmented homeland as an act of defiance against occupation.

(continued)...

Raja Shehadeh describes the Ottoman Empire as an expansive domain that included a diverse mix of ethnic and religious groups, and due to the absence of rigid national borders, there was a greater blending and movement among its diverse population. Shehadeh contests the widely held belief that the period under Ottoman dominion was marked by a lack of progress, highlighting the Tanzimat era's administrative reforms and the level of autonomy granted to different religious factions through a structured communal system.

The system of millets allowed different religious communities to have a measure of self-governance.

Raja Shehadeh explores how the administrative methods of the Ottoman Empire fostered a unique form of social cohesion, granting various religious communities a measure of self-governance over their personal affairs, education, and communal events. This structure, he argues, nurtured a variety of religious and cultural identities, standing in stark contrast to the homogenous national identities that modern nation-states highlight.

The establishment of a system by the Ottoman Empire enabled free movement and integration across the region.

The author emphasizes that in the time of the Ottoman Empire, Najib Nassar's travel from Lebanon to Palestine encountered no travel barriers. In cities like Haifa, Arabs from diverse regions interacted with people of various religious backgrounds, fostering a level of peaceful coexistence that has since lessened.

The collapse of the Ottoman Empire led to significant changes that resulted in the creation of new independent nations.

The author contrasts the relatively open and tolerant atmosphere prevalent during the Ottoman era with the segmentation of the Levant into separate nations following World War I. Shehadeh underscores the profound impact that the establishment of boundaries and the rise of nationalistic feelings have had on the inhabitants of the region.

The region was divided into separate nations, each imposing strict limitations on travel.

Shehadeh describes how the collapse of the Ottoman Empire led to the creation of rigid national borders, greatly limiting the movement of people and goods. Raja Shehadeh reflects on how Najib Nassar could travel from Nazareth to Damascus in just two hours by train, contrasting this with the present-day difficulties Palestinians face when navigating intricate border controls. This splintering, he contends, stems directly from the territorial reshaping carried out by European colonial powers in the aftermath of World War I.

Israel enacted measures to alter the demographic makeup and the inherent physical traits of the region.

Shehadeh emphasizes that the alterations in the terrain went further than just establishing boundaries. New states, particularly Israel, enacted policies to alter the demographic and geographic characteristics of the region. Raja Shehadeh explores the compulsory displacement of Arab populations, the erasure of Palestinian villages, and the establishment of Jewish settlements, while also initiating substantial development projects that transformed the terrain. Raja Shehadeh notes the contradictory actions of Israeli officials who strive to erase traces of Arab history while simultaneously employing that very history to support their territorial assertions.

Other Perspectives

• The Ottoman Empire's governance was not uniformly benign; various ethnic and religious groups sometimes faced discrimination and hardship.
• The fluidity of borders during the Ottoman era also led to administrative challenges and difficulties in maintaining law and order.
• The millets system, while granting autonomy, also segregated communities, potentially sowing the seeds for future ethnic and religious tensions.
• The notion of free movement across the region under the Ottoman Empire may overlook the restrictions and taxes imposed on trade and travel, which could be burdensome.
• The collapse of the Ottoman Empire and the subsequent creation of new nations were influenced by a complex interplay of local and international factors, not solely by external European powers.
• The establishment of strict national borders can also be seen as a way to foster a sense of national identity and to build a cohesive state apparatus.
• The demographic and physical alterations of the region, particularly by Israel, can be viewed within the context of nation-building and security concerns, which are common to many states.
• The erasure of certain historical elements in the landscape by Israel could be argued as part of creating a new national narrative, a process not unique to Israel and practiced by many nations throughout history.

The ongoing occupation has deeply affected the residents of the region, including the author, forcing them to confront the profound consequences of displacement and the imperative to reconnect with their ancestral roots.

Toward the end of the book, the author reflects on the lasting impact of displacement and its prolonged impact on Palestinian lives. He intertwines his familial legacy with a personal exploration to scrutinize the lasting influence of Najib Nassar.

The author's family deeply felt the loss of their connection to their ancestral land in 1948.

In his narrative, Shehadeh underscores the deep ties to historical events by recounting his family's experiences during the chaotic events of 1948. He narrates how the Nassar family was scattered throughout the region, forced to leave their homes and businesses behind, which led to the forfeiture of their assets and their eventual resettlement in different countries across the Arab world, where they had to start their lives anew as exiles. He poignantly conveys the enduring bond and profound grief his grandmother experienced for their ancestral residence in Haifa, sentiments shared by many Palestinians who have had to abandon their homeland.

The Nassar family scattered, with many members finding refuge in Lebanon.

The author narrates the tribulations faced by his relatives, emphasizing the circumstances that forced the siblings of Najib and their descendants to abandon their residences in Haifa and Nazareth during the turmoil of 1948. He narrates their travels across various countries, including Lebanon, where they faced new challenges in their efforts to rebuild their lives after being displaced.

Julia, the matriarch of the author's lineage, harbored a profound longing for the family's ancestral dwelling located in the city of Haifa.

Shehadeh shares tales of his grandmother Julia, highlighting her enduring connection to Haifa, her birthplace and the city she had to abandon. Her memories of the family's longstanding home and the inn, along with their life before the catastrophe, are deeply woven into the story, adding a poignant layer to the author's exploration of his heritage and the collective Palestinian experience of displacement and grief.

The author embarks on an expedition to trace the route of his ancestor Najib, thereby reconnecting with the region's historical narrative.

Shehadeh recounts his journey along the route his forebear Najib traversed, highlighting the challenges encountered in navigating the transformed landscape and the deep effect of uncovering histories that have disappeared. He reflects on his travels as a means to preserve Palestinian cultural heritage and to recall an era unmarred by separating boundaries.

Navigating through the altered terrain and the divided geography presents its own set of challenges.

The author elaborates on the numerous obstacles encountered in tracing Najib's journey, highlighting the profound changes and divisions political upheavals have wrought upon the landscape. Israeli settlements, military installations, and sealed frontiers, along with regions that have been renamed, add complexity to his journey, necessitating continual adjustments to the ever-changing landscape as he attempts to imagine the land as it once was. The author suggests that the key to resisting annihilation and maintaining a connection to the land is found in the challenging act of balancing reflections on history with involvement in present-day circumstances.

The author reflects on the importance of imagining the land in its unfragmented form, viewing this act as a means to defy the current state of occupation and settlement.

The book by Shehadeh emphasizes the importance of perceiving the Great Rift Valley as an integral entity, free from separations. He advocates for a viewpoint that transcends current land conflicts, promoting reflection on an area defined by free mobility and shared heritage. Raja Shehadeh suggests that this creative pursuit stands as a powerful act of resistance against the divisions and the systematic dispossession of property by colonial and nationalistic entities. Shehadeh is of the opinion that understanding our history and envisioning a different trajectory is crucial for dealing with current situations and restoring our position in the world.

Other Perspectives

• The impact of occupation can be perceived differently by various groups within the region, and some may argue that the occupation has also led to certain developments or improvements in infrastructure and economy, albeit controversial and not without significant cost to the original inhabitants.
• While reconnecting with ancestral roots is important, some might argue that focusing too much on the past can hinder the ability to adapt and thrive in the present circumstances.
• The loss of connection to ancestral land is a profound issue, but others might point out that such disconnection is a common historical occurrence for many peoples and not unique to the author's family or the Palestinian experience.
• The scattering of the Nassar family and their refuge in Lebanon could be viewed through a different lens, highlighting the resilience and adaptability of the family members rather than solely their loss and displacement.
• While Julia's longing for her ancestral home is understandable, some might suggest that new generations need to forge their own connections and legacies, potentially in new lands or contexts.
• The author's journey to trace his ancestor's route is a personal and symbolic act, but some might question the practicality or broader impact of such an endeavor beyond its personal significance.
• The challenges of navigating altered terrain and divided geography are real, but others might argue that new geopolitical realities necessitate acceptance and adaptation to the current state of affairs.
• Imagining the land in its unfragmented form is a powerful act of resistance, yet some might contend that it is equally important to work towards realistic and pragmatic solutions within the existing political framework to improve the lives of those affected by the occupation.